SUA—the Problem That Can’t Be Waved Away

For the metallurgist in all of us. The problem of Sudden Unintended Acceleration in Toyotas and other automobiles is raising its ugly head again, even after NHTSA had declared that there was absolutely no electrical cause for it. The latest explanation is also one of the earliest raised—tin whiskers, metal dendrites that can form on electroplated tin:

Much of the debate over tin whiskers died down in February 2011, after Secretary of Transportation Ray LaHood called on teams of NHTSA and NASA engineers to search for the cause of Toyota’s problems. “The verdict is in,” LaHood declared emphatically after the scientists reached their conclusion. “There is no electronic-based cause for unintended high-speed acceleration in Toyotas. Period.”

After that conclusion was announced, the National Academy of Sciences said that all available data indicated there was no electronic or software problem on the Toyotas.

Still, the buzz about tin whiskers continued in some quarters, especially after a separate team of NASA scientists published a study (PDF) of Toyota accelerator pedals on the Internet in September 2011. The scientists said they found tin whiskers in an accelerator assembly, and “a tin whisker induced short was responsible for the failure of a 2003 Toyota Camry Accelerator Pedal Position (APP) Sensor based on a Dual Potentiometer Design.”

In his letter, Grassley cited that study and its author, Henning Leidecker of NASA Goddard, to support his claim that more questions needed to be answered.

In response to the latest volley, Toyota officials argued that tin whiskers may cause failure of pedal sensors, but they’ve never caused unintended acceleration. “We know that tin whiskers can form — we’ve never said they couldn’t,” Brian Lyons, a spokesman for Toyota, told us. “But when pedals fail — for whatever reason — the vehicle enters into a fail-safe situation, a limp-home mode.”

While I would be completely unsurprised if most of the incidents of sudden unintended acceleration were, indeed, caused by driver error, I am 99.9% certain that some of the incidents can’t be explained that way. Or by floor carpets or mechanical linkage problems.

My own preferred explanation is software problem. The notion that such a problem could unquestionably be identified by code inspection alone (which is what Toyota and NHTSA have done and said) is laughable.

16 comments

Too Big Not to Break Up

Courtesy of Washington’s Blog an impressive list of bankers, economists, and financial experts who’ve called for breaking up the big banks. They represent a broad range of the political spectrum, too.

It’s an idea whose time has come. Maybe ten years ago.

35 comments

A Creative Fed Produces Uncertainty

That’s the five word summary of John B. Taylor’s commentary on Fed actions:

The Fed has effectively replaced large segments of the market with itself—it bought 77% of new federal debt in 2011. By doing so, it creates great uncertainty about the impact of its actions on inflation, the dollar and the economy. The very existence of quantitative easing as a policy tool creates uncertainty and volatility, as traders speculate on whether and when the Fed is going to intervene again. It’s bad for the U.S. stock market, which is supposed to reflect the earnings of corporations.

2 comments

The Smaller Glass

The Bureau of Economic Analysis has produced its first estimate of 2nd quarter 2012 growth in the United States. Expectations were for an increase of 1.2%; the BEA estimated an increase of 1.5%.

More interesting are the revised estimates for previous quarters and years. The first quarter’s growth was revised upwards slightly from 1.9% to 2%. 2009 growth was re-estimated upwards very slightly, 2010 growth re-estimated downwards very slightly, and 2011 growth upwards very slightly. From 2008 through 2011 real growth has increased an average of .3% per year. That compares with the longterm average real growth rate of 2%.

From an economic standpoint it’s increasingly clear that whatever they call what we’re in it’s actually an L-shaped recession. Real growth is all but flat and has been for the last three years. It’s similar to what Japan has experienced following its balance sheet recession, ongoing for twenty years. The traditional driver of economic recovery, housing, is no longer on the floor and a drag on GDP but it is unlikely that it will resume its importance in producing increased economic growth any time soon.

Politically, the news is not as bad as it might have been but the White House must surely have been hoping for something better. Many econometric models for predicting popular vote outcomes depend heavily on this BEA report. 1.5% growth means too close to call.

The upside, of course, is that the economy is not actually deteriorating. The downside is that it’s growing too slowly to bring the millions of unemployed back to work. Further, the emerging picture of economic activity in the U. S. undercuts the administration’s explanations of what happened somewhat: what really happened is that their policy responses were inadequate to the actual economic situation. The administration will, of course, continue to blame that on its predecessor but certainly that excuse must have a sell-by date which has already passed.

There’s an old engineering wisecrack: a pessimist says the glass is half empty; the optimist says the glass is half full; the engineer says you need a smaller glass. Unfortunately, we now have a smaller glass.

Update

James Pethokoukis says that when you plug the latest GDP growth figures into Ray Fair’s econometric model of presidential popular vote outcomes, it predicts a Romney win:

And when you plug these new numbers into the election forecasting model of Yale University’s Ray Fair — assuming next quarter is no better than the past two — it shows a 4-point Mitt Romney victory over Barack Obama (in the two-party vote totals).

Dr. Fair should have an update of his election projection within the next few days. I’ll wait for that.

6 comments

Right-Sizing Infrastructure

Hardly a day goes by without an op-ed, editorial, or television commentary calling for additional infrastructure spending in the United States, citing “crumbling infrastructure”, “frayed infrastructure”, “decayed (or decaying) infrastructure”, etc. How would you go about measuring the objective truth of the claim?

For doing this I think that absolute measurements of infrastructure quantity are useless. Measurements of quality don’t help much, either. Does it really matter how many bridges or how many miles of road we have and what their condition are? If so, the requirement can be satisfied just by building more without regard to where it’s placed or whether it’s useful or not. That would mean that concerns about building the “Bridge to Nowhere”, a bridge to be built at a cost of $400 million that would serve 50 residents of an island in Alaska, were completely misplaced.

Does it matter how many bridge, etc. we have per U. S. resident? Same thing: utility and suitability to task are more important than coarse measurements like road miles per 100,000 population.

In my view what’s more important is whether we can get from Point A to Point B at reasonable time and expense. That would need to be weighted by traffic and intensity, tricky since time and expense influence both. I think it’s more important whether you can ship freight from Omaha to Toledo than it is whether the morning commute from Hinsdale downtown can be done in less than 40 minutes but I suppose that’s where value judgments enter into the calculation.

Criticisms of U. S. infrastructure are occasionally (particularly those by New York Times columnist Tom Friedman) made in disparaging comparison with China. In my view the comparison is patently absurd. I would be willing to bet a shiny new dime that you can ship a new iPad from the factory in which it is produced in China anywhere in the continental United States faster than you can ship an iPad from that same factory to a destination in some places in China. That’s how you compare infrastructure capabilities.

China has great needs; it’s been building new infrastructure at a furious pace to meet those needs. Some of that construction has been effective, other has not as can be gauged in part by the entire cities without inhabitants, the collapse of newly-built schools in the earthquake of a few years ago, the now-empty Olympic stadiums for the last Summer Olympics, the accidents involving highspeed passenger rail that are a cause célèbre in China, and China’s still overburdened rail freight system.

I’ve given my opinion on this subject from time to time: I think we’d be better off putting intensive effort and investment into improving our energy infrastructure, e.g. oil and gas pipelines, the power grid, power distribution, power generation, than we would be in investing more in our transportation infrastructure.

23 comments

The Waste

It had never occurred to me before but now that I think of it carloads of garbage shipped by rail might be a pretty good indicator of GDP and as you can see from the graph above, courtesy of Business Insider, it is. Interestingly, sometimes, as in 1999, it’s a leading indicator, and sometimes, as in 2008, a trailing one but mostly carloads of garbage shipped by rail tracks GDP pretty closely. 82%, according to Bloomberg.

How can we explain the sharp, even historic, divergence that’s apparent today? One reason may be that we’re just not as trashy as we used to be. Or that less trash as a proportion of the whole is being transported by rail as state and local govenrments tighten their belts.

It’s possible that if enough of the growth is purely financial growth, concentrated in few enough hands, that the historic relationship could break down. Surely there’s some limit to how much garbage one person can produce. Although if folks up on Capitol Hill are any gauge that might not be the case.

It does seem to me that railways cars of waste is a lot easier to calculate on a timely basis than GDP. The BEA’s first estimate of 2nd quarter 2012 growth is due tomorrow. Expectations for that are growth of 1.2% on an annualized basis, down from 1.9% the previous quarter. It may be that we are in for some unwanted news.

23 comments

In the Future

From time to time I’ve written here about 3D printing, fablabs, and other related technologies. There’s something mesmerizing about this Dutch designer’s video of an old Chinese industrial robot he’s adapted to creating the furniture that he’s designed:

It’s pretty interesting how the recycled interiors of refrigerators are harvested and repurposed into usable furniture. It took a while to perfect but his machine can now produce a piece of furniture in a few hours.

In related news researchers at the University of Glasgow are working on a system to create pharmaceuticals using 3D printers. In their process the vessels in which the drugs are created take an active part in the process:

A new research paper, published in the journal Nature Chemistry, outlines how the process has been proven to work. Using a commercially-available 3D printer operated by open-source computer-aided design software, Professor Cronin and his team have built what they call ‘reactionware’, special vessels for chemical reactions which are made from a polymer gel which sets at room temperature.

By adding other chemicals to the gel deposited by the printer, the team have been able to make the vessel itself part of the reaction process. While this is common in large-scale chemical engineering, the development of reactionware makes it possible for the first time for custom vessels to be fabricated on a laboratory scale.

Professor Cronin said: “It’s long been possible to have lab materials custom-made to include windows or electrodes, for example, but it’s been expensive and time-consuming. We can fabricate these reactionware vessels using a 3D printer in a relatively short time. Even the most complicated vessels we’ve built have only taken a few hours.

“By making the vessel itself part of the reaction process, the distinction between the reactor and the reaction becomes very hazy. It’s a new way for chemists to think, and it gives us very specific control over reactions because we can continually refine the design of our vessels as required.

“For example, our initial reactionware designs allowed us to synthesize three previously unreported compounds and dictate the outcome of a fourth reaction solely by altering the chemical composition of the reactor.”

In the future a drugstore may be a place where custom-designed pharmaceuticals are produced to order. Or it could be your basement.

There are lots of exciting, even frightening, aspects of something like this. Physicians, drug companies, even governments are losing control.

3 comments

A Roadmap to Compromise for CPS

…right over Chicago’s taxpayers. If Joe Moreno doesn’t want more jobs in the 1st Ward, Mayor Emanuel has a solution ready at hand: hire more teachers! The first step on the road to a compromise between the mayor and the Chicago Teachers Union over longer work days and years for Chicago teachers in the form of hiring nearly 500 more teachers has been proposed as a solution to the impasse between the mayor and the CTU over the mayor’s plans for longer school days and years and the teachers’ demand for more pay:

Removing a major hurdle in the contentious contract talks with the teachers union, Chicago Public Schools agreed Tuesday to hire nearly 500 teachers so students can put in a longer school day without extending the workday for most teachers.

Both sides claimed victory, as Mayor Rahm Emanuel was able to keep his plan for a longer day intact and the union was able to add teachers while holding the line on how long they work.

But the two sides warned that several sticking points have yet to be resolved in the contract dispute, and the union said Tuesday’s agreement does not eliminate the threat of a strike.

“It is too bad this solution, which was actually presented months ago, was rejected out of hand” at that time, said Chicago Teachers Union President Karen Lewis. “It has taken a march of nearly 10,000 educators, a strike authorization vote and a fact-finder’s report to get CPS to move on this issue.”

Emanuel called the agreement “a breakthrough” but said “there are a lot of other issues to still be resolved.”

What’s not to like? The solution allows the CTU’s leaders to declare victory for their members and provides an additional 500 dues-paying union members. The mayor avoids a strike and gets a minimally-increased school day.

Unfortunately, the Chicago Public School’s budget is already $665 million in the red and this plan would expand that deficit by at least $32 million with more red ink to come in the normal course of events. As I’ve mentioned before the CPS’s only real recourse is to increase property taxes. That amounts to $250 for every man, woman, and child in Chicago. In practice I strongly suspect it means at least $1,000 more in property taxes for every homeowner in the city. It’s not clear to me what that would be buying. Other than an opportunity for the mayor and the head of the CTU both to declare victory, I mean.

5 comments

Acceptable Owners Only, Please (Updated)

There’s quite a bit of Chicago news worth commenting on today. Chicago 1st Ward Alderman Joe Moreno has inserted himself into the Chick-Fil-A controversy. I haven’t been following the controversy closely but my understanding is that the fast food chain’s owner is a vocal opponent of gay marriage. Alderman Moreno has moved to deny the chain a zoning permit to build a store in his ward:

A Chicago alderman wants to kill Chick-fil-A’s plans to build a restaurant in his increasingly trendy Northwest Side ward because the fast-food chain’s top executive vocally opposes gay marriage.

Ald.Proco “Joe” Moreno announced this week that he will block Chick-fil-A’s effort to build its second Chicago store, which would be in the Logan Square neighborhood, following company President Dan Cathy’s remarks last week that he was “guilty as charged” for supporting the biblical definition of marriage as between a man and woman.

“If you are discriminating against a segment of the community, I don’t want you in the 1st Ward,” Moreno told the Tribune on Tuesday.

For those of you who aren’t familiar with Chicago’s system, city council members, known as aldermen, have great influence over the building permits issued in their wards. The city does have a building permit department but aldermen must sign off on just about anything built in their wards and they have, essentially, unlimited discretion in that area.

I think there are legitimate reasons for such a system. Aldermen provide local knowledge, are aware of local conditions, and act as the city’s interface with the people of the ward. I’m not as sure that this is a legitimate exercise of discretion on Ald. Moreno’s part. I believe there is an abundance of case law limiting the denial of permits and variances to cases other than the ones Ald. Moreno cites.

I have been unable to identify any Chicago-specific opinion polling on this subject. I’m sure there is some somewhere. I suspect that Chicagoans, like other Americans, are closely divided on this subject.

For me the essential question about denying Chick-Fil-A the right to open a store in the 1st Ward is the legitimacy and, indeed, prudence of rejecting businesses not because of what they do but because of what their absent owners say. That’s troubling to me. It seems to me that if Chick-Fil-A is unable to make it in the 1st Ward because customers won’t patronize a store whose owner espouses the views held by Chick-Fil-A’s, that’s Chick-Fil-A’s lookout. In rejecting Chick-Fil-A’s application, Ald. Moreno is also rejecting the sales tax revenue and jobs that the store will bring.

Update

Eugene Volokh lends some support to what I suggested in my post:

…denying a private business permits because of such speech by its owner is a blatant First Amendment violation. Even when it comes to government contracting — where the government is choosing how to spend government money — the government generally may not discriminate based on the contractor’s speech, see Board of County Commissioners v. Umbehr (1996). It is even clearer that the government may not make decisions about how people will be allowed to use their own property based on the speaker’s past speech.

And this is so even if there is no statutory right to a particular kind of building permit (and I don’t know what the rule is under Illinois law). Even if the government may deny permits to people based on various reasons, it may not deny permits to people based on their exercise of his First Amendment rights. It doesn’t matter if the applicant expresses speech that doesn’t share the government officials’ values, or even the values of the majority of local citizens. It doesn’t matter if the applicant’s speech is seen as “disrespect[ful]” of certain groups. The First Amendment generally protects people’s rights to express such views without worrying that the government will deny them business permits as a result. That’s basic First Amendment law — but Alderman Moreno, Mayor Menino, and, apparently, Mayor Emanuel (if his statement is quoted in context), seem to either not know or not care about the law.

and, as pointed out in comments, the taxpayers of Chicago are on the hook for Ald. Merino’s misfeasance. If Chick-Fil-A elects to sue the city, the city will lose, pay lawyers’ fees, court costs, and whatever judgement is levied. This is no small matter. In 2010 alone Chicago spent $85 million defending against lawsuits. Further tens of millions are pending in cases the city is trying to settle right now.

I honestly don’t see what recourse the people of Chicago have against this sort of thing. Only the voters of the 1st Ward vote for the alderman of the 1st Ward. Once he’s been elected he’ll serve his full term, come hell, high water, or law suit. I don’t think we should pay for aldermanic overreaching any more than we should pay for police chiefs torturing people that have been arrested. The settlements imply there’s something we could have done about it. There wasn’t. No one is ever elected or appointed to violate the law.

17 comments

The Gray Middle

Imagine my disappointment on reading a post titled “How big is the output gap?” from economist Mike Bryan of th Atlanta Fed that his answer is “Not as low as zero and not as high as $1 trillion” (the straight line projection of GDP growth from 2005 through 2007 illustrated here).

He’s right. It is an important question and I wish at the very least he had offered an opinion as to whether it’s closer to zero or $1 trillion. I guess that’s what a PhD in economics is good for.

As I have suggested I think the output gap is much closer to zero than it is to $1 trillion, that Keynesian polices intended to close the gap between present output and the non-existent additional $1 trillion are in vain, and the real problem we should be trying to solve is to make GDP grow faster. As I have also suggested I think the path to faster GDP growth lies through producing a lot more energy, reducing spending on healthcare and education without reducing the actual amounts of healthcare and education produced, sharply reducing the size of the financial sector, and rationalizing our immigration and trade policies. Just to name a few impossible dreams.

However, he does ask an interesting question. If the output gap is small, why hasn’t a restructuring of the economy occurred? I have two answers to that question. First, the problems we’re experiencing did not start in 2007 but go back much farther. This isn’t the dream (or nightmare, I guess). 1996 through 2006 were the dream. This is the reality. The reason we had so much employment during that period was bubbles. Imaginary production.

My second answer is that policy since 2007 has almost entirely been devoted to preventing the restructuring that should have taken place. With trillions spent on behalf of maintaining an impossible status quo it would be surprising if restructuring had taken place. Financial sector bailouts. Auto industry bailouts. Block grants to states to allow them to keep their impossible compensation schemes for public employees intact. Maintaining unemployment benefits which nearly everyone agrees reduces employment by something between 1% and 5%. Just where in that range is a subject of bitter argument.

19 comments