The End of Chavismo?

The New York Times and multiple other media sources are reporting that there are “clashes” going on in Caracas, Venezuela subsequent to the call by the leader of the opposition, Juan Guaidó, for a popular uprising against the Chavist Maduro government:

Anti-government protesters and law enforcement officers clashed in Caracas on Tuesday after Venezuelan opposition leader Juan Guaidó appeared alongside soldiers at a military base and called for the population to rise up against the president.

“Today, brave soldiers, brave patriots, brave men attached to the Constitution have followed our call,” Mr. Guaidó said in a video posted on social media, speaking from Generalissimo Francisco de Miranda Air Base, a military airport in Caracas known as La Carlota, in a direct challenge to the government.

He has called before for the military to rise up against the government of President Nicolás Maduro, but doing so flanked by men in uniform, at a base in the heart of the capital, was a new step. With few exceptions, the military has so far protected Mr. Maduro.

Mr. Guaidó claimed that “the definitive end of the usurpation starts today,” but it was not clear how many civilians or soldiers would heed him.

I have no particular fondness for the Maduro government. I do not believe it is good for the Venezuelan people and is rather obviously corrupt. However, I also suspect that the U. S. media do not give us an accurate picture of how much support that government has in Venezuela, particularly among the poor.

We may be learning that right now.

3 comments

What’s the U. S. Interest?

I reamin unconvinced by Michael McCaul’s argument at The National Interest that the United States should be providing more military and security aid to Ukraine:

The free and fair election in Ukraine of new President-elect Volodymyr Zelensky reflects a positive step for Ukraine’s democratic future, but the same challenges from Russia remain. There is still the looming cloud of Ukraine’s active military conflict with Vladimir Putin’s Russia, as well as ongoing efforts by the Kremlin to sow discord and chaos through sophisticated disinformation and propaganda campaigns against the Ukrainian government and society. If we want to deal a blow to Russia, then helping challenge Putin on his doorstep sends a strong signal that America will stand by its allies wherever they are.

Moscow continually ignores international law and the Minsk Accords by actively supporting the rebels in Eastern Ukraine and maintains its illegal control of Crimea while also blockading Ukrainian ports from vital commerce. More importantly, Russia’s November 2018 attack on the Ukrainian Navy in the Sea of Azov occurred in neutral waters and in clear violation of freedom of navigation. While the imposition of sanctions on the Russian officials responsible for these acts by the administration on March 15 are having an impact, the biggest blow to Russia is the continuation of a free, independent, and democratic Ukraine.

I think he’s getting ahead of himself. Let the new president of Ukraine demonstrate that his government isn’t a kleptocracy as every previous Ukrainian government has been.

I understand Russia’s interest in Ukraine. Ukraine was a part of Russia for hundreds of years. The port at Sevastopol is one of Russia’s very few warm water ports. Ukraine has a sizeable Russian population.

And I understand that U. S. support for Ukraine threatens Russia. I don’t understand why threatening Russia is an objective of American foreign policy. What? We have always been at war with Eastasia?

0 comments

Cannot and Will Not

At The American Conservative Robert Merry is stewing about the crumbling of the status quo:

When the status quo begins to crumble, the natural reaction of most people is denial. We cling to what we know, and the specter of the unknown often sends shivers down our spines. But eventually events overwhelm the denial and mock the shivers. That is going to happen in coming years with increasing frequency because the status quo is fraying in many realms of politics and geopolitics. Denial is rampant.

Perhaps the best prism through which to view this phenomenon is what we might call “sustainability.” What do we see happening in America and the world that is not sustainable and yet is not recognized as such? As it turns out, quite a lot.

Consider the recent report that Social Security costs will exceed the program’s income next year, which means Social Security will have to begin dipping into its $3 trillion trust fund to maintain benefit payments. And that trust fund, under current projections, will run out of money within 15 years.

He goes on to analyze the public debt, immigration, unipolarity as an objective of American foreign policy, and our policy with respect to Iran in a similar vein, characterizing all as “unsustainable”. I think he’s overly optimistic.

Social Security, the increase in the public debt, and our excessively truculent foreign policy can all maintain their present courses for quite a long time. Social Security may be reformed if the political heat rises enough. It’s hard to see how we limit the increase in the public debt. That has practically no constituency at this point. The preponderance of the evidence suggests that of itself it will retard economic growth but that will be dismissed as a systemic problem.

My toe in the water suggests that illegal immigration has reached a point at which pushback is beginning. How strident or determined that will be remains to be seen.

Unipolarity as an objective of American foreign policy and our policy with respect to Iran will be obviously increasingly absurd. How long we will hold onto them as their absurdity becomes more obvious remains to be seen.

There are other unsustainabilities. The concentration of wealth in the hands of the top .1% is nearing its highest level in American history, the greatest since the Great Depression. Political polarization is at its highest level certainly in my lifetime and probably since the end of the Civil War. Is that sustainable?

There is quite a bit of breastbeating in the media right now about the terrible murders in a synagogue in California. Not to rain on anyone’s parade but we’d best get used to it. There will always be crazy or just plain malicious people and there will always be means for them to act out their real or imagined grievances. There are no foreseeable measures that will completely eliminate such awful acts and, as the population grows, their incidence will increase.

4 comments

Apocalypse Not

In his latest Washington Post column Robert Samuelson turns to a topic that I’ve addressed any number of times here—the overblown fears of “robots coming for your jobs”:

Jobs have been eliminated; there can be little doubt of that. But jobs have also been created. The lesson from history is that inventions and innovations have typically been more than offset by employment gains. Automobiles displaced horses, and job gains were not only in manufacturing but also in gasoline stations, auto repair shops and highway construction.

Jet planes are another good example. Although they decimated most long-distance train travel, airlines now move vastly more people than trains ever did. A similar shift may be happening now. Over the past decade, 4 of 10 new jobs were created in “digitally intensive industries,” the OECD says.

On the other hand, there’s a tendency to exaggerate the significance of novel developments. Annual robot sales, though impressive, are equal to less than one-tenth of 1 percent of the 571 million jobs in OECD countries at the end of 2018. As yet, they haven’t destroyed many jobs.

Indeed, it’s possible — though the OECD study barely mentions it — that the supply and demand for workers, after many years of favoring business, is slowly shifting the advantage to workers.

The preponderance of the evidence is that automation creates new jobs and new types of jobs. Yes, there are fewer master weavers than there were 300 years ago but more woven goods are being produced at higher quality than ever before with more people employed under better conditions with higher wages for producing them. Yes, there are fewer smiths than there were 150 years but more goods made of iron and steel are being produced at higher quality than ever before with more people employed under better conditions with higher wages for producing them. And so on.

What we really have to fear is not a robot job apocalypse but the modern day equivalent of master weavers and blacksmiths having the power and motivation to protect their own jobs from automation, keeping those jobs artisanal and expensive.

1 comment

Women in Japan

The very best course I took in college was a history of modern Japan. It was essentially a graduate-level discussion course, there were just ten of us in it. The midterm was at the end of the first week of classes. It was a multiple choice names, dates, and places factual-type test, designed to ensure that we knew something about Japan.

Each of us picked a topic relevant to modern Japanese history that interested us, researched it, and presented our findings to the class. I think that mine was giri and ninjo as they apply to modern Japan.

One of the women in the class asked the instructor if she could present on the women’s movement in Japan. She was directed to find another topic because “there was no women’s movement in Japan”.

All of that came flooding back to mind when I read this piece in the New York Times on the upcoming ascension ceremony of Naruhito:

Under the Imperial Household Law, which governs the line of succession as well as most matters of protocol related to Japan’s monarchy, women in the royal family are not permitted to be in the room when the new emperor receives the sacred regalia signifying his rightful succession to the world’s oldest monarchy.

But the prohibitions go much further. Women are not allowed to reign on the throne. In fact, women born into the royal family must officially leave it once they marry, and none of their children can be in line to the throne.

Apparently, there are some things which have not changed greatly over the intervening years. I am told that public opinion in Japan favors an expanded role for women. Since Japan is a consensus society that itself suggests that there have been a few changes.

If the women’s movement in the United States were worthy of the name it would be more engaged in the role of women all over the world. In much of the world the situation is still pretty medieval if not neolithic. As it is the women’s movement in the United States appears to be primarily a movement of upper middle class white women, given the lack of interest in real women’s lives outside that group.

1 comment

The Secret of Success

I strongly recommend reading this study at RAND on the factors that allow U. S. military interventions to succeed:

Using an original data set of 145 ground, air, and naval interventions from 1898 through 2016, this report identifies those factors that have made U.S. military interventions more or less successful at achieving their political objectives. While these objectives were often successfully achieved, about 63 percent of the time overall, levels of success have been declining over time as the United States has pursued increasingly ambitious objectives.

As should surprise no one the critical success factors are:

  • Massive use of ground forces
  • Narrow political objectives
  • The quality of the institutions of the host nation

or, in other words, if you were looking for a project that was doomed to fail, our adventure in Afghanistan would be hard to beat.

5 comments

Sea Change

It wasn’t all that long ago when nearly all Americans were committed to a generally balanced federal budget. Jefferson did. Jackson was. FDR was. Even Keynesians thought (as Keynes did) that it should be balanced over the business cycle. That all changed in 1960 and it’s been that way ever since as this post by Christopher DeMuth at The American Interest on a speech by Pat Moynihan in 1986 points out. Here’s a snippet:

And here was Pat’s big, singular insight. Listen again to his strange admonition which seemed to come out of the blue: “The temptation is real to use debt not as a form of investment, but a means of consumption. Far from the denial of gratification, it can, and frequently does, reflect just the opposite.” Frequently does—he is not expounding Leviticus. And now consider his sally about borrowing a trillion and throwing a party. Pat was well aware of Reagan’s robust military buildup; he supported it and wanted it to continue. But he saw that something else was afoot. The public was not restive but festive. It was, he emphasized, getting what it wanted.

The flaw in this “borrowed benefits” theory of government is that it assumes a much more prosperous United States a generation from now than is the case today—forever and ever, amen. It assumes that Americans will be better able to pay in 25 years than they are now.

Are those still good assumptions?

As I have said before, I think we can run small deficits for a very long time without dire economic effects. The problem is that isn’t the case now and is unlikely to become the case for the foreseeable future. Also note than “can” and “should” are two different things. I think we should balance the federal budget over the business cycle but the Congress is incapable of that sort of restraint. I also think that the reduction of deadweight loss is a better fiscal strategy than tax cuts but that’s the fodder of a different post.

5 comments

The Field

I’m soliciting comments to consider in a post I’m writing on the field of Democratic candidates as it stands now. I doubt that many more will throw their hats into the ring and I wouldn’t be surprised if some withdrew even before the primaries and caucuses begin.

I can think of several for whom I can see myself voting, several for whom I would not vote, and several that I can’t see what possesses them in running.

What do you think the odds of the candidate who finally emerges victorious from the pack being a white guy over 70 years old? About a third of the announced candidates have the demographic profile.

8 comments

Playing With Fire

I sometimes think that Democrats do not realize what they’re toying with. At Outside the Beltway James Joyner takes note of a move to block ballot access to any candidate who has not released five years worth of tax returns:

A growing number of blue states are trying to force Donald Trump to release his tax returns as a condition of appearing on the 2020 presidential ballot.

The problem with this, of course, is that there have been Supreme Court decisions finding that state and local governments are not empowered to impose their own requirements or restrictions on offices whose qualifications are defined in the U. S. Constitution and the office of president is one of those. From Article Two:

No Person except a natural born Citizen, or a Citizen of the United States, at the time of the Adoption of this Constitution, shall be eligible to the Office of President; neither shall any person be eligible to that Office who shall not have attained to the Age of thirty five Years, and been fourteen Years a Resident …

That’s it. No other qualifications may be piled on top of that. Imposing additional requirements for electors to the Electoral College should be seen in the same light—an attempt to do an end run around the Constitution. They can’t impose their own qualifications for president, senator, or representative and they can’t impose their own qualificiations for voting for federal offices.

Consider this scenario. One of the states decides to abolish its present government in favor of a monarchy. That would be an express violation of Article Four of the Constitution:

The United States shall guarantee to every State in this Union a Republican Form of Government…

Citizens of the state who prefer a republican form of government would be completely legitimate in overthrowing the state’s monarchy by force.

I can think of little more likely to foment a civil war in the United States than such pseudo-legal politically-motivated gambits.

12 comments

Sen. Warren’s Profession

I suppose I should comment on the proposal by Sen. Elizabeth Warren that all student debt should be forgiven and that higher education should be provided free of charge or, more precisely, the full cost of higher education should be borne by the taxpayer. I think those are very bad ideas, I will attempt to explain why, and repeat the proposals for reform that I’ve suggested in the past.

To understand why those proposals are bad ideas first consider who benefits from the status quo, then consider who benefits from Sen. Warren’s proposals, and who bears risk. Educational and lending institutions are the primary beneficiaries of the present system while students who wish to pursue courses of study which will not provide credentials with which to get a job are secondary beneficiaries, bearing no more risk than they would in any event.

Under Sen. Warren’s proposal educational institutions would be the primary beneficiaries and the secondary beneficiaries would be middle to upper middle class families for whom risk, other than the risk of time, would be eliminated. Lending institutions would lose as would the children of the poor (since money is fungible). Additionally, there would be a grave increase in moral hazard—students would have even greater incentives to pursue courses of study which would not qualify them for employment or even slack off altogether. There would be no risk in doing so.

I agree with Sen. Warren that our present system is desperately in need of reform but my proposal would be to align risks with rewards. The five largest states should each close one of their non-performing institutions of higher learning (they all have them) and the savings should be used to create a free, online degree-bearing institution. I am agnostic on whether it should be a two-year or four-year course of study and degree.

Taxpayers would bear no additional risks. If those trumpeting higher education as our sole industrial policy are right, the rewards should be enormous. If they’re wrong (as I believe), all that will have been lost is time.

I would also propose the following:

  1. A formula should be found by which student loan debt can be dischargeable in bankruptcy;
  2. No federally-subsidized loans should be provided for courses of study for which there are no jobs available. An example of this would be journalism. Every year the J-schools graduate a third as many journalism grads as there are jobs in journalism and every year the number of jobs for journalists decreases. We need fewer journalism, psychology, French, art history, and interest studies majors. Courses of study which would qualify for federally-subsidized loans would be determined annually by the Department of Labor in conjunction with the Department of Health, Education, and Welfare.
  3. Educational institutions should bear some of the risk. Presently they bear none. Presumably, the form that would take is that students who graduate from institutions but are unable to get a job in their chosen field should have a legal cause of action against their institutions.
14 comments