Why Have People Lost Faith in Phrenology?

Phrenology is a pseudoscience which reached its highest level of prestige and practice in the 19th century. It is based on the belief that the external morphology of the brain and relative sizes of different sections of the brain are significant in predicting behavior and can be determined by an inspection of the skull. It has a distinguished history, tracing its origins to Aristotle, and an elegant, intricate, and developed supporting theory. It fell from favor not for lack of a distinguished history and elegant theory but for a lack of reproducible, empirical evidence (to be succeeded by other theories, mostly similarly lacking in reproducible, empirical evidence).

In his column in the Washington Post today Robert Samuelson muses over the loss of confidence in economists:

Last week, interest rates on 10-year U.S. Treasury bonds fell to 1.4 percent. This was the lowest on record and less than present or expected inflation (generally 2 percent to 3 percent). On 30-year Treasuries, rates have tumbled to 2.5 percent. The investors piling into Treasuries and driving rates down aren’t buying risky stocks or using their cash to expand businesses. They’re protecting themselves against unknowns. The question is whether the resulting plunge of rates signals something more ominous: renewed recession, deflation or both.

Granted, there are always the standard unknowns of business cycles, new technologies, competitive pressures and shifting government policies. But today’s seem on a scale unprecedented since World War II. Does Europe — one-fifth the world economy — face stagnation or collapse because debt-ridden countries cannot defend the euro? What happens to the weak U.S. recovery if it drops off the “fiscal cliff”: the $500 billion of spending cuts and tax increases (as estimated by the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget) scheduled for early 2013?

To these daunting uncertainties must be added at least one other that, though less recognized, is perhaps more powerful. It is an intellectual breakdown. There is a loss of faith in economic ideas — and government policies based on them — driven by most economists’ failure to anticipate the financial crisis and many subsequent events.

Economics is not without its useful, commonsensical, practical, predictive side. But it also has plenty of reading the bumps on skulls. Some of its predicted results are replicated again and again. Others, like so many of the prescriptions of Keynesians and neo-Keynesians, have non-existent or such weak empirical support that they can be explained by data collection error or in any number of other ways.

Economics is and will remain a science of human behavior. There’s a critical difference between, say, chemistry or physics, and sciences of human behavior. There is an inherently faith-based component to the latter. If you have built your rocket according to established principles of chemistry, physics, and engineering and calculated its path correctly and fired it correctly it will, in fact, go to the moon whether you believe it will or not. In economics it matters who does it and whether people have confidence in them and whether people believe the things that are done will work.

I think that much of what we’ve seen in our economy over the period of the last twenty or so years can be explained by trade policy. The practice of foreign governments, China’s in particular, taking so much of the proceeds of trade and using it to buy Treasury bonds has caused much of the benefits of trade to accrue to the federal government. The federal government has then spent the money on finance, weaponry and security and military personnel, and healthcare. Should we be surprised that our economy has become disproportionately oriented towards finance, weaponry and security and military personnel, and healthcare?

Right now about half of all federal spending is being financed by selling Treasury bonds and just about 80% of all Treasury bonds are being purchased by the Federal Reserve. Yes, something like $1 trillion per year, about 40% of all federal spending is not a transfer but is in effect being spent into existence. As I understand the theory that should be producing inflation. It does not appear to be. Additionally, I would think it would be producing more growth than it is, significantly more than $1 trillion in additional growth if the Keynesians are correct. Explanations for both would be handy right about now.

18 comments

Do the Math

Andrew Hacker inadvertently illustrates why you shouldn’t take advice on mathematics education from a social scientist who probably hasn’t taken a math course other than “Statistics for Social Scientists” since he struggled with math in high school seventy years ago:

Nor is it clear that the math we learn in the classroom has any relation to the quantitative reasoning we need on the job. John P. Smith III, an educational psychologist at Michigan State University who has studied math education, has found that “mathematical reasoning in workplaces differs markedly from the algorithms taught in school.” Even in jobs that rely on so-called STEM credentials — science, technology, engineering, math — considerable training occurs after hiring, including the kinds of computations that will be required. Toyota, for example, recently chose to locate a plant in a remote Mississippi county, even though its schools are far from stellar. It works with a nearby community college, which has tailored classes in “machine tool mathematics.”

I don’t honestly know what it’s like in the field of political science, Dr. Hacker’s actual area of expertise, but in science, technology, engineering, and math advanced skills are built on a foundation of basic skills. In engineering in particular differential equations are essential. They’re built on a foundation of calculus which is built on foundations of algebra, geometry, and trigonometry which are built on a foundation of arithmetic. Mechanics and dynamics are built on foundations of physics, geometry, and differential equations.

I was once kicked out of an undergraduate social sciences class for knowing too much math. I’ll repeat the whole story some other time. Back when I was in grad school I used to tutor social sciences grad students in statistics. I was dismayed at their lack of mathematical maturity and their complete lack of a feel for numbers. Essentially, whatever was spit out of the computer statistics package they were using was good enough for them. They had no idea what it all actually meant. If I’m judging my timeframe correctly, these were the scholars who were, at least, the contemporaries of the doctoral candidates that Dr. Hacker advised and who in all likelihood are heads of departments now, preparing for retirement. If you want an explanation for the sorry state of the social sciences, this is it.

I’ll go farther and hazard a guess that poli sci, like the other social sciences, is much more empirical and quantitative now than it was then and that Dr. Hacker would be hard put to earn a doctorate in his own field nowadays.

If you want to drop something out of the high school curriculum, drop high school social sciences courses. They’re worse than useless—they’re propaganda. They give no foundation in anything including an undergraduate or graduate degree in the social sciences.

31 comments

Losing Control

Here’s a story I found fascinating. Remember the 3D printing I mentioned not long ago? It seems that there’s a chap who has used a 3D printer to print a gun:

So, can you print a gun? Yep, you can and that’s exactly what somebody with the alias “HaveBlue” did.

To be accurate, HaveBlue didn’t print an entire gun, he printed a “receiver” for an AR-15 (better known as the military’s M16) at a cost of about $30 worth of materials.

The receiver is, in effect, the framework of a gun and holds the barrel and all of the other parts in place. It’s also the part of the gun that is technically, according to US law, the actual gun and carries the serial number.

When the weapon was assembled with the printed receiver HaveBlue reported he fired 200 rounds and it operated perfectly.

The personal computer caused mainframe manufacturers to lose control of computing.

Low cost laser printers caused professional printing establishments to lose control of printing.

The Internet has caused the print and broadcast media to lose control of the distribution of news and other information, something that’s only been accelerated by the advent of social media.

Amazon.com has changed the power structure of publishing. VCRs, then DVDs, then BDs and streaming have changed and are changing the power structure of the distribution of music, movies, and other entertainment.

3D printing has the potential of causing the government to lose control over all sorts of things from guns to pharmaceuticals and beyond.

21 comments

A Discouraging Picture Emerges

I’ve mentioned before that I’m discouraged about the presidential campaigns. Not the least reason is that I vote for president primarily on foreign policy and, weak as Obama has been from my point of view, Romney is shaping up to be much worse. This is actually a little bit encouraging:

JERUSALEM — Mitt Romney said Sunday that he respects the right of Israel to defend itself, but seemed to back off a foreign policy adviser’s earlier suggestion that he would support a unilateral military strike by Israel against Iran to stop Tehran from obtaining nuclear weapon capability.

The presumptive Republican nominee began a series of meetings with top Israeli officials here Sunday and plans to deliver a muscular defense of Israel in a formal speech delivered near Jerusalem’s Old City.

Asked during an interview with CBS’s “Face the Nation” whether he would “support Israel’s bombing of Iran,” Romney responded, “That would be statement which would be of a different nature than what our nation has already expressed with regard to Iran. What we have said and with which I concur is that we should use every diplomatic and political vehicle that’s available to us to keep Iran from becoming a nuclear capability state…

“If all those options fail, then we do have other options and we don’t take those other options off the table. But that’s as far as I’m willing to go in terms of discussing this matter while on foreign soil.”

The dichotomy in U. S. foreign policy positions on Israel has been between the “no daylight” strategy favored by both the Clinton and Bush 43 administrations and the “conditional support” view favored by the Obama Administration. A return to the “no daylight” strategy probably won’t do a thing for Romney’s support among American Jews who, as George Will noted on This Week today, will continue to vote overwhelmingly Democratic but it will shore up his support somewhat among evangelicals, still unsure of him, who are a make or break voting bloc for him.

Unfortunately, although the “conditional support” strategy is probably objectively a better one for the United States, the Obama Administration has gotten precious little for its approach. The Arab states of the Middle East still don’t consider us an unbiased interlocutor and, honestly, the ship for that has probably sailed. The best we can be for the foreseeable future is the Far Evil as opposed to the Near Evil (Iran) and it’s hard for us to claim that status with the huge military presence we continue to have in the region.

Despite that tiny glimmer of hope in what has otherwise been one foreign policy snafu after another for the Romney campaign, I’m still unhappy. Let’s consider the possible outcomes that have even a remote likelihood of actually coming about.

Status quo: Obama re-elected, Republicans hold House, Democrats hold Senate

As Shakespeare said, nothing will come of nothing. Does anyone see any great likelihood that the Republican House will be more favorably predisposed to a lame duck Obama than they have been to a first term Obama? Or that the president will exert greater efforts to work with them now than he has to date? Or that the Senate will become less stupid if it continues under its present leadership?

Bipolar government: Obama re-elected, Republicans hold House and take Senate

At this point I think this is the most likely outcome and, if I thought that controlling Congress would make Congressional Republicans and the White House more eager to work together, it would be my favored outcome. That would, basically, be the Clinton Administration 1995-1998. Unfortunately, I think we’re more likely to get the Clinton Administration 1999-2000.

An uneasy balance: Romney elected, Republicans hold House, Democrats hold Senate

If I believed that a Democratically-controlled Senate would really act to restrain the new Romney Administration’s worst foreign policy impulses (or, as, I think Dan Drezner has suggested, that Romney is just saying the stuff about foreign policy required to get elected and would actually be more like Bush 41), this would not be an awful outcome. Unfortunately, I think the present Senate cannot be trusted to act prudently and that Romney actually believes some of the stupid things he’s been saying about foreign policy.

The Wave: Romney elected, Republicans hold House, Republicans take Senate

We’ve seen this movie before: George W. Bush in 2001-2004. During this period the federal government was not notable for either its fiscal or foreign policy restraint. If it is, in fact, true that both parties are bipolar, showing one face when out of power and one face when in power, and the face we saw during George W. Bush’s first term was the face of today’s Republican Party when in power, I do not see a return to that as something to which I’d look forward.

17 comments

The Impossible Dream

In a report at Brookings William Galston makes a quixotic case for a major overhaul of government in the next administration. After presenting a historical list of how previous crises have resulted in governmental reform from the Articles of Confederation to Dodd-Frank, he outlines the Obama Administration’s efforts at institutional reform and its critique by Republicans. He continues by outlining a series of areas ripe for reform including the budget, overlapping even conflicting areas of federal responsibility, mistaken over-consolidation in other areas (DHS), and electoral reform.

A man’s reach should exceed his grasp or what’s a heaven for?

I suppose that what he’s outlining is a best case scenario for a prospective Romney Administration. It is a chore for which I strongly suspect Mitt Romney is very well prepared. However, I find it hard to imagine that any of Mr. Galston’s ideas, much as I agree with them, will gain any traction. Over the period of the last three quarters of a century the trend under Republican administrations and Democratic ones has been in the direction of greater consolidation of power in Washington. Every administration has acted to reward its supporters and punish its opponents. I don’t see that as a formula for wide-reaching or even incremental government institutional reform.

Contrariwise, I think the prospects for governmental reform are much stronger from the bottom up, from local governments to state governments. Just as ever-increasing wages, benefits, and influence for public employees had implications for how the business of local government has been conducted so will the ever-decreasing wages, benefits, and influence that necessity is just now beginning to impose and of which the string of municipal bankruptcies in California is only the first harbinger.

4 comments

Municipal Bankruptcy Watch: Discharging Stockton’s Obligations in Bankruptcy

A federal bankruptcy judge has approved Stockton’s plan to reduce retiree healthcare payments while it reorganizes:

SAN FRANCISCO (Reuters) – A federal bankruptcy judge on Friday cleared the way for Stockton, California to cut health care benefits for retirees while it is in bankruptcy proceedings.

Stockton is seeking Chapter 9 protection from its creditors and said that it would cut retiree health benefits while it reorganizes. Retired employees sued to stop those cuts.

Judge Christopher Klein on Friday issued a temporary order denying the bid to stop the benefit cuts, and he said a formal decision was on its way.

Stockton’s attorneys had argued that bankruptcy law gave the city wide latitude on how to spend its revenue while it prepares a plan to restructure its finances.

“For the reasons explained in the forthcoming decision of this court, the Application for Temporary Restraining Order and Preliminary Injunction or in the Alternative for Relief from Stay is DENIED,” Klein wrote.

“A further order will be entered contemporaneous with the formal decision,” the temporary order said.

The case in U.S. Bankruptcy Court, Eastern District of California, is an adversary proceeding, 12-02302, associated with the main bankruptcy case, 12-32118.

Just the tip of the iceberg.

0 comments

Recycling

John Kass weighs in on the controversy over denying a zoning permit to Chick-Fil-A on the basis of the chain’s owners expressed beliefs:

So if a business owner makes public his personal views, it won’t be the public that decides whether to patronize the establishment. Instead, politicians will decide for us and swing the government hammer to knock the business down.

The message from Chicago’s City Hall is simple: Speak out of turn and we’ll crush you. And if you think that the Bible should inform you, then you’re nothing but a bigot who deserves to be crushed.

Personally, I’m ambivalent on the gay marriage issue. The libertarian in me says people should swing the way they want to swing. The Christian in me is informed by the Bible and my church, which define marriage in the traditional way. But my Christianity also tells me to love thy neighbor, baby, and to remove the beam from my own eye before worrying about the splinter in my neighbor’s eye.

Kass’s view expressed here is much my own.

I am dismayed by the ongoing discussion of this subject. There is no ambiguity or gray area on the illegality of the alderman’s actions. There is abundant case law rejecting the power of officials to deny permits based on the petitioner’s prior speech.

If you disapprove of the views articulated by the owner of a fast food chain, by all means do not patronize the chain. By what right do you deny him to what, in the absence of those views, would otherwise be perfectly acceptable? I find the eagerness of people to use the power of government to punish people with whom they disagree politically far more frightening than the views they’re condemning.

In a more humorous vein, I never thought we’d be able to re-purpose Oscar Wilde’s wisecrack about fox-hunting: the unspeakable in pursuit of the uneatable. Clearly, I was wrong.

9 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Here are this week’s full results:

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The post on the Council site is here.

0 comments

Can’t Figure It Out

There’s something I’ve been chewing on for a while which I’ve finally decided I just don’t understand. Why are individuals who self-insure “free riders” while companies that self-insure, which is most large companies, aren’t?

This is, by the way, one of the subsidies to large companies that I complain about here from time to time.

24 comments

Does Medal Inequality Present a Problem?

Mark Perry presents a table of the distribution of Olympic medals side by side with the distribution of income. One difference between the two that I can think of is that there may be a better case that getting medals influences the judges to award you more medals in the case of income than in the Olympics. In either case my concern is more about the role of the Romanian judges in the awarding of medals than in who gets the medals.

As I’ve tried to indicate before I think a lot of the argument over income inequality is misdirection. I see very little discussion of redistribution from the top 10% of income earners to the bottom 10% of income earners and lots of discussion of redistribution among people in the top 10% of income earners. On behalf of the bottom 10%, of course.

2 comments