First Down Then Up

Here’s a fascinating observation from Alexis Madrigal at The Atlantic. The adoption of cellphones during the 1990s may have been responsible for the drop in crime:

It’s practically an American pastime to blame cellphones for all sorts of societal problems, from distracted parents to faltering democracies. But the devices might have also delivered a social silver lining: a de-escalation of the gang turf wars that tore up cities in the 1980s.

The intriguing new theory suggests that the arrival of mobile phones made holding territory less important, which reduced intergang conflict and lowered profits from drug sales.

Is it also possible that criminal gangs have now learned to use smartphones in their activities and that’s the reason that crime is rising again. What’s the relative role between technology and demographics?

1 comment

Reminder

Just as a reminder all executive branch departments derive the entirety of their authority and power from the president. They are in no way independent of the president and do not derive their authority directly from the Congress independent of the president. They do not constitute a separate branch of government.

It is true of the Department of Justice. It is true of the Department of State. It is true of all executive branch departments.

If you don’t like the president, impeach him. If you don’t like that arrangement, amend the Constitution.

22 comments

How Systems Work

There’s an interesting piece by Joe Pinsker at The Atlantic on divorce:

Lange seems to have avoided repeating his parents’ relationship history. But divorce, as a thorough body of research has demonstrated, often perpetuates itself across generations—“children of divorce,” as they’re called, are more likely to get divorced themselves than are people from “intact families.” A parental split, it turns out, can shape the next generation from childhood on.

Researchers have been aware of the connection between a parent’s divorce and a child’s divorce for nearly a century, says Nicholas Wolfinger, a sociologist at the University of Utah. Further, as Wolfinger found after he started studying the subject in the 1990s, people with divorced parents are disproportionately likely to marry other people with divorced parents—and couples in which both partners are children of divorce are more likely to get divorced than couples in which just one person is.

Wolfinger says that researchers have some ideas about why divorce would be heritable. One theory is that many children of divorce don’t learn important lessons about commitment. “All couples fight,” Wolfinger explains. “If your parents stay together, they fight and then you realize these things aren’t fatal to a marriage. If you’re from a divorced family, you don’t learn that message, and [after fights] it seems like things are untenable. And so you bounce.”

One other (albeit minor) factor is genetics. By way of explanation, Wolfinger talked through a hypothetical generation-spanning chain of assholery: “Some people are jerks, and there is some component of being a jerk that appears to be purely genetic. So: You’re a jerk, you get married, you have a kid, you don’t stay married—because you’re a dick—your kid inherits some of the genetic propensity to be a jerk. And so they get divorced.”

I was tremendously fortunate that my parents’ joint response to their awful childhoods was to create the most stable, loving idyllic childhood for me and my siblings that they possibly could.

There’s a considerable body of scholarship suggesting that children do best when reared by their biological parents as well.

Commitment, marriage, stable parental relationships, happy, secure children, secure old ages. These things are all interrelated. That’s how systems work. Traditional values are a system.

If we are to reject traditional values as inadequate to modern needs, we might consider coming up with alternatives that achieve the same or better outcomes. Something to the left of “whoopee”, as Murray in the play A Thousand Clowns put it, is probably inadequate.

3 comments

Constitutional Remedy

Contrary to the way the media have been framing it this morning Robert Mueller hasn’t “pushed” anything to the Congress. Special counsels are not now and never have been the constitutional remedy for wrongdoing by a sitting president. That is and always has been the responsibility of the Congress. Mueller is just suggesting that the Congress put the Jack of Clubs on the Queen of Diamonds.

What we are presently seeing is the Democrats’ establishing the relative importance in priority of their goals and values. I know here I’d put my money.

Otherwise partisan bickering does not interest me.

27 comments

Those Pesky Details

At Forbes Jude Clemente has a reasonably dispassionate article on the five issues that any Green New Deal must address. They are:

  1. Spacing
  2. Intermittency
  3. Developing Nations
  4. Sinking Other Investments
  5. Fossil Fuel Inputs

I’ve been pointing out that last one for decades. To accomplish their goals the proponents of any GND must paradoxically be willing to increase carbon emissions in the short term if they are to reduce them in the long term.

2 comments

Supply Chains Without Chinese Characteristics

There are all sort of article around this morning about the next moves that China might make in the so-called “trade war” with the United States, most of them self-destructive which IMO is why China won’t do them. Niall Ferguson warns of a new Thirty Years War. IMO we’ve been in a new Thirty Years War since the Iranian Revolution but nobody has noticed that’s what it is. What else would you call a war without borders and without end?

You might want to glance at this piece at Bloomberg by David Fickling which explains why blocking exports of rare earths to the U. S. is just about the dumbest thing that the Chinese might do:

As is often pointed out, most rare earths aren’t in fact rare. Lanthanum and cerium are as abundant as copper and lead, and are used in such pedestrian applications as pool cleaner and cigarette-lighter flints. Even the more prized magnetic elements such as neodymium, dysprosium, praseodymium and samarium are humdrum enough that Apple Inc. uses rare-earth magnets to make its power cables stick in place. Pottery enthusiasts can pick up neodymium oxide for around $50 a kilogram online to give a blue tint to their glazes; that’s probably a bit more neodymium than you’d find in a typical electric car.

Supply is particularly generous when you set it against the most crucial and alarming segment of demand: military hardware. This amounts to no more than around 500 metric tons a year, according to a U.S. Department of Defense study, equivalent to what you’d get from Lynas’s plant in about 10 days. Solvay SA, a French chemicals company, recently set up a demonstration project to produce nearly 200 tons a year of rare earths just from recycling light bulbs.

In hindsight, the U.S. government might have been wise earlier this decade to provide the loan guarantees to put Mountain Pass on a more solid footing.

It might be worthwhile to consider why the Department of Energy demurred from guaranteeing Molycorp’s loans. It was mostly the Obama Administration’s environmental concerns.

The only dumber thing the Chinese might do would be to dump Treasuries, something that would remind me of nothing so much as that scene in Blazing Saddles in which Cleavon Little held a gun to his own head.

15 comments

The Less You Know

I don’t think that Bruce Jepsen really understands why in his words:

much is to be done to educate the public at large even as single payer supporters like Sens. Bernie Sanders, Elizabeth Warren and Kamala Harris push Medicare for All on the campaign trail.

Read his piece at Forbes. It’s actually a pretty fair survey of some of the plans out there.

The reason is that only having a slogan maximizes support. You don’t need to get into analyzing, producing, or defending the messy details. Once you get into the messy details opposition will mobilize quickly.

That same principle applies to a broad swathe of hot-button political items including the Green New Deal and “comprehensive immigration reform”. Yes, there are plans out there but no omnibus plan, no “real” plan. It’s a nice strategy as long as you can make it work. It also provides the opportunity to draw yourself up to your full height and demand that your political opponents produce their plans. Playing defense is easier than offense.

2 comments

Another Perfectly Fine Idea

…shot to hell. At Forbes Sally Pipes reports on the results of implementing electronic health records (EHR), one of the provisions of the Affordable Care Act:

The EHR push started with the 2009 American Recovery and Reinvestment Act. President Obama approved billions in spending to encourage the healthcare industry to embrace the technology. Doctors and hospitals who failed to adopt a government-approved digital system by the end of 2014 faced cuts in their Medicare reimbursements.

So providers rushed to implement EHRs. Ninety-six percent of hospitals have EHR systems today, up from 9% in 2008. Most doctors adopted them as well.

But these EHRs ended up being seriously flawed—and dangerous for patients.

For one, patient records routinely have errors. In one survey, 21% of patients reported mistakes in their own electronic medical records. In some cases, when a physician pulls up a patient profile, the system displays a doctor’s note for a different patient.

Other issues abound. Systems are supposed to flag potentially dangerous drug orders but often fail to do so. Records frequently don’t list the correct start and stop dates for prescriptions. And transmitting data between systems is a huge challenge.

Consequently, the recent Fortune-KHN investigation revealed, “alarming reports of patient deaths, serious injuries and near misses—thousands of them—tied to software glitches, user errors and other flaws.”

More than 3,000 medication errors at pediatric hospitals from 2012 to 2017 were due in part to EHR problems, a study in Health Affairs found. About one in five of these could have caused patient harm.

A 2016 test simulation of hospital EHRs revealed that, in roughly four in ten cases, the system failed to detect potentially harmful drug orders. Of those, 13% could have been fatal errors.

I take a sort of perverse satisfaction in seeing that just about everything I have predicted about EHR has actually happened. Back in 2010 or 2011 I recounted the story of the presentation by an EHR vendor to one of my physician clients. At the conclusion of the horrifically arrogant presentation and after the vendor had left, I turned to my client and said “You were much more polite than I would have been. I would have thrown him out a half hour ago.”

Good systems and health care are not a congenial match. It is rare indeed that a system is designed following an industry-wide study of needs and practices. What is much more common is that systems will be what is easy to implement, what is fashionable, what a single client would pay the designers or implementers for, or whatever sticks against the wall. I haven’t look at EHR systems for a while but I would predict that today’s systems have all sorts of glossy claims about artificial intelligence, blockchain, and other buzzwords du jour.

I have looked casually at the systems being used by my wife’s health care providers and so far all of them have been ghastly. Any system in which the physician, PA, or nurse is tethered to a monitor and keyboard IMO is a failure.

Regardless, I think that EHR systems have tremendous, largely unrealized potential. It will take a while before it is realized.

8 comments

What’s That Got To Do With the Price of Gas?

There is a school of thought that all economic growth can be traced back to the price of gasoline. More broadly, that school would hold that the more energy that is produced, the greater the economic growth. Consider the chart above in that context.

That, too, is the context of this post at RealClearEnergy from Kathleen Hartnett White:

The economy is picking up steam. Fears of a recession have faded. Unemployment has hit a 50-year low, and it could go even lower. Wages are rising, and consumer confidence is sky-high.

Energy is driving all of those indicators. Cheap, abundant, concentrated energy fuels a manufacturing boom. Consumption of electricity has a direct correlation with economic growth. Our GDP, indeed, is rising at a brisk pace.

There is no inherent conflict between that view and strategies for a greener future. There is a conflict between that view and anti-development and BANANA strategies. Care should be taken to avoid conflating opposition to anything that might actually produce more energy with advocating strategies to use resources more efficiently, release fewer pollutants into the air, or decrease carbon dioxide emissions.

0 comments

Moving Down the Division of Labor

I agree with a lot of what’s in this piece at Founder’s Broadsheet but not this:

Populist nationalists in the Republican Party and socialists in the Democratic Party both believe that government should intervene to protect society’s members from the disruptive effects of economic development. They both believe that government can do a good job at this. Both share a delusive nostalgia for a bygone manufacturing era that cannot possibly return — as manufacturing becomes more capital-intensive and dependent on fewer but better educated workers.

[…]

We certainly need to thwart Chinese theft of US trade and defense secrets, but if China wants to take over and subsidize the production of our low-tech manufactures so our workers can move up in the division of labor, so much the better. It’s the Chinese theft of US trade secrets in advanced and military-related products that should concern us and their attempts to thwart the marketing of these products where our companies attempt to do so in China.

The emphasis is mine. It would be fine if that were happening but it isn’t and the author must surely know it. Just look at any monthly Bureau of Labor Statistics Employment Situation Report. Manufacturing jobs have been replace by service sector jobs requiring even lower skills and paying considerably less. I’d like to see his model of how that is good for most Americans.

The problem of our self-destructive relationship with China is not merely that the Chinese are capitalizing on our investments by letting us do the R&D, it’s that they’re using what they gain to force the U. S. economy into an dead end niche. We are a very diverse country and we need an equally diverse economy, one in which there’s room not only for professional and highly-skilled manufacturing workers but less-skilled workers, primary production, and agriculture.

6 comments