Factoid

I think I’ve mentioned that for every post I actually publish I research and draft probably two or three others that never see the light of day for various reasons. The most important reason is that I just lose interest. Blog posts, at least my sort of blog posts, are essentially newspaper columns and not every idea fits into a newspaper column. There are other forms, i.e. articles, monographs, and books, and some ideas require treatment at greater length than can be comfortably accommodated by a blog post that is optimally less than 800 words long and maxes out at about 1,200 words.

At any rate I was researching a post that may or may not ever see the light of day and stumbled across something I found interesting. Of the present Fortune 500 companies more than half opened their doors, i.e. date their establishment birthdates during recessions or depressions.

It is not that more businesses are started during economic contractions. Historically, that is not the case.

It’s interesting to speculate why such a large percentage of Fortune 500 companies started up during economic downturns. One possibility is that the economy is like a forest. Small trees do not flourish in the shade of established, forest-spanning sequoias.

7 comments

Taking Steps

Fareed Zakaria argues along lines similar to the points I made yesterday. Tax cuts are just about played out as a means of fiscal stimulus and founding an economic policy based on them is just handwaving:

In the wake of a financial crisis caused by excessive debt, tax cuts are highly unlikely to lead to increased economic activity. People use the money to pay down their debts rather than shop for cars, houses and appliances. As for the idea that job creators are not creating jobs because their taxes are too high, think about it: Would Mitt Romney invest more of his money in American factories if only he had paid less than the 13.9 percent rate he paid last year?

However, as we’ve learned over the last several years there are no shovel-ready projects. This morning I heard Larry Summers being interviewed, making his case for borrowing money at today’s low interest rates and bringing forward maintenance projects which would otherwise be necessarily performed some time in the future, say, rebuilding Kennedy Airport.

The reason that’s not done is that there are no plans in place for doing it, it will take years to put together such plans, approve them, and let the contract, and the bidder to whom the contract would ultimately be let is a large, established company with a proven track record and incentives to perform the contract, now five or ten years from today, with the equipment and labor it has on hand rather than purchasing new equipment or hiring new workers. Construction projects aren’t performed the way they were during the Depression of the 1930s any more than banks operate the way they did in the 1830s.

This is not to say that there aren’t substantial, worthwhile infrastructure projects that would contribute materially to our productivity in the future. However, those projects would not do much for our economy now. Congress does not possess that kind of foresight; its vision extend mostly to the next election.

So, fiscal policy is just about tapped out as a means of boosting our economy out of the doldrums. Federal Reserve Chairman Bernanke has made it pretty clear that he is disinclined to use monetary policy to goose the economy, either. That leaves what we dread most: changing our behavior. Our behavior must change in such a way as to produce more economic activity rather than less.

Today 70% of the economy depends on personal consumption. That’s more than any other OECD country and higher than it was here not all that long ago. 70% personal consumption expenditures is not a law of nature.

5 comments

Jeremiad

Of all of the reactions to the recall election in Wisconsin I’ve read I think that this anguished cri de coeur from Matt Stoller must be the most hysterical. Hysterical in the sense of irrational from fear, shock, or other strong emotion not in the sense of extremely funny. Here’s a snippet from a difficult-to-excerpt post:

In other words, first, liberals lost a policy battle, then they failed to strike, then they lost a primary election, then they lost a general election to the most high-profile effective reactionary policy-maker in the country. The conservative beat the moderate who beat the liberal. And had Barrett won, he wouldn’t even have rolled back Walker’s agenda. Somehow, in a no-win electoral situation, Democrats and labor managed to lose as badly as they possibly could.

What happened?

I wish I could say I had a new insight, but it’s basically the same problem I’ve been writing about for years. Put simply, it’s that Obama’s policy framework is now the policy framework of the Democratic Party, liberals, and unionism. Up and down the ticket, Democrats are operating under the shadow of the President, associated with unpopular policies that make the lives of voters worse and show government to be an incompetent, corrupt handmaiden to big business. So they keep losing.

I think he’s overrreacting, to say the least. A better analysis is that Wisconsinites prefer Scott Walker over Tom Barrett, they don’t like government by mob action, and the public employees’ unions aren’t nearly as popular in Wisconsin as its leaders apparently think they are.

My only other remark is that, when Alexis Tsipras is the standard bearer for what you believe in, you’re in a world of hurt. Let me remind everybody that when you get right down to it there are only two potential mechanisms for allocating resources: markets and fiat. When your preference is for a command economy you will inevitably get burned.

Update

Forsooth! The criticisms of Stoller’s post from other progressives are even more over-the-top than the post is.

15 comments

Quick Prediction

Unless the European economic downturn is shallow and brief, there will be major political upheaval in the Middle East. As in “you ain’t seen nothing’ yet” upheaval.

7 comments

Wishful Thinking

I don’t know that I’ve ever encountered an airier excursion into wishful thinking than in Phil Gramm and Glenn Hubbard’s op-ed in Wall Street Journal. It’s title, “What a Romney Recovery Might Look Like” certainly grabbed my attention. Here’s the meat of it:

Mr. Romney’s economic principles are strikingly similar to Reagan’s. He would reduce the size and cost of the federal government. He champions a reduction in marginal tax rates in the context of a general tax reform. Particularly powerful are his proposals to reduce marginal tax rates on business income earned by corporate and unincorporated businesses alike. His goal, like Reagan’s, is to make it profitable to invest in job creation.

Let’s go through that sentence by sentence. When Ronald Reagan took office the top marginal tax rate was 70% and had been greater than 60% for nearly a half century. Inflation was in double digits. The unemployment rate was just over 7%. Personal consumption was about 60% of GDP. Manufacturing employed a little over 20% of the population. Under Reagan the top marginal rate was slashed by 35 points, the rate of inflation was cut by 9 percentage points, and unemployment was cut by about 1.5 percentage points.

Now the top marginal tax rate are 35%, inflation is under 3%, and unemployment is 8.2%. Personal consumption is 70% of GDP. Manufacturing employees fewer than half the percentage of workers it did thirty years ago, a drop in absolute numbers.

I think was can agree that President Romney would not reduce the top marginal rate by 35 points and inflation by 9 points. If unemployment is reduced by 1.5 percentage points it will be roughly where it was when Reagan assumed office. Will significantly smaller changes produce large results? Mr. Romney’s economic philosophy may be like Reagan’s (a debate for another time) but the circumstances are completely different. One size does not fit all.

How, precisely, will cutting taxes by the very small percentage that is foreseeable induce a resurgence in growth? The tax cuts at the beginning of the Aughts didn’t have that effect. Neither did the multiple tax cuts at the end of that decade. The former did produce a small bump in consumption, the effects off which had vanished from the economy by 2003. The bumps in consumption that followed the multiple tax cuts at the end of the last decade were too small to measure with any real confidence.

Do we really need to increase the role of personal consumption in our economy? It’s already as high as any country in the world.

I agree that Mitt Romney is probably the right man at the right time to reduce the size of government operations. He is very well prepared to do that by training and experience. Unfortunately, federal government operations other than defense is small potatoes and he’s pledged to increase defense spending.

The real opportunities for cost-cutting are in defense and the entitlements which, at this point, Mr. Romney has pledged to preserve.

I agree that making it profitable to invest in job creation is essential for an economic recovery worthy of the name. Unfortunately, what Mssrs. Gramm and Hubbard list are pretty weak tea.

Assuming that the recovery (and, technically, we are in a recovery) continues during a hypothetical Romney Administration in the absence of serious structural reforms, greater than anything proposed to date, I believe it is overwhelmingly likely to resemble the recovery during the Obama Administration: inflation that’s too high, unemployment that’s too high, and growth that’s too slow.

8 comments

Lessons Not Learned

Quite a few people are asking what lessons have been learned from the failure of the recall of Wisconsin Governor Scott Walker on Tuesday. If the interviews I’ve heard with Wisconsin public employees’ union officials are any gauge, like the House of Bourbon they have learned nothing and forgotten nothing. Charles Lane muses:

I would like to ask Gerald McEntee, the leader of the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees union, if it was a bit excessive to call Walker’s budget reforms “an attack on the freedoms of every Wisconsin citizen”?

Now that Walker has been freely and peacefully elected — again — does Harold Meyerson regret writing that Walker’s policies represented “a throwback to 19th-century America, when strikes were suppressed by force of arms. Or, come to think of it, to Mubarak’s Egypt or communist Poland and East Germany.” How about Katrina vanden Heuvel? She, too, pushed the Cairo analogy, asserting that the fight in Wisconsin was “about basic democratic rights and the balance of power in America.”

This rhetoric wasn’t just hyperbolic. It was strategically suicidal. The unions and their various apologists whipped progressive Wisconsin into such a frenzy — falsely claiming, for example, that Walker was about to unleash the National Guard — that the anti-Walker forces could no longer perceive political reality.

Michael Gerson makes a point similar to the one I made yesterday:

In flush economic times, public workers’ unions and progressive advocates of spending get along just fine. There is plenty of money to go around for both the system and the services. In lean times, however, the interests of union Democrats and progressive Democrats have diverged, forcing politicians to choose.

E. J. Dionne does not seem to understand this:

There was a sense of focus on the right that did not exist on the left. It was foolish for progressives not to work much harder to avoid a gubernatorial primary that wasted resources they couldn’t spare. This was not an ordinary election. The right knew this. The left seemed to forget.

It is not that the right was more focused or that the left forgot. It was that Wisconsin voters hadn’t changed their minds in two years—Walker was reaffirmed by roughly the same percentage with roughly the same demographics as elected him in 2010—and that the Democratic Party is not a monolithic “the left” but a coalition of people with differing objectives and some of them disagreed with the public employees’ unions.

8 comments

Catastrophe

The word “catastrophe” comes from a Greek word meaning an overturning, as in the capsizing of a boat. It can also mean an abrupt ending. In a recent article at The New Criterion James Piereson argues that we are in the process of reaching an abrupt ending in the political strategy we have employed for the last 80 years:

The conflict today between Democrats and Republicans increasingly pits public sector unions, government employees and contractors, and beneficiaries of government programs against middle-class taxpayers and business interests large and small. In states where public spending is high and public sector unions are strong, as in New York, California, Illinois, and Connecticut, Democrats have gained control; where public sector interests are weak or poorly organized, as in most of the states across the south and southwest, Republicans have the edge. This configuration, when added up across the nation, has produced a series of electoral stand-offs in recent decades between the red and blue states that have been decided by a handful of swing states moving in one direction or the other.

This impasse between the two parties signals the end game for the system of politics that originated in the 1930s and 1940s. As the “regime party,” the Democrats are in the more vulnerable position because they have built their coalition around public spending, public debt, and publicly guaranteed credit, all sources of funds that appear to be reaching their limits. The end game for the New Deal system, and for the Democrats as our “regime party,” will arrive when those limits are reached or passed.

I think he’s both right and wrong. I think that the federal government can continue on its present path for some time. It is a monetary sovereign and the dollar remains the reserve currency of last resort. We can either borrow or simply spend money into existence as some have suggested for some time to come. I do not believe we can do either of those things without both economic and political repercussions and those are hard to predict.

However, I think that states are very literally coming to an abrupt ending of the strategy they’ve been using for the better part of a century. For the states, which do not have their own currencies, are finding borrowing increasingly expensive, and may find themselves unable to raise additional revenue through increased taxation, there may not only be a catastrophe but a cataclysm (also from the Greek; a violent upheaval, deluge, washing clean). It could result in a collapse of the federal system, something that some long for but I believe would be both a catastrophe and a cataclysm, or an end of the Union itself.

Or there could be a sudden expression of prudence, temperance, and wisdom. A man’s reach should exceed his grasp or what’s a heaven for?

Read the whole thing. In the article the author examines what he characterizes as the three previous political revolutions in our history: the Jeffersonian revolution of 1800, the Civil War, and the New Deal.

5 comments

You Cahn’t Get They-ah from Hee-ah

I have some difficulty in seeing how Henry Kaufman, writing in the Wall Street Journal, gets from his premise to his conclusion. The title of the op-ed is “Big Banks Are Not the Future”. Here’s his opening:

The halcyon days of large financial conglomerates are over.

This assertion may seem surprising in light of the growing power—and profitability—of the leading financial institutions in recent years. The trend toward oligopoly, already in full swing during the 1980s and ’90s, only accelerated during the financial crisis of 2008, as faltering firms were absorbed by a handful of burgeoning survivors.

Coming out of the crisis, those at the top seemed unassailable.

Today, a mere 10 highly diversified financial institutions are responsible for 75% of total financial assets under management. Not only are they too big to fail, if the 2010 Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act works as intended, they are supposed to become more stable going forward.

Many observers therefore assume that these behemoths will dominate into the foreseeable future.

Or will they? The same crisis that shrank the number of leading players also exposed many of their frailties.

Yes, big banks are lousy, slow, and maladaptive. Over the period of the last half century at least when banks fail they’re absorbed by bigger banks. What’s the mechanism for divvying up a big bank into smaller banks? Youth wants to know.

0 comments

Striking Out in Court

Over at the Wall Street Journal Ilya Shapiro examines why the Obama Administration’s track record with the Supreme Court has been so poor:

This term alone, the high court has ruled unanimously against the government on religious liberty, criminal procedure and property rights. When the administration can’t get even a single one of the liberal justices to agree with it in these unrelated areas of the law, that’s a sign there’s something wrong with its constitutional vision.

Maybe Justice Ginsburg has become a right wing ideologue. Or maybe the lawyers representing the Obama Administration aren’t good enough. Or maybe the administration is wrong.

Read the whole thing. Mr. Shapiro examines the results case by case.

3 comments

And the Fingerpointing Begins

The fingerpointing over the results of the Wisconsin recall has already begun, looking at everything but the obvious.

Greg Sargent blames the Citizens United Supreme Court decision:

There’s no sugarcoating what this loss means for organized labor. Unions invested heavily in this battle in order to make an example of Walker. The goal was to show that Republican governors who attempt to roll back organizing rights will pay the ultimate political price. That effort failed, and the failure will have major repercussions for labor groups as they gear up for future fights over bargaining rights in states.

But Walker’s win also has major implications for Democratic elected officials across the country. It shows with crystal clarity that Republicans may very well be able to successfully use the new, post-Citizens United landscape to weaken the opposition in a structural way, and to eliminate major sources of support for that opposition.

That’s flummery. Let’s state what happened another way. In 2010 Scott Walker, without the help of big wads of out-of-state dough, defeated Tom Barrett to become governor of Wisconsin. A little over a year later Scott Walker defeats Tom Barrett again to hold onto his job and it’s because of the big wads of out-of-state dough? That violates Occam’s Razor. The simplest explanation is that a majority of Wisconsinites preferred Scott Walker to Tom Barrett and still do. I think that the only way you can believe otherwise is to assume that public employees’ unions are universally beloved in Wisconsin, something not in evidence.

Chrs Cilizza points his finger in several different directions. I think this one’s the daffiest:

To hear those who worked in the trenches of the recall tell it, the fact that Democrats had a contested primary between Barrett and former Dane County Executive Kathleen Falk bears considerable responsibility for Walker’s victory.

Not only did the primary take place less than a month before the general recall election but organized labor spent millions in support of Falk (and against Barrett), spending that many Democrats believe weakened the eventual nominee. Democratic pollsters insisted that Walker was languishing in the early spring but rebounded as Barrett and Falk fought amongst themselves in the primary.

So, let’s review this one. If this is true, there are two possibilities. Either the candidate who didn’t get enough Democratic votes to win the primary and who has no statewide name recognition would have won the general election or the public employees’ unions should never have opposed Barrett. In other words their miscalculation in the primary would have transmogrified to a winning stoke in the general election. Isn’t it simpler just to believe that the public employees’ unions miscalculated full stop?

IMO that’s where the finger should be pointed: the public employees’ unions miscalculated.

I may update this post as I find more fingerpointing.

Update

I don’t know whether to put this under “Overreaching” or “Fingerpointing”. Lexington Green posts that

Mr. Walker’s victory is the Stalingrad of the Left.

I’ve met Lexington Green on several occasions, dined at his home, and know him to be a very intelligent, well-educated, pleasant, and hospitable chap. I think that’s goofy.

E. J. Dionne blames the gender gap:

Women voted for Democrat Tom Barrett while men voted for Walker. Indeed, Walker’s share of the vote among women was 12 points lower than his share among men. But he carried males by a landslide: 59 percent to 40 percent. Walker lost women much more narrowly, 52 percent to 47 percent. The lesson is that Republicans can survive a rather big gender gap as long as they win men overwhelmingly.

That was almost precisely the same pattern as in 2010. What is it that they say about the definition of madness?

1 comment