Today it seems that Bloomberg is two media outlets in one. In the previous piece I cited David Fickling argued that information is good, at least when it’s in the hands of the Chinese. In this article at Bloomberg Pankaj Mishra certainly seems to be arguing that information in the hands of Indians is bad:
The smartphone in India is also sparking earthshaking transformations in private and public life. To hundreds of millions of young and poor Indians, the device offers their first — and exhilaratingly simultaneous — experience of a camera, computer, television, music player, video game, e-reader and the internet. The smartphone compresses a timeline of technological advances that in the West took centuries — from the invention of letterpress printing to the advent of photography, radio, television, personal computer and modem – into just a few years.
A social and political revolution accompanied these technological leaps in the West: For instance, a rising middle class empowered by the printing press cracked open the exclusive world of a tiny literati.
India today is witnessing an even more drastic shift in class power. Anyone with a smartphone possesses the means to express an opinion and disseminate it far and wide, not only bypassing but also confronting the traditional elite of political representatives, technocrats and opinion makers in the media.
The experience offers few reasons to believe that faster communications will encourage greater democracy and freedom globally. Fake news, spread through WhatsApp and Facebook, has already fueled lynch-mob murders in India. It now threatens to influence India’s ongoing general elections just as decisively as it did the Brazilian elections late last year.
Smartphone owners are constantly exposed to high volumes of information and disinformation — both of which have a misleadingly uniform digital texture. One obvious result is the weakening of analytic ability — the capacity to distinguish between the essential and the inessential, truth and untruth.
And when state education is poor, private education largely a con and competition fierce for even menial jobs, conditions are ripe not for revolution, as Marxists like to believe, but for a mass exodus into the smartphone’s screen.
Demagogic politicians adept at social media such as Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro can only benefit when politics blends with entertainment, and campaign commercials as well as Bollywood videos flash forth from the same portable screen.
I think that I can reconcile these two apparently conflicting positions.
The ease of dissemination of information when every citizen has a sound and video recording device, a library, and a communications device in his or her pocket has simultaneously rendered secrecy virtually impossible, removed the ability of politicians to control the messages that people are hearing, and exposed just how greatly they have been working against the people’s wishes but rather in their own interests. This tool has not created opinions; it has revealed long-held opinions.
Here’s a wacky suggestion. If politicians want to be treated like philosopher-kings they damn well should start acting like philosopher-kings, beginning with austerity in their own lives. They can’t hide any more and it will only become more difficult with each passing year.
You cannot combat vice with even greater vice. You combat it with virtue and that cannot be faked.







