Achieving transcendence

Marc Danziger of Winds of Change writes about a concert performance of Tristan und Isolde:

It was amazing; I don’t think I’ve heard an orchestra play Wagner better; the singers were amazing, and the video backdrop was interesting, until the very end when it became transcendental.

Many years ago I attended a performance of Tristan at Chicago Lyric Opera. John Vickers, probably the greatest Tristan of my lifetime, was at the height of his powers. During the famous Liebes-Tod (Love-Death) scene I was transported. A Zen experience. A no-mind experience. A transcendent experience. I completely lost track of time and space and was surrounded and filled with the glorious sound.

It’s possible to have this sort of experience in many venues—through religion, or the martial arts, or even through one’s work but this has been the only time I’ve ever had such an experience through music.

Are these experiences mere fleeting instances of heaven or can one fill one’s life with them? Certainly psychologist Mihaly Czikszentmihaly thinks that it is possible. In his fabulous book, Flow: the Psychology of Optimal Experience, he discusses this citing case studies, controlled experiments, literature, and historical examples.

In one of the most famous passages in all of literature Dante describes the poet’s experience of the source of that experience:

Within the deep and luminous subsistence
Of the High Light appeared to me three circles,
Of threefold colour and of one dimension,
And by the second seemed the first reflected
As Iris is by Iris, and the third
Seemed fire that equally from both is breathed.
O how all speech is feeble and falls short
Of my conceit, and this to what I saw
Is such, ’tis not enough to call it little!
O Light Eterne, sole in thyself that dwellest
,
Sole knowest thyself, and, known unto thyself
And knowing, lovest and smilest on thyself!
That circulation, which being thus conceived
Appeared in thee as a reflected light,
When somewhat contemplated by mine eyes,
Within itself, of its own very colour
Seemed to me painted with our effigy,
Wherefore my sight was all absorbed therein.
As the geometrician, who endeavours
To square the circle, and discovers not,
By taking thought, the principle he wants,
Even such was I at that new apparition;
I wished to see how the image to the circle
Conformed itself, and how it there finds place;
But my own wings were not enough for this,
Had it not been that then my mind there smote
A flash of lightning, wherein came its wish.
Here vigour failed the lofty fantasy:
But now was turning my desire and will,
Even as a wheel that equally is moved,
The Love which moves the sun and the other stars.

Paradiso, Canto XXXIII

0 comments

Catching my eye: A through Z (UPDATED)

Here’s what’s caught my eye this morning:

That’s the lot.

0 comments

Catching my eye: A through Z

Here’s what caught my eye this morning:

  • Alice in Texas explains Liberal Trauma.
  • Brad DeLong on a key problem with Social Security privatization: the economy just isn’t likely to grow that fast forever.
  • I see that Captain Ed of CG agrees with me about the Intelligence Reform Bill. So does The Talking Dog (from a somewhat different perspective).
  • David of Cronaca says Jefferson’s being misquoted.
  • Noah Millman of Gideon’s Blog comments on the U. S. budget deficit (it’s less than Germany’s, France’s, or Japan’s), the trade deficit, and the dollar.
  • Omar of Iraq the Model on the two halves of the blogosphere.
  • Dave Neiwert of Orcinus provides quite a good Leftist critique of the War on Terror in general and the Iraq War in particular in refutation of Peter Beinart and Kevin Drum.

    The problem with Neiwert’s prescription—infiltrate terrorist organizations—is that, in the case of the radical Islamists that are the enemy we’re facing, it’s impossible. Successful infiltrations by Westerners—like Richard Francis Burton, for example—have been by successfully passing themselves off as non-Western outsiders since any native Arabic speaker can easily identify outsiders by their manner of speech. The close tribal and familial affiliations of these organizations assures that infiltration is just not an option. The best you’ll do is John Walker Lindh— a meaningless spear-carrier. They resist subornation for the same reason.

That’s the lot.

5 comments

Why the Intelligence Reform Bill won’t make us more secure

In this post I’m going to try and make the case that there’s little reason to believe that the Intelligence Reform Bill that has just passed the House will make us any more secure. There are a few links you may find handy in the discussion. First, here’s the text of the bill. And here’s a decent summary of its contents. As it stands now the bill:

  1. Calls for a Director of National Intelligence
  2. Creates a National Counterterrorism Center
  3. Calls for standardized driver’s license rules
  4. Requires screening interviews for visa applicants
  5. Establishes new programs for airline and border security
  6. Creates an independent Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board.
  7. Expands FBI powers on wiretapes, etc.
  8. Calls for a variety of diplomatic overtures.

I’d call these measures probably necessary but not sufficient.

[continue reading…]

7 comments

Catching my eye: A through Z

Here’s some of the things in the blogosphere that caught my eye this morning:

  • Abu Aardvark reports the results of the lastest opinion polling from the Palestinian territories on the upcoming elections there.
  • Gerald Vanderleun of American Digest has a lengthy post on the future of the blogosphere.

    Allahpundit makes a guest appearance in the comments section and explains why he’s stopped blogging.

  • New kids on the blog, The Becker-Posner Blog, posts on Pre-emptive War. Be sure to read the comments.

    That’s Nobel Laureate Gary Becker and federal circuit judge Richard Posner. If the tone in the blogosphere keeps going up like this, they’ll be asking riff-raff like me to leave.

  • Jeff Medcalf of Caerdroia has an excellent post on intelligence reform.

    I’m working on an essay of my own, “Why Intelligence Reform Won’t Make Us More Secure”.

  • Captain Ed of Captain’s Quarters assures us that the intelligence reform bill will pass.
  • Daniel Drezner posts (again) on outsourcing.

    This time he’s posting on medical outsourcing. My own reservations on offshoring or offshore outsourcing have less to do with job loss than with potential loss of intellectual property (and future industries) and, in this case, liability issues. How does one prosecute an Indian doctor in India for medical malpractice? Are there international standards of care?

  • The Medium Lobster of Fafblog takes on Becker and Posner (see above). Welcome to the Blogosphere, Dr. Becker and Your Honor!
  • Have you noticed that your Ecosystem rating has become, well, erratic? N. Z. Bear of The Truth Laid Bear explains all.

That’s the lot.

0 comments

Carnival of the Liberated

Carnival of the Liberated, a weekly sample of the best from Iraqi blogs, is available at Dean’s World. Trips, warnings of sectarian civil war, a courtesy lesson, and an injured blogger. And the honeymoon isn’t over yet.

0 comments

High-rise fire in downtown Chicago

A fire is raging this evening on the 29th floor of the historic LaSalle Bank Building at 135 S. LaSalle in downtown Chicago. Eighteen people including two firefighters have been injured. At this point no fatalities have been reported. It’s a three-alarm fire and a third of the city’s firefighting capability has been brought into play to battle the blaze.

The 43 story building was completed in 1934 and until the completion of 1 Prudential Plaza was considered the premiere office building in Chicago.

1 comment

Everything you wanted to know…

…about U. S. force structure—where it’s been and where it’s going—but were afraid to ask is laid out for you in Milstuff for Dummies: Force Structure. Brought to you by Tim Oren on Winds of Change.

0 comments

Voting is still going on

Voting is still going on for the 2004 Weblog Awards. The Glittering Eye is a finalist for Best of the Top 1000 – 1750 Blogs.

I could really use your support. You can vote once per day until December 12.

0 comments

The Economist on UN Reform

The Economist has weighed in on reform for the United Nations (hat tip: American Future):

Long-awaited proposals on reforming the United Nations have been unveiled. Backers hope they will rejuvenate the world body. But they come at a time when the UN is under fire—especially from Americans, many of whom think it is irrelevant and corrupt

[…].

The UN’s sorry state became most obvious with the Iraq war. Those favouring the war were furious that after a decade of Security Council resolutions, including the last-chance Resolution 1441 threatening “serious consequences” if Iraq did not prove its disarmament, the UN could not agree to act. Anti-war types were just as frustrated that the world body failed to stop the war. But Iraq was not the UN’s only problem. It has done little to stop humanitarian disasters, such as the ongoing horror in Sudan. And it has done nothing to stop Iran’s and North Korea’s pursuit of nuclear weapons.

Well, yes, the Iraq War is a factor. But I believe that the critical failings of the UN were brought into sharp relief more than twenty years ago at the time of the Iran hostage crisis. What seems to be forgotten about it is that the U. S. embassy was seized and held over a very long period. I believe that the UN needed to respond to that challege: it was a challenge to diplomacy itself. Either the new revolutionary government was complicit in the hostage-taking or it was helpless or unwilling to resolve it i.e. Iran was a failed state.

International law had been violated. The local government was either unwilling or unable to correct the situation (or there was no local government). That’s a prima facie case for a UN intervention.

And there was no intervention. Nothing happened. The most obvious conclusion that Americans could draw was that the world believed that the purpose of America was to support the UN not to receive support from it.

[continue reading…]

0 comments