On Comments

It may be surprising to some but I read every comment made on this blog, generally refraining from responding to them but occasionally doing so. I get comments on even 15 year old posts with some regularity.

A common theme is to accuse me of willful ignorance for not lending credence to some conspiracy theory or other. As a blanket response to such comments let me observe several things:

  1. Not every post is about every thing.
  2. If you want to write about that, get your own blog.
  3. I try to give all sides of a question a reasonable hearing.
  4. Avoid the fallacy of onus probandi (burden of proof). It is up to you to provide good evidence for your views not up to me to disprove every theory for which little or no evidence exists.
1 comment

Why, Oh Why?

This October we will celebrate, if that is that right word for it, the 90th anniversary of the stock market crash from which many mark the start of the Great Depression of the 1930s which persisted despite strenuous efforts right up until World War II broke out, in the process changing our views about what the economy, politics, and government should do. It is one of the mileposts by which we reckon our history. There is before the Great Depression and after it.

There have probably been hundreds of books written trying to explain the depression, its causes, and why it persisted so long most completely forgettable but some, notably Keynes’s 1936 book Employment, Interest and Money, tremendously influential. We still don’t know and there are probably as many explanations as there are analysts, many of them, unsurprisingly, justifying views that the author held before engaging in his or her analysis.

I have little doubt that the same will be true of the Great Recession. Hundreds (at the very least) of books have already been written about it. This morning Robert Samuelson devotes his Washington Post column to commentary on the most recent salvo, by Ben S. Bernanke, Timothy F. Geithner and Henry M. Paulson Jr. Without reading it I feel confident in saying that it justifies all of their actions and blames every bad thing that happened on somebody else. Here’s a snippet from Mr. Samuelson’s commentary:

The book is a CliffsNotes for the crisis. The 129-page text provides a lucid chronology, followed by nearly 100 pages of charts and tables. The authors no doubt hope that their narrative buttresses their reputations. Still, most of their analysis rings true, with one glaring exception: their theory of what created the crisis.

Here’s one passage, “The story of how the crisis happened is . . . about risky leverage, runnable funding, shadow banking, rampant securitization, and outdated regulation.” A rough translation: Lenders lent too much, borrowers borrowed too much, and arcane financial instruments stymied regulators from stopping the process.

This is the conventional wisdom. It’s also wrong, because it mistakes the crisis’s consequences for its underlying cause. The cause lay in the delusional beliefs that the economy had changed so much that practices that in the past would have been considered risky were no longer so.

Everyone drank the Kool-Aid, so to speak. Economists argued that the business cycle had smoothed. They called this the Great Moderation. Recessions would be shorter and less severe than in the past. This seemed to be confirmed by the decade-long expansion in the 1990s, the longest in U.S. history.

Would it be too snide of me to suggest that the Great Recession itself and the long, phlegmatic recovery that followed shared a common cause, summarizable in four words? The Fed screwed up.

At the very least I think it is not unfair to blame the surge in the prices of financial instruments, e.g. the DJIA went from 11,000 to 26,000 today, on the Fed. That was the stated objective of the policy the Fed deployed to spur economic growth, blandly deemed “quantitative easing”. Translated: giving money to rich people in the hope that they would invest in the real economy. It has not succeeded, at least not in the domestic economy.

Whatever the causes of the Great Recession and the slowness of the recovery, very little has been done to change the system that was in place prior to 2008. Banks sustain even less risk than they did then, presumably in the hope that less risk will induce bankers to behave more responsibly.

My modest proposal is that there should be consequences for bad behavior. Consequences for managers, consequences for bankers, consequences for politicians, and consequences for Federal Reserve governors. It is only human for people to persist in their folly as long as they face no consequences for doing so. Managers, bankers, politicians, and Federal Reserve governors are far from philosopher-kings.

8 comments

What Fishing Subsidies Do

Against all odds the editors of Bloomberg have found something the United States is doing right:

Subsidies make it possible for enormous boats to travel long distances to fish the deep waters that lie far from any coastline. More than half of this high-seas fishing would be unprofitable without subsidies. Curtailing it would boost populations of migratory fish, helping to restock coastal fisheries.

China provides the biggest subsidies for overfishing. Japan, Spain and South Korea spend heavily also. But in the U.S., beginning in the 1990s, both political parties came to recognize the problem and pull back. For many years, Congress barred appropriations for new boat loans, and in the late ’90s and early 2000s even spent millions on buying back vessels, gear and fishing permits. These days, most of the government’s investment in fishing goes to research, monitoring and conserving fish stocks, and other beneficial activities.

The U.S. has pushed to end other countries’ subsidies. Prohibitions against them are included in both the Trans-Pacific Partnership (which the U.S. subsequently discarded) and the yet-to-be ratified United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement. The U.S. is also part of an ongoing effort at the World Trade Organization to cut subsidies for capacity. Agreement in that forum would be ideal, because it would encourage the broadest possible compliance. All this makes it especially counterproductive for the U.S. to change its approach.

We should continue doing it right. Not only should the United States not further subsidize commercial fishing, it should impose punitive tariffs on countries that subsidize commercial fishing, especially countries that subsidize commercial fishing as ferociously as China and Japan do with factory ships that virtually sweep all life out of the oceans. Paradoxically, such tariffs would encourage freer trade.

These are mercantilist countries who subsidize commercial fishing to maintain food independence and minimize their imports. Not only do their practices hurt the environment and us, they hurt developing countries. If they want to maintain food independence, let them. But there should be a steep price to pay for it.

And in case there are any hypocrisy-hunters out there, I oppose our own subsidies for cotton and sugar, too.

1 comment

The Best Old Sitcom I’m Watching

As I’ve mentioned before I subscribe to Amazon Prime. It’s not as worthwhile for us as it was when I was purchasing a lot of equipment and taking advantage of Amazon’s free two-day delivery but we continue to buy enough online that it’s still worthwhile.

One of the perks of Amazon Prime is Prime Video. You can stream thousands of different movies and television programs, some old, some new, some domestic, some foreign. I’m using Prime Video, for example, to brush up on my Russian by watching Russian television programs.

Recently, we discovered a gem of a Canadian situation comedy from the recent past that I’d never heard of: Corner Gas (2004-2009). We find it hysterically funny. It takes place in a tiny town in rural Saskatewan that consists, mostly, of a gas station and a cafe. Here’s the words to its theme song:

You can tell me that your dog ran away
Then tell me that it took three days
I’ve heard every joke
I’ve heard every one you’d say
You think there’s not a lot goin’ on
Look closer baby, you’re so wrong
And that’s why you can stay so long
Where there’s not a lot goin’ on.

If you’re on Prime (or find it somewhere else) check it out.

5 comments

The State of Higher Education, 2019

The infographic above was sampled from the organization Third Way’s assessment of the state of higher education in the United States in 2019:

This report examines whether US institutions of higher education are successful in educating and preparing the next generation of workers. Specifically, it looks at three critical measures of success: 1) college completion; 2) post-enrollment-earnings; and 3) loan repayment. It examines these outcomes at four-year, two-year and certificate-granting institutions. It also provides a breakdown by educational sector, including student success rates at public, private non-profit, and for-profit institutions. We also examine whether institutions are succeeding across multiple measures, as federally-funded higher education institutions should ultimately be leading most of their students to graduate, earn a decent living, and pay down their loans over time.

and it’s a pretty fair summary of their findings. They also find that many are unable to pay the educational debt they’ve acquired with the pay they’re bringing down with their degrees.

I wish the article only cited medians in the context of normal distributions and standard deviations. As it is there’s no way to determine the relevance of the median. They may be completely irrelevant as would be the case in distributions other than normal ones.

There is one interesting factoid in the piece. The majority of students of more than 10% of four year institutions cannot pay down the interest on their educational debt let alone the principal after five years.

Multiple different conclusions may be drawn from Third Way’s assessment. You could decide that more loan subsidies are in order. You could infer that non-loan subsidies are necessary.

My own conclusion is that the number of people pursuing higher education is considerably higher than the number of jobs that pay what people with higher educations might be expected to earn. One metric that might support my conjecture is whether employers are increasingly demanding degrees beyond bachelors of their applicants (they are). For too many young people higher education is no longer the key to a brighter future but a treadmill.

13 comments

The Shrinking Middle Class

I found this article at MarketWatch by Brent Arends about the shrinking U. S. middle class and anxiety over the same interesting, too. In it he has some useful information, for example, a definition of “middle class”:

The “middle class,” counted as people earning between 75% and 200% of the median income in each country, has shrunk since the mid 1980s from 64% to 60% of the population of richer countries.

61% of Americans were middle class by that definition in 1971 and 51% are now. The situation for millennials in their 20s is sharply different than it was for Baby Boomers when they were in their 20s. I can’t help but wonder whether that reflects economic or demographic change or both.

Here’s the conclusion of the piece:

“The recent stability in the share of adults living in middle-income households marks a shift from a decades-long downward trend,” he added. “From 1971 to 2011, the share of adults in the middle class fell by 10 percentage points. But that shift was not all down the economic ladder.”

I don’t find that encouraging. Maybe I’m perverse but a society congealing into an upper class, a lower class, and a struggling middle class, e.g. Mexico, considerably delineated by race, is not what I wanted or expected when I was in my 20s.

3 comments

The Real IBM

I’m sorry to say that Tyler Cowen lost me in the first paragraph of his post at Globe and Mail in defense of large tech companies:

It may seem odd, but it’s not unreasonable to say that the U.S. economy in the 1960s belonged to a company that, when it was amalgamated in 1911, was best known for its meat slicers, coffee grinders and systems to track employee punch cards.

The problem is that it tells a story that is either false or at best incomplete. All of the major typewriter manufacturing companies with the exception of IBM turned their manufacturing facilities to the production of machine guns and other military equipment during World War II. When WWII broke out Royal dominated the market. Upstart IBM used the war to develop the Selectric and when the war ended and Royal, Remington, and others returned to typewriters they had to play catch-up. They never really recovered.

The real story of IBM is that the company cleverly exploited the patent system to corral another development of the war—the digital electronic programmable computer by controlling the inputs (cards, electric keyboards) and outputs (cards, line printers). They never produced the best computers but they did enforce their patents ruthlessly and used them to dominate other markets, a clear misuse of monopoly power.

4 comments

Young and Unemployed

I encourage you to read this piece at Brookings on the more than 2 million young people in the United States who are not attending school and are unemployed. In the piece they profile five different subgroups. They are 17% of the total youth population. They are disproportionately black or Hispanic. Many are poor.

2 comments

Why Aren’t Wages Rising at the Bottom?

One way in which I could critique the editors of the Washington Post’s most recent editorial in favor of unlimited immigration of unskilled workers from Mexico and Central America would be to point out the logical fallacies it contains, all aligned in the same direction. Tertium non datur, non sequitur, and appeal to unnamed authority all come to mind.

However, rather than that, consider this passage:

That stopgap is symptomatic of what has become a broader worker shortage across the U.S. economy, which faces a shrinking native-born labor force as baby boomers retire at a rate of 10,000 daily , unemployment reaches historically low levels, and immigration continues to dwindle from Mexico, a traditional source of cheap documented and undocumented employees. In March, the Labor Department reported there were 7.6 million unfilled jobs and just 6.5 million unemployed people, marking 12 straight months during which job openings have exceeded job seekers.

The labor shortage is sapping growth as well as state and municipal revenue. Small businesses and major corporations have sounded the alarm as the delivery of goods is delayed by a drastic shortage of truckers, and housing prices in some markets are driven up by an inadequate supply of construction workers. Mr. Trump’s admission Friday that he will consider transporting new migrants to so-called sanctuary cities as a means of punishing those cities is probably an empty threat given the scheme’s blatant illegality. But if he were to fulfill the threat, he might do some of the cities an unintentional favor by providing them with badly needed workers.

The deficit is particularly acute in lower-wage jobs, as more and more Americans attend college and are reluctant to take positions in skilled trades and other jobs requiring manual labor.

Why aren’t wages rising for these workers? I think that’s the question that the editors need to address.

The wages of those without college degrees have been declining for decades. There’s plenty of evidence that not merely a continuing supply but the expectation of a continuing supply of unskilled workers reduces the wages of other unskilled workers. What do the editors plan to do about the situation of unskilled workers already here? Increasing the minimum wage will help some at the expense of others.

0 comments

The Rich Are Different From You and Me

James Freeman makes an observation about Bernie Sanders’s version of “Medicare for All” in his Wall Street Journal column. After quoting the relevant passages he observes:

The legislation does have a provision for private contracting for medical services, and assuming doctors, patients and nurses obey the various rules for such contracts, there would be a path for some small amount of non-government health care. But remember insurance products and corporate plans are not allowed to compete against the broad coverage promised by the government plan. And the Sanders bill prohibits private contracts “entered into at a time when the beneficiary is facing an emergency health care situation.”

So there would generally be no escape for patients who realize too late that they will die before they get to the front of the line for necessary care. But for someone who does not require insurance and is willing and able to pay cash for any needed services—and who contracts ahead of time to cover possible needs in a way that complies with the Bernieaucracy—there appears to be a narrow path to high-quality service. But how many Americans are financially capable of paying cash for any needed medical care?

We already have several different classes of health care in this country. That’s a decision that was made a half century ago. The classes include those on Medicaid, those on Medicare, those whose employers pay for their health care insurance, those whom the federal government subsidizes, and those who pay for concierge medicine. I’m sure that some will protest that the standard of care ensures that everyone gets the same level of care but the reality is different.

Under Sen. Sanders’s plan (as well as under the “Medicare for All” Act already pending in the House), those classes would be greatly narrowed. Under the present system most in the middle class have a pretty good level of care available to them. Under M4A there would be two classes: those who can pay cash and everybody else. What level of care “everybody else” would actually receive is presently unknown. You can assume the best or you can assume the worst.

I should also point out that, based on the snippets quoted by Mr. Freeman (particularly this: “the automatic enrollment of individuals at the time of birth in the United States or upon the establishment of residency in the United States”), the plan raises the prospect of people in the country illegally being covered by it which would seem to me to be a non-starter. That could be fixed by amending it to read “legal residency” but that could well be a non-starter for other reasons.

8 comments