Chicago Teachers’ Strike in Second Day

The strike of Chicago Public School Teachers has entered its second day. The Tribune is offering ongoing coverage, e.g. here, as is the Sun-Times. I found the Trib’s coverage less sympathetic to the teachers.

The remainder of this post will be a more-or-less disjointed collection of impressions.,

To be honest after 24 hours I’m becoming somewhat more sympathetic with the teachers. The frequently-repeated assertion that the strike was not about wages, for example. There’s quite a collection of other explanations for the strike:

Class sizes are too large, not enough social workers, not enough nurses, not enough counselors, not enough speech therapists, not enough computers, no new language-arts teachers to staff the longer school day.

Take a breath. No air conditioning, no place for students to play during recess, nobody to supervise recess, textbooks ordered and delivered too late, not enough music and art teachers, no respect.

And oh, yes, every now and then if prompted, I’d run across a teacher who would mention one of the two items that Mayor Rahm Emanuel contends are the only real issues left on the bargaining table: teacher evaluations and procedures for rehiring laid-off teachers.

I’m wary of strikes for pay, especially when those striking are already well-compensated. However, I think that striking for working conditions is just and reasonable.

I understand that teacher evaluations is a hot button. Administrators want complete discretion and so do teachers. There’s no way to square that circle. Some process must be developed that’s not completely subjective but that doesn’t over-emphasize test scores. I recognize that it’s learning that’s important rather than test scores and that emphasizing test scores over all else inevitably motivates teachers to teach the test rather than encouraging learning. I just wish that the CTU were more proactive on the issue of evaluations than they apparently have been.

I’m getting the distinct impression that the real reasons for the strike are, of all things, interpersonal problems between Mayor Rahm Emanuel and Karen Lewis, head of the Chicago Teachers Union. From the Trib article:

The strike on Emanuel’s watch cuts against the narrative the mayor is trying to craft as a leader who’s a problem solver moving the city forward. Emanuel’s aggressive posture in pushing for a longer school day and year, while also cutting the pay raise teachers were supposed to get last year, galvanized the union.

It may be that Emanuel’s coarse language and brusque demeanor has alienated people unnecessarily.

The strike has compelled Mayor Emanuel to suspend his fund-raising activities on behalf of the Obama re-election campaign. That recalls to mind the questions I raised when he ran for mayor. Rahm Emanuel was co-chair of President Obama’s re-election campaign. He resigned that post to undertake fund-raising activities for a SuperPAC. He took a day off in the middle of negotiations with the union so that he could attend the Democratic National Convention, something I honestly cannot imagine Mayor Daley having done.

I wonder if he has time to be mayor. It’s not just a full-time job. It’s a more than full-time job.

10 comments

The Maple Syrup That Wasn’t There

People have been chuckling for the last week or so over the uncovering of the theft of $30 million dollars worth of maple syrup from Canada’s Global Strategic Maple Syrup Reserve. My wife had, I think, the most appropriate reaction. She laughed and said “There’s a Global Strategic Maple Syrup Reserve?”

It might be fun to round up all of the waggish reactions to the story but a $30 million theft is actually no laughing matter. If I had to make a guess about what happened, I think I’d start looking at the shipping and receiving process. I wonder if that missing maple syrup was ever actually there. That’s a lot of maple syrup and it doesn’t sound to me like something that could easily go unnoticed. I’m guessing we’re talking about between a half million and a million gallons.

5 comments

Medical Humor

On the unsuccessful self-treatment of writer’s block. Hat tip: Greg Mankiw

0 comments

A Welcome Addition

Garrett Jones has joined Econlog as a guest blogger. I hope he sticks around.

1 comment

They’ll Make It Up On Volume

Apparently, GM is losing money on each and every Volt it sells:

Sept 10 (Reuters) – General Motors Co sold a record number of Chevrolet Volt sedans in August – but that probably isn’t a good thing for the automaker’s bottom line.

Nearly two years after the introduction of the path-breaking plug-in hybrid, GM is still losing as much as $49,000 on each Volt it builds, according to estimates provided to Reuters by industry analysts and manufacturing experts.

Cheap Volt lease offers meant to drive more customers to Chevy showrooms this summer may have pushed that loss even higher. There are some Americans paying just $5,050 to drive around for two years in a vehicle that cost as much as $89,000 to produce.

And while the loss per vehicle will shrink as more are built and sold, GM is still years away from making money on the Volt, which will soon face new competitors from Ford, Honda and others.

GM’s basic problem is that “the Volt is over-engineered and over-priced,” said Dennis Virag, president of the Michigan-based Automotive Consulting Group.

The detailed analysis of the Volt’s costs is something like this. Each Volt costs GM between $20,000 and $32,000 to build. A comparable conventional GM car has production costs of about half that. Add to that the amortization of the huge development costs, at this point estimated as something like $50,000 per car.

Will that go down as more are sold? Maybe, maybe not. There are financing charges, opportunity costs, and the costs of producing the next generation Volt, something that will become increasingly urgent as competition from Ford, Honda, and, of course, the niche leader, Toyota, increases.

3 comments

Chicago Teachers Go On Strike (Updated)

I think we can confidently put a period on the Richard M. Daley era of Chicago city governance. This morning the Chicago Teachers Union went out on strike:

“Negotiations have been intense but productive, however we have failed to reach an agreement that will prevent a labor strike,” Chicago Teachers Union President Karen Lewis said at a dramatic 10 p.m. Sunday press conference. “Real school will not be open [Monday]. … No CTU member will be inside our schools.

“Please seek alternative care for your children.”

The announcement was quickly blasted by Mayor Rahm Emanuel as “a strike of choice” that didn’t have to happen if talks continued. He repeatedly declared: “My team is available now.”

But Lewis, just before the midnight strike deadline, said talks wouldn’t resume until Monday. She said she texted School Board President David Vitale and they agreed to meet Monday.

A “disappointed” Emanuel said the latest deal offered to the teachers was “very respectful of our teachers and is right by our children.”

I’ve already expressed my opinion of wage increases for Chicago teachers: half of Chicago’s teachers (plus more than half of Chicago’s police officers and firefighters) are already in the top 10% of Chicago’s income earners. They are the rich. The only feasible way to fund pay increases is by increasing property taxes, the burden of which will fall hardest on the poorest and weakest. We are living in a period during which public revenues are struggling to remain where they are. This is not the time for public employees to demand pay increases.

The last strike by Chicago teachers was in 1987 when Eugene Sawyer was president. The Chicago Public Schools was brought under Chicago’s city government during the mayoralty of his successor, Richard M. Daley, who has been mayor ever since.

Richie Daley’s father, Chicago Mayor Richard J. Daley, gained a reputation as a tough negotiator with Chicago’s public employees’ unions by bringing the union leadership into his office, closing the door, and giving them everything they wanted.

If you assume (as I do) that Mayor Emanuel’s ambitions extend beyond being mayor of Chicago, he may rue the day that CPS came within the purview of City Hall. The job is a lot harder when you may need to say “No”.

Update

Chicago area resident Mike Shedlock makes his own, somewhat harsher comments about the strike and publishes an email he received from John Tillman of the Illinois Policy Center. From the email alert:

The fiscal reality is that Chicago Public Schools are broke. CPS will be draining cash reserves this year just to stay afloat, and will be $1 billion in the red next school year. The 30 percent raise CTU originally asked for is out of the question, and so are other double-digit raises that CTU has demanded. Average teacher pay in Chicago is already at $71,000 without benefits, while the average Chicagoan makes only $30,203 and the unemployment rate in the city is nearly 11 percent.

Median pay for a Chicago Public School teacher is $76,000.

As I’ve written before I think that professionals and public servants need to regulate their wage requirements to the capabilities of the community they serve. There is no blood in this stone.

I haven’t looked at the CPS’s financial statements lately but I strongly suspect that the real, untold story in all of this is the rising cost of healthcare. When the cost of insuring Chicago’s teachers rises much faster than Chicago’s revenues do, something has to give. It could be the number of teachers or teacher pay. Chicago already has the highest sales tax in the country. Property values are falling and increasing property taxes by the amounts that would be required will be confiscatory. It will drive people from city.

31 comments

Desperately Seeking Coherence

The Washington Post summarizes President Obama’s acceptance speech:

The president offered an appealing, even a stirring, vision of a shared citizenship and commitment to democracy. “We don’t think government can solve all our problems,” he said. “But we don’t think government is the source of all our problems — any more than are welfare recipients, or corporations, or unions, or immigrants, or gays, or any other group we’re told to blame for our troubles.”

But the attractiveness of that vision made all the more frustrating Mr. Obama’s refusal to fill in any substance, his once again promising hard truths that he did not deliver. “They want your vote, but they don’t want you to know their plan,” he said of the Republicans. If Mr. Obama has a plan, Americans who listened Thursday don’t know how he would achieve it.

That brings to mind a concern I’ve had about the Obama Administration’s approach to the economy practically from the outset: the lack of a coherent approach to solving the problems at hand. As I see things there are three different theories competing for attention on the source of our problems: the Keynesian view that our problems are caused by a shortfall in demand, the idea first put forward by Richard Koo but occasionally advanced by the Obama Administration that it’s a “balance sheet recession” brought on by excessive household debt, or that the problems of the American economy are primarily structural.

In 2009 then-director of the White House National Economic Council for the Obama Administration Lawrence Summers said:

To address the deep and severe crisis he inherited, President Obama started from two main premises. First, the most immediate priority was to rescue the economy by restoring confidence and breaking the vicious cycle of economic contraction and financial failure. Second, the recovery from this crisis would be built not on the flimsy foundation of asset bubbles but on the firm foundation of productive investment and long-term growth.

The President was clear from the beginning that these two tasks needed to be dovetailed—that confidence in our ability to rescue the economy depended on a sense of our commitment to reform and a vision for rebuilding.

The economic problems confronting the United States as President Obama took office were of a unique character. This was not the standard post-World War II recession in which rising inflation had led to monetary contraction which led to economic contraction. Nor was it a crisis of the kind frequently experienced in emerging markets in which the country had experienced a sudden loss of external confidence. Indeed, the dollar strengthened over the second half of 2008.

Rather, the crisis was qualitatively similar to the crisis in Japan after its asset bubble collapse, the early stages of the Great Depression, or other major domestic financial crises in which asset bubbles burst, credit flow contracted and de-leveraging reduced spending.

We were very much aware that there were few, if any, examples of success in rapidly restoring economic growth and stability after broad-based financial crises. We concluded that this was a reflection of insufficiently aggressive action taken too slowly and decided that our policy response would be neither too little nor too late. The Administration decided to pursue a policy approach of seeking to reverse the vicious cycle connecting income declines and financial instability by directly supporting incomes and restoring stability to the financial system.

[…]

The rebuilt American economy must be more export-oriented and less consumption-oriented, more environmentally oriented and less fossil-energy-oriented, more bio- and software-engineering-oriented and less financial-engineering-oriented, more middle-class-oriented and less oriented to income growth that disproportionately favors a very small share of the population.

That statement combines all three of the theories and, indeed, suggests a fourth: that the problems of the American economy are caused by maldistribution of income.

If the intent of the ARRA, the “stimulus package”, was Keynesian pump-priming, it was not a coherent approach for two important reasons. The theory calls for counter-cyclical spending increases to make up for inadequate demand and pro-cyclical spending cuts. According to the NBER the longest post-war economic contraction prior to that of the Great Recession was 16 months (that of the Great Recession was 18 months). With the recession having begun in December 2007 it could reasonably have been expected to end by the middle of 2009.

Without utterly unrealistic assumptions about the Keynesian multiplier that would be realized by a stimulus, the amount that would have needed to have been spent was around $400 billion. Both the ARRA’s size and timing were inadequate.

It’s not that there were no available ways of spending the required amount of money in the time necessary. There were any number of ways of accomplishing that, all based on tax cuts. For example, suspending FICA both for workers and employers for six months would have resulted in leaving more money in the economy in 2009 than was actually spent in 2009 under the ARRA.

Why wasn’t such a plan adopted? Because Republicans wouldn’t have supported it? Because Democrats wouldn’t have supported it?

There have been a few half-hearted attempts at speeding up the reduction in household debt, HAMP, the Home Affordable Modification Program begun in 2009, is the most significant. By most accounts it hasn’t succeeded in its goals. According to a report from the McKinsey Global Institute household debt has declined by about a half trillion dollars since 2007 and two-thirds of that has been in the form of foreclosures and defaults. That’s significantly different from paying off the debt in its economic effects due to the difference in the wealth effect.

Assuming that the recession was a balance sheet recession due to excessive household debt how much farther would that debt need to decline before the economy could return to robust health? According to the St. Louis Federal Reserve household debt is now roughly where it was in 2007. For it to return to what it was in, say, 1999 it would need to decline ten times as much as it has so far. Over the last six months household debt has hardly declined at all, only about $20 billion. That’s another way of saying “Never”.

An additional problem with concluding that the reason for the phlegmatic recovery is that recoveries from financial crises are slow is that, at least according to a recent paper from the Cleveland Fed, that does not appear to have been true historically in the United States.

I wish I had the time, inclination, and resources to produce an empirical measure of the administration’s actual beliefs based on how often President Obama mentions something when speaking. I have no way of verifying it but my impression is that the president believes that the primary reasons for high unemployment are structural. For example, back in June 2011 on the Today Show the president said:

&133;a couple of things happened. look, we went through the worse crisis since the great depression. we are now in a process where the economy is growing again and we created 2 million jobs over the last 15 months. but it’s not as fast as it needs to be to make up for all the jobs that were lost. the other thing that happened, though, and this goes to the point you were just making, is there are some structural issues with our economy where a lot of businesses have learned to become much more efficient with a lot fewer workers. you see it when you go to a bank and you use an atm, you don’t go to a bank teller , or you go to the airport and you’re using a kiosk instead of checking in at the gate. so all these things have creakrecreated changes in the economy and this counsel is identifying where the jobs of the future are going to be, how do we make sure there’s a match between what people are getting trained for and the jobs that exist, how do we make sure that capital is flowing into those places with the greatest opportunity. we are on the right track. the key is figuring out how do we accelerate it.

That’s clearly a structural argument. Emphasizing the impact of offshore outsourcing:

We should start with our tax code. Right now, companies get tax breaks for moving jobs and profits overseas. Meanwhile, companies that choose to stay in America get hit with one of the highest tax rates in the world. It makes no sense, and everyone knows it.

So let’s change it. First, if you’re a business that wants to outsource jobs, you shouldn’t get a tax deduction for doing it.

That money should be used to cover moving expenses for companies like Master Lock that decide to bring jobs home.

Second, no American company should be able to avoid paying its fair share of taxes by moving jobs and profits overseas.

From now on, every multinational company should have to pay a basic minimum tax. And every penny should go towards lowering taxes for companies that choose to stay here and hire here in America.

Third, if you’re an American manufacturer, you should get a bigger tax cut. If you’re a high-tech manufacturer, we should double the tax deduction you get for making your products here. And if you want to relocate in a community that was hit hard when a factory left town, you should get help financing a new plant, equipment, or training for new workers.

and education:

I also hear from many business leaders who want to hire in the United States but can’t find workers with the right skills. Growing industries in science and technology have twice as many openings as we have workers who can do the job. Think about that: openings at a time when millions of Americans are looking for work.

It’s inexcusable. And we know how to fix it.

Jackie Bray is a single mom from North Carolina who was laid off from her job as a mechanic. Then Siemens opened a gas turbine factory in Charlotte and formed a partnership with Central Piedmont Community College. The company helped the college design courses in laser and robotics training. It paid Jackie’s tuition, then hired her to help operate their plant.

I want every American looking for work to have the same opportunity as Jackie did. Join me in a national commitment to train 2 million Americans with skills that will lead directly to a job.

as President Obama did in his 2012 State of the Union address, are structural arguments, too. These themes were repeated in his recent acceptance speech during the Democratic National Convention. I found little or no mention of the argument that our economic woes are caused either by a shortfall in demand or too much household debt in that speech.

The problem with this theory of our economic problems is that it doesn’t comport with what has actually happened and it doesn’t comport with the Obama Administration’s consistent laying of the blame for those problems on the previous administration. Technological progress didn’t suddenly start eliminating jobs in 2001, culminating in 2007, and offshoring did not reach some sort of tipping point then. Indeed, there’s been as much offshoring of jobs during President Obama’s first term as there was during President Bush’s first term. President Clinton lobbied hard to grant China Most Favored Nation trading status and for China’s admission to the WTO, both of which gave impetus to the problems about which President Obama is complaining. There’s plenty of blame to spread around and the factors go back at least 20 years.

It might be argued that the scattershot approach to economic policy is an appropriate strategy for dealing with uncertainty or with complex conditions. I don’t think that excuse holds water when none of the solutions being proposed are adequate to address any of the explanations that have been proffered. Additionally, the approach assumes an infinite amount of time, money, and political will in which to execute it. I don’t believe that we have any of those.

A coherent approach to our problems would consist in enunciating a theory of those problems that comports at least in part with what’s actually occurring, proposing solutions that would address those problems effectively, advocating those solutions tirelessly until they’re implemented, and following those solutions until they’re successful or proven inadequate. Our problems are already at hand. We need a coherent approach to solving them.

For the last five years we’ve had incoherence. Enough. I’m not letting Mitt Romney off the hook in these remarks. Unless you believe that our problems are that the highest marginal tax rate is too high which does not comport with the facts since we’ve had higher marginal tax rates for most of the last century and faster growth for most of the last century or that some unspecified regulations are restraining a gigantic surge of economic activity that’s straining at the bit to be released, something I think is unlikely, his proposals are as incoherent as those of the man he seeks to replace.

25 comments

The Conventions

Well, the major party political conventions are over. For me it couldn’t happen soon enough. I didn’t watch a second of either one of them. For a summary of what happened and what was accomplished you could probably do worse than reading Sean Trende’s analysis.

It looks like my prediction of what the conventions would bring for the candidates is right on target. We’ll see in a week or so.

Update

Apparently, Dick Morrris thinks that Gov. Romney got a bit more out of his convention than I do. However, he also suggests that the president didn’t do much for himself with his own convention, with which I agree.

37 comments

Another Precinct Heard From

Scott Sumner must be smiling. At the recent meeting at Jackson Hole a paper was presented that found, essentially, that when the Fed funds rate is near zero quantitative easing (the Fed tactic of buying long-dated bonds and mortgage-backed securities) doesn’t do much for the real economy while verbal commitments by central banks to specific goals or outcomes AKA “nominal GDP targeting” do. There’s a lengthy post summarizing the paper here at Business Insider.

2 comments

Something For Everyone!

Yet again, the Bureau of Labor Statistics has produced an Employment Situation Report that has something for everyone. If the only thing you’re interested in is the headline unemployment rate figure, there’s good news for you: in August the unemployment rate declined from 8.3% to 8.1%. If you’re a Republican looking for ammo to use against the president, you’ve got that, too: only 98,000 jobs were created last month, an extremely phlegmatic result.

Unfortunately, there’s not much of a silver lining if you’re looking for a job. The reason that the unemployment rate declined is that so many people stopped looking entirely and left the labor force, whether to take a forced early retirement, go on disability, or go back to school to prepare for some nonexistent job other than the nonexistent job you used to have.

The labor force participation rate is the lowest it’s been in more than 30 years, since 1981.

Update

ZeroHedge notes an all-time record in the spread between the reported unemployment rate and the implied unemployment rate (the rate without the precipitous drop in the labor force participation rate).

5 comments