Making a Problem Unsolveable By Expanding It

Take a look at that map (hat tip: Zillow) of mortgages in negative equity (underwater) and explain to me again how the home mortgage nightmare is a national problem.

It isn’t. It’s a local or regional problem with national implications. Fixing it requires solutions tailored to the specific conditions of the areas with the problems. Treating it as a national problem is like responding to a hurricane’s striking the Gulf Coast by rushing emergency services to all 50 states. It dilutes the response.

Triage, people.

8 comments

What We Need to Do

Take a look at this lengthy and excellent presentation on our fiscal conundrum over at Business Insider. It goes some way to explaining why I believe as I do, namely that we both need to return tax rates to what they were in 2000 and cut spending, which inevitably means cutting military and healthcare spending.

I wish the presentation were as complete on the spending side as it is on the revenue side but I guess if it had it would have run to a hundred slides.

0 comments

November By the Numbers

Any Obama supporter who thinks that re-election is in the bag should at least consider the inforrmation in the table above. As you can see all of the numbers are closer to those in years in which the incumbent was defeated and all but two are worse.

The economy is not moving in the right direction, either for the country or for the president’s re-election. Every econometric prediction model I’ve been able to identify to date is predicting a loss for the president even as electoral college projections show a near-landslide victory for him.

It’s not difficult to find the reason for the discrepancy. Those projections all assume there is such a thing as a state that’s safely in the president’s column and that states that are leaning towards the president end up being in his column.

The numbers above and the econometric models give reason to believe that won’t be the case.

At this point it strongly appears that the president’s campaign strategy is to ensure that the electorate does not see Mitt Romney as an acceptable alternative. Maybe it will work. Maybe it won’t. Romney and his campaign are already adapting as I think can be seen in his Wall Street Journal op-ed and this interview with Fox Business.

Hat tip: Business Insider

15 comments

Negativity

The Pew Center for Excellence in Journalism has a lengthy and interesting analysis of the “master character narratives” that have appeared in the media for President Obama and Gov. Romney during the campaign:

An examination of the dominant or master narratives in the press about the character and record of presidential contenders finds that 72% of this coverage has been negative for Barack Obama and 71% has been negative for Mitt Romney. The study, conducted by the Pew Research Center’s Project for Excellence in Journalism, examined the personal portrayal of the candidate in 50 major news outlets over a 10-week period.

These numbers make this as negative a campaign as PEJ has seen since it began monitoring the master narratives about candidates in press coverage in presidential campaigns in 2000. Only one campaign has been comparable-2004 when coverage was filled with the controversy over the war in Iraq, the prison scandal at Abu Ghraib and the Swift Boat documentaries. That year, 70% of the personal narrative studied about Democrat John Kerry and 75% of that about incumbent George Bush was negative, numbers similar to now.

That’s an intriguing interpretation but I’m not sure it’s one that actually comports with the facts. Let me provide an alternative.

The media narrative, emphasizing the “horse race” aspect of campaigns and cognizant of the advantages of incumbency, is always harder on the incumbent. Otherwise there would be no “horse race”. That explains the present negative master character narratives, the strongly negative narratives during the 2004 campaigns, and the notably negative treatment that Al Gore received in 2000. He was being treated as incumbent, a commonplace among “third term” candidates.

While Pew repeatedly remarks on how journalists have lost control of the emerging narratives, I think the more interesting finding is how easy the media went on candidate Barack Obama in 2008 (31% negative character narratives then compared to 72% now and 57% for McCain then). That the character narratives for both the president and Gov. Romney are so negative despite the obvious preference of professional journalists for the president must be very disconcerting to the Obama Campaign.

4 comments

The Awful Truth

James Hamilton has an excellent analysis of the long term trends in federal spending and revenue which I commend to your attention. Lots of charts and graphs.

Here’s the bottom line:

To return to long-run fiscal solvency, the U.S. will need both tax increases, defense cuts and significant entitlement reform.

The fact that I don’t hear more people delivering the same clear message suggests to me that we don’t have enough objective observers.

I think it’s actually even simpler than that. We’ve got to tax a little bit more and we’ve got to reduce healthcare spending.

3 comments

My Record

Recently there’s been a bit of gentle impugning of me as, remarkably, a yellow dog Democrat at least where the rubber hits the road in the voting booth. Remarkable because in Left Blogosphere comment sections I’m usually castigated as a Democrat in name only, a charge in which I see a profound misunderstanding of the Democratic Party.

I’m usually pretty circumspect about this stuff but I thought I’d set the record straight.

Over the period of the last 40 some-odd years I have voted for precisely two presidential candidates that were actually elected: Bush in 2004 and Obama in 2008.

In 2004 I ruined my record of consistent failure by voting for Bush not because I liked him but because John Kerry was manifestly such a pompous nincompoop. Additionally, although I opposed our invasion of Iraq in 2003, I thought that our complicity in the carnage that would have resulted if we had bolted the country in 2005, which almost certainly would have occurred had Kerry become president, would have been immoral.

In 2008 I voted for Obama for exactly one reason: I find John McCain’s “national greatness” foreign policy deeply disturbing. Has the man ever met a military intervention he didn’t like?

Prior to that I had generally voted for a variety of third parties and independent candidates. That was, clearly, a protest vote on my part but I gradually came to realize that such protest votes have perverse consequences: they implicitly support the candidate whose views are least like your own.

I believe that not voting at all is the weakest form of protest vote. Nothing will come of nothing. It has the same perverse result as other protest votes: it grants implicit support to the candidate whose views are least like your own.

I still don’t know for whom I will vote in November. I wish that Mitt Romney were giving me more reasons to like him. I find his foreign policy views distressing. I wish the Republicans had presented a candidate for whom I could have voted without such severely mixed feelings. That was not to be.

46 comments

Round 3!

Do you remember the squabble I mentioned between Niall Ferguson and Paul Krugman? It’s entered round 3.

Round 1 began with Dr. Ferguson’s Newsweek/Daily Beast article. Round 2 was the exchange of charges among Paul Krugman, Niall Ferguson, and a cast of characters from the American Left Blogosphere. Niall Ferguson has responded with a counter-attack on Paul Krugman in particular and the Left Blogosphere in general.

I think that some of his responses are rather weak, viz. his retort to Matthew O’Brien’s observations on the likelihood of China’s GDP surpassing ours:

Well, there you have it. It “doesn’t really matter” that for the first time since the 1880s the United States is about to cease being the world’s largest economy. Fact checked, found to be correct, and countered with an utterly naive opinion.

However, I think that some of his criticisms are quite strong, particularly his statement of the problems that President Obama has in running on his record:

Notice, then, that my central critique of the president is not that the economy has underperformed, but that he has not been an effective leader of the executive branch. I go on to detail his well-documented difficulties in managing his team of economic advisers and his disastrous decision to leave it to his own party in Congress to define the terms of his stimulus, financial reform, and health-care reform. I also argue that he has consistently failed to address the crucial issue of long-term fiscal balance, with the result that the nation is now hurtling toward a fiscal cliff of tax hikes and drastic spending cuts.

I don’t find his extending that argument into foreign policy nearly as telling if only because I don’t believe that American foreign policy can be understood solely through the prism of presidential activity or leadership.

All in all Dr. Ferguson’s counter-attack is an interesting and entertaining exercise in polemic. IMO Americans are not by temperament, education, or experience so skilled at polemic as Brits and we should avoid entering the lists with them in that particular area. Our press is not nearly as rough and tumble as theirs and the rules of decorum for both houses of our Congress, which set the stage for our political discourse, more closely resemble the patrician Lords than the more confrontative Commons which sets the tone for theirs.

1 comment

Do Courtiers Have Ethical Obligations, Too?

500 or more economists have put their signatures on a web site, Economists for Romney. The list is headlined by five economists who have won Nobel Prizes: Gary Becker, Robert Lucas, Robert Mundell, Edward Prescott, and Myron Scholes. In scanning down the list I noted the names of many economists familiar from the blogosphere or op-ed pages and an acquaintance of mine from many years ago.

This list has evoked sharp criticism from fellow economist Laurence Kotlikoff:

Economics holds itself out as a science, yet here we have supposedly impartial scientists declaring that all of Romney’s proposed economic policies are good and that everything the president has done on the economics front has been misguided and flawed.

No impartial economist would make such blanket assertions. By their very nature, such statements represent political, not scientific, opinion. Yet the signatories not only identified themselves as professional economists; they also specified their university or other institutional affiliations, thereby implicating places such as the University of Chicago in their political pronouncements.

Dr. Kotlikoff also mentions several economists, e.g. Paul Krugman and Glenn Hubbard, by name as being engaged in ethically questionable actions.

I have been unable to identify an explicit, formal code of ethics for economists. Such things have been bandied about from time to time but I don’t believe there is an actual, formal, accepted code of ethics. There is, however, such a code for university professors. Here’s what would appear to be the relevant portion:

As members of their community, professors have the rights and obligations of other citizens. Professors measure the urgency of these obligations in the light of their responsibilities to their subject, to their students, to their profession, and to their institution. When they speak or act as private persons, they avoid creating the impression of speaking or acting for their college or university. As citizens engaged in a profession that depends upon freedom for its health and integrity, professors have a particular obligation to promote conditions of free inquiry and to further public understanding of academic freedom.

Dr. Kotlikoff does have a point but IMO not only is economists’ threatening the reputation of their chosen field of study but that particular horse bolted the paddock when academics participated in and even organized student protests in the 60s. That horse has already left the barn, has been out frolicking in the fields for years, and is on the cusp of dying of old age.

How, for example, do you explain the conduct of Lawrence Summers? If published accounts are true, not only did Dr. Summers groom his economic advice to suit what he perceived as political realities and the policy preferences of his patrons, he ensured that dissenting views from other economists within the Obama Administration were squelched.

1 comment

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The Council’s site post is here.

0 comments

The Collapse

I agree with Dean Baker’s very interesting explanation of the housing bubble, the consequences of its inevitable collapse, and the remedies that were put into place with one small exception. Here’s a snippet of it:

The basic story is very simple. (Remember, the purpose of economics is to make simple things complicated so as to exclude most of the public from debates on the most important policy issues that affect their lives.) The economy in the bubble years was driven by the bubble. The huge run-up in house prices led to an extraordinary building boom. Residential construction, which is ordinarily 3-4 percent of GDP rose to more than 6 percent of GDP at the peak of the boom in 2005.

Bubble-inflated house prices created close to $8 trillion dollars of housing equity. The housing wealth effect implies that people would spend between 5 to 7 cents on the dollar of this additional wealth, creating between $400 billion and $560 billion in additional annual consumption. The property taxes on inflated house prices also helped support perhaps $80 billion or so in state and local government spending. For good measure there was a bubble in non-residential real estate that followed in the wake of the housing bubble, which created a boom in this sector as well.

When the bubble burst, there was nothing to replace the lost demand. Residential construction fell by more than 4 percentage points of GDP ($600 billion annually in today’s economy). It fell below normal levels because the boom of the bubble years had led to record vacancy rates. Consumption plunged because the housing bubble equity disappeared. When the wealth was gone, the consumption that it generated also vanished. And, we saw cutbacks in government spending at the state and local level in response to the lost tax revenue.

All of this seems clear and simple. We lost $1.2 trillion to $1.4 trillion in annual private sector demand. Some of this has been replaced by the federal government’s budget deficits, but not enough to fill the gap.

The small exception relates to this:

The simple story is that we need a new source of demand to fill the gap left by the collapse of the housing bubble. In the short term that can only be the government. In the longer term it will have to be trade, which means a reduction in the trade deficit. That means first and foremost getting the value of the dollar down, but macho politicians in Washington don’t talk about a lower valued dollar.

To explain my disagreement with Dr. Baker we need to go back to 2008. At the time, alarmed by the extensive layoffs in mostly large companies in all sorts of sectors, I began a systematic report on layoffs comparing them with sales, net revenues, and so on. There was simply no correlation. The layoffs were completely out of proportion to the decline in sales or revenues.

What I think happened is that companies used the recession as a pretext for restructuring in ways they might have wanted to do long ago. Something like letting an old, obsolete office building burn down so you can replace it with a better one, less expensive to maintain and operate. The difference is that buildings don’t have lives to ruin or stunt while workers do.

My concern is unemployment, the very large number of people who can’t find jobs, are underemployed, or who have left the workforce entirely. I don’t think that over the last four years we’ve seen a clear relationship among employment, consumption, GDP, or government spending presumably intended to boost employment. At the level of GDP growth, government spending, and consumption we should seen more employment than we have. Basically, Okun’s law has broken down.

“Okun’s law” is the rule-of-thumb that says that with decreased GDP you should get decreased employment and, implicitly, vice versa.

I don’t think we can completely explain the sharp decrease in employment solely on the basis of the collapse in the housing bubble and, consequently, I think that solutions that stop at compensating for the gap in consumption will fall short of their objectives. I don’t doubt that those measures will cause employment to increase. I just think that it will increase in China and Vietnam.

32 comments