Saving the Planet

The editors of the Washington Post are very concerned about preserving the environment:

NATURE IS not only pretty, it is also valuable. And humans are squandering its value with behavior that will grievously harm future generations. That is the bottom line of a landmark report on biodiversity that the United Nations released in Paris on Monday.

Too often, advocates for ecological preservation talk about conserving irreplaceable natural beauty, which is, indeed, a key justification for setting aside lands and waters. But that argument only goes so far when one is referring to a peat bog, a tangled mangrove forest or a tiny bird’s scrubby habitat — especially when humans struggling with poverty see opportunities to develop zones that are unsightly and seemingly unused.

In fact, these areas, particularly the threatened tropics, hold vast value to human beings. “An estimated 4 billion people rely primarily on natural medicines for their health care and some 70 percent of drugs used for cancer are natural or are synthetic products inspired by nature,” the report notes. “More than 75 percent of global food crop types, including fruits and vegetables and some of the most important cash crops such as coffee, cocoa and almonds, rely on animal pollination.” Plants, the oceans and other natural features clean the air and water, and they suck up much — though not enough — of the planet-warming carbon dioxide emissions that threaten human society. Preserving biological diversity preserves options and opportunities — to develop the next lifesaving drug, improve crops or adapt to environmental changes.

and I agree with their proposal to reduce subsidies for the consumption of fossil fuels. Unfortunately, they don’t seem to realize where the problem actually is. China, Mexico, and India all subsidize domestic consumption to the tune of $15-20 billion annually (China’s is probably higher but that’s what they admit to)—twice ours. Saudi Arabia alone accounts for most fossil fuel subsidies—$60 billion per year. We don’t have a lot of influence on policy in those countries but we should exert what we can and much of that would be by imposing tariffs.

BTW do you recall the infrastructure plans the WaPo is so much in favor of? A lot of that is backdoor subsidies to fossil fuel consumption.

11 comments

It Hurts When I Do This

One of the big differences between vaudeville and radio, television, or film is that a vaudeville act could earn a reputation and get bookings on the basis of a single act. One great example of that is Smith & Dale. Smith & Dale got their start at the turn of the last century but rose to prominence in the 1920s. Their act was “Dr. Kronkheit and his Only Living Patient” and they made a good living from that act over a period of a half century. If you’re not in on the joke Smith & Dale’s real names were Joe Seltzer and Charlie Marks and their first language was Yiddish. “Kronkheit” is Yiddish (and German) for “disease”. Get it?

The act had a long laundry list of corny wisecracks that have become staples, e.g.

SMITH: Look at this, doctor.
DALE: Look at — oh, that there? Did you ever have that before?
SMITH: Yes, I did.
DALE: Well, you got it again!

but probably the most famous was this exchange:

SMITH: Doctor, it hurts when I do this.
DALE: Don’t do that.

With that introduction, I’ve got to admit that I don’t get the point of Robert Samuelson’s latest Washington Post column. It’s ostensibly about income inequality:

Americans have long tolerated some inequality, because almost everyone would like to strike it rich. If you harbor these ambitions, you’ve got to accept the consequences. But today’s gaps between rich and poor, or between the super-rich and upper middle class, long ago exceeded these permissive limits. The present inequality must make all but the most avid enthusiasts of laissez-faire (“let it be”) squirm.

Anyone who doubts this should consult a recent study by the Federal Reserve. Until now, most studies of inequality have focused on income — what people earn or receive in a year. By contrast, the Fed study concentrates on the less common subject of wealth — what people own, from cars to homes to stocks.

The study’s most striking feature is how gigantic the numbers are. In 2018, the Fed estimates that Americans owned $114 trillion of assets, including $26 trillion of housing and real estate, $26 trillion of pensions (such as 401(k) accounts), $22 trillion of corporate stocks and mutual funds, and $6 trillion of durable goods (vehicles, appliances, furniture). Liabilities — mostly mortgages and consumer credit — totaled about $15 trillion, leaving net worth at nearly $100 trillion.

Income inequality is at the highest level in the United States since the 1920s, coincidentally also the period at which we last had the level of immigrant population we do now. Mr. Samuelson offers no explanations for the causes of the present situation or what we might do about it.

It’s not that great a mystery. Consider, for example, this recent study on income inequality from the Netherlands Central Bank:

…loose monetary conditions strongly increase the top one percent’s income and vice versa. In fact, following an expansionary monetary policy shock, the share of national income held by the richest 1 percent increases by approximately 1 to 6 percentage points, according to estimates from the Panel VAR and Local Projections (LP). This effect is statistically significant in the medium run and economically considerable. We also demonstrate that the increase in top 1 percent’s share is arguably the result of higher asset prices. The baseline results hold under a battery of robustness checks, which (i) consider an alternative inequality measure, (ii) exclude the U.S. economy from the sample, (iii) specifically focus on the post-WWII period, (iv) remove control variables and (v) test different lag numbers. Furthermore, the regime-switching version of our model indicates that our conclusions are robust, regardless of the state of the economy.

That is hardly a state secret. It was the explicit, openly-stated reason that the Federal Reserve adopted its policy of quantitative easing during the Great Recession in the hope that it would produce “animal spirits”. It flopped except in that it substantially exacerbated income inequality. After 30 years of Fed policy aimed at boosting asset prices it’s hardly surprising that the incomes of the ultra-rich and the rest of us have diverged.

My prescription is stop doing that.

34 comments

Unbalancing Our System

At OTB Steven Taylor has been musing about the separation of powers and Federal 51. See his posts here, here, and here. In the second of those posts a regular commenter here made an observation about which I’d like to comment:

I would just add that most people do not seem to understand how powerful Executive Branch and indendent agency rulemaking is. It really is shadow legislation, arguably a de facto fourth branch of government. I think the judiciary made a mistake in allowing this to grow to where it is today.

In the 230 years since we adopted the U. S. Constitution we have slowly been changing our system of government. Some notable milestones in that process have been:

  • In Marbury v. Madison the Supreme Court arrogated to itself the authority, ungranted under the Constitution, to determine what the Constitution permits. That was later expanded by Martin v. Hunter’s Lessee, Cohens v. Virginia, and a dozen later decisions.
  • The Pendleton Civil Service Act of 1883 established the federal civil service, ostensibly placing it beyond party politics.
  • The 16th Amendment, empowering the Congress to impose an income tax, had other, presumably unintended consequences.
  • The 17th Amendment, which provided for the popular election of the Senate, also further diminished the reach of state governments.
  • Wickard v. Filburn greatly increased the reach of the Congress.
  • The Social Security Act of 1935 and the Social Security Act of 1965, which set up Medicare, redefined the role of the federal government in ways that could not have been foreseen.
  • The considerable reforms in the earmark process that took place between 2007 and 2011 altered the role of the Congress.

Individually these rulings, laws, and amendments were intended to reform our system, to improve it. Corporately they have willy-nilly upset the careful “balance of powers”, granting far more authority to the president and the executive branch generally than could conceivably have been intended as well as granting greatly increased power to the federal government. I would also argue, possibly counter-intuitively, that the relatively small number of cases heard by the Supreme Court has altered the balance as well. The Supreme Court accepts just about as many cases per year as it did in 1950. I find it hard to believe that a country of 330 million people has the same number of cases of sufficient importance as to be heard by the Supreme Court as a country of 150 million people did. I think the riddle is more closely related to the workload the Supreme Court is willing to bear than to the number of cases it should be hearing, a profoundly undemocratic and illiberal outcome.

The effect of all of these rulings, laws, amendments, and practices has been to move power from state governments and the people to the federal government and from the federal government to the executive branch, particularly the civil bureaucracy. IMO major civil service reform has become a matter of pressing urgency. The contours of the needed reform are unclear to me but what is clear to me is that we are becoming quite authoritarian and, what’s worse, authoritarian in a way that is indifferent to the economy welfare of the country.

5 comments

Some of the Animals

Some of the animals are clearly more equal than others, as illustrated in this piece by Christopher Rulo at City Journal. The background is that in Seattle a woman was raped by a man living in one of the city’s sponsored homeless encampments. The author assisted the woman in making a short documentary video testimony about her attack. Here is the sequella:

Progressive activists launched a counterattack against Lindsey on social media. Local journalist Erica Barnett claimed that the story drew attention because Lindsey is an “attractive blonde woman” and dismissed the victim’s “many tears” as theatrics serving a false narrative that the homeless represent a danger to the community. She demanded that the media temper its reporting and be mindful that “graphic descriptions of violent rape may be triggering for survivors.” Barnett’s message was amplified on left-wing Twitter; Councilwoman Lorena Gonzalez claimed that Lindsey’s story would create fear and cause harm to communities “that may already be triggered.”

The reality: city-sanctioned encampments in Seattle have become magnets for crime and violence. According to the Seattle Times, when the city opened a low-barrier encampment in Licton Springs, the police recorded a 221 percent increase in reported crimes and public disturbances. Neighbors witnessed a dramatic rise in property destruction, violence, prostitution, and drug dealing in the area. According to King County Jail statistics, homeless individuals are 38 times more likely to commit crimes than the average citizen (the homeless represented 0.5 percent of the population but 19 percent of jail bookings last year).

Seattle’s activist class seems, then, to have more compassion for transient criminals than for the victims of their crimes.

I think it’s more complex than that. There must be some hierarchy, heavily weighted by race and class, for assessing victimhood. I don’t quite have the instincts for it and I suspect it’s rapidly evolving but there must be some way of making these assessments.

3 comments

Does Xi Need an Excuse?

I have a question about this passage from Hal Brands’s essay at Bloomberg on eschewing the “clash of civilizations” metaphor:

The Chinese government, by contrast, has embraced the concept of civilizational difference as a means of autocratic self-protection. Beijing has long rejected the idea that it should liberalize its political system — or simply stop throwing dissidents in jail — on grounds that “Western” concepts of democracy and individual rights are incompatible with the traditions of China’s unique civilization.

The U.S. should not be supporting this idea, even implicitly; it should not be affirming the civilizational wall the Chinese regime has sought to build between its citizens and the democratic world.

The clash thesis is also geopolitically dangerous, because here, too, it plays into China’s hands. The Chinese government has long argued that the world should, in fact, be divided along civilizational lines: That Asians have more in common with each other than they do with the U.S., and that Washington should therefore leave Asia to the Asians — meaning that it should allow China to dominate that part of the world. This argument provides an intellectual underpinning for everything Beijing is doing to push the U.S. out of the Western Pacific: Undermining U.S. alliances, building up its military, and weaving webs of economic dependence around its neighbors.

Is it really the case that China’s bolstering a dividing line between the United States and the other countries of Asia is a result of U. S. actions? Or would it proceed regardless of what we did? What’s the evidence that China would not follow such a strategy but for the United States?

My own view is that the U. S. should pursue its own interests and stop trying to suck up to the cool kids. Is there really a “West”? I think we have a lot more in common with Canada, Mexico, or Brazil than we do with the United Kingdom, France, or Germany.

I am also blithely unconcerned about China gaining the support of South Korea, Japan, Philippines, India, or other Asian countries. They are not fools and can handily identify what actually threatens them.

4 comments

The Influence of the New Immigrants

One of my favorite posts of the early days of this blog was “The influence of immigrants on American political thought”. My basic thesis was that each cohort of immigrants has left its mark on American politics. The Irish brought us machine politics; the Scandinavians progressivism. About the most recent cohort I demurred from making a judgment:

Most of our new immigrants are from Mexico and they will be no different in this respect than their predecessors: they have arrived with political ideas and beliefs they’ve brought from their homeland. I know nothing whatever of Mexican politics and will leave the commentary on that for other more knowledgeable people. But, as Mexican-Americans gain more political influence here, I suspect we’ll be learning a lot more soon.

I think we have enough information to start making a judgment now. The two most notable new developments in American political thought today are a newfound respectability of claiming to be a socialist and a loss of confidence in American political institutions. The most prominent of those who are claiming to be “democratic socialists” are either immigrants or the children of immigrants so I don’t think it’s too much of a stretch to suspect that it’s an exotic foreign import that is becoming fashionable.

That’s all the more remarkable considering how poorly socialism has performed over the last 75 years. Germany under Hitler, the Soviet Union under Stalin, and China under Mao murdered more than 100 million of their own citizens in the pursuit of socialism. Cuba is poor and dilapidated; in a little less than 20 years Venezuela has gone from relative prosperity to the point of collapse Chavismo; the examples do not stop there. There’s North Korea, Somalia, and North Yemen as well. To add insult to injury Castro’s children are prosperous and Chavez’s daughter is rumored to be a multi-billionaire.

More than a century ago, when asked if he were a socialist, Elbert Hubbard replied, when more people want to give rather than get I’ll be a socialist. The utopian community he started in East Aurora was more eccentric communal capitalism than it was socialist. Eschewing personal enrichment or that of your children would seem to be a prerequisite for espousing socialism but, apparently, that is not the case. To my ear today’s variant seems more closely allied to a highly American sentiment—the belief that there’s a sucker born every minute, which sounds to me more like self-interest, red in tooth and claw, than it does like socialism.

I do not believe that our problems in the United States are caused by insufficient socialism. I think they’re caused by inadequate social cohesion, a factor likely only to become worse, and, ironically, not nearly enough capitalism. As Chesterton observed, the problem is not with capitalism but that there are too few capitalists.

10 comments

About Those Health Care Jobs

I’m glad that Justin Fox is taking note of the growth in the number of health care jobs at Bloomberg:

Of the 263,000 nonfarm payroll jobs that the Bureau of Labor Statistics estimates were created in April, 27,000 were in health care.

This is not really news: Since the beginning of 2015, the average monthly gain in health-care jobs has been 28,959. Since 2010, it’s been 23,893; since 2000, it’s been 24,041; since 1990, it’s been 23,709. Only four of the 351 months since January 1990 have seen declines in health-care employment.

but I’m a bit disappointed that he doesn’t point out what the real problem with that is:

All this good news for health-care workers is not necessarily good news for the U.S. economy, though. Health care is a low-productivity-growth sector that, over time, has arguably been a drag on other U.S. industries. Plus, its share of employment can’t keep growing forever, right? A 27,000-job gain doesn’t mean as much when employment is at 16 million as when it’s at 8 million, so the percentage increases in health-care employment are smaller now than in the 1990s and 2000s. But they’ve still been higher in most recent months (not April, when the two were pretty much even) than the gains for total nonfarm payroll employment. The end of the health-care boom is not yet in sight.

Let me try to explain. Health care is heavily subsidized. At least sixty cents of every dollar spent on health care comes from tax dollars.

There is no such thing as perpetual motion. It never works. We cannot build a healthy economy based on a sector that’s funded by tax dollars at that level. The greater the number of people employed in health care the worse the situation will be.

2 comments

How Should New Antibiotics Be Developed?

This may come as a bolt from the blue but private corporations are not in business for the public good. The entire idea behind a private corporation is to find a need, satisfy it, and make money doing it. That’s why power companies don’t implement the kind of redundancy security experts say our power grid needs—they cannot make money if they do it. And it’s why pharmaceutical companies aren’t investing in the development of new antibiotics as Robert Langreth frets about at Bloomberg Businessweek:

Achaogen Inc. spent 15 years racing to develop antibiotics against resistant superbugs. It targeted one of the most-feared superbugs lurking in intensive care units: carbapenem-resistant Enterobacteriaceae, or CRE, a strain that can kill up to half the people it attacks. Last June its first drug, Zemdri, which kills CRE bacteria in the test tube, was approved by U.S. regulators. From a public health perspective, Achaogen is a success. But as a business, it’s a failure. Zemdri’s sales in its first six months on the market were less than $1 million. Achaogen filed for bankruptcy in April.

The failure has set off alarm bells among infectious disease doctors and public health experts. Big drug companies have been exiting antibiotic research for years, prompting the U.S. government and medical charities to step in with research funding. Now health experts are realizing that research funding doesn’t matter if there’s no market for the drugs when they get approved. “We have a broken antibiotic market, and this is a stunning example of how broken it is,” says Helen Boucher, a doctor at Tufts Medical Center and treasurer of the Infectious Diseases Society of America. The IDSA is “very worried” that other biotechs with promising new antibiotics are going to collapse if something isn’t done, she says.

Developing new antibiotics is a lot harder than it used to be. The low-hanging fruit was picked long ago.

The article goes on to thrash a bit about strategies for dealing with the situation. Solutions aren’t that difficult to propose. There are some things we can’t expect private companies to do. It used to be that the thought of governments actually building and doing things wasn’t as horrifying as it has become.

We might also want to think about cracking down on the abuse of antibiotics, both here and abroad. Overuse and misuse are among the reasons that we need to find new antibiotics in the first place. Maybe we should be imposing trade sanctions on countries that sell antibiotics over the counter. Heresy, I know.

1 comment

Do We Have a White Nationalist Terrorism Problem?

Maybe I’m being obtuse but I found Clint Watts’s post at RealClearDefense on the subject above terribly garbled. Is the source of my confusion the implication that Americans are somehow responsible for white nationalist terrorism everywhere?

Mosques are attacked abroad and desecrated in the States. American synagogues in Pittsburgh and San Diego have become the site of mass shootings. White nationalist terrorism has long been on the rise. Why doesn’t America do something about it?

Is it the conflating of political posturing with terrorism?

Not long after the election of President Barack Obama, all indicators pointed to a dramatic rise in domestic terrorism in the U.S. White supremacist threats mounted after America elected its first African-American president. Online conspiracy theories regarding the president’s citizenship and religion helped fuel a rise in racism intertwined with domestic politics. Alongside race-based groups, anti-government groups rose as well, powered by erroneous beliefs about abortion, repealing of the Second Amendment, or declaration of martial law.

Is it the failure to apprehend the fundamental difference between Islamist terrorism that reaches us and a single armed nutcase that kills people at worship in Southern California?

From 2001 to the summer of 2016, the threat of international jihadists far outpaced domestic extremists. Al Qaeda, the Islamic State, and their legions of inspired supporters knew who they wanted to attack and why. They were highly motivated to commit violence to advance their agendas. The challenge for jihadists came down to whether they could gain access to high-profile targets and whether they had the weapons, bombs, skills, and experience to pull off an attack. For domestic extremists in America, nearly all had or could acquire weapons; some even had training, but few were focused on who and where to attack—and almost none were willing to commit violence.

Today, domestic extremist violence outpaces Islamist extremism, and the character of the threat has changed dramatically in the last three years. Right-wing extremists and international jihadists from the last decade have many parallels and some differences.

Let me give it a shot. Every single Islamist terrorist group of international reach has had state sponsorship. Osama Bin Laden’s Al Qaeda was sponsored by Saudis. DAESH has had Saudi sponsorship. Do you see a pattern emerging here? The Taliban is sponsored by the Pakistanis. I could go on.

Contrast that with the murders in the Poway synagogue. I have heard no credible allegations of any state sponsorship of the evil cretinous perpetrator of those murders. I haven’t even heard allegations of a conspiracy in that attack. Just one malfactor who found likeminded people to support his venomous beliefs on the Internet.

The proper instrumentality for dealing with such isn’t the U. S. military or the FBI. It’s local law enforcement. Let’s not make a federal case of this.

The reality is that in a country of 330 million people a certain number will be vicious and with the enormous power that modern weaponry gives to individuals they will be able to do a significant amount of harm in a very short period of time. No foreseeable course of action will change either of those factors and holding out the possibility that there is such a course of action is delusional.

10 comments

Only the Dead Have Seen the End of War

I encourage you to read this offering at Small Wars Journal on ending the war in Afghanistan:

From January to April of this year, a National War College professor and eight student-combat veterans, Team 6031,[6] met weekly to consider two subjects: the American experience in conflict termination, and the potential for ending the war in Afghanistan. The material that follows is not meant to provide negotiators a searchlight to guide their journey, but only a few, well-lit candles to draw the attention of interested observers to important, and sometimes overlooked issues. We make no claim to having a comprehensive solution to ending the war in Afghanistan, only a few well-considered thoughts on the process and its aftermath.

We have divided our observations on Afghanistan into those about ending wars in general, U.S. objectives, negotiating peace in alternative formats, and creating the infrastructure and policy for future development and the maintenance of peace.

and here are their recommendations:

  • First, to remain patient and guided by long term objectives.
  • Second, to march in lockstep with its Afghan and coalition partners.
  • Third, to keep pressure on Pakistan to make peace and encourage Iran, India, China and Russia to play constructive roles.
  • Fourth, to seek a nationwide ceasefire as soon as possible.
  • Fifth, to accelerate interagency and coalition planning for post-conflict Afghanistan, and
  • Finally, to craft a new strategic narrative to convince friends and foe alike that the United States is in Afghanistan not just for a temporary peace or a “decent interval,” but also to accomplish its long-term strategic objectives.

IMO it is overwhelmingly likely that, tired of endless war with no discernible end or advantage to us, we will simply remove our troops and declare an end to our war. Let’s not be deluded into believing that will end the war. It will merely end our involvement.

If there is any lesson here it should be the grave immorality of going to war without the will to achieve your objectives. It is the worst possible course of action.

6 comments