Comeuppance

At RealClearPolitics Charles Lipson warns that various law enforcement and intelligence officials are about to receive their comeuppance:

Over the next few months, we will learn the extent of that failure. We will see if top officials misused their agencies to investigate and crush their political opponents. Constitutional democracies cannot permit that. They cannot wave it off as yesterday’s news and expect to survive unscathed. If undetected and unpunished, it will happen again to another party, another candidate.

As the evidence comes out, a hard rain’s gonna fall. The damage will be compounded by partisan divisions, corroding trust in our basic institutions, and an impending election. For democracy’s sake, let’s hope the bitter winds are not a Cat-5 storm.

I don’t know. I’d be willing to bet a shiny new dime that not one of the worthies mentioned by Professor Lipson (James Comey, John Brennan, James Clapper, Loretta Lynch, and their senior aides) are ever convicted of anything. There’s already an iron-clad case for perjury against several of them and they haven’t even been indicted.

I’d also be willing to bet that all of their net worths are higher today than on the day they took office. Nice gig.

16 comments

Illinois’s Big Idea

Meanwhile, here in Illinois the Democrats in the state legislature have another big idea on which they can agree—that there is no limit to the amount of revenue that may be extracted from the taxpayers of the state of Illinois as this Sun-Times column from Mark Brown explains:

Sometime before the end of the coming week, the Illinois General Assembly is expected to approve a constitutional amendment allowing for a graduated state income tax, at long last putting the matter before voters in the 2020 general election.

What happens next is something most Illinois voters may have never seen: a chance to directly decide a major public policy issue by referendum, accompanied by the bruising campaign that goes with it.

I’m looking forward to the vote, having believed for some time that Illinois needs to scrap its flat tax, but dreading the campaign that will come first.

All the same mechanisms we are accustomed to seeing deployed in support of major political candidates — tons of television, digital and direct mail advertising — will be trained instead on an idea. The nuances of tax policy will be reduced to 15- and 30-second spots that further exploit our culture wars.

IMO Gov. Pritzker’s “Fair Tax” proposal is less workable in Illinois than it might be elsewhere for the simple reason that while the legislature may be able to raise the marginal tax rates on “the rich” they can’t force the actual rich to stay here. Note that those making $250,000 per year, the proposed threshold for those who will pay more taxes, include married couples consisting of a Chicago firefighter and a Chicago public high school teacher or the median physician. They will find it harder to leave Illinois than the top management of a big company will. Illinois is losing population faster than any other state in the Union and I suspect the “Fair Tax” will not slow that process.

4 comments

The Parties With Just Two Ideas

Have the two major political parties become parties with just two big ideas on which their members can agree? For Republicans those ideas are a) cutting taxes and b) opposing a sitting Democratic president. Needless to say Democrats have a similar resistance to presidents of the opposing party. This editorial from the Washington Post may give you some inkling of what the other idea is:

THE MOST enduring — and unforgivable — civil rights offense in our country today is the consigning of so many poor, often minority children to failing schools. Among the more promising efforts to deal with this urgent issue have been public charter schools, which give poor families the choice in their children’s education that more prosperous parents take for granted. That makes all the more distressing the bid by some Democrats to blame charter schools for all the ills of public education.

Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.), a candidate to become the Democratic presidential nominee, launched a broadside against charter schools, calling for a moratorium on federal funding for all charter schools and a ban on for-profit charters (which account for a small proportion of charters). “The proliferation of charter schools has disproportionately affected communities of color,” wrote Mr. Sanders as part of his 10-point education plan this month.

Mr. Sanders is right about the outsize effects on minority communities — but those effects have been positive, not negative. Of the nearly 3.2 million public charter school students, 68 percent are students of color, with 26 percent of them African Americans. Studies indicate that students of color, students from low-income families and English-language learners enrolled in public charter schools make greater academic progress than their peers in traditional schools. Research from Stanford University’s Center for Research on Education Outcomes found that African American students in charter schools gained an additional 59 days of learning in math and 44 days in reading per year compared with their traditional school counterparts.

Charter schools are not a replacement for traditional schools, and not all charter schools are good. Bad ones should not be tolerated. But blanket calls to curtail charter schools are wrongheaded. There is a reason that parents line up on waiting lists for coveted high-quality charter schools. Like wealthy parents who pay for private schooling or middle-class parents who move to neighborhoods for better schools, poor parents want a good education for their children. Without it, they know there will be diminished hope for upward mobility and a better future.

The politics of charter schools have always been fraught for Democrats because of the influence of teachers unions — which oppose charters for reasons having nothing to do with the welfare of children. We hope candidates keep in mind the polls that consistently show support for charters among black and Hispanic voters. It’s easy to oppose charters if you are well-off and live in a suburb with good schools. We hope we will also hear from candidates who know about the value of charters from their experiences — including as a mayor who used them to begin to turn around a failing district, as a partner in an administration that promoted charters, as a schools superintendent who made a place for charters.

George Santayana once quipped that a fanatic is someone who redoubles his efforts after having lost sight of his goals. It is not too much to say that Democrats’ support of public employees’ unions has become fanatical, to the actual detriment of the goals purportedly being sought.

We need to open a new can of political parties.

10 comments

The Energy of the Future

There’s an article about a nuclear fusion start-up at Forbes you might be interested in:

Walking with Michl Binderbauer into his 2-acre laboratory feels a bit like taking a factory tour with Willy Wonka. In one corner Binderbauer, chief executive of TAE Technologies, shows off a new machine that blasts cancer tumors with a neutron beam. Engineers huddle in a control room. Beyond their window: Norman.

That’s the name of TAE’s 100-foot-long prototype nuclear fusion reactor, a magnificent assemblage of stainless steel vessels, electromagnets and particle accelerator tubes. Once every eight minutes Norman emits a clang, as it transforms 100 million watts of electricity into a cloud of 30 million degree Celsius plasma that it blasts with beams of protons (the simplest form of hydrogen). They smash together with enough force to fuse into helium—releasing copious amounts of energy in the process. “It’s a function of violence,” says Binderbauer, 50, with a smile.

TAE, known until last year as Tri Alpha Energy, has raised $600 million, most recently at a valuation of more than $2 billion. Investors include the late Paul Allen’s Vulcan Capital, the Rockefeller family’s Venrock, and Big Sky Capital, family money of billionaire stock trader Charles Schwab. They’re betting that TAE will be able to tame fusion into a source of electricity.That’s the name of TAE’s 100-foot-long prototype nuclear fusion reactor, a magnificent assemblage of stainless steel vessels, electromagnets and particle accelerator tubes. Once every eight minutes Norman emits a clang, as it transforms 100 million watts of electricity into a cloud of 30 million degree Celsius plasma that it blasts with beams of protons (the simplest form of hydrogen). They smash together with enough force to fuse into helium—releasing copious amounts of energy in the process. “It’s a function of violence,” says Binderbauer, 50, with a smile.

TAE, known until last year as Tri Alpha Energy, has raised $600 million, most recently at a valuation of more than $2 billion. Investors include the late Paul Allen’s Vulcan Capital, the Rockefeller family’s Venrock, and Big Sky Capital, family money of billionaire stock trader Charles Schwab. They’re betting that TAE will be able to tame fusion into a source of electricity.

Nuclear fusion has been the energy source of the future since I was a kid. Back then they thought commercially-viable fusion was 15 years away. It still is. If they’re right this time, it will transform life on earth.

10 comments

Sabrina and Sabrina

Yesterday my wife and I watched Sabrina (1956) and Sabrina (1995) back to back. They are very different movies. All things considered I think the Billy Wilder-direct 1956 version starring Audrey Hepburn, Humphrey Bogart, and William Holden the better picture but the 1995 version starring Julia Ormond, Harrison Ford, and Greg Kinnear has much to recommend it, in particular Greg Kinnear’s charming performance as Sabrina’s obsession, David, Maude Larrabee played by Nancy Marchand, and the location shooting in Long Island, Paris, and Edgartown.

But Julia Ormond’s performance is not the star-making turn that Audrey Hepburn’s was in the 1956 version. And I’m glad that we have Humphrey Bogart’s performance on film just as I’m glad we have his performance, repeating his stage triumph, playing Duke Mantee in Petrified Forest. Linus is probably more like the real Humphrey Bogart, the child of privilege, than any of the heavies he played in the movies was. Or, indeed, as Rick was.

Neither of the two movie versions has the heft of their source material, Samuel Taylor’s Sabrina Fair, although to my eye the 1995 version takes more from it.

0 comments

Memorial Day, 2019

As I think I have mentioned before to the best of my knowledge none of my ancestors has died in war. Four of my great-great-grandfathers took part in the Civil War, on the Union side. None of them were killed although I believe that two, both of whom died young, had their lives cut short by the privations they experienced during the war.

The last member of my family to have fought in war has been dead now for 17 years. That was my mother’s uncle, Ed. He was one of the lucky few to be called up for World War II, Korea, and Vietnam. He was 97 when he died, a long and, I hope, happy life.

Neither I, my siblings, their spouses, their children, or their children’s spouses have ever served in the military. I was called up for Vietnam but was ultimately rejected for service. We have all depended on the sacrifices of others. Isn’t that what Memorial Day is about? Recalling our dependence on the sacrifices of others?

A number of my high school classmates lost their lives during the Vietnam War. I don’t know the precise number but it was not insignificant in a class of 215.

I do not recall ever hearing any of my nephews or nieces speak of never having served or the sacrifices of those who did. I hope they do not take their good fortune for granted.

6 comments

The Follow-Up Question

I just love sentences like this one from Bloomberg:

The first part of Inslee’s plan focuses on U.S. emissions, pledging to convert the country to 100% carbon-neutral electricity by 2030, and to mandate that all new buildings, cars and buses emit zero carbon.

Okay, let’s assume that starting in 2020 all cars emit zero carbon. When will the U. S. fleet emit zero carbon?

The answer is all other things being equal 2040 at the earliest. It takes at least 20 years for the U. S. passenger vehicle fleet to turn over.

There really aren’t many ZEVs (zero emission vehicles) sold in the United States. The entire boondoggle sounds like a backdoor subsidy to Tesla to me. I also wonder what the environmental impact of such a massive shift to fuel cells would be—a lot of those ZEVs will inevitably be powered by fuel cells.

I’d also like to see the net effect on emissions that would result from the mandate on buildings. It goes unmentioned in the article but producing cement is one of the largest sources of carbon emissions. Less than transportation or electricity but more than agriculture.

16 comments

How Did Women Lose the Right to Vote?

Many people are not aware of it but in the early federal period, in the thirty years between 1777 and 1807, women actually lost the right to vote one state at a time. New Jersey was the last state to revoke women’s right to vote in 1807.

I’ve known that for the last 50 years but I’ve never known how it happened, the circumstances, the reasons. Does anyone know?

4 comments

Truth Decay

The RAND organization has studied “news in the digital age” and here are their three main takeaways:

  • Print journalism and reporting on broadcast television have been mostly consistent in tone and style over the last 30 years. But since 2000, there’s been a gradual shift toward more-subjective reporting.
  • When comparing prime-time cable programming with broadcast television, there were significant differences in how the news was presented.
  • “Old media” is more grounded in traditional reporting. “New media” tends to lean more subjective.

Those are merely the tip of the iceberg. To those I’d add the following:

  • The younger people are the more likely they are to get their news from online sources.
  • Online sources have a more subjective, agonistic style than print media.
  • Print media have declined substantially over the past 20 years.
  • Print media adopting the style and tone of online media has made them less reliable and accelerated their decline.

There’s a lot to study on this subject.

1 comment

When Do the Facts Matter?

The editors of the Washington Post are shocked, shocked to find nasty things going on in politics, in this case President Trump’s retweeting of a video of Nancy Pelosi, purporting to show Speaker Pelosi slurring her words and showing other signs of being indisposed. The incident of their displeasure is the claim that the video has been edited in a misleading way:

These difficulties both are caused by and contribute to the erosion of trust in today’s America, where it is hard to say what there is more of: false cries of “fake news,” or viral “news” that is actually fake. Technology certainly has helped this issue along, providing both an easy means to craft propaganda and an easy means to promote it. The increasing sophistication of image editing that creates the threat of actual deepfakes filling the Web will make that worse.

In the best of circumstances, the emergence of these tools for mass deception would be disturbing. It becomes absolutely alarming at a time when America is led by somebody who is intent on deceiving. The role of a responsible leader is to be a bulwark against an assault on truth, yet instead Mr. Trump is a battering ram. That’s not a problem Twitter or any other platform can solve.

But wait! There’s more! As acknowledged by the editors, although there is a misleadingly edited video of Speaker Pelosi making the rounds the video retweeted by Trump was not misleadingly edited.

Does it matter? My opinion is that it ain’t beanbag. If Speaker Pelosi or her supporters object to the Speaker being portrayed in an unflattering light, truly or not, they should reconsider careers in politics. Or exit the public sphere entirely.

Over the period of the last 30 years we have elected the candidate with the lower character too frequently. Weighing the factors and deciding that character doesn’t really matter that much is the way you get Donald Trump elected in the first place.

18 comments