Reading Between the Lines

This news feature:

A small company in the north of England has developed the “air capture” technology to create synthetic petrol using only air and electricity.

Experts tonight hailed the astonishing breakthrough as a potential “game-changer” in the battle against climate change and a saviour for the world’s energy crisis.

The technology, presented to a London engineering conference this week, removes carbon dioxide from the atmosphere.

The “petrol from air” technology involves taking sodium hydroxide and mixing it with carbon dioxide before “electrolysing” the sodium carbonate that it produces to form pure carbon dioxide.

Hydrogen is then produced by electrolysing water vapour captured with a dehumidifier.

The company, Air Fuel Synthesis, then uses the carbon dioxide and hydrogen to produce methanol which in turn is passed through a gasoline fuel reactor, creating petrol.

Company officials say they had produced five litres of petrol in less than three months from a small refinery in Stockton-on-Tees, Teesside.

The fuel that is produced can be used in any regular petrol tank and, if renewable energy is used to provide the electricity it could become “completely carbon neutral”.

caught my eye for a number of reasons. The first, obviously, is that anything that sounds too good to be true probably is. Is this a hoax? Could be. A web site and a press release do not a breakthrough make. I actually think it’s something even simpler—misdirection.

The first question that leapt to my mind when I read the article was “how much does it cost?” It’s possible that free fuel distilled from the air is more expensive than the stuff refined from petroleum. Then there were a few words that caught my attention: electrolysing, dehumidifier, passed, gasoline fuel reactor. Not only do each of those require energy but in all likelihood more energy is used in the production process than can be produced by the fuel that’s the end product.

So, not only is this air capture technology likely to be more expensive than the petroleum-based product it’s replacing, it may not be any more “green” than the product it’s replacing. There’s no way to tell from the article itself. It’s completely dependent on the energy sources that are used.

File this one under “geoengineering”. If electricity gets cheap enough and is produced cleanly enough, air capture and conversion to usable fuel might be a good use for carbon dioxide scrubbed out of the atmosphere. Otherwise, maybe not so much.

18 comments

Why Is the U. S. Impossible to Govern?

Maybe it’s because we make more than 1,000 different kinds of cheese here.

10 comments

It’s Not Housing

Housing start have rebounded to the highest level since the collapse of the housing bubble:

WASHINGTON — New residential construction starts surged 15 percent in September to their highest annual rate in more than four years, as the housing sector continued to show signs of a burgeoning rebound.

The number of new privately owned housing units that began construction was up for the third straight month, and rose in September to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 872,000, the Commerce Department said Wednesday.

The figures surpassed economists’ expectations of about a 770,000 annual rate.

September had the best monthly performance since July 2008, when housing starts were on an annual pace of 923,000. Compared with last September, new housing starts are up 34.8 percent, the Commerce Department said.

Last month’s growth was “surprisingly strong,” said David Crowe, chief economist at the National Association of Home Builders.

However, the unemployment rate then was 5.7%. The reason for our economic doldrums clearly is not housing, at least not in any straightforward way. Look for another explanation.

9 comments

Morituri

Today is the 25th anniversary of “Black Monday”: the largest single day percentage drop in the stock market in history. Art Cashin offers some interesting recollections of the day from a front row seat:

On this day (+1) in 1987 (that’s 25 years ago, if you are burdened with a graduate degree), the NYSE had one of its most dramatic trading days in its 220 year history.

It suffered its largest single day percentage loss (22%) and its largest one day point loss up until that day (508 points). No one who was on the floor that day will ever forget it.

While it was an unforgettable single day, there were months of events that went into its making.

The first two-thirds of 1987 were nothing other than spectacular on Wall Street. From New Year to shortly before Labor Day, the Dow rallied a rather stunning 43%.

Fear seemed to disappear. Junior traders laughed at their cautious elders and told each other to “buy strength” rather than sell it, as each rally leg was soon followed by another.

One thing that also helped banish fear was a new process called “portfolio insurance”. It involved use of the newly expanded S&P futures. Somewhat counterintuitively, it involved selling when prices turned down.

The rally topped out about August 25th with the Dow hitting 2722. Interest rates had begun creeping up amid concerns of early signs of inflation.

As I think I’ve mentioned before I was sitting in a client’s office when the drop began. This particular client had realtime stock reports coming in on a monitor on his desk, a rarity at the time, and we watched the dramatic events unfold as they happened.

1 comment

Foreign Policy Blogging at OTB

I’ve just published a foreign policy-related post at Outside the Beltway:

Why Pick on China?

Mitt Romney’s frequently repeated criticism of China as a currency manipulator is misdirected. Our problem is with currency manipulation and, in particular, the illegal holding of large quantities of U. S. currency and Treasuries as a matter of policy by any country, not just by China. Putting the emphasis on currency manipulation rather than on China would be both more fair and more effective.

9 comments

Whoever Wins, Loses

There’s another point made in the article I cited in the previous post that I thought was worthy of a post all its own:

Here’s a prediction: The political party that controls the White House after January could, four years later, be out of power for a generation. The economic challenges are that daunting.

So, here’s my question: will the winner in November be Roosevelt or Hoover? Like Mr. Smick I think that the likelihood of the latter being the case is pretty strong.

Europe is likely to be worse off in four years than it is now. Same with China. Our recovery without recovery has now lasted 39 months. What will it be like in another 48 months?

And then there’s the legislative “cliff” waiting.

4 comments

Au Revoir, Ma Mondialisation

David Smick makes a pretty darned good argument that whatever the outcome of the November election the winner is likely to preside over a dismantling of the system of globalization that’s dominated the world economy for the last 30 years:

The globalization model of the past 30 years is cracking up. And there appears to be no new model to replace it.

Since April, an ugly economic world has turned uglier. The annual growth rate of total global exports has collapsed. Exports were a crucial engine in powering the U.S. economy out of the worst of the recession in the second half of 2009 and remain important for growth.

Lately, even China and India, which were thought able to decouple from the weakness of the industrialized world, have fallen victim to the seizing up of global trade. The World Trade Organization is slashing its estimates for trade growth. The U.N. Conference on Trade and Development reports that economic growth is weakening worldwide.

Meanwhile, the Doha Trade Round is on life support. The world is at the edge of a currency war with at least 12 countries beyond China manipulating their currencies against the dollar for trade advantage. China is experiencing trade deficits and has slapped tariffs on American-made automobiles in response to U.S. duties on Chinese tires. Leto Research analyst Criton Zoakos argues that rapid Chinese wage inflation and new software-based cost-cutting manufacturing technologies in the United States are helping make the globalization model “obsolete.”

Another casualty: financial liberalization.

Over the period of the last thirty years foreign trade has added about a trillion dollars a year to U. S. GDP (in 2012 dollars) but the income that corresponds with that production hasn’t been distributed evenly within the society. The benefit has accrued overwhelmingly to the highest income earners, to the federal government, and to politicians. It has fostered income inequality.

A collapse of globalization might be uncomfortable and unsettling here but it would be disastrous for Europe and even worse for Brazil, Russia, India, and China. Be prepared for interesting times.

A revitalization of globalization should be a top agenda item for the next four years. We will not benefit by a decline in globalization and increasing world misery presents security threats. Unfortunately, given these two candidates the likelihood of that happening is practically nonexistent.

7 comments

The Second Presidential Candidate Debate

Yesterday afternoon I heard an interesting feature on the radio. In the interview with the Hofstra University individual for selecting the audience for last night’s “town hall” format presidential candidate debate, the individual (I missed his name) persistently referred to them as “uncommitted voters” rather than “undecided voters”. According to him they were preponderantly individuals who had voted for Obama in 2008 but hadn’t made their minds up whether to vote for him again or not. The process that, apparently, was used in the debate was that, first, the participants were selected. Then Candy Crowley and her editors interviewed the participants to determine the questions they might ask. Finally, Candy Crowley and her editors pre-selected the participants and their questions.

That’s a good illustration of why I’ve called the town hall format “contrived”. Make me the moderator and I could produce any outcome I cared to and make it look fair while I was doing it.

BTW, based on the commentary of the debate I’ve read I’ve got a great idea for a new, revised presidential candidate debate schedule that will be more exciting and interesting than anything we’ve seen so far. Three debates. In the first debate the moderator should side with one candidate and advocate for that candidate, in the second the moderator should side with the other candidate and advocate for him or her. In the third debate, Perfect Paul can ask each question and let the two candidates go after each other for 15 minutes per question.

As well as I can determine those who support Obama believe that he won a solid victory last night while anyone who doesn’t particularly support Obama thought it was a draw. Randomly selecting an Obama supporter, let’s go to Jonathan Capeheart:

Obama hit Romney on his economic plans, immigration stance, women’s health and equal pay. They sparred over energy policy. And when it came to Libya, Romney got clobbered. It’s not that there aren’t serious and real questions that must be answered by Obama and his administration. It’s that Romney is a flawed vessel to have that conversation due to his unstatesmanlike press release amid the swirl of events that saw four Americans, including Ambassador Christopher Stevens, murdered.

There were a few other uncomfortable moments for Romney. For instance, he didn’t directly answer a young woman’s question about equal pay for equal work for women. And the question asked of Romney about how he would be different from President George W. Bush was not a shining moment.

But the “amen” moment for Obama’s base came at the very end. In answering a question asking about a misperception of him, Romney answered by saying he cared about “100 percent” of the country. A clear reference to the damaging video that showed an unguarded Romney trashing 47 percent of the country as freeloaders. Obama didn’t let that go when he got the chance to answer the question. After saying he believes that Romney is a good man, the president pounced…

For the other point of view, how about the editors of the Wall Street Journal?

No doubt much of the media attention will focus on the exchange over Benghazi, which we agree was Mr. Romney’s weakest moment. He let the President get away with some scripted high dudgeon over politicizing the attack, without pointing clearly to the State Department testimony that a request for more security was denied.

We should point out, however, that he was more right than wrong about Mr. Obama’s remarks the day after the attacks. Mr. Obama used the words “acts of terror” only at the end of his remarks that day and in passing, and well after he had made an indirect and defensive reference to the anti-Islamic video. Moderator Candy Crowley was wrong to put her thumb on the scales for Mr. Obama in this exchange.

Based on what I’ve heard it seems to me that James Joyner gets it about right: the president stopped the bleeding while Romney continued to hold his own:

In terms of substance, those of us who’ve been paying attention for a while didn’t learn anything new. But we seldom do. Both candidates scrupulously followed Rule 1 of these debates: answer the question you want to answer, regardless of what was actually asked. Obama did it a bit more fluidly than Romney but neither went too far astray.

[…]

Overall, even if the debate is a draw, it’s a minor win for Obama simply because it stops the bleeding from Round 1. I don’t imagine it’ll result in much of a bounce in the polls, though.

9 comments

Pushback

Drs. Reinhart and Rogoff are pushing back against those economists, mostly Romney advisors, who have, contra the findings of Reinhart and Rogoff, claimed that American economic recoveries after a financial crisis are different than those in other countries:

Although no two crises are identical, we have found that there are some recurring features that cut across time and national borders. Common patterns in the nature of the long boom-bust cycles in debt and their relationship to economic activity emerge as a common thread across very diverse institutional settings.

The most recent U.S. crisis appears to fit the more general pattern of a recovery from severe financial crisis that is more protracted than with a normal recession or milder forms of financial distress. There is certainly little evidence to suggest that this time was worse. Indeed, if one compares U.S. output per capita and employment performance with those of other countries that suffered systemic financial crises in 2007-08, the U.S. performance is better than average.

This doesn’t mean that policy is irrelevant, of course. On the contrary, at the depth of the recent financial crisis, there was almost certainly a risk of a second Great Depression. However, although it is clear that the challenges in recovering from financial crises are daunting, an early recognition of the likely depth and duration of the problem would certainly have been helpful, particularly in assessing various responses and their attendant risks. Policy choices also matter going forward.

John B. Taylor has responded:

Also, as Jon Hilsenrath and Ezra Klein report, over the weekend Carmen Reinhart and Ken Rogoff released a short rebuttal to Bordo and Haubrich as well as to several opeds. Reinhart and Rogoff argue in favor of a narrower definition of a financial crisis, and they thus focus on a subset of the eight Bordo-Haubrich recessions with financial crises (for example, they exclude 1913 and 1982). This alone does not change the Bordo-Haubrich results as the figure in my post of last week makes clear. But Reinhart and Rogoff argue that one should look at the downturn as well as the recovery when looking at severity. There is no disagreement that recessions associated with financial crises have tended to be deeper than those without financial crises. The disagreement is over the recoveries. By mixing downturns with recoveries Reinhart and Rogoff get different results from Bordo and Haubrich.

For me the greatest question is where you go from here and I’d like to see a lot more from the Obama Administration on what they’d do with another four years of stewardship.

48 comments

Tonight’s Presidential Candidate Debate

Tonight’s second presidential candidate debate will be in the absurd “town hall” format. Consistent with the last two debates I do not plan to watch it. I do plan to comment on the commentary tomorrow as it emerges. There’s already some pre-commentary appearing and I think I see a common theme emerging: why the heck does Barack Obama want to be re-elected to the presidency?

Ezra Klein puts it pretty succinctly:

At this point, Romney and Obama are running almost perfectly opposite campaigns. Romney can tell you exactly what he wants to do, but barely a word about how he’ll do it. Obama can’t describe what he wants to achieve, but he can tell you everything about how he’ll get it done. It’s a campaign without real policies against a campaign lacking a clear vision.

also this:

Obama campaign officials insist that they have an agenda. They want to create a million new manufacturing jobs, hire 100,000 new math and science teachers, and require the rich to pay a bit more in taxes to protect our most important public investments.

Sorry, but I don’t buy it. The guy who ran in 2008 to change, well, almost everything, isn’t enduring the grind of another presidential campaign to give the manufacturing sector a modest push. Obama hasn’t forgotten his more ambitious goals on climate change or campaign finance reform or the American Jobs Act. He has just stopped mentioning them.

Elect me because I’m me. Or because I’m not the other guy.

Harold Meyerson, on the other hand, frames his column today rather poetically around Rabbi Hillel’s first and third question:

If I am not for myself, who will be for me?

But if I am only for myself, who am I?

If not now, when?

The most important of these in the present circumstances may be the second. Is Barack Obama only for himself? Who is he? Is Mitt Romney only for himself?

Mr. Meyerson goes on to propose his own agenda for a second Obama term:

A vote for Obama should mean more than consolidating the reforms of his first term and fending off the Republicans’ dismantling of the New Deal. In Tuesday night’s debate, why not unveil a plan to reinstate the Glass-Steagall barrier between investment banks and federally insured depositor banks? How about putting a ceiling on the level of assets a bank can have, as Sen. Sherrod Brown (D-Ohio) has proposed? These ideas aren’t just prudential economics; they would also align the president with Main Street against Wall Street.

Such an alignment would work to the president’s advantage not only in itself but also because Romney remains a creature of Wall Street, a man comfortable in homes where he can casually slander half of the American people to the quiet approbation of his donors.

revealing that he has, apparenty, been living in a cave for the last four years. By what measurement is President Obama not “a creature of Wall Street”? Our alternatives are between Mitt Romney, a creature of Wall Street, and Barack Obama, a creature of Wall Street. Rejoice! If we pour enough credit into the banks, I’m sure the economy will recover some day.

I note that housing prices in Long Island, Connecticut, and Arlington, Va are rising nicely.

4 comments