Settling on “No”

I wanted to make a remark or two about Bob Woodward’s reporting of the failure of President Obama to reach an agreement with House Speaker John Boehner on spending and taxation last summer:

The book, “The Price of Politics,” on sale Sept. 11, 2012, shows how close the president and the House speaker were to defying Washington odds and establishing a spending framework that included both new revenues and major changes to long-sacred entitlement programs.

But at a critical juncture, with an agreement tantalizingly close, Obama pressed Boehner for additional taxes as part of a final deal — a miscalculation, in retrospect, given how far the House speaker felt he’d already gone.

The president called three times to speak with Boehner about his latest offer, according to Woodward. But the speaker didn’t return the president’s phone call for most of an agonizing day, in what Woodward calls a “monumental communications lapse” between two of the most powerful men in the country.

When Boehner finally did call back, he jettisoned the entire deal. Obama lost his famous cool, according to Woodward, with a “flash of pure fury” coming from the president; one staffer in the room said Obama gripped the phone so tightly he thought he would break it.

“He was spewing coals,” Boehner told Woodward, in what is described as a borderline “presidential tirade.”

“He was pissed…. He wasn’t going to get a damn dime more out of me. He knew how far out on a limb I was. But he was hot. It was clear to me that coming to an agreement with him was not going to happen, and that I had to go to Plan B.”

Hat tip: James Joyner

In negotiations when one party re-opens a subject that the other party believes already to have been settled and then, when called on it, reacts angrily, it is reasonable to conclude that the party that re-opened the previously settled subject was negotiating in bad faith, i.e. had no intention of arriving at an equitable settlement. At that point withdrawal from negotiations is the only viable alternative.

Something else I’ve mentioned here before: there is an asking price, a selling price, and an insult price, i.e. a price so out of the ballpark that it’s taken as a deliberate affront to the other party. It’s also possible that’s how Speaker Boehner interpreted the president’s escalating offer.

Both of these things are traps that experienced negotiators should know how to avoid. I think this adds weight to an argument I’ve made here before: I don’t think that Barack Obama’s experience in Illinois prepared him for a situation in which he would need to negotiate. Indeed, his election to the U. S. Senate here was a mark of just how supine the Illinois Republican Party has been.

13 comments

Facts Are Two-Edged Swords

At this point it seems to me that regardless of who is elected president, much of the blood drawn in this election will be that of Big Media-based “fact-checking” columns or adjuncts. The latest fact check making news is a check by Politifact.com of former President Bill Clinton’s remark in his speech last night that more jobs were created during the terms of Democratic presidents than during those of Republican presidents. Clearly, as a matter of historical fact that’s true.

I could make all sorts of analyses of the analysis in the fact-check but I’ll limit my observations to just three. First, I don’t think that anything previous to 1979 matters at all. Not even a little. In 1979 China renounced its official policy of autarky. That’s not just a once a decade or once a century development. That was a once in a millennium development. The entire economic game has changed and whatever went before is just nostalgia.

Additionally, I think that policies matter and, indeed, matter much more than party labels. I think that Nixon was more like Kennedy and Clinton like Reagan than Bush 43 was like Reagan or Obama like Kennedy. Presumably, that’s an observation which will make almost no one happy.

However, what struck me most about the analysis was the bare net job creation during the Obama presidency to date that the fact check presented: 332,000 jobs in four years. That’s fewer than any president of any party with any term length over the period of the last 50 years other than Bush 43. And Democratic presidents are supposed to create more jobs than Republican ones. This is good news?

45 comments

These Are the Good Old Days

Just a reminder. According to the National Bureau of Economic Research, the official scorekeeper on recessions, the present recovery has been in progress for more than 36 months. During the post-war period the average period from the trough of a recession to the peak of the next cycle has been 59 months.

That means that there is a very great likelihood that the economy will go into recession again during the next presidential term regardless of who is elected president. Given the economic woes in Europe, in China, the volatile situation in the Middle East, and the fragility of the present recovery, I strongly suspect that recession will be at least as severe as the last.

Have a nice day.

13 comments

Preparing the Battlespace

If President Obama is re-elected will Congressional Republicans seek common cause with him in his second term? That’s what Chicago Mayor and former Obama Chief-of-Staff Rahm Emanuel says will happen:

The year after Clinton won a second term, Emanuel boasted, he and the GOP balanced the budget, reached agreement on health care coverage for children, and cut other deals.

So what’s that got to do with what Obama might do in a second term, given the prevailing gridlock in Washington.

“Elections…have consequences,” the mayor said. “If the president wins reelection, I think the Republicans will finally, after four years of trying to beat him, will try to work with him. The American people will have delivered their verdict.”

This post hoc propter hoc analysis has a number of problems with it. First, today’s Congressional Republicans are very much different than those of 16 years ago. They are much more ideological, they are much more activist, and the party, always more united than the Democrats, is even more united now.

Second, a growing economy produces different political dynamics than today’s stagnant one does.

That fatuous response ignores one very important fact: there is not just one election. Each of the 535 members of Congress won their own elections. Their constituents have delivered their verdicts, too. If President Obama wins re-election it will be because the voters believed he was a better choice than Mitt Romney not because they thought he was the best of all possible choices. They will have made other choices, too, in electing their Congressional representatives, senators, governors, and so on. The branches of government are co-equal. Congress is not subordinate to the presidency. If anything it’s the other way around.

Since Rahm Emanuel is not an idiot, why would he predict something that is so obviously not going to happen? I think he’s preparing the political battlespace for the next four years and for 2016 (when I expect him to throw his hat in the ring for the presidency).

If President Obama is re-elected, the squabbles between the Congressional Democrats and the Congressional Republicans and between the president and the Congressional Republicans will continue in full vigor. Clearly, Democrats are preparing to campaign against intransigent, obstructionist Republicans. I think that this is the strongest argument for electing Mitt Romney. If you liked the 112th Congress (that would be all 12% of you, voters), you’ll love the 113th!

4 comments

Where the Candidates Stand

Scientific American has an interesting side-by-side comparison of the responses of Barack Obama and Mitt Romney to fourteen questions on “some of the biggest scientific and technological challenges facing the nation”. Issues raised in the questions include education, R&D, energy, and global warming, just to name a few.

As you might suspect I have points of serious disagreement with both candidates. For one thing what good is producing or importing more science and technology grads if there are no jobs in science or technology for them to fill?

1 comment

The Republicans’ Case

Whatever you may think of him or his views, Fox television personality Bill O’Reilly is not stupid. Here he makes the Republicans’ case against Obama and for Romney pretty succinctly:

Take a look at this chart: When President Obama took office, unemployment was at 7.8%. After three and a half years, it stands at 8.3%. Median income when the President took over was about $55,000. Now, $51,000. Gasoline prices in January 2009 were $1.84 per gallon. Now, $3.82 per gallon. That’s painful to working folks and it’s largely ignored by the President. National debt of $10.6 Trillion when President Obama took the oath of office. It is now more than $16 Trillion – an astronomical and dangerous rise. Finally, the budget deficit in President Bush’s last year was $458 Billion. In 2011, under President Obama, it had risen to nearly $1.3 Trillion – again, a dangerous amount of money to have to borrow.

There’s no way the Democrats can spin those facts; they’re in stone. The country’s in trouble, no question about it. But there is a question about how to get out of that trouble. Many voters believe that President Obama has had enough time to improve things. That if a football coach inherits a team, and that team is worse three and a half years later, the coach is out of there, the coach gets fired. But Mr. Obama says, “wait a minute!” His situation is unique.

President Obama: Historically, after these big financial crises where a lot of people are dealing with debt or a collapse of a housing market, that creates bigger challenges. And we’re seeing this, not just in here the United States, but around the world. But, what I would say is that the steps that we’ve taken in saving the auto industry, in making sure that college is more affordable, in investing in clean energy and science and technology and research. Those are all the things we’re going to need to grow over the long term.

Bill O’Reilly: Now, there’s no use in debating President Obama’s opinion. He believes it, and so do his followers. All the charts in the world are not going to change their minds. So it is up to you, the voter, to decide whether Mitt Romney and the Republicans should get a chance to improve things, and therein lies the question mark. Talking Points has said from the beginning of this campaign that the vote will be a referendum on Barack Obama. It will be an up or down vote on him.

The Republican Party knows that, and therefore Governor Romney is going to play it very safe. He’s not going to be drawn into any policy controversy. He’s not going to make any bold and fresh statements. He’s simply going to say that President Obama has failed to bring prosperity to America, and that he, Mitt Romney, will be able to do that.

22 comments

Disinvestment in Education?

Speaking of people who’ve taken leave of their senses, yesterday I heard an interview with Elizabeth Warren, candidate for the Senate in Massachusetts. I don’t usually butt into the political affairs of states other than my own but Dr. Warren said something I found bewildering. She complained about the “disinvestment in education”.

What disinvestment in education? This year we’re poised to spend around $1 trillion on education. That’s more overall, more per student, and more per capita than just about any other country by a significant margin.

Our problem isn’t disinvestment in education. It’s in value received for dollars spent.

I say this in the context of living in a city whose public school teachers, half of whom are already among the top 10% of income earners in the city, are poised to go on strike next week for, among other things, higher pay.

1 comment

Have They Lost Their Minds?

In a Wall Street Journal symposium nine prominent Democrats present

their recommendations for an Obama second-term agenda, assuming that Republicans control at least one house of Congress.

Those in the symposium include SEIU president Andy Stern, California Lt. Gov. Gavin Newsom, and former Tennessee Congressman Harold Ford, Jr. The proviso gets short shrift.

Their prescriptions range from addressing climate change to introducing new programs (in addition to existing Social Security) for providing retirement income.

Have they lost their minds? There are more than 20 million people who are unemployed or underemployed. The Social Security Disability roster has grown so rapidly over the last half dozen years, largely from individuals who have lost their jobs and are unable to secure new ones, that the program is, essentially, bankrupt. Half of those who are unemployed have been unemployed for more than 99 weeks.

There’s only one agenda item for the next presidential term: increase the rate of job creation. If they don’t believe that, they don’t have any ideas for what could be done, or they don’t believe that anything can be done, they should get the heck out of the way in favor of people who do believe that, do have ideas, and do believe that something can be done.

Without more people getting jobs we won’t have a robust economy. Without a robust economy none of the bright, shiny objects that have captured their attention will come to pass.

15 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

0 comments

But On the Other Hand…

Edward Lazear maintains that the reason that unemployment remains stubbornly high is the failure to address the problems of inadequate demand:

Research I’ve done with James Spletzer of the U.S. Census Bureau shows that the problems in the labor market are not structural. They reflect slow economic growth, and the cure is a decent recovery.

In 2007, the unemployment rate was 4.4%. Two years later, it reached 10%. The structure of a modern economy does not change that quickly. The demographic composition of the labor force, its educational breakdown and even the industrial mix did not differ much between 2007 and 2009.

More specifically, from 2007 to 2009 unemployment grew dramatically in a few industries, and these changes contributed to the rise in overall unemployment. But the changes were similar to those experienced in prior recessions. As unemployment rates declined somewhat after 2009, the pattern played out in reverse. Industries that saw the largest increases in unemployment were the ones with the largest decreases as overall unemployment fell.

I think that’s an excruciatingly weak argument. For one thing it assumes that the cause of developments in 2007 through 2009 must have occurred in 2007 through 2009. That reminds me of the old joke that I’ve mentioned here before. A guy jumps off of a skyscraper as he passes the 48th floor some wiseacre yells out the window: “How are you?” He replies “So far, so good.” You’ve got to keep in mind that it’s the jumping that will kill him.

The events that caused the recent financial crisis had been developing for decades. They didn’t suddenly occur in 2007. The question he should be asking is why were demand and employment so high?

For another thing a lot of the people who’ve lost their jobs over the period of not just the last 5 years but the last 15 years were involved in the creation of organizational capital. That’s something that companies don’t see as nearly so essential when they’re hunkering down in survival mode. However, as I predicted in 2007 and 2008, some companies inevitably overshoot. Then they re-hired people. That’s no proof of Dr. Lazear’s claims. The dynamics of U. S. job market were just completely different from what he’s suggesting.

The title of this post refers to another old wisecrack. This one was by Harry Truman. When confronted with economists who not only corporately but individually gave him conflicting advice, saying “Well, on the one hand…” he quipped that what he needed was a one-handed economist. The search continues.

10 comments