I Don’t Care Who Started It. What We’re Doing Isn’t Working

James Joyner complains about the nasty turn of American politics:

The links between Obama and former Weatherman William Ayers were tenuous and decades removed from whatever radicalism Ayers might have engaged in—but there was at least a veneer of truth in the smear. And the Swift Boat idiots were a fringe group; they weren’t run by a former Bush spokesman. Now, though, we’ve got the Obama administration signing off on an ad insinuating that Mitt Romney killed a woman and the vice president refusing to back away from the suggestion that Romney wants to put black people back in chains. So, yeah, I’d say it’s worse than four or eight years ago.

quoting liberally from a six year old post of his complaining about the nasty turn of American politics. He goes on to lay most of the blame for the present sad state of affairs at the feet of Congressional Republicans:

As bad as Bush Derangement Syndrome was, though, Obama Derangement Syndrome is much worse. While Democrats were bitter over the way Bush won in 2000 and some even charged that 2004 was stolen, too, there was at least no question that Bush was an American citizen.

As bad as Harry Reid was in opposition, the Republicans are even worse now. While Reid and company did their best to deny Bush controversial appointments, McConnell and company took it up several notches, baldly declaring that their top legislative priority was keeping Obama from getting re-elected. Not just in the election year, mind you—but for Obama’s whole term. Oh, and the country just happened to be in the worst economic crisis in generations.

for which he is duly taken to task by his commentariat for failing to blame the Congressional Republicans for everything from the state of the economy to the kidnapping of the Lindbergh baby and enter a nunnery to repent for his sins.

I don’t care who started it. Other than as a historical footnote useful in examining how we arrived at the point at which we have, it’s completely uninteresting to me. Trying to figure out who shot John is childish. It isn’t working. It isn’t moving the ball forward.

Of the following alternatives:

  1. The Congressional Republicans, Congressional Democrats, President Obama and his surrogates are working well with each other.
  2. The Congressional Democrats and President Obama are vile and obstructionist and there’s nothing the Congressional Republicans can do to work with them.
  3. The Congressional Republicans are vile and obstructionist and there’s nothing the Congressional Democrats or the President can do to work with them.
  4. The Congressional Republicans are obstructionist and the Congressional Democrats and President Obama have done Sweet Fanny Adams to encourage them to do anything else.

which do think most accurately describes the status quo? If you have an alternative that can be expressed succinctly, in twenty-five words or less, propose it. If I like it, I’ll add it to the list.

I think we’re at “D”.

I interpret the Constitution as placing greater onus on the president to cooperate with the Congress than vice versa. If you think something else, please state your case with evidence and citations.

15 comments

More Bad Assumptions

Speaking of bad assumptions, Kevin Hassett and Glenn Hubbard, in an op-ed in the Washington Post, make what looks to me a pretty good case that there’s an intrinsic contradiction in the economic case the President Obama is making:

A Keynesian stimulus like the one the Obama administration advanced in 2009 would be appropriate if a recession were expected to be short and deep, followed by a quick and robust recovery. Such a stimulus has three stages: the initial short increase in GDP from the spending, a subsequent phase of approximately equal reductions in GDP after the stimulus runs out, and then an additional reduction in GDP when higher borrowing or taxes are needed to pay for the stimulus. If you expect a recession to be long and drawn out, a Keynesian stimulus is likely to be ineffective, because the hangover from the second two stages could easily push the economy back into recession. In such a world, policies that stimulate long-run growth such as fiscal consolidation and tax reform are clearly preferable to a Keynesian stimulus.

Thus the administration’s economics suggest mistakes of diagnosis or cure, or both. If the Obama administration believes that the Reinhart and Rogoff analysis is correct, then the White House should concede that it was mistaken when it proposed a stimulus that would boost growth for only a short time, and it should stop calling for marginal hikes in tax rates.

If the president wants to continue claiming that the stimulus was the appropriate economic policy and that we can afford the damage from higher taxes because growth is going to be high in the near future, then he should concede that Reinhart and Rogoff’s results do not explain the slow recovery of the U.S. economy — and that the more likely explanation is the failure of his own policies.

I think the mechanics of the Obama Administration’s fiscal policies went something like this in its early days. Very early on the White House, determined not to let a good crisis go to waste, had arrived at a number that they had concluded was the largest stimulus package they could get through the Congress. Its economic advisor, unethically, groomed their reports to conform to that number, providing intellectual cachet for what was, in fact, a political judgment.

Once the details had gone through the Congress it was much what one might expect. It scratched itches that had been festering for years, rewarded friends, punished enemies, and, generally, maximized the political benefit of fiscal stimulus rather than its economic benefit. Whatever you think of fiscal stimulus in theory I think that we should all agree that in practice what actually happened was inadequate to the need.

7 comments

GM Dead Again?

I want to commend Louis Woodhill’s fine analysis at Forbes of the fix that GM is in to your attention:

President Obama is proud of his bailout of General Motors. That’s good, because, if he wins a second term, he is probably going to have to bail GM out again. The company is once again losing market share, and it seems unable to develop products that are truly competitive in the U.S. market.

He continues by analyzing the new Malibu, GM’s latest entry in the D-Segment of the auto market, noting that GM’s cost basis is such that the company needs to sell a lot more cars than its competitors to make a profit, and contrasting GM’s top management with VW’s.

Essentially, there is no place in today’s market for a company that makes mediocre products and needs to sell a lot of them to maintain its operations. Further, unlike VW GM does not appear to be preparing to make and sell the best cars in the world but to progressively reduce its operations until, presumably, there is nothing left but the smile.

When the federal government bailed out GM there were essentially two viable alternatives. The company could be allowed to resolve its problems in ordinary bankruptcy with the government’s attentions focused on bailing out GM’s employees or GM’s cost basis, most of which is labor costs for employees present and past, could be reduced and the company forced to modify its fundamental way of designing, manufacturing, and selling cars to do much, much more with much, much less, an enormously tall order.

The Obama Administration elected to do neither, choosing to remove top management (as Woodhill puts it “rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic”), preserve GM’s labor cost problems, and double down on GM’s losing investment on EVs, assuming that the tremendous sales of an enormously popular vehicle which has proved itself anything but would right all wrongs. These were catastrophically bad assumptions. If there were vast demand for street legal golf carts in the United States, I suspect we’d already know about it.

GM now seems to be heading inexorably towards bankruptcy again. Will the federal government leap in at the nick of time to preserve it again? Stay tuned.

33 comments

More Than 10,000 Gather at Navy Pier

Taking organizers of the event completely by surprise, more than 10,000 applicants showed up to apply for temporary protected immigration status:

Thousands of people showed up to Navy Pier, carrying school transcripts, plane tickets and other proof of their time in the United States as they sought temporary protected status under an Obama administration program geared toward students and young adults in the country illegally.

The crowd of mostly teenagers and young adults packed into the Navy Pier grand ballroom, where volunteer attorneys waited to help people apply, and spilled down Illinois Avenue and onto a Lake Shore Drive bike path for several blocks, approaching Millennium Park.

By mid-morning, the crowded was estimated at 11,000 people.

They had expected 1,500 people; nearly ten times that number showed up.

Leaving questions about the legality of the president’s decision to implement something approximating the DREAM Act by executive order, the wisdom of doing it, or the prudence of these young people in surrendering information that they have no assurance won’t be used against them in future deportation proceedings, what does this say about the number of individuals to whom the law might apply?

3 comments

Walking the Dog

There is nothing like walking a Samoyed, an act of love in which I engage anywhere between three and ten times a day, to put you in your proper place in the scheme of things. Not once but multiple times on every walk someone will approach, (if you’re lucky) ask to pet your dog, and remark on how beautiful, sweet, loving, charming, and friendly your dog is.

To rephrase Browning

The year’s at the spring,
And day’s at the morn;
Morning’s at seven;
The hill-side’s dew-pearl’d;
The lark’s on the wing;
The snail’s on the thorn;
Dog’s in His heaven—
All’s right with the world!

2 comments

The Pattern of History

If you’re looking for some doom and gloom to brighten your day, have I got a treat for you. Consider this post on the aftermath of the financial crisis of 2008 by Jeff Thomas. He describes eleven stages, the first which are:

  1. Initial crashes
  2. Initial knock-off effects of crashes
  3. Immediate actions by government

which have a certain ring of familiarity about them. Like many analysts he does a lot better job of predicting the past than the future. If you’re the kind of person that likes to skip to the end of a mystery, his last step is “Revolution”.

I think he’s right that there are patterns in events. As the man said, history doesn’t repeat itself but it does rhyme. (It’s misattributed to Sam Clemens.) That is what you would expect when people respond to events in accord with motivations common to all of us.

I don’t believe that Jeff has the right pattern though. Note that, at least in the United States, the depression of the 1930s did not see either hyperinflation or revolution. I think the post is more a work of fiction than of scholarship, fiction of the genre “if this goes on”.

19 comments

David and Julia

After my mother my first major influence in learning how to cook was Graham Kerr. I watched his television program, The Galloping Gourmet, intently, with fascination and laughter. Reacting, perhaps, to his flamboyant style and charming manner I began to experiment with his recipes and bought a copy of his book based on the program. I still have a GG spurtle, a sort of stirring stick, given to me by some friends.

I began to read cookbooks, particularly James Beard. However, I longed for a broader, more sophisticated exposure to cooking. I began to watch Julia Child’s The French Chef on PBS. I finally embarked on my major, multi-year cooking project. I made every recipe in Julia Child’s, Louisette Bertholle’s, and Simone Beck’s monumental Mastering the Art of French Cooking. Unlike the author of Julie and Julia, I was not a young woman, I did not live in New York, I didn’t blog about it, and I didn’t write a book about the experience. Even if I had I can state with confidence that Amy Adams could never have portrayed me credibly.

However, I did complete the project. Over the period of several years I made dozens of different sauces and hundreds of dishes, in many cases using ingredients with which I was unfamiliar. Asparagus. Eggplant. Goose. Tripe. The first time I had ever eaten tripe was when I had prepared it myself. I still love it and, frankly, my preparation of it was the best I’ve ever had to this very day.

I made dishes I’d never heard of. Gallantines. Ballotines. Quenelles. Dacquoise. To this day a dacquoise with apricot filling and rum buttercream frosting is my favorite cake. I learned techniques I had never imagined and used them over and over again. I only gave myself a dispensation from a few dishes on the grounds of extraordinary expense or unavailability of ingredients.

Slowly, painstakingly, I became a cook. A very good cook. A very good French cook.

I’m sure that Julie Powell and I are not the only ones who’ve set out to cook every recipe in Mastering the Art of French Cooking. I had certain advantages so I suspect I had a leg up over some others. I already was a fairly decent cook. I had a family tradition of cooking—my dad’s family owned a restaurant, my maternal grandmother was an excellent cook, and my mom was a good cook. I am very tenacious.

And all through college I cooked 300 breakfasts six days a week. Additionally, for years I prepared lunch for twenty people every Saturday, cooked for 150 at least once a month, and cooked for 500 at least once a year. There is absolutely nothing like cooking for a crowd to enable you to hone your skills.

Today is the 100th anniversary of the birth of Julia Child. Thank you, Julia. Your book was my cooking school.

11 comments

The Shrewd Stewards

Never let it be said that a little thing like, say, blatant unconstitutionality might stand in the way of the Chicago City Council’s pursuing its objectives:

Under the proposal, Chicago would use its power of eminent domain to seize the mortgages of underwater homeowners who are current on their loans and, with Mortgage Resolution Partners’ help and investor funds, acquire the loans at a discount.

The mortgage would be written down to close to fair market value, and the homeowner would be offered a refinancing at a slightly higher amount than the loan was purchased for; the new mortgage would contain lower payments, and the homeowner would retain at least 5 percent equity in their home. Mortgage Resolution Partners would receive $4,500 for every mortgage resolved, and the city would only have administrative costs.

Executives of the firm said they would provide Chicago with a list of homeowners eligible for such a program. “We’re talking about 16,000 to 20,000 families in Chicago that can benefit from this program,” said Steven Gluckstern, a co-funder of Mortgage Resolution Partners, San Francisco.

To his credit Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel opposes the plan:

Mayor Rahm Emanuel said Tuesday that he does not support the idea of using eminent domain to seize underwater homes and then refinance those mortgages to more affordable terms.

He made the statement as Chicago aldermen were in a committee hearing trying to understand the proposal floated by a California firm.

“I don’t think it’s the right way to address the problem,” Emanuel told reporters when asked about the idea during an unrelated news conference. “I think there are other places to do it. I don’t think it’s the power of the city to do, to deal with the housing issue. We have a national issue. I think we have to address the issue. I just don’t think that’s the right instrument.”

I wish he had stated that a little more clearly. What’s the referent of “right instrument”? Does he mean eminent domain or the city’s power of eminent domain as opposed to the federal government’s?

More important than it not being the right instrument is that it’s a misuse of eminent domain whether it’s done by the city or the federal government. If it does not fall under the rubric of an unjust taking, what does?

4 comments

China’s History Is Bunk

I want to commend to your attention an excellent article by John Lee of the Centre for International Security Studies at the University of Sydney. The article discusses how the Chinese Communist Party has, er, burnished China’s history to promote a specific geopolitical agenda. Here’s a snippet:

The argument that China is unchanging and its dynasties never expansionist is nonsense. Like all imperial dynasties, expansion was a bloody, constant, opportunistic and ruthless affair.

That’s only the tip of the iceberg. The ancient history of China as it’s known to practically all Chinese and Westerners alike is a willful fabrication by Sung dynasty scholars. That China’s history is 5,000 years long in a way distinguished from, say, Poughkeepsie’s, is just one example of that fabrication.

The real story that’s arising slowly and painstakingly from the archaeological record is less glorious and a lot more interesting than the legends we’ve been lead to believe.

Read the whole thing.

4 comments

Where Romney Is Right

Rounding out my “examining both sides and finding them wanting” trio, in a piece contrasting the president’s energy policy with Gov. Romney’s the Lexington column at The Economist points out:

As befits the small-government candidate, he argues for less regulation, laxer environmental standards and fewer subsidies. He criticises Mr Obama for favouring pet firms and technologies. He recently said that he would allow a tax credit that serves as the main incentive for wind power to lapse, to howls of dismay from Republicans and Democrats alike in windy states.

But Mr Romney abjures any concerted effort to stem global warming. He wants to repeal the government’s power to regulate greenhouse gases under the Clean Air Act, but does not propose any alternative. While still governor of Massachusetts, in 2005, he backed away from a regional emissions-trading scheme that he had initially supported, and then lambasted John McCain in the Republican presidential primaries of 2008 for proposing something similar.

I think this highlights a problem of Democrats, generally, and progressives in particular: I believe they tend to undervalue the role of incentives. Getting the incentives right is essential.

0 comments