Dumb and Dumber

This post is a riff on James Kwak’s plaint over The Economist’s implied characterization of Barack Obama’s favoring big government vs. Mitt Romney’s favoring small government rather than what Mr. Kwak believes: that President Obama favors small government and Gov. Romney favors tiny government. Rather than discuss the merits of Mr. Kwak’s claims (I disagree) I want to go off on something of a tangent.

I don’t honestly know whether President Obama favors large government over small government as a matter of principle. I don’t know about Gov. Romney, either. Neither one of them is proposing small government let alone tiny government. Characterizing a government that controls 40% of GDP as “small” is, to say the least, an exaggeration. Characterizing a government that controls 20% of GDP as “tiny” is deranged.

I think all of this is largely beside the point. It’s possible to have good large government and bad small government. IMO good large government is as difficult as a camel going through the eye of a needle but, as Jesus of Nazareth observed, with God all things are possible. Possible but unlikely. Human beings being what they are it’s very unlikely.

The reason to favor small government over large government is to mitigate the risk of inevitable failures.

I believe we’ve reached the point where, large or small, we can no longer tolerate dumb government or, at least, so much dumb government.

That we spend so much on security is dumb.

That we continue to maintain price supports in agriculture when we know them to be economically inefficient is dumb.

I think that we import so much in the way of goods and materials and export bonds is dumb. I recognize that’s a matter of hot dispute. Others think that it’s smart and our trading partners exporting goods and materials to us and importing bonds is dumb.

Spending a multiple of what other advanced economies do for healthcare with poorer outcomes is dumb.

Continual saber-rattling is dumb.

Compensation for public employees that’s obviously above the market clearing price for such compensation is dumb.

Trying to pick winners and losers in the economy is dumb.

Importing an unskilled or semi-skilled labor force when we have a large native population of unskilled or semi-skilled workers is dumb.

Subsidizing big banks, shuttering small banks, and complaining that so many of the remaining banks are too big to fail is dumb.

Bailing out companies whose main problem is an unworkable labor cost structure and maintaining the labor cost structure is dumb.

That it takes so long and is so onerous to get a building permit or a business permit is dumb.

Requiring that corn be used to make fuel when corn crops are failing is dumb.

Refusing to capitalize on cheap, available, cleaner production of energy and complaining that energy production is too dirty is dumb.

We don’t have a choice between big and small. We have a choice between dumb and dumber.

When you’re the only game in town you can afford to be dumb. We can’t afford to be dumb any more.

15 comments

The Evolution of a Word

The word “gaffe” is of obscure origins (possibly deriving from a French word for a boat hook) and means or at least used to mean a blunder. In recent years the word has been expanded to include something journalist Michael Kinsley once wisecracked: a gaffe is when a politician inadvertently tells the truth.

Over the last week or so the meaning of the word has, apparently, expanded once again to include telling uncomfortable truths. When Mitt Romney questioned the security arrangements at the London Olympics was it a blunder? An inadvertent telling of the truth? Or just plain telling an uncomfortable truth?

A day or so ago when Mitt Romney remarked that the reason that the per capita GDP of the Israelis was so much higher than that of the Palestinians was it a blunder? An inadvertent telling of the truth? Or just plain telling an uncomfortable truth? I think almost unquestionably the latter and, apparently, Marc Thiessen agrees with me:

The media is accusing Mitt Romney of having committed another “gaffe” abroad — this time when he suggested that cultural differences help explain why the Israelis are so much more economically successful than Palestinians.

One small problem with that: What Romney said was not a gaffe. He was absolutely right.

In reporting the so-called gaffe, the New York Times explained that Romney simply does not understand that the Palestinians’ economic problems are all Israel’s fault: “The Palestinians have long complained that their economy is in a chokehold from Israeli security measures,” the Times declared, adding “The West Bank is subject to trade restrictions imposed by the Israelis, while Gaza was subject to a near-total Israeli blockade on people and goods after Hamas took control of its government five years ago. Mr. Romney mentioned neither during his speech on Monday.”

But these security measures are the direct result of culture — the culture of terrorism that permeates the Palestinian territories. In 2009, the Pew Global Attitudes Project showed support for suicide bombing on the decline across the Muslim world, with just one lonely exception: the Palestinian territories: “[M]ajorities or pluralities among eight of the nine Muslim publics surveyed this year say that suicide bombing and other forms of violence against civilians can never be justified to defend Islam; only in the Palestinian territories does a majority endorse such attacks.” [Emphasis added].

That’s just the tip of the iceberg. I have little doubt that there’s a kernel of truth in the Palestinians’ complaint that the Israelis’ sanctions are suppressing their economy below what it otherwise might be. That could explain a fraction of the difference between the economy of the Palestinians and that of the Syrians or even the Lebanese. The sanctions do not explain the difference between the economy of Israel and those of Lebanon, Syria, the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, Jordan, and Iraq, just to name a few of the countries in the region.

The Palestinians’ problems do not end with Israel’s sanctions. There’s also corruption, lack of liberty, cronyism, kleptocracy, and undercapitalization. That the Arab countries have a tradition of not lending money at interest, clearly a cultural difference, might have something to do with their inadequate capitalization.

Under this new definition of “gaffe” what isn’t a gaffe? Discrete lying by omission?

25 comments

Yet Another Headwind

Just what we need. When people talk about the potential hazards we may encounter in our economic recovery without any recovery, they usually talk about monetary crisis and recession in Europe or China’s economy slowing from its blistering pace to a slower rate, more characteristic of a developed country. Or they talk about the paiinfully slow, tentative recovery in the housing market.

They haven’t been talking about rising gas prices but that certainly appears to me to be what’s happening. Here in Chicago the gas prices have risen 10% in just the last two weeks. A quick check has suggested to me that’s true in other parts of the country as well.

Some have mentioned unease about the situation in the Middle East but I don’t see much reason to be more concerned now than a month ago. U. S. consumption actually seems to have decreased. I’m at a loss to explain it.

The linked article suggests speculation.

Whatever their cause may be higher gas prices going into the fall are not going to improve the economic picture.

4 comments

Tony Martin, 1913-2012

Tony Martin, Hollywood singer-actor of the 1940s and 50s has died:

Tony Martin, the last of the big-name singer-actors from the golden age of Hollywood musicals, has died. He was 98.

Martin, who toured for years with his wife, dancer-actress Cyd Charisse, died of natural causes Friday at his home in Los Angeles, his longtime business manager, Stan Schneider, told The Times.

He appeared in more than 30 films, most memorably as a thief at odds with Peter Lorre’s inspector in 1948’s stylish “Casbah,” one of the many movie musicals that helped turn Martin into a star.

He apparently took it quite hard when Cyd Charisse, his wife of sixty years and night club act partner, died a few years back. But that didn’t stop him from performing. I suspect that going on stage was therapy.

Mr. Martin had a charming manner about him and a beautiful voice. His musicals aren’t shown on TV as frequently as the dancing musicals featuring Fred Astaire or Gene Kelly are but they’re worth catching if only for a basis of comparison.

However, the first sentence of that LA Times obit is a trifle misleading. There are a number of singer-actresses from the “golden age of Hollywood musicals” still around (and performing!) notably Jane Powell and Debbie Reynolds. And, of course, Deanna Durbin, retired and maintaining her privacy for more than 60 years, is still alive. But they’re actresses.

And Marc Platt, who was featured in or starred in a number of Hollywood musicals of the 40s and 50s, turns 99 in December. He was the original “Dream Curley” on Broadway and played Daniel in Seven Brides for Seven Brothers. Despite being over 40 when the picture was made, he kept up handily with men who were decades his junior. He’s probably still dancing.

0 comments

When the Bubble Bursts

What happens when the bubble bursts and that $1 million property is now selling for a third of what it cost? What happens when that’s in the fastest growing market? What happens when it’s in Hong Kong, we’re talking about ultra-luxury automobiles, they have incredibly high margins, and they’re mostly imported from Europe?

For some reason or other I found this post on the potentially collapsing market for ultra-luxury cars in Hong Kong thought-provoking.

1 comment

The Guy Behind the Tree

Lambert Strether at naked capitalism argues that the policies put in place in the early part of President Obama’s first term are the policies that the Congressional Democratic leadership and the Obama Administration wanted to put in place.

3 comments

As Good As It Gets

Bill Gross, head of bond giant PIMCO, makes an interesting observation:

If wealth or real GDP was only being created at an annual rate of 3.5% over the same period of time, then somehow stockholders must be skimming 3% off the top each and every year. If an economy’s GDP could only provide 3.5% more goods and services per year, then how could one segment (stockholders) so consistently profit at the expense of the others (lenders, laborers and government)? The commonsensical “illogic” of such an arrangement when carried forward another century to 2112 seems obvious as well. If stocks continue to appreciate at a 3% higher rate than the economy itself, then stockholders will command not only a disproportionate share of wealth but nearly all of the money in the world! Owners of “shares” using the rather simple “rule of 72” would double their advantage every 24 years and in another century’s time would have 16 times as much as the skeptics who decided to skip class and play hooky from the stock market.

Conditions are just about as favorable for corporate profits right now as they can get. Taxes’ share is at an historic low. Labor’s share is at an historic low. How far are taxes and labor expected to fall? Zero? Doesn’t sound like a realistic expectation to me.

If it’s not a realistic expectation and conditions are as favorable as they’re likely to get, how realistic is the idea of a stock market that rises at 6.6% per year?

Tying this to something I’ve written about from time to time, public employee pension funds typically assume a return of 7% or even 8% per year to remain solvent. Bonds are practically guaranteed to earn less than stocks. If stocks earn less than 6.6% and bonds earn less than that, exactly how are they going to earn 8%?

32 comments

The Plan Is Working

You know, you’re pretty much guaranteed to have a low per capita electrical power consumption when your grid doesn’t deliver any power.

0 comments

Fair Model Update

Ray Fair has updated his econometric model of the presidential popular vote outcomes with the latest GDP and inflation figures. For the first time this cycle he finds that President Obama’s percentage of the popular vote is likely to fall below 50%. With becoming focus on his model rather than the politics, essentially he says that if the popular vote isn’t very, very close, there’s something wrong with his model:

Comparing the April 27, 2012, prediction with the July 27, 2012, prediction, the lower growth rate hurt Obama and the lower inflation rate helped. On net, the predicted two-party vote share for the Democrats (VP) fell from 50.2 percent to 49.5 percent. The main message, however, is the same as it has been since October 30, 2011, namely that the election is too close to call. The ex ante standard error is around 3 percent—see Table 5 in Presidential and Congressional Vote-Share Equations: November 2010 Update—and a predicted loss for the Democrats of 0.5 percentage points is well within this standard error. If the election is in fact close, the vote equation will have done well. If one of the two candidates wins by a fairly large amount, it will not have done well.

The president’s prospects are going in the wrong direction.

0 comments

Looking Back

When posting this quick summary of my martial arts experience in comments it occurred to me that, since I consciously avoid a lot of intensive autobiography here, some of my commenters might be interested in getting a little idea of what I’ve done with my life and the experiences that have informed my views. Here are some of the posts in which I’ve talked about this stuff more directly:

Me and music
Starting businesses
Hard work

I thought I’d written a post on the many and varied things I’ve done for pay over the years but I can’t put my hands on it. Maybe later.

While I’m waxing reminiscent and since it’s high summer, here’s an old reminiscence of a summer now nearly sixty years gone.

3 comments