Forever and Ever. Amen

Charles Lane has lurch uncontrollably on to a point I’ve been trying to make around here for some time:

Since the 2010-11 school year, more than 40 percent of education job cuts were due to attrition or declining enrollment, as opposed to outright staffing cutbacks, according to a survey of school systems by the American Association of School Administrators (AASA), published in March.

So when David Axelrod declares that “we have lost 250,000 teachers in the last . . . couple of years,” as he did on Sunday, he’s exaggerating. According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, employment of all kinds in “local government — education” is down 224,100 since the recession began in December 2007.

Oh, and what measures were school systems least likely to use in order to avoid job cuts, according to the AASA survey? That would be reductions in health or pension benefits. Despite the potential for savings that could help preserve jobs, those perks are locked in by multi-year union contracts.

In other words, in the name of stimulating the economy, the president would shovel dollars into school systems regardless of specific need and without requiring reforms in return for the cash.

You could argue that the infusion, like previous rounds in the 2009 stimulus bill and in 2010, will enable schools to avoid drastic cuts — but it may also let them postpone structural changes that improve educational quality and long-term financial stability.

The problem facing state and local governments isn’t merely that revenues have fallen. In many jurisdictions revenue has increased sharply since 2007. It is that revenues aren’t rising as fast as healthcare and pension costs and state and local governments don’t have the ability to change the former or the flexibility to respond to the latter.

Under the rubric of “never letting a good crisis go to waste” you’d think that the federal government would put a few strings on the money the president is proposing that we’d dole out to enable or compel state and local governments to correct the underlying problems. Otherwise the additional money will only help until it runs out. What then? Another dollop of money, just to tide them over?

7 comments

The Wizards’ Duel

Mike Shedlock has an amusing post in which he describes the debate about the correct policy going on among economists as a duel between wizards:

  • Keynesian wizards believe governments can spend their way to economic health and although fiscal deficits may matter at some point in time, they never matter now, in practice.
  • Monetarist wizards believe money will cure any and every problem if enough is dropped from helicopters and interest rates held low.
  • Austrian wizards believe that economic problems are created by unsound money, haphazard loans, excessive debts, and government manipulations.
  • Keynesian and Monetarist wizards believe in the voodoo principle “the problem is the solution if only you do more of it”. The former relies primarily on fiscal voodoo, the latter relies primarily on monetary voodoo.
  • Austrian wizards do not believe “the problem is the solution”, no matter how many times it is repeated.

Since I’m pretty sure the subject will come up, there’s another school of wizardry, not mentioned by Mish. As best as I can tell the new school believes that the problems of the economy can be cured if you issue enough credit. Over time that will have its own bad consequences.

I’m not an economist and I don’t belong to any school. I think that different tools work under differing circumstances and that pretty much anything can work, at least in the short term, depending on circumstances and that you need to choose the right tool for the conditions in which you find yourself. I also think that discretion is almost always bad while rules are generally better. When the incentives are high enough any policy strategy can and will be gamed.

I can’t tell you how many times over the last several years I’ve thought of a scene in from the early days of the M*A*S*H television, during the Henry Blake/Trapper John period. Radar comes in and hands a document on a clipboard to Col. Blake saying “Sign here, sir”. Col. Blake says “Radar, there’s nothing on this paper” to which Radar responds “Oh, I’ll fill in the rest later”.

11 comments

Broken Window Fallacy Alert

E. J. Dionne leaps to the defense of government:

So when conservatives say, as they regularly do, that “government doesn’t create jobs,” the riposte should be quick and emphatic: “Yes it has, and yes, it does!”

I don’t want to fall into the technocratic fallacy but is the word of a man who’s probably never taken an economics course in his life (and may not have taken a math course since junior high) sufficient evidence to believe this? The only way that the federal government can on net create jobs is by creating more money to pay for salaries of those workers. That may have economic repercussions of its own, at the very least deadweight loss.

That alternative is not available to the states. In the states, when left to their own resources, more higher-compensated government workers either means fewer total government workers or fewer private sector workers or both.

He really should read The Seen and the Unseen. He sees the teachers, firefighters, and police officers. He doesn’t see the millions of retail jobs lost due to higher sales taxes, the homes lost and urban blight induced by higher property taxes.

71 comments

Only Nixon Could Go to China

John Ellis concludes his framing of Obama’s reelection prospects, in which I think he confuses the popular vote (which is optional for a president) with the electoral vote (which is mandatory) with something with which I actually agree:

“Framed choice” is Team Obama’s only hope of holding enough white voters to avoid dismissal. The “framed choice” strategy is basically this: Everyone knows that pensions (Social Security) and health care (Medicare, Medicaid, child health programs) are going to bankrupt the nation unless they are “right-sized” to revenue and existing debt. Whoever is elected president in 2012 will have to “right-size” these programs over the course of the next four years.

The framed choice for the white voters who will decide this election is this: Who do you think will better protect the interests of working-class and middle-class families when the inevitable cuts are packaged? Who do you want negotiating for you when it comes down to who gets hurt and who doesn’t? Do you really want Mitt Romney and a bunch of right-wing congressmen making these decisions? Only a Democrat can be trusted to properly right-size the great Democratic social welfare programs.

The remaining questions are is Obama the right candidate for that job either and if not what Democrat is?

3 comments

What Won’t Happen in a Second Obama Term

The question in the lead of Ryan Lizza’s article in the New Yorker, The Second Term is “What would Obama do if reëlected?” If you expect an answer to this question in the article you will be disappointed. The closest thing you’ll receive, on the ninth page of a rambling ten page (online) article is a quote from Obama campaign strategist David Plouffe:

It took considerable arm-twisting to get Plouffe to think past the details of the daily campaign and consider the long view. “If we win,” he said finally, “January of 2017, what do we want to look back and be able to say? One, we’ve recovered from the recession. Second, our economic and tax policies in this country are more centered on the middle class and on people trying to get in the middle class. Third, the big unmet challenges—health care, education reform, energy, immigration, and reducing the deficit in the right way—we met them.

“We’ve also ended a period of war while taking out our leading terrorist enemies,” he added. “Think about that! That’s a pretty important book of business, and I think that’s the legacy he’d like to leave.”

I think that we can say with some confidence that whatever does happen in a second Obama term that list will not happen. At least according to present projections we’ll still have troops in Afghanistan and in all likelihood we’ll still be taking out “leading terrorist enemies” who will be replaced by other leading terrorist enemies who will be replaced by others.

With the arguable exception of healthcare the domestic agenda items were not addressed when the president was at the height of his power and influence—in the first two years of his presidency when he’d just been elected by a majority of the popular vote, something that eluded Bill Clinton and Jimmy Carter, and was backed by Democratic majorities in both houses of the Congress. Is it likely that he will accomplish them now? With a Congress even more polarized than the one he faced in 2009?

If President Obama is reelected, I think we can expect three things:

  • He will act as custodian of healthcare reform, his signature legislative accomplishment. His veto will prevent its repeal.
  • He will appoint one or more Supreme Court justices. Since the justices most likely to die or retire are both in the liberal wing of the Court, that won’t alter the Court’s present balance.
  • He will react to foreign policy challenges as they occur. And they will occur. Most of Europe may be in outright depression by that time. China’s housing bubble appears to be collapsing at the time of this writing. Syria continues to be in turmoil and we have not yet seen the fullness of the “Arab Spring&148;. Iran will still be doing whatever it is doing, desperately trying to maintain its client, Syria, while it is doing it.

For some that will be enough. For others far too much.

3 comments

Skyrim Update

I’m still playing Skyrim, continuing to build a character specializing in stealth. My new character is at Level 41 now with skill levels over 80 in combat with one-handed weapons, light armor, stealth, and lockpicking.

The subplots that are available to me with this character are quite different from those available to my fighter character, so much so that’s almost a completely different and much more difficult game. It’s made even more difficult because I upped the difficulty level.

My fighter character hit a sort of sweet spot at a character level in the upper twenties or lower thirties. After the game was quite easy. I think I’ve just now reached that point with my thief/rogue character in the lower 40s.

I’m actually becoming kind of antsy to cut to the end of the game so I can re-start as a magic user which I anticipate will be much, much more difficult. I just don’t see how the spells that are available are powerful enough to deal with the situations I’ll face.

3 comments

R-E-S-P-E-C-T

Doug Mataconis has a post at OTB in which he muses about why public opinion of the Supreme Court has deteriorated:

So, what’s the cause of the public’s decline in approval for the Court? The easy answer that many will jump to is that it’s related to the decisions that the Court has made, but it strikes me that this explanation doesn’t make sense, or at least that it’s not entirely complete.

[…]

If it was public dissatisfaction with the Court’s work that was the cause of this dip in approval, then one would have expected to see a significant drop off in the aftermath of the decision in Bush v. Gore. Instead, public opinion remained relatively consistent until 2004-2005 when it began dropping, and indeed reached a point in 2005 where slightly more people disapproved of the Court than approved.

Consider the chart above. If the reason for the decreasing approval of the Court is that the Court has been captured by a cabal of right wing ideologues, how do you explain the increasing number of 5-4 decisions in the Stone, Vinson, and Burger courts? You might argue that the Court is being whipsawed between left wing ideologues and right wing ideologues but I don’t believe that explains the change, either.

I think that most of the decline in mostly due to a decline in respect for authority that’s been ongoing for generations. In that context that 44% of the people continue to approve of the Supreme is astonishingly high by comparison with the Congress’s approval rating of under 17%. People even disapprove of the performance of their own Congressmen these days.

I doubt that the decline in the SCOTUS’s approval has anything to do with the actual performance of the Court. I’m going out on a limb here but I suspect that 99% of the people don’t read Supreme Court rulings or have any basis of understanding for evaluating the performance of the Court. Basically, they’re being told by other people—news media, pundits, and all sorts of others that the Court is acting out of ideological bias so they believe that’s the case. It’s become cool to disrespect the Supreme Court. That culminated with the president’s public criticism of the Supreme Court during his State of the Union address.

If the president doesn’t respect the Supreme Court, why should the rest of us?

3 comments

Underwriting and Reform

In an editorial contrasting Scott Walker with President Obama, the editors of the Chicago Tribune observe, I believe correctly:

On this we all can agree: Wisconsin’s election was a referendum on Walker. All else paled. A traditionally liberal electorate knew he had made mistakes, then decided that, on balance, his policies had helped his state. That conclusion — not whichever Democratic candidate opposed him — sealed Walker’s fate.

We invoke Wisconsin not to predict the outcome of the nationwide presidential race, but rather for what it teaches about the sitting president.

On Nov. 6, 2011, when we launched this series of occasional editorials on a defining contest in a divided nation, we didn’t anticipate that the election of Nov. 6, 2012, would narrow in scope to a referendum on Barack Obama. But it has.

Yes, the balky U.S. economic recovery and the rise of taxpayer debt (see today’s companion editorial) were destined to play large roles, and they have. But over the past seven months, Americans mostly have used these issues as prisms through which to view the one overarching issue of this yearlong campaign cycle: Obama, yes or no. Vote.

We wish the White House understood that Americans won’t make their choice because of Bain Capital, or Romneycare in Massachusetts, or whether the Republican nominee transported his dog atop his car. No, the issue is the president.

When the kerfuffle over the president’s remark to the effect that the private sector was doing fine arose last week my immediate reaction was that it was a poor choice of words being blown completely out of proportion. However, Mickey Kaus makes a good point:

The problem is the public jobs part, not Obama’s “private sector” characterization (which seems like ordinary misspeaking). There are at least two ways to read it: 1) As a Keynesian, Obama’s arguing that if state and local governments could stop laying people off for a while it would have a salutary effect on the economy by boosting demand, the same way tax cuts or public works projects or unemployment benefits boost demand; or 2) Public jobs are equivalent to private jobs, including housing jobs. In a healthy economy we have lots of private jobs, lots of housing jobs, and lots of goverment jobs. They’re all good!

Obama clearly means #1–he’s proposed $35 billion in subsidies to help states rehire “teachers and cops and firefighters,” with a fairly explicit Keynesian rationale. But does he also mean #2? There’s nothing in his press conference to suggest he doesn’t, and lots to suggest he does–the parallelism with the construction industry, for example, in which goverment jobs are treated as just another “sector” in which more employment is better.

The problem is that many voters (myself included) don’t think government jobs are just another sector. We want the number of housing and manufacturing jobs to keep growing–the more the merrier, all things being equal. We don’t want the number government jobs to keep growing, in part because we pay for them without the assurances, offered in a competitive private economy, that we’re getting our moneys worth or that the jobs are necessary at all. It’s one thing to boost government jobs as a temporary stimulus measure. It’s another thing to never let federal, state and local governments shrink to a more sustainable size.

Nationwide the states’ problem isn’t that their revenues aren’t growing. State tax revenues rose 6% last year, substantially faster than inflation. Their problem is that the cost of public employee benefits is not only rising faster than revenues but rising faster than the underlying goods, i.e. property values, incomes, and retail sales, on which their tax revenues depend. Due to the contracts they have with the public employees’ unions state and local governments have little recourse but to cut the number of employees to stay within their budgets.

Raising taxes is not an adequate solution. As long as present circumstances (slow growth, rising costs) persist it would take a commitment to repeatedly raising taxes, indefinitely. Raising taxes once is sufficiently politically painful. Repeatedly raising taxes, indefinitely, is not a credible strategy.

The federal government could step in a fill the gap, as the legislation that President Obama was advocating in the speech cited by the Tribune editors, would do. However, merely filling the gap of itself is not nearly enough and IMO is feckless. The federal government should tie any such aid to changing the conditions faced by the states.

IMO if the president wants to push legislation to help the states, a better choice would be for the federal government to take on a greater percentage of Medicaid or Medicaid in its entirety. An even better solution would be to reform the healthcare system in such a way as actually to reduce costs but, as we have seen, the federal government is unwilling to reform the system as radically as would be necessary.

1 comment

Help Wanted. Or Not

I want to draw your attention to a post I found genuinely interesting from Dave Altig of the Atlanta Federal Reserve. In the post he examines a peculiar fact of the recession and its aftermath: despite the large number of unemployed many employers report an inability to hire workers.

I recommend that your read the post in full but I’ll summarize it quickly. Roughly 10% of employers aren’t willing to pay what prospective employees demand. More than half of the employers report that they can’t find candidates with the necessary skills, experience, or inter-personal skills and there is some evidence to suggest that experience is the most important of these factors. Although once again I am reminded of the help wanted ad I saw in 1982: “IBM PC Expert Wanted; Must Have 5 Years Experience” (the IBM PC was introduced in 1981—not even the people who designed it had five years of experience with it).

Around here it’s been suggested that employers are reluctant to hire the long-term unemployed even when they have the necessary skills. I suspect that reluctance is reported either under the lack of technical skills or lack of inter-personal skills category.

It’s an interesting and important subject.

19 comments

Debt

There’s an article over at Forbes that should warm the cockles of the hearts of those who’ve been chiding me for not posting about the dangers of private debt. Here’s a snippet:

Economists who have studied the impact of indebtedness have found that low levels of debt are essential to growth, but that high levels of total outstanding debt can hurt an economy. Beyond a tipping point, adding on more debt will reduce growth over the long run, even if it inflates a bubble in the short run.

“At low levels, debt is good. It is a source of economic growth and stability,” concluded Stephen Cecchetti, M.S. Mohanty and Fabrizio Zampolli, economists for the Bank of International Settlements, in a paper presented at the Federal Reserve’s Jackson Hole conference last August. “Beyond a certain point, debt becomes dangerous and excessive,” and can lead to increased volatility, financial fragility and slower growth. It can even bring down the real economy with it, as we have seen. Read the BIS paper, “The Real Effects of Debt.”

Cecchetti and his co-authors found that growth can be impaired once nonfinancial corporate debt hits about 90% of GDP, or when household debts hit 85% of GDP, or when public debts hit about 85%.

In the U.S., household debt has now fallen to 84% of GDP from a peak of 98%. Nonfinancial corporate debt has fallen to 77% from a peak of 83%. Financial sector debt has plunged from 123% of GDP to 89%. Public debt has risen to 89% from 56%.

There’s an interesting graph that shows the ratio of total debt to GDP taking sudden jumps in the early 80s, the late 80s, the late 90s and another around 2000. I wish the article had included some conjectures about why that might have been.

I also found a major omission in the article: the rate at which debt to GDP is declining has slowed recently. At the present rate of decline it will a decade or more for it to return to the level it had in 2000 let alone the much more sustainable level it had in 1983. That would take centuries.

I wonder if debt to GDP is the right measure to be looking at. I realize it’s much harder to measure but how about debt to wealth? Debt to GDP may be what it was in 2005 but the Case-Shiller index is where it was in 2003. That’s not a perfect measure but it gives you the general idea.

3 comments