When Policy and Politics Collide

For the last day or so we’ve been absolutely deluged with 30 second television spots for President Obama’s re-election featuring Bill Clinton. I think it’s possible they’re targeting the senior demographic. Isn’t that the group most likely to respond to such spots?

I’m sure you can find the ad itself on YouTube. Here’s the transcript:

“This election to me is about which candidate is more likely to return us to full employment.”

“This is a clear choice. The Republican plan is to cut more taxes on upper income people and go back to deregulation. That’s what got us in trouble in the first place.”

“President Obama has a plan to rebuild America from the ground up, investing in innovation, education, and job training. It only works if there is a strong middle class.”

“That’s what happened when I was President. We need to keep going with his plan.”

I think I can hear the sound of Paul Krugman’s head exploding. Doesn’t that message undercut the last four years of policy? If “innovation, education, and job training” are what is necessary to put the 20 million people unemployed and underemployed to work, then the problem that faces us is clearly a structural one.

But that isn’t the message I would take away from the ARRA, for example. Yes, it was a grab-bag of policies without strong coherence but the largest percentages of spending went to tax cuts, infrastructure spending, and aid to the states which could only have been effective in restoring the economy back to health if our economic problem were mostly a cyclical one.

That’s not to say that I think that Mitt Romney’s economic plans, at least to the degree that we know about them now, are any more effective.

Let me try to summarize my views quickly. I think that the jolt we experienced had components that included a serious cyclical downturn, excessive indebtedness, and structural problems that had been at work, literally, for decades. We are enormously over-invested in the financial sector, the housing sector, education, and the healthcare sector. Not to mention defense, automobile manufacturing, and concrete-and-asphalt infrastructure. None of those will correct themselves so long as we keep spending as much as we have been on them.

But it’s not just spending. We need to change what we’re doing in healthcare, defense, trade policy, immigration policy, education, tax policy, just to name a few. Doubling down on what we’ve been doing is an error. If we do that the future will be bleaker than it should be.

12 comments

Paying for College

In a post over at OTB noting the surprising finding that most college students don’t borrow to finance their education, Doug Mataconis links to this study. Check Figures 5 through 7. Somewhat belying Doug’s post but also unsurpringly they illustrate that the lower the student’s family income the more likely he or she is to borrow and that students from lower income families may borrow as much as 40% of the cost of their educations.

As I’ve said before I find it unconscionable that public higher education isn’t dragged kicking and screaming into the 21st century, costs cut substantially, and offered at low or no cost just as primary education is.

A diploma isn’t the only factor in securing your first job. For many there’s such a thing as contacts or pull including the influence of that diploma being from an elite school. I think it would be interesting to see a chart that illustrated the pay rate of the graduate’s first jobs by family income level. My guess is that the rule of thumb probably is something like the more you owe, the less likely you are to be able to pay it off.

In my own case I paid for college by having a scholarship, working, and borrowing in about equal amounts. My scholarship paid for my tuition. I covered my room, board, books, and other expenses by a combination of work and borrowing. I worked between 35 and 50 hours a week as an undergraduate and graduate student. Once I left school and started working a full-time job I repaid my college loans on an accelerated basis in three or four years. I hate debt.

33 comments

Factoid

I have never attended a public school. I attended parochial schools from kindergarten through 8th grades, a private high school, a private college, and a private graduate school. I am the only member of my family of whom that is true. All of my siblings attended public high schools and most attended public colleges. My youngest siblings also went to kindergarten at a nearby public school since our parish’s school didn’t have a kindergarten.

My parents both attended public schools K-12. My dad attended private undergraduate and graduate schools. My mom attended a public undergraduate school and a private graduate school.

I’m not citing my experience as an advantage. In some ways I think it was a disadvantage. It’s merely a fact.

20 comments

Foundational Myths

I want to draw your attention to a talk given, I’m guessing, more than 30 years ago by Milton Friedman on “Myths That Conceal Reality”. The myths that he addresses might be thought of as the foundational myths of our current political-economical system.

The five “myths” that Dr. Friedman addresses in his talks are:

  • Robber barons played a dominant role in the U. S. economy of the 19th century.
  • The Great Depression of the 1930s was caused by a failure of the private sector.
  • There’s a high, persistent demand for services that only the government can provide.
  • Government can spend money at nobody’s expense.
  • Government benefits the poor at the expense of the poor.

I found some of the sections of his talk stronger than the others. For example, I thought his treatment of the Depression of the 1930s and the demand for government services were stronger than his treatment of the robber barons and the U. S. economy of the 19th century. Let me give a few examples.

In the talk Dr. Friedman asserts that rising prices for prime farmland demonstrate that farmers were becoming better off rather than worse off. I don’t think you can make that claim based on the available data. All that rising prices for farmland demonstrates is that people wanted more farmland. Land prices could well increase even as farmers became worse off as a consequence of a large increase in the number of farmers, something we know was definitely the case in the 19th century. Prices of farmland increasing from 1870 to 1880 says less about whether farmers in the United States were better off in 1880 than in 1870 than it does about whether farmers in the United States in 1880 were better off than farmers in Germany in 1880. And that might have been due to other factors like, say, Bismarck’s military draft.

Additionally, I think he was too ready to give the “robber barons” of the 19th century credit for their own riches by comparison with today’s ultra-rich. While I don’t disagree that today’s .1% benefit enormously from government intervention of various different kinds, I think the same was true of the 19th century robber barons. John D. Rockefeller was a war profiteer and I believe the same was true of Cornelius Vanderbilt and Jay Gould. Land franchises and monopolies granted by state governments were enormously influential in the construction of the railroads and steamboat lines. The robber barons had no compunctions against wielding the levers of government, particularly against each other whether via lawsuit or outright bribery.

I also think he misinterprets the history of political power in the United States and elsewhere as a conflict among the rich, the middle class, and the poor in which the middle class has triumphed. I think that the history of political power everywhere is an internecine conflict among the top 10% of income earners. That conflict occasionally breaks out into bloody warfare as in the French and Russian Revolutions. It may have been the poor charging the barricades but on both sides of those conflicts it was those in the top 10% of income earners who were giving the orders.

Still, the talk is well worth a listen. It’s nearly a full hour in length so you might want to listen to it in pieces.

16 comments

Just For the Record

Just to make certain that I’ve committed my predictions about the impact of the Republican and Democratic National Conventions to print/display, what I’ve been saying is that Mitt Romney will get a small boost from the RNC and, if the president gives roughly the same speech as he’s been giving for the last four years, he will get an even smaller lift in the polls from the DNC this week. On the other hand if he gives a barn-burner he could receive a much higher post-convention bump. Whether the conventions provide any lasting help to either campaign we’ll know in mid-September.

So far, so good. Based on the post-convention Rasmussen poll, Romney has gotten a small bump, consistent with my prediction. The RealClearPolitics composite of polls has Obama at +.1 or, said another way, too close to call.

21 comments

You Can’t Go Home Again

Top marks to Matthew Dowd among the Allen’s Alley of characters on the talking heads programs this weekend. On ABC’s This Week Mr. Dowd, after noting the retrospective or nostalgic quality to last week’s Republican National Convention, reminded us that the winners of presidential elections tend to be the candidates who’ve painted the brighter but still believable picture of America and its future.

Obama political advisor David Plouffe’s performance just a few minutes earlier strongly suggested that the question that the Obama campaign wants to ask, rather than answering Ronald Reagan’s famous “Are you better off than you were four years ago?”, is “Are you better off than you would have been if Bush were still president?”

The emerging picture of the two campaigns is that the Romney campaign wants to run against the Obama economic record of the last four years and the Obama campaign wants to run against the Bush economic campaign of the previous eight years, joining it with Romney’s plans. While accomplishing each of those tasks may be necessary for victory, will they be sufficient? I don’t believe so and I certainly hope not.

Gov. Romney needs to explain how tax cuts and trade war with China will put 23 million people to work. The president needs to explain how his stalled jobs bill will accomplish that. Or what else he plans to do. And how he plans to accomplish whatever he plans under the conditions that are likely to prevail in Congress in the next term.

Nostalgia is all well and good but whether it’s nostalgia for the New Deal, the 50s, or the 90s today’s conditions are different from the conditions then and we need to address today’s problems with today’s solutions. Time’s a-wastin’. Chop chop.

5 comments

Climbing the Risk Ladder

Here’s a great example of how public pension funds, in a desperate grab at realizing the high returns their financial strategies require for them to remain solvent, are undertaking increasingly risky bets investments:

NEW YORK — Wall Street investors aren’t the only ones feeling the sting of Facebook Inc.’s falling stock: So are some of the country’s troubled government pension funds.

Public employee retirement funds from around the country took part in the Menlo Park, Calif., social networking juggernaut’s May 18 initial public offering and plowed millions of dollars into Facebook stock before its value plunged.

Facebook shares continued their decline Friday, falling $1.03, or 5.4%, to a record low of $18.06, or less than half their $38 offering price.

Although public pension funds staked only tiny portions of their multibillion-dollar portfolios on Facebook’s fortunes, the stock’s poor performance has added to the funds’ woes. Chronic underfunding and poor returns could lead pension funds to pursue riskier investments such as hedge funds, private equity, commodities and real estate, or even cut benefits for retirees.

Three pension funds have joined a class-action lawsuit against Facebook and its underwriters. The suit, filed in U.S. District Court in Manhattan, N.Y., alleges that lead underwriters led by Morgan Stanley gave only some select investors a heads-up that Facebook’s revenue forecast had soured.

Sometimes you eat the bear, sometimes the bear eats you.

CalPERS, the California public employees’ pension fund, owns more than a million shares of Facebook stock. Doesn’t putting that many eggs in a basket that has never made a profit and might not even have a plan to do so sound sort of risky to you? I mean for CalPERS not for Mark Zuckerberg. I’m sure he’s doing fine. That Facebook employees sold so much of their own stock as soon as the window had re-opened should show you which way the wind is blowing.

It should be noted that this is one of the great problems with defined benefit programs. Unless they are fully funded and managed extremely conservatively, the earnings they realize just may not be enough to pay what they’re required to pay.

9 comments

Illinois’s Political Dysfunction

I’d meant to get to it last week but somehow it eluded me. The state of Illinois’s credit rating has been downgraded again:

On Tuesday, Standard & Poor’s downgraded Illinois bonds to A from A-plus, with a continuing negative outlook. The credit rating agency singled out five years of budget deficits ranging from bad to worse to way worse. It now stands at $44 billion—another national record. S&P was also more troubled than the Springfield political class about $83 billion in unfunded pension liabilities. The legislature ended a special session on pension reform this week without, well, passing any reform.

Obviously, there’s a problem. Not quite so obvious is what the problem is. Here’s a table that compares Illinois with its adjoining states:

State GDP (billion $) Population GDP per cap State spending Median income State spending per capita State spending as percentage of GDP
Illinois 670.727 12869257 52118 58.14 55735 4518 8.67
Indiana 278.128 6516922 42677 25.39 47697 3896 9.13
Wisconsin 254.818 5711767 44612 27.5 51598 4815 10.79
Missouri 249.525 6010688 41513 23.83 46262 3965 9.55
Iowa 148.986 3062309 48651 14.29 48872 4666 9.59
Kentucky 164.799 4369356 37716 23.55 41576 5390 14.29

Sources: usgovernmentspending.com, U. S. Census Bureau State & Local QuickFacts

Illinois is the richest Midwestern state, rejoicing in both the highest GDP, the highest per capita GDP, and the highest median income in the region. Its state spending per capita is higher than that of some of its neighbors, lower than others. Wisconsin, nominally a Blue State, spends more per capita. So does Kentucky, nominally a Red State. Clearly, Illinois’s problems aren’t there.

It spends less as a percentage of state GDP than any other state in the Midwest. Obviously, the problem isn’t there, either.

I can only speculate. Here are a few guesses:

  • Illinois’s financial problems aren’t due to current spending. They’re due to its huge overhang of public employee pension obligations, the result of years of incompetence in Springfield, particularly over the last dozen years.
  • Illinois’s peculiar political dysfunction is due to the enduring upstate (Chicago metropolitan area)-downstate (everywhere else) conflict.
  • Illinois’s problems are in part a consequence of its being the richest state in the Midwest. No one in Illinois lives more than about 150 miles from some other state and most of Illinois’s population lives within reasonable commuting distance of another state. That makes Illinois easy prey when business or sales taxes rise.
  • Illinoisans don’t believe they are receiving value for what the state is spending.
  • Illinoisans don’t believe that the state government has a right to a fixed (or rising!) percentage of their income.

I’m open to other suggestions. The reasons are important since it’s darned hard to know where to put the bandage unless you know where it’s bleeding.

Whatever the cause of Illinois’s dysfunction, a downgrade of Illinois’s bond rating will only make it harder for Illinois to solve its problems due to the increased cost of financing.

Update

Now we’re getting somewhere. Prodded by a remark in comments I went after total state debt. Here’s a comparison of Illinois and its adjoining states:

State Total state debt (billion $)
Illinois 271.1
Indiana 37.1
Wisconsin 79.6
Missouri 65.8
Iowa 25.2
Kentucky 63.7

Source: State Budget Solutions

Pretty obvious where Illinois’s problem is, isn’t it? Illinois’s per capita indebtedness is the highest in the nation at $21,067 per Illinoisan. That’s higher than California, New York, Texas, or New Jersey and dwarfs the figure for Illinois’s neighboring states. Note that via the linked source most of Illinois’s debt isn’t on the operating budget. It’s on public employee benefits and pensions.

Given those statistics it’s pretty obvious what Illinois needs to do. First, it needs to honor the First Rule of Holes. That means it needs to convert to a defined contribution plan for new public employees and revise the health insurance plans for public employees ASAP. I’ve already posted at length about Illinois’s unique issues in dealing with its existing public employee pension commitments.

Second, Illinois desperately needs to pay down the principle on its debt on an accelerated basis.

Third, Illinois needs to remove borrowing authority from its state legislature (the legislature is empowered to borrow 15% of the state’s budget per annum) because, obviously, they can’t be trusted with it.

As I see it there are three barriers to putting Illinois’s fiscal house in order: 1) the political cowardice of its elected officials; 2) understandable opposition from the public employees’ unions; 3) the state constitution.

10 comments

Y = C + G + I + (X – M)

That’s just to remind you that gross domestic product is equal to personal consumption expenditures plus government expenditures plus business investment plus net exports, i. e. exports less imports. When I say that I think we need more domestic business investment, I’m making a statement about how I think that GDP should grow. Ditto when I say that I think we should export more. If personal consumption expenditures or government spending rises and so do imports, that will result in less GDP growth than otherwise might be the case.

If Okun’s law, the rule of thumb that suggests a positive correlation between GDP and employment, is broken, I think it’s pretty clear that the reason that it’s broken is that consumption expenditures (either private or government) and business investment aren’t resulting in increased employment.

GDP has grown all through the alleged recovery. How fast would it have to grow to put a dent in U. S. unemployment?

27 comments

Help Wanted

I said I wasn’t going to post on the political conventions and I plan on sticking to that. However, I’ve got to say that I’m baffled by the commentary about the Republican National Convention. The blogosphere and media outlets are absolutely full of posts, articles, columns, etc. debunking Paul Ryan’s speech of last night.

I haven’t hear any of it but I have read snippets of the prepared text as well as some of the criticisms. Outside of the mendacity that I’d associate with any political speech but especially political speeches giving during national conventions I didn’t see anything particularly outrageous. What’s all the hub-bub, bub?

To my ear the reactions sound a bit desperate. Can somebody please interpret this stuff for me? I really don’t get it.

Update

Let me expand on my remarks above a little. According to the RealClearPolitics average, a composite of polls, President Obama leads by 1.1%. That’s not a very big lead for a sitting president.

Now, maybe Mitt Romney will completely fall on his face when he gives his acceptance speech tonight. Maybe President Obama will completely knock the ball out of the park when he gives his next week. I don’t expect either of those things to happen. I expect Mitt Romney to get a small bounce from the RNC and President Obama to get not much of anything from the DNC. He’s not exactly underexposed to the American people.

What does that mean? To me it means that the presidential election is too close to call, there’s still a slight likelihood that the Republicans will get a majority in the Senate, and, although it looks like it might be possible that Democrats will narrow the Republican lead in the House slightly, the Republicans are likely to hold the House. Which is, essentially, what I’ve been saying for the last year.

Partisans of both parties have unenviable chores ahead of them. Democrats must defend the indefensible. President Obama has gotten nearly everything he’s asked for and the economy is still in the toilet. We’re still in Afghanistan, bleeding lives and dollars every day. Pakistan destabilizes a bit more every day and our drone attacks are contributing to that, at least at the margins. Guantanamo is still open. The president continues to repeat that Iran’s getting nuclear weapons is “unacceptable”, whatever that means. The Holder Justice Department and the Geithner Treasury are just about as horrible as any of my memory.

Republicans must embrace the incoherent. Gov. Romney wants to shrink federal spending but he wants to expand defense spending. His tax reform plan, even if it were to be adopted, would not of itself heal the problems with our economy, at least not in the near term. And that it would suddenly produce 4% real GDP growth is beyond understanding.

56 comments