The Triumph of Hope Over Experience

A frequently-encountered bit of wishful thinking is that Democratic (or, less frequently, Republican) control of the White House and both house of Congress would solve all of our problems. There is, apparently, empirical evidence of the existence of this belief:

The Gallup survey found that Democrats currently favor one-party government much more than Republicans do. That fits a historical pattern, wrote Andrew Dugan of the Gallup organization, “in which members of the president’s party have the strongest desire for one-party government when an incumbent is competing for a new term.”

In 2004, when George W. Bush was seeking a second term, Republicans preferred unified government and Democrats favored divided government. However, when one party controls both the White House and Congress, as in 2006 and 2010, all voters favor divided government.

Morris P. Fiorina, a thoughtful Stanford political scientist, believes divided government produces “reasonable compromises when there are reasonable people on both sides,” as happened in 1983 on Social Security. But, he cautioned, it leads to gridlock “in today’s climate of a political tong war.”

Gridlock may be the best that we can hope for. While the belief in the need for single-party rule is persistent the evidence for its effectiveness is pretty darned hard to come by. Chicago has had complete Democratic control of City Hall and the City Council for generations. Chicago is broke and recent moves to raise taxes have produced less revenue than their advocates had projected.

I do not think think that single-party rule is ipso facto pernicious but it’s no panacea, either. Until relatively recently Chicago was the “city that works”. But that was back in the early 60s in the Richard J. Daley days (before the 1968 convention) when big cities all over the country were collapsing in decay while Chicago kept ticking right on. Nobody who lives in Chicago can possibly hear the claims that Democratic control of the White House, House of Representatives, and Senate will solve all of our problems without chuckling.

What has changed for Chicago? Too many people with too many hands in a cookie jar with only so many cookies in it.

2 comments

Why Must They Be Geniuses?

There’s something that genuinely puzzles me. Why do so many Democrats seem to demand that their presidents in particular be geniuses? That’s certainly not my view but I have a peculiarly jaundiced opinion of politicians. My dad was very involved politically, his uncle was sheriff of St. Louis, his grandfather was a party bigwig, the chairman of the St. Louis Board of Aldermen was a close family friend, I went to school and Boy Scouts with Symingtons and Schlaflys, etc..

I don’t believe that Barack Obama, Bill Clinton, or, (heavens help us) Hillary Clinton are great minds. I think they’re politically astute but otherwise perfectly commonplace members of the professional class. I.e. IQs one or two standard deviations above normal; smart enough but no geniuses. I’ve known truly brilliant intellects over the years. They ain’t it.

I don’t expect presidents to be super-intelligent but I do expect them to be hard-working and not to have just fallen off the turnip truck. In that I’ve been gravely disappointed in recent years.

10 comments

Deflating the Bubble

“Deflating the bubble” might be a good metaphor for the last four years. Four years ago it was apparent that the bubble economy created by too many houses with too little value and too high a price and the financial assets founded on those houses and the belief that the increase in price would continue forever was beginning to deflate. Now two consecutive administrations, first a Republican administration, then a Democratic one, have devoted themselves to re-inflating that bubble or, at the very least, to slowing and controlling its deflation with the effect that the economy is in the doldrums, flat or slowly cratering.

President Obama has a bubble all of his own and it apparently began to deflate on Wednesday evening. Today Peggy Noonan remarked:

All the books being written about the 2012 race will tell us the background and circumstances of Mr. Obama’s surprising and deeply unimpressive performance. For now what can be said is this is how journalists described it in real time: passive, listless, effete, detached, flaccid, dull-brained, disengaged, professorial. The last is unjust. Professors are often interesting. When Mr. Romney gave him the sweet-faced “You’re a cute little shrimp” look, and he gave it to him all night, Mr. Obama couldn’t even look at him. When Mr. Obama stared down and nodded at his notes it looked, as someone observed in an email, like his impersonation of a bored wife. Everything he said—everything—was something you’d heard too many times. Mr. Romney gave the president some openings. The president didn’t take them. Why? It crossed my mind he was playing possum. But possums wake up at some point.

Mr. Obama’s likability numbers are about to go down. It’s going to be a reverse Sally Field: You don’t like me, you really don’t like me.

Those likeability numbers will go down for a reason more sustained than the debate. It is all but certain that the Obama campaign will now go after Gov. Romney hammer and tongs. The effect of negative campaign advertising is to raise the negatives of both candidates in the hope that your opponent will get dirtier in the mudslinging than you will. It’s a challenger’s tactic, not an incumbent’s.

If, as early indications suggest, the direction of the attack will be to portray Romney as untrustworthy that, too, has its hazards:

The downside of assertively presenting himself as American’s No. 1 truth-teller is that Obama will be called to account more ferociously in the final weeks of the campaign by the media, Republicans and the Romney campaign for anything and everything that is not transparent, accurate or clear in his administration. The specifics of Obama’s own economic plan and what he meant when he said Wednesday that he and Romney agree that Social Security should be “tweaked” are examples. How the administration guarded against and then described the attacks on the U.S. consulate in Libya, which killed the ambassador and three other Americans, are another.

The president must build the case for his re-election himself. He can’t rely on his professional staff or his supporters or the court eunuchs of the major media to do it for him. He also won’t do it by attacking Romney.

The president will double down. It is what he does. The question now is what he will double down with.

Update

More in a similar vein from Paul Roderick Gregory:

This media template of Obama has not been tested by a primary challenge. The White House press corps treats him with the softest of gloves, does not challenge his press representatives, complains little of the lack of press conferences, and ignores inconvenient news items (such as the claim that our Libyan ambassador was killed by a spontaneous mob or the newly surfaced video of Obama singing the praises of Reverend Wright).

Orchids grow wild in Hawaii. Here in Chicago they’ll only flourish under controlled conditions, carefully nurtured.

And the editors of the Wall Street Journal:

The most instructive exchange came early, after Mr. Obama had already denounced Mr. Romney’s “central economic plan” for the third time. He repeated his lines from the stump about Mr. Romney’s $5 trillion tax cut for millionaires and billionaires that “dumps those costs on middle-class Americans” and raises their taxes by $2,000.

Mr. Romney has no such plan. Mr. Obama simply made it up, with an assist from one of his former economists and others at a liberal Washington think tank. Mr. Romney said as much categorically. He then added that Mr. Obama would continue to make the accusation, on the theory that incantation could make it true, “but that is not the case, all right?” and “I will not, under any circumstances, raise taxes on middle-income families.”

Mr. Obama was nonplused, perhaps because he had come to believe what he was saying in the bubble of his campaign rallies and unquestioned by the media. The best reply he could offer was that, “Well, for 18 months he’s been running on this tax plan. And now, five weeks before the election, he’s saying that his big, bold idea is ‘never mind.'” But for 18 months it has been Mr. Obama who has campaigned against a mirage of his own imagining. No wonder he was stumped.

IMO there’s a critical and fatal point in the lives of famous people when they start reading and believing their own press releases. Tertullian wrote that behind every Roman emperor there was a voice that warned him “Remember, you are a man.” Today the voices behind the great are all advising them that they are gods.

20 comments

Tacking Toward the Jacksonians

Walter Russell Mead pinpoints why Mitt Romney’s performance last night was a good one and, simultaneously, why I’m uneasy about a Romney presidency:

This was not just about optics. Romney chose last night as his moment to shift toward this high center ground in American politics. He is not an austerity president or a penny pincher where causes dear to Jacksonian hearts are involved. He wants to be an education president and hopes we hire lots of new teachers, he incorporated his Massachusetts health care plan into his narrative and attacked Dodd-Frank from the left as a sell-out to big banks — and an assault on the right of Americans to get cheap mortgages. He pledged to make sure the share of the tax load paid by the rich would not decrease on his watch and he promised no tax cuts that would increase the deficit. This may not be libertarian, small government orthodoxy, but it is mainstream Jacksonianism. Romney is attempting to brand himself as a red-blooded American rather than as a doctrinaire conservative in the race. He wants to run against Barack Obama like John Wayne versus Barney Fife — or Ronald Reagan versus Jimmy Carter.

It was a shift; his enemies might well call it a flip flop. It was also well timed and well calibrated; the right of his party has been mollified by the Paul Ryan selection and now in the heat of the race, GOP conservatives will stand by their man. The Republicans want to win, and they will applaud Romney’s ingenuity rather than complain about his doctrinal deviations as he embraces the pro-defense, pro-middle class, anti-elite rhetoric of Jacksonian democracy.

Today’s Wilsonians are either neo-conservatives, intent on bringing democracy to benighted countries at the point of a gun, or, if of the left, armed with even greater weapons of mass destruction—educating women and birth control. Today’s Hamiltonians, optimistic realists and mostly business-oriented, undoubtedly consider Mitt Romney one of their own.

What few Jeffersonians there are today have largely been without influence in the national discourse for a generation or more. Jacksonians, ironically and of somewhat different stripes, form the backbone of both political parties. If Mitt Romney is trying to position himself as a Jacksonian, it’s a shrewd move.

12 comments

The Impact of Debates on Presidential Elections

My colleague at OTB, Steven Taylor, considers the impact of the debates in the last six presidential elections:

Now, on the one hand, the number of observations is small (6 elections and 16 debates), so no, we cannot draw ironclad inferences from the figures. On the other hand, as Holbrook notes, “Across all 16 presidential debates the average absolute change in candidate support was just less than 1 percentage point.”

I think there are a couple of problems in comparing last night’s debate with those from 1988 to 2008. First, in only three of those, 1992, 1996 and 2004 [ed. corrected], was an incumbent running for re-election. Second, the president’s re-election campaign appears to be unique in that he’s de-emphasizing his record in favor of emphasizing that he’s a better candidate than his opponent. In that respect it more closely resembles his primary campaign against Hillary Clinton or his successful presidential run against John McCain.

The prevailing wisdom is that re-election campaigns are always referenda on the incumbent. Assuming otherwise is going against the evidence of history. The conventional way of stating this going along the lines of “No president since FDR has been re-elected with an unemployment rate above 8%” or something along those lines.

The president is, in effect, running as a challenger rather than as an incumbent. Will he be allowed to do so? If not, performances in the debates by Mitt Romney that suggest that he’s a viable alternative to Barack Obama may provide a lot more than “less than 1 percentage point”. In an election as close as I suspect that this one will be that could be significant.

5 comments

Sight Unseen

I didn’t watch the debate last night and I haven’t read any commentary on it yet today. So, y’all, what did you think?

Metric: at one point during the debate’s time slot Netflix crashed. I interpret that as either tremendous disinterest in the debate or the debate was boring or both.

Metric: after the Netflix crash I went over and looked at InTrade. Although the sentiment over there still reflected an overwhelming likelihood that the president would be re-elected, the president’s odds had already dropped 5 points while the debate was going on. I take it the president did not have a good night.

Update

The New York Times commentators (mostly grudgingly) say that Mitt Romney won the debate. From Timothy Egan:

Mitt Romney clearly was more aggressive, more chipper, better focused on attacks against the president. Forget about the zingers he rehearsed — a few were launched, though they sounded flat. Romney was loaded with the Mormon equivalent of Red Bull, and it showed.

On cosmetics, on delivery and on zip, Romney won. He may move some people who think he’s a cold, unlikeable plutocrat. He was a warmer, more likeable plutocrat. You can change the man — and Thursday night’s Romney was clearly a polished remodel — but you can’t change the policies.

From Harold Meyerson:

Does all this matter, with so few voters out there who have yet to make up their minds? Hard to say, but Romney is sure to get a bounce in the tone of media coverage, and some major GOP donors who were about to spend their remaining dough on senatorial and congressional candidates might decide to throw more money Romney’s way. For his part, Obama will be under intense pressure to step up his game, be more engaged, come out blazing, in the two remaining debates. He needs to, and his Beltway supporters can’t count solely on the Nats to lift their spirits.

Colby King compares the debate to the first Patterson-Johansson boxing match:

After winning the heavyweight, title at age 21, Patterson dusted off three contenders who never should have joined him in the ring. But when he went up against Johansson, Sweden’s top heavyweight, Patterson met, well not quite his match, but, a fighter who wasn’t the least bit scared of him, and who could, most important of all, hit, and hit hard. Johansson whipped Patterson, knocking the champion down seven times in the third round before the referee stopped the fight.

Patterson regained his title in a rematch, and defeated Johansson in a third contest. But the similarity to tonight’s presidential debate is inescapable: Obama got his butt kicked in Denver by a contender who was well prepared, unafraid, and willing to take it to his opponent regardless of the rules of engagement. Romney put Obama on the canvas tonight.

Can the president clear his head, regain his footing, and find some fortitude within himself for the next contest? He had better do so. Otherwise, he has the title “former” in his future.

Daniel Henninger:

This is a president, dismissive and condescending to any opposition, who went into that debate in Denver and essentially got his head handed to him by better-prepared opponent.

What was especially damaging to Mr. Obama is that when it became clear early in the initial discussion of tax policy that Mitt Romney was going to take his argument to a deeper level, the president’s response was essentially to start cutting and pasting stock lines from speeches he’s been giving for years. After awhile, he looked like a guy who was rummaging through a drawer for old audio cassettes. “The oil industry gets $4 billion a year in corporate welfare.” He even rolled out the corporate jets.

The president sounded like someone who had simply run out of ideas. His challenger was elaborating detail on his policies, and the president was the candidate living in the past. His references to what he would do with a second term were minimal. Instead, he had to spend most of the 90 minutes trying to defend his policies from Mr. Romney’s critique.

The incumbency brings enormous advantages but it has its handicaps as well. You must inevitably defend your record.

James Fallows:

If you had the sound turned off, Romney looked calm and affable through more of the debate than Obama did, and the incumbent president more often looked peeved. Romney’s default expression, whether genuine or forced, was a kind of smile; Obama’s, a kind of scowl. I can understand why Obama would feel exasperated by these claims and arguments. Every president is exasperated by what he considers facile claims about what he knows to be impossibly knotty problems. But he let it show.

That’s an important observation. Academic studies of popular reactions to presidential debates (yes, there are such things) suggest that people don’t consider the factual data being presented so much as the social cues. They listen to the debates as though they had the sound off.

The Romney campaign is predicated on the Obama Administration’s record of the last four years. The Obama campaign is predicated on Barack Obama being a better alternative than Mitt Romney. Based on the commentary on this debate Mitt Romney accomplished what he needed to by it while the president did not.

Andrew Sullivan (in his live-blog of the debate):

Look: you know how much I love the guy, and you know how much of a high information viewer I am, and I can see the logic of some of Obama’s meandering, weak, professorial arguments. But this was a disaster for the president for the key people he needs to reach, and his effete, wonkish lectures may have jolted a lot of independents into giving Romney a second look.

Obama looked tired, even bored; he kept looking down; he had no crisp statements of passion or argument; he wasn’t there. He was entirely defensive, which may have been the strategy. But it was the wrong strategy. At the wrong moment.

Kevin Drum:

Noodling a little more about this, I think my disagreement with the media consensus is more over Romney’s performance than Obama’s. I agree that Obama didn’t bring his A game. But I didn’t think Romney was all that good either. Yes, he attacked, but he did it in a curiously hyperactive way, constantly insisting on getting in one more rebuttal and then using it to go over every single point that Obama had just made. I thought that was both confusing and exhausting. Romney also made frequent references to things that Beltway junkies understand but ordinary viewers probably didn’t.

Like most of those defending the president’s performance in the debate he’s looking at the information rather than the presentation and, as I noted above, that may not be how most people evaluate these debates.

Josh Marshall seems to be hoping that media fact-checking will provide a band-aid for the debate. He asks “Are they coming to have a discussion or coming to make a point?” Neither. They’re coming to leave an impression.

72 comments

Tally at 14½

Today is Tally’s 14½th birthday and the picture above was taken just a few minutes ago in our backyard.

When people ask how long Samoyeds live, there’s a stock answer: 12 to 14 years. Tally has surprised everyone. She has lived longer than her parents, grandparents, or littermates. I believe she has lived longer than any dog bred by her kennel and they’ve been in operation for 50 years.

She remains in good health considering her advanced age. She has aches and pains, none excessive. She loves playing ball in the backyard (she’s waiting for me to pick up and throw her a ball in the picture above). She has increasing difficulty in finding a ball thrown more than four or five feet from her these days. Some combination of vision and processing.

If we’d let her she’d try to run an agility course. Walking her around the block is about the limit of her strength these days although her spirit, vibrant and eager as ever, pushes her and me to do more.

A couple of times a week I need to feed her by hand. She just doesn’t feel like standing that long. It’s a labor of love I do for an old friend.

15 comments

When Did You Stop Beating Your Wife?

In preparation for the first presidential debate this evening we’re beginning to see suggested questions for each of the candidates. USA Today proposes five questions for President Obama and five for Gov. Romney.

The Washington Examiner proposes seven questions for the candidates including this surprisingly tough question for Gov. Romney:

You have said you will not cut defense spending, nor Medicare, nor Social Security benefits for those within 10 years of enrolling. These promises, combined with interest payments on the national debt, would place about 70 percent of the federal budget off limits for cuts by the end of the decade. How can you then promise to balance the budget by 2020, given that you have also promised not to raise taxes?

Presumably, his answer will boil down to “economic growth” which would need to take place at a really unrealistic pace to accomplish the objective.

This evening’s topic is the economy. What single question would you ask each of the candidates?

I think the Examiner’s question to Gov. Romney is pretty darned good. Another good one might be to ask him what he would propose that was different from the things that President Bush proposed.

The question I would ask President Obama would probably be about the long-term unemployed.

22 comments

Lather, Rinse, Repeat

Stu Rothenberg says there are no real prospects for a Democratic wave election with Democrats gaining control of the House:

After looking at all of the individual district polls, those made public as well as dozens that have not been released for public consumption, and talking with both Democratic and Republican insiders whose main interest is understanding exactly what is happening rather than regurgitating the party line, I see little evidence that Democrats are close to gaining the 25 seats they need to win control of the House.

True, some polling is contradictory, and I would not rule out the possibility that there could be a shift in public opinion between now and Nov. 6. But there is no evidence of a wave at the House level.

I continue to believe that the presidential election will be very close. Assume, just for the sake of argument, that the president is re-elected. What happens then?

If the Republicans hold the House, as seems likely, and the Democrats hold the Senate, as also seems likely, I strongly suspect that the passive aggressive stalemate of the last two years will continue. The president has shown little interest or skill in pursuing mutually agreeable compromise with the opposing party. I strongly suspect that he doesn’t believe he should need to.

The Republicans have, if anything, been more hostile to him than he to them. I think that predictions (including those by the president himself) that the House Republicans, chastened by a second defeat in securing the White House, will come to the table ready to give the president more of what he wants are far-fetched to say the least.

Quite to the contrary, I think they’ll be loaded for bear. Each of them will have won his or her own re-election, affirming that what they’ve been doing has been working. Whatever mandate the president has, each House Republican will have a mandate of his or her own.

11 comments

Driving a Car for the First Time

The first time I ever drove a car was fifty years ago on a backwoods road in rural Kentucky. Believe me when I say that fifty years ago a backwoods road in rural Kentucky was isolated, indeed.

The car was our column-shift family car. Do they make column-shift, standard shift cars any more? My dad, who had gotten his first car when he was 14, thought that it was high time for me to learn to drive. He explained the pedals and shifting to me, had me sit in the driver’s seat, and turned the wheel over to me.

I didn’t hit anything or run over anybody.

12 comments