Breaking Up Is Hard To Do

Hmmm. Remember my mentioning the idea of splitting up New York State not long ago? Apparently, there’s a separatist movement brewing in the Empire State that wants to do just that:

HOST INTRO: Yet another Brexit deadline was missed today. British lawmakers had to negotiate a plan to leave the European Union. But with tensions high and no resolution in sight, they got a two-week extension to decide for good whether the UK wants in or out. Meanwhile, as Ali Swenson reports, there’s another separatist movement brewing — right here in New York state.

((SOUND: Taking steps in the Albany Bus Terminal.

SWENSON 1: When you arrive at the Albany Bus Terminal, it’s immediately clear: You’re not in Manhattan anymore.

((SOUND: Door opening. Country music playing outside the terminal.

SWENSON 2: At this one-room transit station, country music blasts over the speakers. Down the street, hotel doors welcome guests inside with decals that read “howdy y’all.” Albany’s population would fit inside New York City more than 80 times.

Albany is just three hours north of Manhattan, but it feels like part of a different state entirely. And if a new bill in the state assembly passes, it might as well be.

DIPIETRO 1

It’s been talked about. No one’s ever had the guts to actually put it into a bill and say you know what? This is a law, let’s actually move it. (0:06)

SWENSON 3: Assemblyman David DiPietro is from upstate New York. His bill is the first to propose splitting the state into three independent regions. The five boroughs would keep the name “New York,” downstate suburbs and Long Island would be called “Montauk.” Upstate, where DiPietro lives, would be called “New Amsterdam.”

One of the things I learned from reading that article is that Illinois is not the only state that has the upstate/downstate relationship wrong. A lot of Illinoisans who live downstate, i.e. outside Chicago and its “collar counties” believe that Chicago and its “collar counties” are receiving more than their fair share of state revenues. It’s actually the other way around.

I know little about New York politics but I suspect that a divorce between the New York City area and the rest of the state would initially be disastrous for the rest of the state but over time would benefit it. It would also in all likelihood result in two more Republican senators.

1 comment

Foreign Aid to Central America

Another story much in the news is President Trump’s announcement of his plan to cut U. S. aid to Central American countries. NBC News reports:

The Trump administration said Saturday that it intends to end foreign assistance programs for Guatemala, Honduras and El Salvador, a move that Democrats called “reckless” and “counterproductive” in addressing the problems that cause people to flee to the U.S.

A State Department spokesperson said that “at the Secretary’s instruction, we are carrying out the President’s direction and ending FY 2017 and FY 2018 foreign assistance programs for the Northern Triangle,” a term that refers to the three countries.

The spokesperson said “we will be engaging Congress as part of this process,” which could mean it needs Congress’ approval to end funding.

The aid affects nearly $500 million in 2018 funds and millions more left over from the previous fiscal year. The money was destined for Central America but had not been spent yet, the Washington Post reported

That’s something I with which I simultaneously agree and disagree. I think we should actually increase our aid to the “Northern Triangle” but that aid should take a form completely different than it does now. Most of our foreign aid to Guatemala, Honduras, and El Salvador does nothing for the people of those countries. It is snatched by the countries’ elites as quickly as they can get their mitts on it. And for goodness sake we shouldn’t fund their militaries. The militaries function primarily as a means of repressing the people and imposing authoritarian governments. We should be encouraging those countries to eliminate their militaries entirely. One of the reasons that Costa Rica is so stable is that it eliminated its military 70 years ago.

U. S. aid should be in the form of micro-loans to individuals or, possibly, small municipalities. If the State Department is incapable of administering that in a fair and non-corrupt manner, we should be giving grants to NGOs that can to do it.

4 comments

Out of Touch

The story of a Nevada state legislator who says that former Vice President Joe Biden touched her and kissed her inappropriately at a Las Vegas campaign rally may well have legs. It is presently being repeated by the New York Times, the Washington Post, the Wall Street Journal and is a prime topic on the Sunday morning talking heads programs of all four broadcast networks.

It is not news that Joe Biden is, to put the nicest possible coloring on it, an affectionate guy. The word “handsy” is frequently encountered in descriptions. That has been the case for decades. It hasn’t seemed to have made much difference until now. He was elected to the U. S. Senate six times and elected vice president twice, most recently just six years ago.

The story has so many angles one doesn’t know where to start. There’s #MeToo, generational differences, and political infighting. As might be expected the Trump White House is jumping on the story with both feet. The Washington Post reports:

White House counselor Kellyanne Conway is criticizing former Vice President Joe Biden after a former Nevada state legislator alleged he inappropriately kissed her on the back of her head in 2014.

Conway described the woman, Lucy Flores, as “quite bold” to “go against the highest levels of her political party” with the allegations and said Biden now has a “big problem.” Biden, a Democrat, is considering running for president in 2020.

Conway tells “Fox News Sunday” that quote, “He calls it affection and handshakes. His party calls it completely inappropriate.”

Conway suggested that Biden should consider apologizing to Flores.

Flores, who was Nevada’s Democratic nominee for lieutenant governor in 2014, wrote in New York Magazine that she felt uncomfortable with her interactions with Biden.

And what is one to make of people who remain silent when it’s to their advantage but speak up when that’s to their advantage? Ms. Flores is a Sanders supporter. I realize those last sentences will be condemned by some as sexist, racist, and just plain heinous. If we are to make sense of the world around us we must look at events unflinchingly, considering people as they are and not just as we would wish them to be.

Joe Biden is or at least was the presumed Democratic presidential candidate with the brightest prospects in the general election. As I’ve said previously I would vote for him in 2020.

I return to the question I implicitly asked yesterday. Is any candidate capable of winning the Democratic primaries also capable of winning in the general election?

I would be the first person to suggest that I’m out of touch. I don’t see how anyone could support some of the candidates stepping forward but, then, I don’t understand how people voted for Trump, either.

12 comments

Can the Party Compromise?

Maybe it’s just me but the field of candidates who’ve announced they’re running for the presidency as Democrats in 2020 appear to me to present problems. Each would require the balance of the party to abandon some closely-held value or major constituency. White males are seen as a rejection of women and non-whites. Old white males are even worse.

There is a plethora of candidates for whom any claim to authenticity is something between fantastical and surreal.

It seems to me that this is the logical endpoint of the heavy emphasis on identity politics that has emerged. Can the party compromise? And what or who will be thrown over the side in the process?

4 comments

Cosmic Smoke and Mirrors

I encourage you to read Andrew Bacevich’s latest piece at The American Conservative, especially if you enjoy polemic. In it he takes on Thomas Friedman but most especially Robert Kagan. Here’s a snippet:

…Kagan’s insistence on assigning a common label to the regimes of Vladimir Putin, Xi Jinping, Nicolas Maduro, Mohammed bin Salman, Abdel Fattah el-Sisi, et al‚—suggesting that they are devoted to a common cause and subscribe to a common worldview—is sheer nonsense. Contemporary authoritarianism does not derive from or express anything remotely like an ideology. Its origins are as disparate as its manifestations. It is not one thing, but many things.

I have a question. Why do all of Mr. Kagan’s prescriptions rely on force of arms? However politically expedient it may be it’s a violation of both basic moral and basic liberal democratic principles. How can one coherently condemn authoritarianism and espouse it in the same breath?

1 comment

It’s Their Problem

In his most recent column Washington Post columnist David Von Drehle comes out in support of leggings:

Today’s sleek young women are part of a righteous tradition that goes back to the suffragists more than a century ago. They traded their corsets for cotton blouses and their hoops for unstructured skirts. The right to vote and the right to move freely were of a piece. From that day to this, everyday fashion has trended away from imprisoning and concealing women toward liberating and acknowledging them.

“If some boy can’t handle my clothing choices, that’s his problem,” my daughter summarized. I’d say she’s exactly right.

I think she’s exactly wrong for several reasons. First of all private institutions like Notre Dame have significant leeway in defining what is or is not appropriate dress. Religious institutions like Notre Dame have even more leeway. And educational institutions like Notre Dame place themselves in jeopardy of suits claiming a hostile environment under Title IX.

Leggings are different than corsets (his example). Corsets actually impeded women’s ability to breathe—they’re the reasons that fainting couches existed. They were unhealthful, even dangerous. A dress code requiring that secondary sex characteristics be covered modestly is not unreasonable.

Besides, speaking as a former theatrical costumer, leggings are becoming to practically nobody. Nearly two-thirds of teenage girls in the United States two are overweight. AT the top of the column there’s a picture illustrating a row of mannequins wearing leggings. Very few young women today are built like mannequins. Leggings are a fad that can’t be passé too soon.

11 comments

The Case For Federalism

I don’t think that the editors of the Washington Post realize it but in their proposal for raising the minimum wage they are making the case for federalism:

The Third Way think tank has a plan that deals with these realities by setting the federal minimum wage on a regional basis. Each year, the national minimum wage would be set at “one-half of the hourly wage for nonsupervisory workers.” (The figure, in 2019, would be $11.55.) Then local minimums either above or below that would be calculated for metro areas and rural communities based on their living costs. Rep. Terri A. Sewell (D-Ala.) has offered a bill based on this plan, which would end years of minimum-wage stagnation without undue disruptions. Gov. Larry Hogan (R) of Maryland advocated something similar for his economically diverse state in vetoing an across-the-board raise to $15, but the General Assembly overrode his move on Thursday.

The deficiencies of this plan are obvious. Consider Illinois. Chicago’s median wage is significantly higher than in the rest of the state. Wages that may work in Chicago are unlikely to in Cairo or Mattoon.

The formula would require a federal bureaucracy to administer it and we already have institutions well-positioned to do so called “states” and “counties”.

Rather than trying to work out complex but equitable formulae for the minimum wage we would be better served by deciding why we have a minimum wage. Just as a modest proposal why dictate minimum wages at all? Why not dictate a maximum rent? Or the maximum price of a good or service?

1 comment

You’re Fired!

At the Chicago Tribune reporter/columnist Eric Zorn predicts that the Cook County States Attorney will lose her job over her handling of the Jussie Smollett matter:

Cook County State’s Attorney Kim Foxx probably will and arguably should lose her job next year over her office’s handling of the Jussie Smollett case.

Yes, there are many worse crimes committed every day in Chicago than staging a hate-inspired attack and filing a false police report about it — the offense with which Smollett was charged. And no, justice did not demand that Smollett be shackled and shipped off to prison for allegedly orchestrating a stunt.

But justice demanded resolution and accountability. And Foxx appeared oblivious to this imperative as she made the media rounds attempting to explain why her office sent Smollett on his merry way Tuesday morning without extracting an admission of guilt or collecting a meaningful fine.

Her tone-deaf statements included equating Smollett to the raft of no-name, low-level, nonviolent offenders who have received the “go and sin no more” treatment, and patronizing those who are outraged by the outcome as “people who don’t understand the intricacies of the justice system.”

Read the whole thing. My concern is that Mr. Smollett will sue the county and/or the city and we’ll be compelled to cough up millions we don’t have to protect Ms. Foxx’s and County Board President Toni Preckwinkle’s behinds. Misfeasance, malfeasance, and nonfeasance by Cook County elected officials really needs to end. Or at least slow down a little. Right now it’s accelerating.

6 comments

The Kernel of It

After some throat-clearing, H. R. 109 gets down to its kernel:

Resolved, That it is the sense of the House of Representatives that—

(1) it is the duty of the Federal Government to create a Green New Deal—

(A) to achieve net-zero greenhouse gas emissions through a fair and just transition for all communities and workers;

(B) to create millions of good, high-wage jobs and ensure prosperity and economic security for all people of the United States;

(C) to invest in the infrastructure and industry of the United States to sustainably meet the challenges of the 21st century;

(D) to secure for all people of the United States for generations to come—

(i) clean air and water;

(ii) climate and community resiliency;

(iii) healthy food;

(iv) access to nature; and

(v) a sustainable environment; and

(E) to promote justice and equity by stopping current, preventing future, and repairing historic oppression of indigenous peoples, communities of color, migrant communities, deindustrialized communities, depopulated rural communities, the poor, low-income workers, women, the elderly, the unhoused, people with disabilities, and youth (referred to in this resolution as “frontline and vulnerable communities”);

(2) the goals described in subparagraphs (A) through (E) of paragraph (1) (referred to in this resolution as the “Green New Deal goals”) should be accomplished through a 10-year national mobilization (referred to in this resolution as the “Green New Deal mobilization”) that will require the following goals and projects—

(A) building resiliency against climate change-related disasters, such as extreme weather, including by leveraging funding and providing investments for community-defined projects and strategies;

(B) repairing and upgrading the infrastructure in the United States, including—

(i) by eliminating pollution and greenhouse gas emissions as much as technologically feasible;

(ii) by guaranteeing universal access to clean water;

(iii) by reducing the risks posed by climate impacts; and

(iv) by ensuring that any infrastructure bill considered by Congress addresses climate change;

(C) meeting 100 percent of the power demand in the United States through clean, renewable, and zero-emission energy sources, including—

(i) by dramatically expanding and upgrading renewable power sources; and

(ii) by deploying new capacity;

(D) building or upgrading to energy-efficient, distributed, and “smart” power grids, and ensuring affordable access to electricity;

(E) upgrading all existing buildings in the United States and building new buildings to achieve maximum energy efficiency, water efficiency, safety, affordability, comfort, and durability, including through electrification;

(F) spurring massive growth in clean manufacturing in the United States and removing pollution and greenhouse gas emissions from manufacturing and industry as much as is technologically feasible, including by expanding renewable energy manufacturing and investing in existing manufacturing and industry;

(G) working collaboratively with farmers and ranchers in the United States to remove pollution and greenhouse gas emissions from the agricultural sector as much as is technologically feasible, including—

(i) by supporting family farming;

(ii) by investing in sustainable farming and land use practices that increase soil health; and

(iii) by building a more sustainable food system that ensures universal access to healthy food;

(H) overhauling transportation systems in the United States to remove pollution and greenhouse gas emissions from the transportation sector as much as is technologically feasible, including through investment in—

(i) zero-emission vehicle infrastructure and manufacturing;

(ii) clean, affordable, and accessible public transit; and

(iii) high-speed rail;

(I) mitigating and managing the long-term adverse health, economic, and other effects of pollution and climate change, including by providing funding for community-defined projects and strategies;

(J) removing greenhouse gases from the atmosphere and reducing pollution by restoring natural ecosystems through proven low-tech solutions that increase soil carbon storage, such as land preservation and afforestation;

(K) restoring and protecting threatened, endangered, and fragile ecosystems through locally appropriate and science-based projects that enhance biodiversity and support climate resiliency;

(L) cleaning up existing hazardous waste and abandoned sites, ensuring economic development and sustainability on those sites;

(M) identifying other emission and pollution sources and creating solutions to remove them; and

(N) promoting the international exchange of technology, expertise, products, funding, and services, with the aim of making the United States the international leader on climate action, and to help other countries achieve a Green New Deal;

(3) a Green New Deal must be developed through transparent and inclusive consultation, collaboration, and partnership with frontline and vulnerable communities, labor unions, worker cooperatives, civil society groups, academia, and businesses; and

(4) to achieve the Green New Deal goals and mobilization, a Green New Deal will require the following goals and projects—

(A) providing and leveraging, in a way that ensures that the public receives appropriate ownership stakes and returns on investment, adequate capital (including through community grants, public banks, and other public financing), technical expertise, supporting policies, and other forms of assistance to communities, organizations, Federal, State, and local government agencies, and businesses working on the Green New Deal mobilization;

(B) ensuring that the Federal Government takes into account the complete environmental and social costs and impacts of emissions through—

(i) existing laws;

(ii) new policies and programs; and

(iii) ensuring that frontline and vulnerable communities shall not be adversely affected;

(C) providing resources, training, and high-quality education, including higher education, to all people of the United States, with a focus on frontline and vulnerable communities, so that all people of the United States may be full and equal participants in the Green New Deal mobilization;

(D) making public investments in the research and development of new clean and renewable energy technologies and industries;

(E) directing investments to spur economic development, deepen and diversify industry and business in local and regional economies, and build wealth and community ownership, while prioritizing high-quality job creation and economic, social, and environmental benefits in frontline and vulnerable communities, and deindustrialized communities, that may otherwise struggle with the transition away from greenhouse gas intensive industries;

(F) ensuring the use of democratic and participatory processes that are inclusive of and led by frontline and vulnerable communities and workers to plan, implement, and administer the Green New Deal mobilization at the local level;

(G) ensuring that the Green New Deal mobilization creates high-quality union jobs that pay prevailing wages, hires local workers, offers training and advancement opportunities, and guarantees wage and benefit parity for workers affected by the transition;

(H) guaranteeing a job with a family-sustaining wage, adequate family and medical leave, paid vacations, and retirement security to all people of the United States;

(I) strengthening and protecting the right of all workers to organize, unionize, and collectively bargain free of coercion, intimidation, and harassment;

(J) strengthening and enforcing labor, workplace health and safety, antidiscrimination, and wage and hour standards across all employers, industries, and sectors;

(K) enacting and enforcing trade rules, procurement standards, and border adjustments with strong labor and environmental protections—

(i) to stop the transfer of jobs and pollution overseas; and

(ii) to grow domestic manufacturing in the United States;

(L) ensuring that public lands, waters, and oceans are protected and that eminent domain is not abused;

(M) obtaining the free, prior, and informed consent of indigenous peoples for all decisions that affect indigenous peoples and their traditional territories, honoring all treaties and agreements with indigenous peoples, and protecting and enforcing the sovereignty and land rights of indigenous peoples;

(N) ensuring a commercial environment where every businessperson is free from unfair competition and domination by domestic or international monopolies; and

(O) providing all people of the United States with—

(i) high-quality health care;

(ii) affordable, safe, and adequate housing;

(iii) economic security; and

(iv) clean water, clean air, healthy and affordable food, and access to nature.

I take that as a statement of objectives and my commentary on it has largely been devoted to pointing out that those objectives cannot be accomplished by the means also in the plain text of the resolution without dire secondary effects. For example:

(C) meeting 100 percent of the power demand in the United States through clean, renewable, and zero-emission energy sources, including—

(i) by dramatically expanding and upgrading renewable power sources; and

(ii) by deploying new capacity;

cannot be accomplished with existing technology and there is good reason to believe that the technology to accomplish it will never exist.

Recently, I have been taken to task for taking the resolution seriously and I should withhold my commentary until implementing legislation is made available. My view is that a it’s completely fair to respond to a statement of objectives by demonstrating that the objectives cannot be accomplished.

Remarks?

11 comments

The Mess of Pottage

Donald Trump has become an obsession with the New York Times. The Trump angle is sought for every news story and slanted against him. Every editorial or op-ed if not explicitly anti-Trump has an obligatory anti-Trump passage, usually near the beginning. What would have been deemed ordinary political bloviation in any other president (“a chicken in every pot!”) is now termed a lie.

They have little to say that hadn’t been said in 2016. It has become incredibly tedious, preaching only to the choir.

You don’t have to take my word for it. Read Peter J. Boyer’s analysis at Esquire:

Trump was referring to a front-page New York Times article published on August 8, 2016, under the headline “The Challenge Trump Poses to Objectivity.” The opening paragraph posed a provocative question:

“If you’re a working journalist and you believe that Donald J. Trump is a demagogue playing to the nation’s worst racist and nationalistic tendencies, that he cozies up to anti-American dictators and that he would be dangerous with control of the United States nuclear codes, how the heck are you supposed to cover him?”

he author of the piece was Jim Rutenberg, an important byline at the Times. He writes a media column for the paper, a feature deeply informed by Rutenberg’s experience covering politics and as an investigative reporter. Rutenberg has a keen sense of current thinking in the media hive, and when he wrote that “everyone” was asking the questions he raised in his Trump “demagogue” column, it carried the weight of mainstream newsroom consensus. Reporters who considered Trump “potentially dangerous,” Rutenberg wrote, would inevitably move closer “to being oppositional” to him in their reporting—“by normal standards, untenable.” Normal standards, the column made clear, no longer applied.

Trump said that was an important article because “they basically admitted that they were frauds.”

“They admitted in that story that they didn’t care about journalism anymore,” he continued, “that they were just going to write badly. That was an amazing admission.”

It’s an essential Trumpian assertion—wildly hyperbolic, but containing what much of Red America would consider a sort of rough truth.

The Rutenberg column was an astute and honest piece of analysis. The unavoidable takeaway from it was that Donald Trump, in shattering the norms of presidential politics, had baited the elite news media into abandoning the norms of traditional journalism—a central tenet of which was the posture of neutrality.

Read the whole thing. Like Mr. Boyer I’m uncertain as to whether the Times or the Washington Post or CNN can ever recover from the Trump presidency. I’m uncertain as to whether the very notion of the role of the major media outlets can.

3 comments