The Limits of BMI

Every time I read an article that cites BMI, like this one in The Economist, on how we’re getting fatter, it always strikes me. My lean body weight is higher than the standard for my height for being overweight. That means that, using BMI as a gauge, with 0% body fat I would still be overweight.

21 comments

The Service

I thought the prayer vigil televised last night was a model for a good ecumenical service. Is there anything that compares with a Jewish cantor for emotion?

I found the fact of President Obama’s remarks more significant than the remarks themselves. I’m glad he went. It was the right thing to do.

The concluding reading, Romans 8:31-39, is a favorite of mine:

31What, then, shall we say in response to this? If God is for us, who can be against us? 32He who did not spare his own Son, but gave him up for us all—how will he not also, along with him, graciously give us all things? 33Who will bring any charge against those whom God has chosen? It is God who justifies. 34Who is he that condemns? Christ Jesus, who died—more than that, who was raised to life—is at the right hand of God and is also interceding for us. 35Who shall separate us from the love of Christ? Shall trouble or hardship or persecution or famine or nakedness or danger or sword? 36As it is written:

“For your sake we face death all day long;

we are considered as sheep to be slaughtered.”

37No, in all these things we are more than conquerors through him who loved us. 38For I am convinced that neither death nor life, neither angels nor demons,m neither the present nor the future, nor any powers, 39neither height nor depth, nor anything else in all creation, will be able to separate us from the love of God that is in Christ Jesus our Lord.

We used that at our wedding.

0 comments

Meaningful Action

I agree with President Obama that “meaningful action” should be taken in the aftermath of the murders in Connecticut to ensure that horrors like that don’t happen again. After considering it as carefully as I could, my tentative conclusion is that the only really meaningful actions must take place in our hearts rather than in the laws.

As Robert Leider points out in the Wall Street Journal, the factors that the mass murders of the last several years have in common are guns and mental illness:

In addition to guns, the common denominator in most of these mass shootings has been mental illness. Seung-Hui Cho (Virginia Tech), Jared Lee Loughner (Tucson, Ariz.), James Eagen Holmes (in the Aurora, Colo. theater), and now Adam Lanza all had significant mental health problems. As the country turns its attention to overhauling its health-care delivery system, we must discuss improving access and delivery of mental health care to those who need it. As part of this conversation, we need to update federal firearm laws as they relate to persons with mental illness—laws that currently are primitive and rooted in stereotypes.

The measures I’ve heard proposed so far would be ineffective in preventing incidents like the ones that have transpired or even in reducing their likelihood. There are already over 200 million guns in the United States. Any reasonably good machine shop can produce a high capacity magazine and banning them would merely produce a lively black market. Just as with alcohol and now drugs, anyone who really wanted them could get their hands on them.

I don’t see how social stigma can be effective in the context of television, movies, and video games that glorify violence. Or with an armed constabulary.

I presently have two firearms in my home. They’re both “long guns” and neither has been fired in living memory. One is a Civil War vintage rifle that probably belonged to my great-great-grandfather and the other is a shotgun my dad received on his 12th birthday. When my wife and I discovered a pair of pistols that had been stuffed into our basement ceiling by a prior owner, we immediately called the police and had them taken away.

87 comments

Six Degrees

As it turns out we’re acquainted with one of the people who’s been interviewed in the coverage of the aftermath of the murders in Connecticut—the gentleman with the “comfort dogs”. We know him through therapy dog work.

As it turns out there’s good science behind the practice. The dogs know who needs them. I suspect they can smell the cortisol and other products of stress. And humans respond to dogs in ways they don’t to other humans. They don’t have to put on a good front for the dogs. The dogs won’t judge them.

5 comments

The Disease of Our Times

There’s an interesting article in the Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law, “The ‘Pseudocommando’ Mass Murderer: Part I, The Psychology of Revenge and Obliteration” that has some relevance to the events of the last several days. Here’s a bit from the abstract:

The pseudocommando is a type of mass murderer who kills in public during the daytime, plans his offense well in advance, and comes prepared with a powerful arsenal of weapons. He has no escape planned and expects to be killed during the incident. Research suggests that the pseudocommando is driven by strong feelings of anger and resentment, flowing from beliefs about being persecuted or grossly mistreated. He views himself as carrying out a highly personal agenda of payback. Some mass murderers take special steps to send a final communication to the public or news media; these communications, to date, have received little detailed analysis.

It’s been said that each age has a characteristic psychological malady. So, in the Middle Ages that malady was hysteria and in the 19th century depression. If we have a psychological malady that characterizes our own age, it may well be narcissism, the disorder that contributes to “pseudocommando” mass murderers.

206 comments

Notice!

Contrary to what you might be hearing in news coverage and commentary people with autism have no known propensity towards planned violence.

0 comments

Mass Murder Isn’t Reasonable

On May 20, 1988, 30 year old Laurie Dann walked into an elementary school in Winnetka, Illinois, an affluent Chicago suburb, shot and killed one student, and wounded several others. She then went into a house across the street and killed herself. One of those wounded died of their wounds. In the aftermath of the attack, school security in Chicago area schools was strenously tightened. School entrances were limited to one, central entrance. Metal detectors were installed. Guards were placed at entrances. Visitors were required to sign in and out. In the years that have followed many of these security measures have been left in place.

When there is a mass murder like the one that took place in Winnetka, like the one that happened at Columbine High School in Colorado, or like this most recent incident in Sandy Hook, Connecticut, normal, feeling people recoil in horror. We try to understand why it happened. We wonder how it might have been prevented.

Some are convinced that gun control will prevent these incidents from happening. The outcry for tightened gun control has already begun in the aftermath of the terrible murders in Sandy Hook.

Violence in motion pictures, television, video games, and maybe even books inures people to violence. Would censorship make murders like these too horrible for their perpetrators to contemplate?

Mental illness frequently plays a part in these horrific incidents. It certainly did in the case of Laurie Dann and I wouldn’t be surprised if the murderer of Sandy Hook was mentally ill. Would aggressive mandatory mental health screening prevent these horrible incidents?

How do we know that gun control or censorship or mental health screening or any of the other measures that we might put into place to prevent future tragedies would be effective? Wouldn’t they stand to reason?

But mass murder isn’t reasonable.

56 comments

Assume…

There was a mad scientist (a mad SOCIAL scientist) who kidnapped three colleagues, an engineer, a physicist, and a mathematician, and locked each of them in separate cells with plenty of canned food and water but no can opener. A month later, returning, the mad scientist went to the engineer’s cell and found it long empty. The engineer had constructed a can opener from pocket trash, used aluminum shavings and dried sugar to make an explosive, and escaped. The physicist had worked out the angle necessary to knock the lids off the tin cans by throwing them against the wall. She was developing a good pitching arm and a new quantum theory. The mathematician had stacked the unopened cans into a surprising solution to the kissing problem; his dessicated corpse was propped calmly against a wall, and this was inscribed on the floor in blood: THEOREM: If I can’t open these cans, I’ll die. PROOF: Assume the opposite…

Consider this graph (pictured above) of manufacturing output for five manufacturing countries that in aggregate comprise a hefty proportion of total world manufacturing. Assume (as seems to be the case these days) that consumer spending for China, Japan, Germany, and Italy are constrained, growth in those economies is export-driven, and all new spending is by the U. S. consumer. Now assume the opposite, i.e. no new spending by the U. S. consumer.

Extra credit question: is it a coincidence that China’s manufacturing output crossed U. S. manufacturing output in 2007?

Update

Not only do I ask the questions, I answer them.

Here are a variety of answers, some contradictory, to the extra credit question:

  1. You can’t tell anything from that graph. The Chinese component is mostly hooey. It certainly isn’t supported by more empirical measures like container traffic, for example.
  2. It’s mostly a coincidence. Note that manufacturing output is being measured in current dollars. The graph actually depicts two things: the yen, the euro and, particularly, the dollar are inflating rapidly while Chinese manufacturing output is increasing.
  3. It’s not a coincidence. The U. S., Japanese, and Eurozone economies are all stalling because of Chinese manufacturing growth without corresponding Chinese consumer spending.
  4. How ’bout dem Bears?

I think that you either believe the graph is mostly hooey or we’re on the cusp of some very significant social changes all over the world but particularly in China. The flywheel is about to come off.

13 comments

Does the Fed Subsidize the Wrong Behaviors?

There’s a fascinating, dense post on the interrelationships among Fed policy, the financial world, and the present economy from Jeffrey Snider at RealClearMarkets. Here’s the conclusion:

The Fed continues to believe, or at least continues to think that enough others believe, QE’s are a net benefit and that volume-type inflation will eventually break through and create a real recovery at some point. I tend to believe that this continuation of rigidity and asymmetric risks are nothing more than the uninterrupted devolution of banking away from actual intermediation. QE’s are no better monetary propositions than those hybrid Bernoulli CDO’s. Money and credit get less and less productive, while accumulated “capital” still embeds more and more artificial risk. Does any of this volume expansion “buy” actual economic progress?

I think this fits in with the common theme I mentioned below. Doing the wrong thing even for the best of reasons and with the most decent of intentions is a pretty bum solution.

0 comments

Houston, We Have a Problem

Maybe it’s just what I read but today I’m seeing a recurring theme. It’s something I tell my clients fairly frequently: if you idiot-proof something, they will build a better idiot. The response to a work process that’s too cocooned it to become lazy and neglectful. You’ve got to walk a narrow line between letting your employees be more creative and industrious and allowing your lowest-level employees to set company policy.

When you bail out companies that have made dumb mistakes or are just too weak to survive, either by direct government subsidy or the soft, indirect subsidy of asset inflation, as complained about here, it doesn’t build stronger companies. It builds weak, dependent, stupid ones. When real white collar criminals, as complained about in this New Republic article, are treated the same as people who didn’t file their paperwork on time, not only will you get more criminal behavior by thugs who use pens (or keyboards) rather than their fists but you’ll foster the view that there are two standards of justice—one for the rich and another for the poor.

When every kid “succeeds” but nobody actually succeeds and you never allow people to hit rock bottom as a consequence of their own fecklessness, a lot more people will aim for it.

I don’t know the solution to all of this better than anyone else does. But I do think there is a problem.

3 comments