I agree with Dean Baker’s very interesting explanation of the housing bubble, the consequences of its inevitable collapse, and the remedies that were put into place with one small exception. Here’s a snippet of it:
The basic story is very simple. (Remember, the purpose of economics is to make simple things complicated so as to exclude most of the public from debates on the most important policy issues that affect their lives.) The economy in the bubble years was driven by the bubble. The huge run-up in house prices led to an extraordinary building boom. Residential construction, which is ordinarily 3-4 percent of GDP rose to more than 6 percent of GDP at the peak of the boom in 2005.
Bubble-inflated house prices created close to $8 trillion dollars of housing equity. The housing wealth effect implies that people would spend between 5 to 7 cents on the dollar of this additional wealth, creating between $400 billion and $560 billion in additional annual consumption. The property taxes on inflated house prices also helped support perhaps $80 billion or so in state and local government spending. For good measure there was a bubble in non-residential real estate that followed in the wake of the housing bubble, which created a boom in this sector as well.
When the bubble burst, there was nothing to replace the lost demand. Residential construction fell by more than 4 percentage points of GDP ($600 billion annually in today’s economy). It fell below normal levels because the boom of the bubble years had led to record vacancy rates. Consumption plunged because the housing bubble equity disappeared. When the wealth was gone, the consumption that it generated also vanished. And, we saw cutbacks in government spending at the state and local level in response to the lost tax revenue.
All of this seems clear and simple. We lost $1.2 trillion to $1.4 trillion in annual private sector demand. Some of this has been replaced by the federal government’s budget deficits, but not enough to fill the gap.
The small exception relates to this:
The simple story is that we need a new source of demand to fill the gap left by the collapse of the housing bubble. In the short term that can only be the government. In the longer term it will have to be trade, which means a reduction in the trade deficit. That means first and foremost getting the value of the dollar down, but macho politicians in Washington don’t talk about a lower valued dollar.
To explain my disagreement with Dr. Baker we need to go back to 2008. At the time, alarmed by the extensive layoffs in mostly large companies in all sorts of sectors, I began a systematic report on layoffs comparing them with sales, net revenues, and so on. There was simply no correlation. The layoffs were completely out of proportion to the decline in sales or revenues.
What I think happened is that companies used the recession as a pretext for restructuring in ways they might have wanted to do long ago. Something like letting an old, obsolete office building burn down so you can replace it with a better one, less expensive to maintain and operate. The difference is that buildings don’t have lives to ruin or stunt while workers do.
My concern is unemployment, the very large number of people who can’t find jobs, are underemployed, or who have left the workforce entirely. I don’t think that over the last four years we’ve seen a clear relationship among employment, consumption, GDP, or government spending presumably intended to boost employment. At the level of GDP growth, government spending, and consumption we should seen more employment than we have. Basically, Okun’s law has broken down.
“Okun’s law” is the rule-of-thumb that says that with decreased GDP you should get decreased employment and, implicitly, vice versa.
I don’t think we can completely explain the sharp decrease in employment solely on the basis of the collapse in the housing bubble and, consequently, I think that solutions that stop at compensating for the gap in consumption will fall short of their objectives. I don’t doubt that those measures will cause employment to increase. I just think that it will increase in China and Vietnam.