Where Have All the Flowers Gone?

Is it really true that Israel, Iran, the United States, and China are hurtling us down a path to war with Iran because each party thinks it can win? Ron Holland states his case.

67 comments

Rubinism Isn’t the Problem

Over at The Big Picture former federal bank regulator Bill Black launches into an extensive critique of opposition to bank regulation, which he characterizes as “the dangerous myth that financial regulation is unrelated to financial crime”, I’d like to commend to your attention. If I can summarize a 1,000 word essay in a simple sentence, I’d say he blames the financial crisis on financial crime and financial crime on a failure of regulation under the Clinton, Bush, and Obama Administrations, which have adopted a common philosophy which might be called “Rubinism”, i.e. regulation of, by, and for the big banks.

I honestly don’t think he goes far enough. I think the fundamental problem is one of regulators’ incentives. As I see it there are two contrasting strategies for fixing that. Either you can make the big banks much less tempting (by making them smaller) or you can alter the relationship between regulators and the banks they’re supposed to be regulating by making it possible for an aggressive young regulator or prosecutor to make a lot of dough by going after financial crime rather than “going native” and taking a light hand with those institutions in the hope of landing a lucrative sinecure later on.

5 comments

Bad Trades

In Eric Falkenstein’s post on the “bad trades” being made by the federal government there are too paragraphs I think deserve some reflection:

Our economy has many such bad trades going on at any one time, and the sooner these are abandoned, the quicker people will reallocate their time towards something that actually costs less than its revenue. Consider guarantees to farmers, which supposedly allow farmers to withstand the vagaries of weather, ensuring our very survival. We have policies that encourage producer cartels, direct payments via subsidies, paying farmers to not farm, disaster aid, insurance subsidies, and export subsidies and import tariffs. So now farmers who suffered from the recent drought directly get fully insured payments, and those who avoided it get the revenue from higher prices. This isn’t helping us become more efficient farmers.

Then we have clean energy, education, defense, high-speed rail, all costly investments that potentially will pay off big eventually, but in practice are subverted by special interests into a focus on producers not consumers. If the negative present value were revealed via the negative cash flow at market prices, an efficient response would be to reallocate capital and labor. Instead, these activities are propped up under the hope that mere time will allow some sort of critical take-off point in future productivity.

There are a couple of points I’d like to make about this. First, I think it’s important to distinguish between upside gain and downside risk. There are, essentially, three different strategies: you can maximize upside gain, you can minimize downside risk, or you can attempt to strike a dynamic optimal equilibrium between the two. Although the Congress is by its very structure pretty well situated for seeking that equilibrium over the period of the last, say, century it has increasingly devoted itself to minimizing downside risk. Why do we spend as much on defense and security as we do? The Congress increases defense spending to insulate itself against criticism for failure to act in the case of an attack. Why do we regulate banks at all? So that Congress has an answer when irate voters complain about bank failures.

Private and public corporations are mostly in the business of maximizing upside gain. There are exceptions. For example, preserving market share may not actually maximize your profits but it does prevent upstarts from upsetting your apple cart. Nearly every industry with which I’m familiar has an industry leader that gets to set the terms for the entire industry—functionality and durability of products, prices, etc. That’s a position that’s worth preserving.

3 comments

Wait A Minute

A species of fish has been newly discovered that wears its genitalia on its head:

How’s this for a head turner? A tiny new species of fish from Vietnam sports its genitalia on its noggin.

Phallostethus cuulong is only the 22nd known species of its family, Phallostethidae, all of which bear their copulatory organs just behind their mouths.

As with all Phallostethus—”penis chest” in Greek—species, the male uses its bony “priapium” to clasp a female while he inserts sperm into her urogenital opening, also located on the head, said Lynne Parenti, curator of fishes at the National Museum of Natural History in Washington, D.C.

Parenti remembers seeing another species of priapiumfish mate at a lab in Singapore. Attached at the head and together forming a v, the fish “looked like a little pair of scissors, darting around the tank together,” she said.

Wait a minute. I think I knew guys in college who were like that.

8 comments

The New Graduate: “Private Equity”

The base pay of newly minted Harvard MBAs continues to rise. Where they’re going after graduation is changing, however:

A near-record 29% of Harvard’s class of 2012 headed into the still-booming consulting industry, according to the school’s employment statistics. That’s a full five percentage points higher than the year-earlier class of Harvard MBAs and nearly matches the record 30% of graduates who chose consulting in 2003.

Grads entering the financial services industry, on the other hand, slipped by four percentage points to 35%, compared to 39% for the class of 2011. Ever since 2008, when 45% of Harvard’s graduating class went into finance, the numbers have been declining, largely the result of cutbacks on Wall Street and at other large financial institutions. The biggest hit was in investment management jobs, which attracted only 4% of this year’s class, versus 12% of the class of 2011. Investment banking jobs for Harvard MBAs fell to 7%, from 10% a year earlier.

Not all finance jobs were down. At 15% of the entire class, Harvard MBAs who took private equity jobs hit a new record. Last year, 14% of the class of 2011 headed for jobs in PE, up from 9% a year earlier and the highest since 2006, when 13% of the class took PE and leveraged buyout jobs.

The lowest median salaries were in government and the non-profit world. Harvard MBAs who entered those two fields reported median starting salaries of $90,000 — 50% lower than MBAs who went into consulting — with no signing bonuses or other guaranteed compensation. Harvard said about 3% of the class of 2012 went into the non-profit and government sectors, up from 2% last year but still well down from 6% in 2010 and one of the lowest recorded percentages in the past 10 years.

7 comments

What the Heck Are They Waiting For?

The editors of the Chicago Tribune lay out their case that the time for the president and Congress to act is now:

This is, by many measures, the feeblest economic recovery since the Great Depression. Most economists expect the malaise to continue into 2013. Remember, we’re talking about a disturbingly poky recovery from a recession that ended in … June 2009. Yes, 38 months ago.

To some extent, the sluggish results reflect the lingering effects of that downturn. Consumers got hammered through layoffs and a housing bust. The financial system froze, and businesses stopped investing, even after their profits recovered. Government ordered banks to recapitalize and poured on monetary and fiscal stimulus. That was a predictable response, and we generally supported it.

What’s maddening is the self-inflicted damage caused by subsequent inaction in Washington once the crisis subsided. Gridlock on Capitol Hill has created unnecessary uncertainty for employers, for households, for everyone: It has increased risks for businesses that don’t know what the tax and investment rules will be. It has discouraged spending by consumers who worry that the continued high unemployment rate could, in any given week, bite them, too. And while it is difficult to measure these impacts with precision, the cumulative consequences for confidence among job creators, investors and consumers have been huge. Week after week, fresh economic numbers attest to the torpor.

Why blame Congress and the White House with contributing to this maddeningly slo-mo recovery?

Because lawmakers aren’t doing their jobs — postponing rigorous decisions at every turn — all of these measures are weaker than they should be. The business climate is worse. Consumers remain more fearful. The economy is growing less. With Washington in pre-election hibernation, Americans are marooned in a perpetual state of wait-and-see.

If the American people weren’t so torpid, incumbents of both parties would be egged every time they made an appearance until they get back to work. Why re-elect them? So they can keep not doing what they’re not doing now?

2 comments

“Nothing Changed”

To my ear Roger Cohen’s latest column in the New York Times hovers between insightful and delusional. Here’s insightful:

The Obama inner circle remains a group of tough political tacticians: David Axelrod, David Plouffe and Valerie Jarrett. The White House national security team does not boast a single name of strategic stature. Anyone outside Washington would be hard pressed to name one.

The policy upshot has been predictable: cerebral, cool, and with one big exception, cautious. Obama has corrected big mistakes — abandoning the unwinnable global war on terror and pulling out of Iraq. To his immense credit he took a big gamble on killing Osama Bin Laden. But elsewhere he has been cautious to a fault, eyeing the political calendar.

He held out a hand to Iran but promptly reverted to tired old carrots and sticks; his response to the great popular uprising of 2009 was slow. He took half-steps on Israel and Palestine — criticizing Israeli settlements, saying the ore-1967 lines were the basis for a two-state peace — only to offer zero follow-through. Nothing changed.

And here’s delusional:

Then there is Hillary Clinton, a superb secretary of state. But for various reasons (her future is very much ahead of her), she has generally acquiesced to the White House being the locus of major foreign-policy decisions (salvaging things where necessary, as in Pakistan.)

I question that statement on two grounds. First, given the litany of foreign policy vacillation and brinksmanship he catalogues in what sense has Hillary Clinton been “a superb secretary of state”? Because she’s Hillary Clinton? Because of the good advice she’s offered and that has been taken? Because of the difficult treaties she’s negotiated? Bold stands taken?

Second, given that Mrs. Clinton has already rejected the idea of running for the presidency again, how is “her future very much ahead of her” other than in the sense that the future is very much ahead of all of us?

There’s a series of questions that I wonder if Obama supporters are asking themselves. First, did you like the Bush Administration? Second, what dramatic departures from the policies of the Bush Administration has the Obama Administration undertaken? The banks continued to get bailed out, the “Bush tax cuts” were extended, our troops departed Iraq on the schedule negotiated by the Bush Administration, the auto companies were bailed out, the president’s power to order assassinations (now including those of American citizens) has been re-affirmed, the list is practically interminable. The PPACA. Is the PPACA enough reason to re-elect the president? The majority of Americans don’t seem to think so.

What we need are bold departures from past policies and what we’re getting is their fruition.

18 comments

The Republican National Convention

I doubt that I’ll comment much on the RNC this week. This is about it. Does anybody have any ideas on how we could ensure that hurricanes threaten all political conventions? The word I’m getting is that the plan is to condense what they’d planned to do in a week into three days by shortening speeches. That sounds like an unqualified good to me.

16 comments

It’s a Family Affair

Presumably, you’re aware that the English language and, in all likelihood, the foreign languages you studied in high school or college, are members of a far-flung family of languages called the “Indo-European language family”. Not only does it include English, Spanish, French, German, Italian, Irish Gaelic, and Greek but Persian, Armenian, and Hindi, too. Something like 300 languages in all which 500 years ago were spoken across a swathe of territory that reached from Iceland to Sri Lanka. (Just as a reminder, I’m a language junkie. I learned a smattering of German from my dad at home, studied French in grade school, studied Russian, Latin, and Greek in high school, and studied Russian and Chinese in college.)

Just where the Indo-European language family started has been a matter of some debate since the similarities among the languages of this family were noticed 150 years ago. The majority view has been that the family originated north of the Black Sea in Central Asia about 6,000 years ago. A recent study using genetic and epidemiological methods has placed that majority view in some doubt:

The majority view in historical linguistics is that the homeland of Indo-European is located in the Pontic steppes (present day Ukraine) around 6,000 years ago. The evidence for this comes from linguistic paleontology: in particular, certain words to do with the technology of wheeled vehicles are arguably present across all the branches of the Indo-European family; and archaeology tells us that wheeled vehicles arose no earlier than this date. The minority view links the origins of Indo-European with the spread of farming from Anatolia 8,000 to 9,500 years ago.

Assume that’s true. I think it brings up a host of questions including:

  • What does it say about the rate of language change?
  • What about Tocharian?
  • Does this cast more doubt or support the idea of a Nostratic superfamily? Or when Proto-Nostratic was spoken?

The “Nostratic superfamily” is a hypothesized family of language families that includes the Indo-European family; the Afroasiatic family with its Semitic (Arabic, Aramaic), Cushitic, Chadic, and other subgroups; the Uralic family (Finnish, Hungarian); the Dravidian family;and other language families.

0 comments

Prediction Is Hard

In a previous post I mentioned something to the effect that econometric models with which I was familiar were predicting a close November presidential election. Nate Silver corrects me:

I tracked down about every one of these models that I could find, subject to the condition that it couched its forecast in probabilistic terms (or that it was well-documented enough to allow this to be inferred with relative ease, like from the standard error that the model stated).

In my view, it’s in estimating the uncertainty in a forecast where most of the challenge and intrigue lies. To paraphrase Charles Barkley, any knucklehead can make a point prediction — but it takes brains to calculate a confidence interval.

These models are all over the map, forecasting everything from a nearly certain Obama victory to the substantial likelihood of his defeat. But more of them have Mr. Obama as the favorite. If you simply average their win probability estimates together, you get about a 61 percent likelihood of his winning the election.

As it turns out the models with which I was familiar (Hibbs, Cuzan, Fair, Klamer) have something in common: they all predict a closer outcome than the other models in Nate’s list. Lest you suspect some sort of partisan or ideological bias Yale’s Ray Fair is no Republican. His model is an econometric model and the economic fundamentals aren’t working the president’s favor.

I tracked down some of the other models Nate uncovered which, unfortunately, he doesn’t explore in the cited post to any great degree. They, too, have something in common: they’re not technically econometric models; rather they’re models fundamentally based on opinion polls.

Helmut Norpoth’s Primary Model is conceptually very simple. Basically, it says that presidents who don’t face primary challenges get re-elected. It seems to me that this approach would tend to miss wave elections, understandable since real, major wave elections are relatively rare in the United States.

Here’s Sam Wang’s model:

My approach is to take a well-designed statistical snapshot of all the polls. A snapshot of the last 2-3 weeks of polls was 364 electoral votes (EV) for Obama, within 1 EV of the final outcome, 365 EV. Even a one-week snapshot was 353 EV, within 12 EV. Either number came closer than the other sites. Score one for meta-analysis!

Drew Linzer’s model is:

a dynamic Bayesian forecasting model that uni es the regression-based historical forecasting approach developed in political science and economics with the poll-tracking capabilities made feasible by the recent upsurge in state-level opinion polling.

and he finds that:

Contrary to much of the media commentary at the time, Obama’s victory was highly predictable many months in advance of the election.

I’m sticking to my guns. I think the popular vote, whichever way it goes, will be quite close, closer than the 2008 election, and that so much depends on factors that are beyond even sophisticated prediction models that it’s just too close to call. Will a major disaster occur in Afghanistan just before the election? Will we be at war with Iran between now and then? Will the stock market experience a major correction or crash between now and then?

That very much along the lines of what Sean Trende of RealClearPolitics observes:

In 1980, Jimmy Carter didn’t have an argument for re-election that appealed very far beyond the Democratic base. Similarly, in 1984, Walter Mondale simply didn’t have much of an argument for getting rid of Ronald Reagan. The Republicans didn’t have a good argument for holding on to power in 2006, nor did the Democrats in 2010. The elections reflect that.

This year, Barack Obama has an argument — he didn’t inherit the mess, and the economy is slowly expanding. That’s an argument that is probably good enough to get him to 46 or 47 percent of the vote. Similarly, Mitt Romney has a pretty good argument for electing a new president, one that will shore up his base and Republican-leaning independents. Thus, we should probably expect what we’re presently seeing in the polls: a close race, to be decided by a relatively small slice of the electorate.

21 comments