A number of posts and comments recently have touched on the questions that comprise my title so I thought it was time to tackle them head on. As my point of departure I’ll take a post from Ezra Klein’s WP Wonkblog. In the post Mr. Klein lists 14 reasons that the present Congress is awful:
- They’re not passing laws.
- They’re hideously unpopular.
- They’re incredibly polarized.
- They’ve set back the recovery.
- They lost our credit rating.
- They’re terrible even when they’re “super.â€
- The House Republicans’ repeated attempted at repealing the PPACA.
- The budget shenanigans of Senate Democrats
- They can’t get appropriations done on time.
- The transportation-infrastructure fiasco.
- The FAA shutdown
- Not confirming Peter Diamond as a Fed governor
- Thomas Mann and Norm Ornstein say so.
- There actually are problems they need to solve.
I’m late to this party because I rarely read Mr. Klein’s work. If you’re curious as to why, ask in comments and I’ll explain.
I agree with #3, #5, #8, #11, #12, and #14. Please read Ezra’s commentary on why the failure of the Senate leadership to propose or enact a budget is important. Essentially, they’re forcing the country to retain past priorities even in the face of changing circumstances.
Some are frivolous or, at least, make unwarranted assumptions. For example, would Ezra really prefer a Congress that repealed the Pure Food and Drug Act of 1906 (it provided for federal inspection of meat among many other things), the Social Security Act of 1935, the Social Security Reform Act of 1965 (Medicare), and the various laws authorizing the size of our armed forces so that our military was cut to zero? Such a Congress would be very, very busy but I doubt that Ezra would approve of it. Unless you believe that an activist government is ipso facto a better government, what Congress does is more important than how much it does. My ideal Congress would do very little because the laws had been structured in such a way as to render constant tweaking unnecessary. It wouldn’t even be in permanent session, as Congresses have been for decades.
Let me propose what I think are the necessary solutions to some of the problems with our present Congress (see some of my previous observations about critical success factors).
First, reform Congressional compensation. Toughen the outside earning rules. Abolish pensions paid to federal elected officials.
Second, introduce anti-gerrymandering provisions.
Third, prohibit the use of seniority in the Congress for just about anything. Committee chairmen should be chosen by lot annually.
Fourth, reform lobbying. Only actual constituents should be allowed to lobby Congressmen and even then only physically within their Congressional districts.
I’m under no illusions that any of those things are likely to be undertaken. Most would require constitutional amendments or a Constitutional Convention. Sitting members of Congress will never vote to curtail their own power and the delegates to a Constitutional Convention are likely to be largely composed of sitting members of Congress. The only way they’ll be implemented will be by the courts or insurrection. And, as Orval Faubus noted 50 years ago, the Feds have the bomb.