The Many Possible Causes of Autism

There’s an interesting article at Discover Magazine about the search for causes of autism. In all likelihood the root causes of autism are multi-factorial and, consequently, there is no “silver bullet” solution. The diagnosis of autism may not be particularly helpful at all.

Among the causes that have been suggested (in no particular order):

  • Paternal age at conception
  • Parental drug use
  • Exposure to environmental toxins
  • Other intellectual disability
  • Extreme preterm birth
  • Exaggerated maternal immune responses

The factors we can be pretty confident are not implicated are vaccines.

2 comments

Hillary Clinton Exonerated By Mueller Report

We have now entered a period during which the Mr. Mueller’s report will be dissected, paragraph by paragraph, sentence by sentence, and clause by clause, in a wild attempt at rationalizing conclusions that were not reached through reason. As I have been saying for some months now, the pressure on House Democrats to begin impeachment proceedings will only mount. IMO delaying the inevitable will not help Democrats in the general election so they’d better get a move on.

One of the notable passages in the report is this one:

The investigation did not identify evidence that any U. S. persons knowingly or intentionally coordinated with the IRA’s interference operation.

The “IRA” mentioned there is the Russian Internet Research Agency which managed the information operation about which people have been complaining for two years. As Glenn Greenwald points out:

The result of all of that was that not a single American – whether with the Trump campaign or otherwise – was charged or indicted on the core question of whether there was any conspiracy or coordination with Russia over the election. No Americans were charged or even accused of being controlled by or working at the behest of the Russian government. None of the key White House aides at the center of the controversy who testified for hours and hours – including Donald Trump, Jr. or Jared Kushner – were charged with any crimes of any kind, not even perjury, obstruction of justice or lying to Congress.

or, as I noted waggishly in the title of this post, Hillary Clinton has been exonerated by the Mueller report.

1 comment

Notre Dame de Laïcité

I wanted to make a last few observations about the cathedral of Notre Dame, partially in reaction to things I’ve read.

The cathedral is not owned by the French Catholic Church. It is owned by the French government and has been for two hundred years. The roof that burned and came near to destroying the entire edifice was installed in the 19th century, a reaction to Victor Hugo’s campaign to preserve the cathedral. The Catholic Church is merely allowed to use it.

The French government allowed the cathedral to fall into substantial disrepair. It had other priorities.

The modern French state is based on several pillars, including “Frenchness” and laïcité secularism. Those two values are inevitably in tension. What does it mean to be French without French history or French culture? The Church is a substantial component of that history and and culture. These are questions with which the French will need to come to terms. Maybe they shouldn’t rebuild the cathedral at all.

0 comments

Disappointed Again

I was pretty disappointed with the proposals of Josh Hoxie in his piece at MarketWath, “10 practical steps to bridge the racial wealth divide”:

The median black family today owns $3,600 — just 2% of the $147,000 of wealth the median white family owns. The median Latinx family has assets worth $6,600 — just 4% as much as the median white family. (These figures exclude cars, which are a poor store of wealth because they depreciate.)

Put another way, the median white family is 22 times wealthier than their Latinx counterparts — and 41 times wealthier than the typical black family.

Here’s what he proposes:

1 Baby Bonds
2 Guaranteed Employment and a Significantly Higher Minimum Wage
3 Affordable Housing
4 Medicare for All
5 Postal Banking
6 Higher Taxes for the Ultra-Wealthy
7 Fixes to Upside-Down Tax Expenditures
8 A Congressional Committee on Reparations
9 Data Collection on Race and Wealth
10 A Racial Wealth Analysis

The reason I was disappointed should be obvious. Even if all ten were implemented, they would have very little effect for a simple reason. The savings rates of blacks and Hispanics are lower at every income level than those of whites. See this report for more. Try as they might, torturing the data all the way to avoid it, it’s the inescapable conclusion from the data the authors present.

And that doesn’t even take into account another reality: the differences among whites are enormous, too. The Mr. Hoxie tells us nothing about the standard deviation.

7 comments

The Report

In just about an hour Attorney General Barr will make a redacted version of the Mueller report public. At this point I don’t believe that anybody believes that will satisfy the president, his opponents, or his supporters. Neither his supporters nor his opponents are deducing their conclusions from facts; they’re just restating their premises.

But that’s not what this post is about. This post is about a misconception about how our system is supposed to function. Under our system the Congress does not have the authority to demand executive branch work product. The Congress’s powers with respect to the executive branch are limited to just two: the power of the purse and the power of impeachment. The powers of the court over the other two branches of government are even more limited. Basically, it has none. Whatever power the court exerts is just honored by convention. The Supreme Court has no authority to order the Congress or the President to do or not to do anything, as pithily observed by Andrew Jackson almost two hundred years ago.

What raises all of these questions and, indeed, what put President Trump into office to begin with is the dereliction of their duties by all branches of government. I guess that’s the material for another post.

3 comments

Trump’s Veto

I suppose I should comment on President Trump’s veto of S.J. Res. 7. The text of the joint resolution is here. The president’s veto message is here.

I do not think the United States should be supporting the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia’s war against Yemen at all. I think that President Obama was wrong to do so and I think that President Trump is wrong to do so. I do not think the KSA is our friend let alone our ally. Both of us have a burr under our saddle about Iran. I’m more worried about the KSA than about Iran.

That having been said I don’t think much of S. J. Res. 7, either. As President Trump notes U. S. forces aren’t engaged in combat in Yemen and that’s the emphasis of the joint resolution. It’s an order to withdraw forces coupled with a shot across the bow.

Basically, what I think the Congress should have done is given the president 90 days to show cause why we should support the KSA’s war (support of an ally isn’t nearly enough reason) and then denied funding.

8 comments

Absence of Nuance

I had to laugh out loud when I read the opening of Margaret Sullivan’s column at the Washington Post:

It’s certainly possible that the news media will do a nuanced, accurate job Thursday of helping citizens understand the redacted version of the Mueller report.

It is also possible that the atoms of my hand will simply pass through the atoms of my desk when I strike it with my hand but I have no expectation that it will happen. I don’t think the prospect of the media doing a “nuanced, accurate job” of explaining the redacted version of the Mueller report expected tomorrow is a great deal greater.

But this was even funnier:

It’s possible they will do a better job than many of them did with their credulous and misleading coverage of Attorney General William P. Barr’s letter on the report last month in which they failed to adequately challenge President Trump’s false claim of being completely exonerated.

Got that? In her version of nuance it’s the job of the media to challenge claims of the president they find false.

IMO the claim of exoneration is like Schrödinger’s cat, simultaneously true and false. It wasn’t Mueller’s job to exonerate. That’s not what special prosecutors do. What he did not do was indict. If that’s exoneration, then it was an exoneration.

2 comments

Let’s Make a Deal With Chinese Characteristics

As I read this piece at The Hill by Arthur Dong on the emerging trade deal with China, I had a number of thoughts which I thought I’d share. I wonder if Professor Dong or the U. S. trade representatives realize what an enormous pile of codswollop this is:

While the trade settlement has not been formally announced, it is anticipated that China may modify its stance on some key U.S. priorities, namely:

  • China agrees to purchase more U.S. goods and services including energy and agricultural resources;
  • China agrees to open its domestic economy to greater foreign investment and reduced barriers to trade;
  • China agrees to open its cloud-computing sector to outside companies;
  • China agrees to enforce intellectual property rights and eliminate the requirement of sharing technology as a condition of entry; and
  • China agrees to an enforcement mechanism.

In the absence of a robust system of civil law in China, that’s a big pile of nothing. China will enforce the intellectual property rights of U. S. companies or “purchase more U. S. goods and services” for precisely as long and in precisely the quantities desired by the Chinese Communist Party or in other words President Xi who seems to be its Supreme Leader at this point. China is large enough that other than a few Potemkin deals that means nothing.

There are ways of addressing the intellectual property issue completely within the United States where there is a robust system of civil law. For example, any publicly-held U. S. company that surrenders its intellectual property for whatever access to the Chinese market they are deigned to acquire, as is their right should be required to report it to the U. S. federal government and all of that company’s intellectual property present and future should be deemed released into the public domain. Problem solved. Chinese espionage is another story. The federal government needs to take Chinese espionage much more seriously than it does.

As far as China’s managing its trade, imposing tariffs is the right solution. Until China’s economy is completely open to foreign competitors including its banking industry, we should impose tariffs in the amount of our trade deficit with China. Again—problem solved.

5 comments

The Fire

The church of Notre-Dame de Paris is still no doubt, a majestic and sublime edifice. But, beautiful as it has been preserved in growing old, it is difficult not to sigh, not to wax indignant, before the numberless degradations and mutilations which time and men have both caused the venerable monument to suffer, without respect for Charlemagne, who laid its first stone, or for Philip Augustus, who laid the last.

On the face of this aged queen of our cathedrals, by the side of a wrinkle, one always finds a scar. Tempus edax, homo edacior; which I should be glad to translate thus: time is blind, man is stupid.

If we had leisure to examine with the reader, one by one, the diverse traces of destruction imprinted upon the old church, time’s share would be the least, the share of men the most, especially the men of art, since there have been individuals who assumed the title of architects during the last two centuries.

And, in the first place, to cite only a few leading examples, there certainly are few finer architectural pages than this façade, where, successively and at once, the three portals hollowed out in an arch; the broidered and dentated cordon of the eight and twenty royal niches; the immense central rose window, flanked by its two lateral windows, like a priest by his deacon and subdeacon; the frail and lofty gallery of trefoil arcades, which supports a heavy platform above its fine, slender columns; and lastly, the two black and massive towers with their slate penthouses, harmonious parts of a magnificent whole, superposed in five gigantic stories;—develop themselves before the eye, in a mass and without confusion, with their innumerable details of statuary, carving, and sculpture, joined powerfully to the tranquil grandeur of the whole; a vast symphony in stone, so to speak; the colossal work of one man and one people, all together one and complex, like the Iliads and the Romanceros, whose sister it is; prodigious product of the grouping together of all the forces of an epoch, where, upon each stone, one sees the fancy of the workman disciplined by the genius of the artist start forth in a hundred fashions; a sort of human creation, in a word, powerful and fecund as the divine creation of which it seems to have stolen the double character,—variety, eternity.

And what we here say of the façade must be said of the entire church; and what we say of the cathedral church of Paris, must be said of all the churches of Christendom in the Middle Ages. All things are in place in that art, self-created, logical, and well proportioned. To measure the great toe of the foot is to measure the giant.

Let us return to the façade of Notre-Dame, as it still appears to us, when we go piously to admire the grave and puissant cathedral, which inspires terror, so its chronicles assert: quae mole sua terrorem incutit spectantibus.

Three important things are to-day lacking in that façade: in the first place, the staircase of eleven steps which formerly raised it above the soil; next, the lower series of statues which occupied the niches of the three portals; and lastly the upper series, of the twenty-eight most ancient kings of France, which garnished the gallery of the first story, beginning with Childebert, and ending with Phillip Augustus, holding in his hand “the imperial apple.”

Time has caused the staircase to disappear, by raising the soil of the city with a slow and irresistible progress; but, while thus causing the eleven steps which added to the majestic height of the edifice, to be devoured, one by one, by the rising tide of the pavements of Paris,—time has bestowed upon the church perhaps more than it has taken away, for it is time which has spread over the façade that sombre hue of the centuries which makes the old age of monuments the period of their beauty.

That is the opening of Chapter I of Book 3 of Victor Hugo’s novel, called in English The Hunchback of Notre Dame but in French Notre-Dame de Paris. The cathedral is a character in the novel, its most important character. Quasimodo is its genius loci. The passage in Latin Hugo quotes in the second paragraph is from Ovid and means, literally, “Time is gluttonous; Man more gluttonous”.

I do not weep for a building. Buildings may be rebuilt. I weep for Paris. I weep for France. I weep for Europe.

Without its history Europe is just a place—no better or worse than any other place. That history comes complete with wrinkles, scars, and sublimity.

The United States does not even have history. We have natural wonder, largely consisting of empty, undeveloped spaces and the creed on which our country was founded.

Many are quoting Emma Lazarus’s poem, engraved on a plaque on the Statue of Liberty, itself a gift to us from the French, from the children of France. They invariably quote the first phrase “Bring me your poor, your huddled masses” without quoting the second and more important second “yearning to breathe free”. It is not a poem about alleviating poverty. Those who came to the United States thinking its streets were paved with gold were mistaken. It is our creed that is important not wealth.

I weep for us.

0 comments

Notre Dame

When I first walked into Notre Dame cathedral what struck me most was the tremendous aura of spirituality it bore—greater than any other place I’ve ever been. I knelt to pray on the stone floor, worn smooth by a millennium of those who had come before and done the same.

It survived the Revolution; it survived World Wars I and II and who knows how many other wars and other catastrophes. The building may be rebuilt. Can that aura be rebuilt?

I seek to find something good in this terrible loss. I hope it moves a rebirth of the spirit of the French people.

Áve María, grátia pléna,
Dóminus técum.
Benedícta tū in muliéribus,
et benedíctus frúctus véntris túi, Iésus.
Sáncta María, Máter Déi,
óra pro nóbis peccatóribus,
nunc et in hóra mórtis nóstrae. Ámen.

3 comments