The National Sport

This morning I was musing about the national sport. To what degree does the national sport of a country reflect the national character and to what degree does it influence it? For a century baseball was without question America’s national sport. Baseball’s heroes were American heroes, its stories American stories, and its myths American myths.

In roughly the third quarter of the last century, partly driven by how non-telegenic baseball is and the transition from sports being something you participated in or experienced in person to its being something you watched on television, football began to elbow baseball aside. I haven’t looked it up but I’m confident that more people watched the Superbowl this year than watched the World Series.

Football is very different from baseball and requires different traits and abilities. Do we reflect those traits now?

On a disquieting note I worry that professional wrestling is becoming our new national sport. Everything about it is artificial, contrived, and exaggerated. Our politics certainly resemble professional wrestling more closely than it does baseball or football.

5 comments

Unrepresentative Sample

Washington Post columnist Jonathan Capehart decided to gauge the popularity of the field of Democratic presidential candidates by putting the matter to his Twitter followers. The results were interesting:

What I found out was actually rather interesting. I couldn’t get through all of the more than 1,000 responses that I’d received by 1 p.m. on Thursday, but I got through enough to notice a really interesting pattern among my admittedly unscientific and self-selecting sample. While the new polls show former vice president Joe Biden as the runaway favorite in the crowded field, he’s not among the favorites of the folks who responded to me.

Sen. Kamala D. Harris (D-Calif.) was the favorite by far. She was the first choice of 117 respondents. That includes the 10 people who gave her all three of their slots and six people who gave her two out of the three. Seventy-five gave Harris their second slot, and 24 more made her their third choice.

Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) was the next favorite with 49 people giving her their first slot. But folks loved giving her their second slot, as 82 of them did, the most of any candidate. Another 51 responders made Warren their third choice, again the most of anyone in my count. Biden snagged 17 first slots, 17 second and 48 third.

I have no idea of the demographic breakdown of Mr. Capehart’s Twitter followers. I doubt that he does, either. I would speculate that whatever their demographic characteristics they aren’t representative of anything other than Jonathan Capehart’s Twitter followers.

I found this statement particularly interesting:

Harris represents the future of the Democratic Party: A woman and person of color in a party whose foundation rests with African American women.

There are so many things wrong with that statement it’s hard to know where to start. Presently, 74% of Americans are white. The proportion of voters is larger. The percentage of African American women is about 8%. IMO if the future of the party resides in African American women, the party is in terrible, terrible trouble.

But here’s another question for you. Whom does Kamala Harris represent? Do African American women accept her as a “woman of color” or, as Eugene Scott wondered:

Harris has had some different life experiences than many black Americans. Her father is a Jamaican immigrant; her mother is a Tamil Indian immigrant. Her husband is a white man from New York. While she was born in Oakland — a city with a rich history of African American activism — Harris spent her early childhood in Berkeley, Calif., and worshiped at a Hindu temple in addition to attending black Baptist services. She attended high school in Montreal before returning to the United States for college at Howard University, a historically black college.

IMO her candidacy will occasion a debate which is encapsulated here:

“This whole argument that we’re saying she’s not black is really ridiculous,” Yvette Carnell, co-founder of the American Descendants of Slavery movement, told the Philadelphia Inquirer. “We’re saying there is a difference in the justice demands for people who are descendants of slaves in this country and those who were enslaved in Jamaica.”

Carnell fleshed out the argument further Wednesday, tweeting:

“Kamala Harris doesn’t have that in her lineage. She’s anchored in two affluent, immigrant parents. It’s really simple. So since Kamala Harris doesn’t have this experience in her background, or a track record that expresses this understanding, and she announced during MLK Week, at Howard University, of course she’s going to get pressed HARD on the specificity of her #ADOS Agenda.”

(The ADOS, or American Descendants of Slavery, movement seeks to draw attention to the policy issues affecting the lives of blacks who descended from American slaves.)

That’s not frivolous. It will be a serious issue within the black community and it may well be one that the Democratic Party might wish to avoid.

5 comments

Riddle Me This

The editors of the Chicago Tribune, who did not endorse Gov. J. B. Pritker’s election to governor presumably at least in part in opposition to his signature campaign promise—to introduce a graduated income tax to Illinois, are critical of the Illinois Senate’s passage of the amendment to the state constitution to enable the tax:

After giving the matter seven minutes (not hours) of thoughtful deliberation, Illinois Senate Democrats voted Wednesday to put on the November 2020 ballot a constitutional amendment to impose a system of graduated income tax rates on taxpayers. No Senate Republican voted yea.

The promise from Gov. J.B. Pritzker is that under his plan, voter approval of the amendment would mean tax breaks for 97 percent of Illinoisans. But who knows, because Senate Democrats changed Pritzker’s plan, and House members could too. Senators tweaked the tax rates — and they larded up their package with two more promises: If voters approve the graduated-rates amendment, their legislation would eliminate the state estate tax. It also would freeze school district property tax rates if the state meets its school funding obligations.

The stated intent is to increase state revenues to enable the state to pay the public pensions they’ve promised.

Now riddle me this. Will the proposed legislation decrease, increase, or have no effect on state revenues? I honestly have no idea. I do not believe that any serious study has been done of the matter. Certainly not during the seven minutes of debate the Senate gave it. IMO it is quite possible that the proposed legislation will actually reduce state revenues significantly in the name of increasing them.

If you decrease state income tax for 97% of taxpayers whether you increase or decrease revenues by increasing taxes on the other 3% depends on how deftly they avoid the increase or whether they remain in place to shoulder the tax. If the measure actually decreases revenues it could be a real disaster given the state’s present lousy credit rating.

2 comments

The Peasants Are Revolting

I think you may find David Brooks’s most recent New York Times column interesting as I did. I don’t agree with all of his assessments but IMO they’re worth considering. He’s trying to contrast what has happened to the Republican Party over the last several years with what is going on in the Democratic Party now:

The Republican Party has been disrupted from the bottom. In 2016, the educated Republican elites were happy to embrace conventional Republican themes. It was the Republican base that was fed up and wanted Trump — something completely different.

The Democratic Party is facing disruption from the top. In the early stages of the current political season, Democratic rank and file seem to be embracing Biden and his traditional Democratic themes. It’s the coastal, highly educated elites who are fed up and want something transformative.

In other words, the Republican story is a story of populist radicalization; the Democratic story so far is a story of elite radicalization.

I’m not sure that’s actually what has been going on. Yes, yes, that’s the media narrative—the Trump phenomenon is the result of unwashed, uneducated bumpkins from the hinterlands refusing to accept what their betters know is good for them. I think what’s closer to the truth is more like what John Kass calls “the Combine”, i.e. that the Congressional leadership, Republican and Democratic, agreed more with each other than they did with the party rank and file.

But on this I think that Mr. Brooks and I agree:

The crucial voters in this primary election could turn out to be African-Americans. Right now, Biden is dominant among these voters. In a field of more than 20 candidates, 50 percent of nonwhite voters support Biden. Some of these voters like Biden’s longstanding loyalty to the party and its causes; some like his partnership with Obama; some are members of what you might call the Disillusion Caucus. They believe that given the racism and sexism endemic in American society you’ve got to nominate a white man if you want your party to win.

If these voters stay where they are, it will be hard for a disrupter to win. So far white progressives have done a poor job of wooing minority support or even marching in step with minority voters. They talk a lot about social justice but don’t support the candidates that minority voters actually support. Highly educated coastal progressives live privileged, affluent lives but define their identity as allies of the oppressed. This privileged pose involves all sorts of psychological contortions that don’t resonate with a lot of rank-and-file voters.

It will be interesting to see if any other candidates — Kamala Harris? Cory Booker? — can manage to span these two camps. Pete Buttigieg would seem to be an option, but his support so far is massively from the college-educated. Right now, Biden is in a strong position — offering progressive policies to a party that is exhausted and doesn’t want permanent revolution.

Consider the recent mayoral election in Chicago. Black voters voted overwhelmingly for a black candidate in the primaries. That itself marked something of a change from past elections. But the candidate that most black voters supported wasn’t either of the black candidates that eventually faced off in the general election. Their support came primarily from the white Northwest Side or the white Lake Shore.

7 comments

The CBO’s Rain

The Congressional Budget Office has produced a report on the considerations in implementing a “Medicare for All”-type program. The report is here. Here’s the report’s own quick summary:

The transition toward a single-payer system could be complicated, challenging, and potentially disruptive. To smooth that transition, features of the single-payer system that would cause the largest changes from the current system could be phased in gradually to minimize their impact. Policymakers would need to consider how quickly people with private insurance would switch their coverage to the new public plan, what would happen to workers in the health insurance industry if private insurance was banned entirely or its role was limited, and how quickly provider payment rates under the single-payer
system would be phased in from current levels. Although the transition toward a single-payer system would require considerable attention from policymakers, this report does not focus on the transition process.

At the Washington Post Amy Goldstein adds:

The political hurdles also were quickly evident from industry reaction to the report. Charles N. “Chip” Kahn III, president of the Federation of American Hospitals, called a single-payer system “a high-stakes gamble” asking, “Is it worth the risk of upending health care for every American when the law on the books already contains a road map to universal coverage?”

Here’s my question. According to The Centers for Medicaid and Medicare Services, Medicare spending per beneficiary is over $20,000 per year. According to the Kaiser Family Foundation, the average employer contribution for employee health care insurance was $5,477 (82% of the total). How do you reconcile those two facts with a plan than in theory would cost no more than is being spent at present, particularly if M4A is to cover an additiona 10% of the American people? What will not be covered?

13 comments

A Tale of Two Narratives

There are two competing narratives about what happened in the presidential election of 2016. According to one narrative an incompetent doofus prevailed over the obviously more competent female opponent by virtue of Republican shenanigans and the antiquated electoral college. In the other narrative a wily challenger prevailed over an incompetent but highly credentialed unpopular female candidate, losing primarily states that have large electoral vote counts primarily because of their immigrant non-voting populations, a violation of the principle of “one person one vote”. I don’t believe that either narrative is entirely true or entirely false. I think that Democrats are relying too heavily on the imaginary story they’ve told themselves about the 2016 election.

At RealClearPolitics David Brady, Morris Fiorina and Douglas Rivers raise the disquieting possibility that whether Donald Trump is re-elected may depend on whom the Democrats nominate:

Is it really the case that any Democrat can beat Trump? On closer inspection, that outcome looks less certain. For starters, history shows that one shouldn’t put much faith in trial-heat polls 18 months ahead of a presidential election. Moreover one recent survey experiment by YouGov indicates that a surprisingly large proportion of the electorate – about 40 percent — reports that the choice between President Trump and a Democratic challenger depends on the identity of the Democrat. These voters are “in play” or “up for grabs.” There are more of them than there are completely committed Democratic or Trump voters.

YouGov polled 3,000 Americans between Feb. 28 and March 3. We asked our respondents how they would vote in an election between Trump and nine declared or potential Democratic candidates (Joe Biden, Cory Booker, Julian Castro, Kirsten Gillibrand, Kamala Harris, Amy Klobuchar, Beto O’Rourke, Bernie Sanders, and Elizabeth Warren). To avoid voter fatigue we did not ask each voter to make eight decisions. Rather, each voter chose between Trump and three randomly selected Democrats, so roughly 1,000 respondents participated in each trial heat. If respondents said that they would vote for the Democrat in all three trial heats or Trump in all three, we then asked: Would you always (never) vote for any Democrat?

Democrats led in seven of the nine trial heats, but the “always Trump” and “never Trump” blocks were nearly identical in size: 36 of respondents said they would vote for the Democratic candidate in all three matchups and 35 percent said they would vote for Trump in all three. When asked the follow-up question, about one in seven said that there was a Democratic nominee who would cause them to switch parties. The good news for Democrats is that there are more Trump supporters who are willing to consider voting for a Democrat than vice versa. The bad news for Democrats is that 40 percent of the electorate say that their vote in 2020 depends upon the identity of the Democratic nominee. This is the largest segment of the electorate and consists of three groups:

  • People who preferred Trump over a Democrat in one or two of the three trial heats and a Democrat over Trump in the others (4%).
  • People who favored all of the three Democratic candidates in the matchups we asked them about, but in the follow-up question said that there was a Democrat who, if nominated, would cause them to vote for Trump (11%).
  • People who were unsure of how they would vote in at least one of the three trial heats (26%).

Unregistered voters are disproportionately represented in the last group. Among registered voters, the Democratic advantage is larger (38% never Trump, 31% always Trump, and 31% depends), but nearly a third of registered voters are “available” for Trump depending on whom the Democrats nominate.

Read the whole thing.

6 comments

When Bill Met Loretta

RealClearInvestigations says they’ve obtained a transcript of the House Judiciary Committee and the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform’s interview of Loretta Lynch about the meeting on the tarmac between her and former President Bill Clinton on June 27, 2016. You might find it interesting.

7 comments

The Democratic Candidates (Updated)

As promised here’s my assessment of the Democratic field. It’s a big field; I may have missed some. In the interest of brevity I’ve put it into tabular form and limited my comments to just a handful of criteria: the candidate’s name, age, baggage, and whether I am favorably disposed to the candidate. Some of the candidates are so unknown to me I simply have no opinion of them.

Candidate Age Baggage Favorably disposed
Michael Bennet 54 Who?; probably too centrist for today’s Democratic Party X
Joe Biden 76 Age; his record; he’s not a good campaigner X
Cory Booker 49 His imaginary friend X
Steve Bullock 53 Probably too centrist to make it through the primaries; no foreign policy experience X
Pete Buttigieg 37 Age and inexperience X
Julián Castro 44 Identity politics X
John Delaney 55 Who?  
Tulsi Gabbard 37 Anti-“radical Islam”; opposed the Obama foreign policy X
Kirsten Gillibrand 52 Weathervane;DNC  
Mike Gravel 88 Age  
Kamala Harris 54 Willie Brown; her record as DA; will not rally the black vote as Obama did  
John Hickenlooper 67 Long last name; too moderate for primaries X
Jay Inslee 68 Who?  
Amy Klobuchar 58 The staff abuse story  
Wayne Messam 44 Age;inexperience  
Seth Moulton 40 Age; inexperience  
Beto O’Rourke 46 Age; inexperience  
Tim Ryan 45 Age; inexperience X
Bernie Sanders 77 Age; policies  
Eric Swalwell 38 Age; inexperience  
Elizabeth Warren 69 Age; inexperience; lying about ancestry for benefit; policies  
Marianne Williamson 66 Inexperience; policies  
Andrew Yang 44 Age; experience; one issue candidates have typically not fared well  

What leaps out to me about this list is that it has a notable gap. Most of the candidates are either under 45 or over 65. Historically, the “sweet spot” for Democratic presidential candidates has been 45-55 and that group is almost completely absent. That is the price that the Democratic Party is paying for the Obama presidency. Retail politics was not President Obama’s highest priority and, as a consequence, the party lost governors’ mansions, Congressional seats, and Senate seats occupied by people in that age group during his presidency. A number of the candidates have never won statewide elections and, in all likelihood, can’t even carry their home states.

Another gap is in foreign policy experience. For a job two of whose main components are as command-in-chief of the military and diplomat-in-chief that is not insignificant.

There is no perfect candidate here. Every one has some sort of baggage.

I cannot imagine myself voting for Marianne Williamson for president under any conceivable circumstances.

Update

If the Democratic Party had not changed since 2009, candidates like Hickenlooper, Bullock, and Bennet would be seen as viable but not only has the party changed positions, the typical Democratic primary voter probably will not vote for any of them if only because they’re white, male heterosexuals. If any of them had enormous name recognition and looked like shoe-ins to win the general election, they might have a chance. Barring that, they’re out.

14 comments

Thoughts on Health Care Reform

I do not believe it is a coincidence that Germany, the United Kingdom, and France all adopted their present health care systems at the time of greatest national social cohesion. I think that a commitment to cost reduction is a prerequisite for adopting a single-payer system or full-on national health system (like NHS). I think that a single-payer or full-on national health system without a commitment to cost reduction would be a political, fiscal, and economic disaster for the United States. I don’t think we can afford the status quo (I don’t think anybody could).

I also think that the right way to approach our present problem is to decide what we’re trying to accomplish first and then figure out ways and means. I think the overwhelming likelihood is that we’ll shoehorn a means into the problems we’re trying to solve in an irresponsible way.

14 comments

The Situation in Venezuela

The editors of the Washington Post remark on the situation in Venezuela:

The Maduro regime has violated human rights on a massive scale, leaving hundreds of peaceful opponents dead, and it has led Venezuela into economic catastrophe. Millions of Venezuelans have fled to other countries, including hundreds of thousands to the United States. Having first been elected in 2013, Mr. Maduro forfeited democratic legitimacy in January 2016, when he purported to deprive the National Assembly of its powers because the opposition had won control the previous month. He then manipulated the political system to create a parallel puppet legislature and, on May 20, 2018, engineered his reelection through a flawed process from which both international observers and leading opposition figures were effectively barred. His inauguration as president for a new term in January, in defiance of warnings from neighboring Latin democracies, prompted Mr. Guaidó, leader of the National Assembly, to declare the presidential office vacant and himself its interim occupant, as provided in the Venezuelan Constitution — and supported by more than 50 countries, including the United States.

or, in other words, Mr. Maduro has been conducting a military coup against the government and people of Venezuela. Mr. Guaidó’s encouragement of popular uprising then is, at most, a counter-coup.

How should the U. S. respond?

The Trump administration has backed Mr. Guaidó, including — appropriately — through the use of tough new economic sanctions aimed at pressuring the Maduro regime to cede power, or persuading the Venezuelan military to oust him itself. Possibly, Tuesday’s events are a sign that Mr. Trump’s policy is succeeding; or, possibly, that there is nothing left of it but desperate measures. A hopeful sign was the immediate and unequivocal backing Mr. Guaidó received from six South American nations, including Venezuela’s four largest neighbors: Colombia, Ecuador, Brazil and Peru. By working closely with these countries, and not by intervening militarily, the Trump administration may increase the chances that Mr. López’s declaration Tuesday — “It’s time to conquer freedom” — proves out.

which you may notice is precisely the course of action I have recommended in the matter. The best thing we can do is to maintain a low profile. Let Venezuela’s neighbors take the lead. We may or may not be the “indispensable nation” but we’re not the only one.

South America is a real place with real countries that have real interests and where real people live. They are not merely appendages of the United States. Letting them take responsibility in a situation in which they have greater stakes than we is good for them and good for us.

1 comment