This post is a riff on James Kwak’s plaint over The Economist’s implied characterization of Barack Obama’s favoring big government vs. Mitt Romney’s favoring small government rather than what Mr. Kwak believes: that President Obama favors small government and Gov. Romney favors tiny government. Rather than discuss the merits of Mr. Kwak’s claims (I disagree) I want to go off on something of a tangent.
I don’t honestly know whether President Obama favors large government over small government as a matter of principle. I don’t know about Gov. Romney, either. Neither one of them is proposing small government let alone tiny government. Characterizing a government that controls 40% of GDP as “small” is, to say the least, an exaggeration. Characterizing a government that controls 20% of GDP as “tiny” is deranged.
I think all of this is largely beside the point. It’s possible to have good large government and bad small government. IMO good large government is as difficult as a camel going through the eye of a needle but, as Jesus of Nazareth observed, with God all things are possible. Possible but unlikely. Human beings being what they are it’s very unlikely.
The reason to favor small government over large government is to mitigate the risk of inevitable failures.
I believe we’ve reached the point where, large or small, we can no longer tolerate dumb government or, at least, so much dumb government.
That we spend so much on security is dumb.
That we continue to maintain price supports in agriculture when we know them to be economically inefficient is dumb.
I think that we import so much in the way of goods and materials and export bonds is dumb. I recognize that’s a matter of hot dispute. Others think that it’s smart and our trading partners exporting goods and materials to us and importing bonds is dumb.
Spending a multiple of what other advanced economies do for healthcare with poorer outcomes is dumb.
Continual saber-rattling is dumb.
Compensation for public employees that’s obviously above the market clearing price for such compensation is dumb.
Trying to pick winners and losers in the economy is dumb.
Importing an unskilled or semi-skilled labor force when we have a large native population of unskilled or semi-skilled workers is dumb.
Subsidizing big banks, shuttering small banks, and complaining that so many of the remaining banks are too big to fail is dumb.
Bailing out companies whose main problem is an unworkable labor cost structure and maintaining the labor cost structure is dumb.
That it takes so long and is so onerous to get a building permit or a business permit is dumb.
Requiring that corn be used to make fuel when corn crops are failing is dumb.
Refusing to capitalize on cheap, available, cleaner production of energy and complaining that energy production is too dirty is dumb.
We don’t have a choice between big and small. We have a choice between dumb and dumber.
When you’re the only game in town you can afford to be dumb. We can’t afford to be dumb any more.






