They All Have Good Intentions

It’s not uncommon for me to meet with clients before or after regular business hours. It enables me to meet with my clients without interfering with their regular scheduled activities. This morning I went to a client’s early. On my way back I listened to NPR on the car radio as I usually do (yes, I got caught in the snarl on the Kennedy this morning). They reported on a case in Texas in which the EPA was found to have overreached its authority in a case involving interstate sulfur dioxide emissions. If I hadn’t read about this story before hearing NPR’s take on it, I would hardly have recognized it.

In the NPR coverage it was presented as a miscarriage of justice by a, presumably, out-of-control appellate court on behalf of power a companies. The decision would result in additional sickness, death, and medical expense. As best as I could tell they quoted only from the dissent and, possibly, from the EPA’s attorneys.

Here’s the Reuters coverage of the story:

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit said in a 2-1 decision that the Environmental Protection Agency had exceeded its mandate with the rule, which was to limit sulfur dioxide and nitrogen oxide emissions from power plants in 28 mostly Eastern states and Texas.

In the latest setback for the EPA, the court sent the Cross-State Air Pollution Rule back for revision, telling the agency to administer its existing Clean Air Interstate Rule – the Bush-era regulation that it was updating – in the interim. The EPA said it was reviewing the ruling.

I’m not familiar with the details of the case, Texas, or the power companies involved. My concern is for the rule of law. As I understand it, the court’s majority found that the EPA had overreached the empowering legislation, requiring emission standards significantly lower than those required by Congress and that those standards be met with specific remedies where Congress had explicitly allowed significant flexibility.

Good intentions are not enough. If the law does not allow a federal agency to accomplish the objectives of an incoming administration, go back to Congress and change the law. If you can’t get Congress to change the law or don’t feel that you should need to bother going back to Congress, take up needlepoint. Don’t make up the laws as you go along. That puts you in the same moral category as drug dealers, burglars, and tax scofflaws. They’re all just trying to get by.

Good intentions are not enough. Very, very few people set out explicitly to do evil. They all have good intentions. The problem with approving of a regulation because it’s well-intended is that the other guys have their own good intentions and you may not like their good intentions at all.

2 comments

Why We Must Change

Lawrence Summers does a pretty fair job of explaining why there isn’t much chance that, regardless of who is elected in November and regardless of intentions, we will shrink the size of the federal government appreciably. It boils down to:

  1. An aging population means we’ll spend more on Social Security retirement payments and Medicare.
  2. The cost of financing the debt is much more likely to rise than to fall.
  3. Plain old supply and demand and the deadweight loss of government spending.

or, shorter, unless things change they will stay the same, adjusted for demographics and increased cost of borrowing.

Right now there are something like 20 million people unemployed. What we’re doing now isn’t putting those people back to work. If we want to put those people back to work, we’re going to need to change some things. As Shakespeare put it, nothing will come of nothing. If we don’t change anything, those people won’t go back to work.

It is either stupidity or sophistry to claim that we can’t make substantial reductions in military spending without compromising national security. Can we do that without making any changes? No.

It is either stupidity or sophistry to claim that we can’t make substantial reductions in healthcare spending without compromising the American people’s health. Can we do that without making any changes? No.

I might add that Dr. Summers is ignoring something. Federal government is not the only government and, unless you can come up with a good reason that the deadweight loss of government spending only applies to the federal government, if it’s absolutely positively necessary for the federal government to grow, then maybe it’s also absolutely positively necessary for state and local government to shrink. Unless you don’t give a damn about all of those unemployed people.

Or, maybe, in less you don’t care how small the private sector becomes so long as there’s free healthcare. Then you’re Cuba.

59 comments

Don’t Be Silly

I do not for a second believe that come November Barack Obama won’t emerge from Cook County, generally, and Chicago in particular with huge margins. Indeed, the later the polls in Chicago return their results, the higher his margin will be.

11 comments

The Medicare Discussion Is Bollocks

There’s one segment of the Daily Beast Niall Ferguson piece I cited in my previous post to which I’d like to draw your attention:

And then there was health care. No one seriously doubts that the U.S. system needed to be reformed. But the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA) of 2010 did nothing to address the core defects of the system: the long-run explosion of Medicare costs as the baby boomers retire, the “fee for service” model that drives health-care inflation, the link from employment to insurance that explains why so many Americans lack coverage, and the excessive costs of the liability insurance that our doctors need to protect them from our lawyers.

Ironically, the core Obamacare concept of the “individual mandate” (requiring all Americans to buy insurance or face a fine) was something the president himself had opposed when vying with Hillary Clinton for the Democratic nomination. A much more accurate term would be “Pelosicare,” since it was she who really forced the bill through Congress.

Pelosicare was not only a political disaster. Polls consistently showed that only a minority of the public liked the ACA, and it was the main reason why Republicans regained control of the House in 2010. It was also another fiscal snafu. The president pledged that health-care reform would not add a cent to the deficit. But the CBO and the Joint Committee on Taxation now estimate that the insurance-coverage provisions of the ACA will have a net cost of close to $1.2 trillion over the 2012–22 period.

That’s the section that outraged Paul Krugman, who responded in a post also cited in my post. Does it really surprise anyone that total healthcare spending would rise under the PPACA? It covers more people (not nearly enough people to justify the expense and the debate). Of course, it will be more expensive.

At this point the argument seems to be over how fast healthcare spending will rise rather than how to reduce healthcare spending. Even Paul Ryan is content to constrain the increase to GDP plus .5 and nobody really knows how to do that in the context of the present healthcare system.

It’s complete hooey and I’d like to try to explain why. If it were 40 years ago and healthcare comprised 5% of total GDP, he might be onto something but it isn’t and he isn’t. Healthcare spending is already more than a sixth of the economy and closing in rapidly on becoming a fifth of the economy. Under the circumstances it’s looney to talk about GDP growth rate + .5 because healthcare is already such a large component of GDP.

Let’s use a little example. Let’s say that the GDP growth rate is 1.5% per year. If healthcare spending increases by 6%, that’s already 2/3s of all growth. In other words rather than talking about GDP growth rate + .5 we should at the very least be talking about non-healthcare GDP growth rate + .5. Talking about anything else implies that the heatlhcare sector will continue to grow while just about every other sector of the economy contracts. Since healthcare employs fewer people per incremental dollar than just about any other sector of the economy (it’s a mathematically equivalent statement to “wages are higher in the healthcare sector”), that’s a formula for decreasing overall employment. It’s a positive feedback loop.

Advocates will respond that as countries get richer they will naturally spend more money on healthcare. That, too, is hooey. Countries, e.g. Luxembourg, Switzerland with higher per capita GDPs than the U. S. spend substantially less than we do. There’s nothing natural about our spending. It’s an artifact. We’re not getting value for the money we spend.

I honestly don’t see any way of reducing how much we spend on healthcare in the context of the fee-for-service system and his acknowledgement of that reality is the high point of Dr. Ferguson’s article. Both the PPACA and the Ryan plan are desparate attempts at maintaining an out-of-control and unsustainable system.

4 comments

Take This Job and Shove It

There’s something of a kerfuffle going on in the major media, extending into the blogosphere. First, Harvard history prof Niall Ferguson wrote a Newsweek cover article, “Hit the Road, Barack”, stating his case that President Obama doesn’t deserve a second term and, indeed, a second Obama term would be harmful to the U. S.

Paul Krugman lost no time in countering, charging Dr. Ferguson with a breach of professional ethics. Ferguson rebutted, here. At this point, the intellectual content of the dialogue is about at the level of “Oh, yeah?”

I find it revealing to read these articles and posts in the context of a Politico piece outlining the conflicts within the Obama re-election campaign. The essential message of the piece is that the president, himself, is setting the tone for his re-election campaign. Here’s the part of the cited post that I found most telling:

The e-book, produced as part of a two-month reporting project that included interviews with two dozen current and former members of Obama’s team, illuminates how the mood and character of the 2012 reelection effort is flowing from the top — with Obama’s own personality and values shaping his campaign just as powerfully as he did four years ago.

This has produced a campaign being animated by one thing above all. It is not exclusively about hope and change anymore, words that seem like distant echoes even to Obama’s original loyalists — and to the president himself. It is not the solidarity of a hard-fought cause, often absent in this mostly joyless campaign. It is Obama’s own burning competitiveness, with his remorseless focus on beating Mitt Romney — an opponent he genuinely views with contempt and fears will be unfit to run the country.

Obama is sometimes portrayed as a reluctant warrior, sorry to see 2012 marked by so much partisan warfare but forced by circumstance to go along. But this perception is by most evidence untrue. In the interviews with current and former Obama aides, not one said he expressed any reservations about the negativity. He views it as a necessary part of campaigning, as a natural — if unpleasant — rotation of the cyclical political wheel.

The emphasis is mine.

I have a question. It’s not just rhetorical. I’d really like to hear the case. Can anyone tell me why Barack Obama wants to be president without using the words “Republican”, “Mitt”, “Romney”, or circumlocutions for the above? As a follow-up, why isn’t he doing it now? And, as a second follow-up, what conditions will change that will make that possible when it isn’t now?

I don’t much care for Mitt Romney but I think I have a pretty good idea of why he wants to be president. Not so for President Obama. He really doesn’t seem to like the job very much.

Black man given nation’s worst job, indeed.

11 comments

Finding the Recession

Well, I completely wasted most of the morning (don’t ask). Perhaps not completely wasted. In my peregrinations through parts of the Chicago suburbs I don’t usually find myself in I found sure signs of the recession.

I’m used to seeing the empty remnants of defunct (or soon to be defunct) retail chains scattered around. Frank’s. Circuit City. Wickes. Borders. Best Buy. But those are isolated. Today I saw whole blocks of boarded-up storefronts not once but many times. Sometimes several consecutive blocks.

I’d seen this before in inner cities in the 1960s and 1970s but what I saw today was in what had been reasonably prosperous suburbs that had been farmland less than 40 years ago.

This is really different.

19 comments

The Blue and the Red

Arnold Kling has been posting lately about the prospects for civil war in the United States:

Civil War Scenarios
The 1960s and Today
Civil War Watch: Sentences to Ponder

I agree with him that the idea is still pretty far-fetched. I also think that things would need to get much, much worse before there’s a real prospect for civil war. For one thing married couples in which both spouses used to work and at least one spouse still has a job tend to be something of a firebreak against real desparation.

However, when you read about people shooting other people because the shooter disagrees with the political opinions of the employers of his victim you’ve got to wonder.

20 comments

It Aint’t Necessarily So

Alex Tabarrok points out data that suggest that white Democrats, independents, and Republicans are not enormously different in how racist they are:

It is undeniable that some Americans are racist but racists split about evenly across the parties. No party has a monopoly on racists.

I think it’s interesting that the data also suggest that racism is a fringe view in both parties. Or else that everybody’s lying about their views.

1 comment

Status

I chat with strangers in grocery checkout lines. I just strike up conversations. The weather. What they’re buying. What I’m buying.

The other day I struck up a conversation with a woman who was, perhaps, a few years older than I. I bragged, as I sometimes do, about how wonderful my nieces and nephews are. Which they are.

My nieces and nephews range in age from 21 to 28. For some reason or other the woman brought up the subject of tattoos and how different young people’s ideas are of them than are ours.

“We see them as a sign of low status. They don’t”, I said.

She looked at me as though startled. “I’d never thought of it that way”, she said.

6 comments

Spending Madness

Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis

In a despairing op-ed in the Financial Times, economist Jeffrey Sachs declares that the United States has surrendered to a small government nightmare:

America’s two political parties depend on wealthy contributors to finance their presidential campaigns. These donors want and expect their taxes to stay low. As a result, social divisions, broken infrastructure, laggard educational attainments, high carbon emissions and chronic budget deficits are likely to continue no matter who is elected, even though the public supports higher taxes on corporations and the rich.

Only a big political realignment, perhaps spurred by a third party bold enough to campaign on free social media rather than expensive television advertising, is likely to break the status quo. Until then, the demise of public goods and services will continue apace.

He’s simultaneously right and wrong. Although both campaigns are portraying their differences from their opponents in apocalyptic terms, the difference between freedom and slavery, the reality is somewhat different:

Mr Ryan’s plan calls for federal revenues of 18.4 per cent of gross domestic product in 2016 and 18.5 per cent in 2020 (though his lower tax rates would probably put those targets out of reach). His budget outlays come in at 19.7 per cent and 19.5 per cent in 2016 and 2020, respectively. Of the total outlays in 2016, Mr Ryan targets “discretionary” programmes at 5.9 per cent of GDP; social security, 5 per cent; Medicare, 3.2 per cent; other mandatory spending, 3.7 per cent; and interest payments, 1.9 per cent.

Now consider Mr Obama’s budget unveiled in February. Federal revenues are targeted at 19.1 per cent of GDP in 2016 and 19.7 per cent of GDP in 2020, only about 1 percentage point above Mr Ryan’s revenue targets. In Mr Obama’s 2016 budget targets, discretionary spending is set at 5.9 per cent of GDP; social security, 5 per cent; Medicare, 3.2 per cent; other mandatory spending, 5.8 per cent; and interest payments, 2.5 per cent.

These are minuscule differences. Neither plan reduces the inexorable growth in government spending; they merely change the rate at which spending increases. Each plan achieves its objectives through a combination of hand-waving and wishful thinking.

By Dr. Sachs’s standards this is a triumph for small government.

Consider the graph above illustrating total U. S. government spending as a percentage of GDP. As you can see current spending is actually higher as a proportion of GDP than it was at the height of World War II, when the United States in fact had a command economy, and is more than twice as high as it was in the bad old socialist New Deal days. BTW, the ratio falling below 33% you see between 1995 and 2007 is not due to a decline in spending but rather to a sharp increase in GDP, something I see as illusory since it was the consequence of two successive bubbles. The spending is real but the additional production is bogus.

We’ve seen this debate before in the battle over healthcare reform. Government spending accounting for more than 60% of all healthcare spending, a ratio that the Republican ticket has committed to by default for the foreseeable future (unless you believe that the Ryan plan is a stalking horse for a complete abolition of government spending on healthcare, something not present in the plan itself), is a “free market”. Government spending accounting for something like 85% of total healthcare spending (as in, say, France) is intolerable socialism.

It’s madness. It’s all madness.

We already have socialism in the United States. It’s incompetent, inefficient, self-serving, corrupt socialism that serves mostly to redistribute income among the top 10% of income earners. And the people know it which is why confidence in government is so low and declining.

Our problem in the United States is not that the government isn’t disbursing enough of the country’s production. We’re spending plenty on healthcare, education, pensions, the military, and even infrastructure. We’re spending nearly 40% of GDP and rising. Our problem is that we’re not getting value for our money.

25 comments