Finishing the Pool Game

In anticipation of the end of the world, my wife and I have decided that it might be prudent to eat an extra piece of chocolate this evening.

The title of this post refers to an anecdote about Ignatius Loyola, founder of the Jesuit order. One evening Loyola, while shooting pool, was confronted by an outraged novice who wondered what Loyola would do if he knew that the world would end in ten minutes? Without missing a beat Loyola replied, “Finish the pool game.”

22 comments

Does It Make a Sound?

If anybody were to read Peter Cove’s very interesting op-ed at RealClearPolicy, I would think it would create quite a stir:

But here are cultural reasons we have become so dependent. First, we have witnessed stigma being replaced by selfishness. There was a time when being on welfare was considered shameful. There was a time when out-of-wedlock births were an embarrassment. Once rewards for not working were ignoble. Now single motherhood is considered a right to be supported by government. Not working now calls for disability payouts to support an otherwise largely employable class. The life of responsibility has become the Life of Riley with most expecting government to be its underwriter in perpetuity.

The second is the liberal notion that every social problem must be met with government spending for new programs. And where has that gotten us? A plethora of unworkable poverty and income support programs that have spent $19 trillion since 1965 has resulted in a de minimis reduction in poverty. With that has come a staggering increase in dependency. And it is this dependency, on medical support, Social Security, and welfare programs, that is pushing us over the fiscal cliff.

Don’t just dismiss him. He puts his money where his mouth is: his job is finding work for welfare recipients and other hard to place workers.

My own complaint is slightly different from his. I think that a lot of our health, education, and welfare apparatus is dedicated to doling out money to people in the top 10% or 20% of income earners who, nominally, work on behalf of the poor. When doctors get paid to treat the poor but the poor don’t get any healthier, is that money well spent? If teachers are paid to teach the children of the poor, but those children aren’t learning anything, do the poor really benefit by it?

18 comments

Do We Really Want Less Work or Investment?

Why am I continually disappointed? This time the question asked in Michael Kinsley’s op-ed was “Given that all taxes are disincentives, what kinds of taxes do we want?” I expected an answer to the question but once again my hopes were dashed. He barely scratched the surface of the question let alone answering it.

Here’s the gist of his remarks:

A good tax — one that has minimal effect on behavior — has two qualities. First, it is as low as possible. Second, it is as consistent as possible across the alternatives.

Sure, a tax of 15% — the current, scandalously low ceiling on the tax on both capital gains and interest — would be less distortive than a tax of 35%, which was the theoretical top tax rate under President Clinton.

But the real distortion comes in a tax system that might take 15% and might take 35%, depending on the situation.

[…]

It’s sometimes said that capital gains are “taxed twice.” First they tax your wage income, and then they tax the return on anything you manage to save out of it. In reality, much of the income of the very rich is not taxed on either occasion. Mitt Romney was embarrassed when the world discovered that he had paid taxes of only about 13% on his income in recent years. But that’s on realized income. What percentage of his total lifetime fortune will have been through the tax mill when he dies?

Anyway, what is so terrible about “double taxation”? There are two economic decisions going on: work versus sloth, and saving versus spending. True, you want to encourage work and saving, while discouraging sloth and spending. But just as true: You must tax something. So it makes sense, or so it seems to me, to tax all of these activities equally at the lowest responsible rate. Right now we are violating this principle in every possible way.

At the end of the op-ed he hoists the Jolly Roger:

Like tuning the piano, reforming the tax code is not something you can do just once and then forget about it. You’ve got to do it and then do it again, forever. Even if we blow it this time, we’ll probably get another chance in 2036.

I think he’s mischaracterized the requirements for a good tax code. Beyond the lowest practical rates and being “consistent as possible across the alternatives” I think a good tax code should be time-consistent as well. A good tax code wouldn’t tinker with the rates, how income is calculated, or what’s being taxed every few years. Otherwise all planning will be short term planning. Confucius said “If your plan is a one year plan, plant rice. If your plan is a ten year plan, plant trees. If your plan is a hundred year plan, teach children.” We’re planting rice to the exclusion of all else.

I would state things a bit differently. You will get less of whatever you tax than you otherwise might. The present income tax imposes a tax on income earned through work, on royalties, on rents, and on income earned through investment. The assembly line worker of his example will, in all likelihood, pay tax only on his work and that only via the payroll tax. Statistically speaking, he’ll pay no income tax at all and, consequently, his behavior will not be affected by taxes on income. Until the point at which the thirst for additional revenue reaches him, something inevitable with the spending commitments we’ve made.

In a living environment in which most people buy things imported from China and the rich buy things imported from Europe while millions of our fellow citizens are unemployed, don’t we really want to have less spending on consumer goods rather than less work (by people whose labor is actually taxed) or less investment?

Meanwhile, I’m sure the people in the government of the Chinese Republic, the Weimar government, and the Soviet government all thought they’d have plenty of time to continually tweak, experiment, and refine. The end of a government can come very quickly and it’s frequently the result of economic turmoil. I.e., tweaking, experimenting, and refining.

33 comments

When the Model Doesn’t Fit

For the more mathematically inclined only, there’s an interesting guest post over at Econbrowser. The post, by Laurent Ferrara (EconomiX-CNRS, University Paris West) and and Valérie Mignon (EconomiX-CNRS, University Paris West and CEPII), considers models of unemployment. Here’s their conclusion:

We clearly see that both ECMs are able to reproduce the main movements in employment during and after the recession. However, there is a persistent gap between the observed employment (green line) and the conditional forecasts from both models (red and blue lines), meaning that the employment is currently well below what it should be according to the models. When comparing both ECM models, taking the non-linear business cycle into account through the non-linear ECM (red line) leads to reduction in the gap. But the contribution of the non-linear cycle to the employment is low (the difference between the blue and the red lines is around 1.2 % in 2010) and tends to diminish (the red line tends to the blue line).

This leads us to conclude that there has been indeed an effect of the Great Recession on the long-term employment. Specifically, on average, since the exit of the recession (2009q2), we get that the employment is 2.7 % below its potential level (according to the non-linear ECM), meaning that, from a structural point of view, around 3 millions of jobs have been lost after the recession. This interpretation is in line with the recent literature on this topic, as pointed out for example by Chen, Kannan, Loungani and Trehan (2011) or Stock and Watson (2012) that put forward various explanations.

As an empiricist I would draw a slightly different conclusion: although their models produce results that are vaguely similar to actual observed behavior they predict neither the degree to which employment has declined nor its lacklustre recovery. Said another way, their model is wrong. Or, at best, inadequate.

When the model doesn’t fit the behavior you’re trying to model, it’s time to change the model.

5 comments

Spenders vs. Savers

Arnold Kling has an interesting thought experiment over at his new digs:

Suppose that Lois Lender and Sammy Spender work at identical jobs, earning identical incomes. However, Sammy spends all his earnings, while Lois saves 20 percent of hers. Do you think that Lois should pay more in taxes than Sammy, as happens when we treat interest, dividends, and capital gains as income?

I find a few flaws in the answers he gives but I think it’s an interesting question nonetheless and provides a bit of insight into the national conversation.

61 comments

Climate Change Is Good For You

That’s the message of this op-ed from Matt Ridley in the Wall Street Journal:

Mr. Lewis tells me that the latest observational estimates of the effect of aerosols (such as sulfurous particles from coal smoke) find that they have much less cooling effect than thought when the last IPCC report was written. The rate at which the ocean is absorbing greenhouse-gas-induced warming is also now known to be fairly modest. In other words, the two excuses used to explain away the slow, mild warming we have actually experienced—culminating in a standstill in which global temperatures are no higher than they were 16 years ago—no longer work.

In short: We can now estimate, based on observations, how sensitive the temperature is to carbon dioxide. We do not need to rely heavily on unproven models. Comparing the trend in global temperature over the past 100-150 years with the change in “radiative forcing” (heating or cooling power) from carbon dioxide, aerosols and other sources, minus ocean heat uptake, can now give a good estimate of climate sensitivity.

The conclusion—taking the best observational estimates of the change in decadal-average global temperature between 1871-80 and 2002-11, and of the corresponding changes in forcing and ocean heat uptake—is this: A doubling of CO2 will lead to a warming of 1.6°-1.7°C (2.9°-3.1°F).

This is much lower than the IPCC’s current best estimate, 3°C (5.4°F).

Honestly, that’s still a bit concerning to me but it does suggest to me that the measures needed to prevent even that relatively smaller increase in average global temperatures should be subjected to cost-benefit analysis.

As I’ve said here any number of times, I think we should stop subsidizing the production of greenhouse gases here. Those subsidies are far-reaching, including policies ranging from ethanol subsidies to highway construction to bailing out automobile companies. I also think that we should be thinking in terms of engineering solutions to remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere rather than draconian restrictions on developed countries to prevent them from releasing them.

Note, too, that China’s greenhouse gas production now exceeds ours and is increasing rapidly. The United States and other OECD countries might consider imposing a carbon duty on Chinese products as long as Chinese policies mean that China’s release of greenhouse gases will continue to grow.

8 comments

Another Part of the Forest

I am reassured to see that John Kass’s reaction to the Sandy Hook horror and, moreover, to the responses to it that came so quickly are very similar to my own.

13 comments

Appalling

I am genuinely appalled at the New York Post’s editorial insinuating that Secretary of State Hillary Clinton is feigning injury in order to escape testifying before Congress about the incidents that occurred in Benghazi last month:

Clinton’s story beggars belief: While traveling in Europe, she contracted a stomach virus . . . which made her dehydrated . . . which made her faint at home . . . which caused her to fall and hit her head . . . which gave her a nasty concussion.

So Clinton’s deputies will appear in her stead before the House Foreign Affairs Committee and the Senate Foreign Relations Committee on Thursday to explain the State Department’s failures.

That is not nearly enough.

I do not much care for the woman but I wish her well, am inclined to take her word for it, and give her the benefit of the doubt. The Post needs more than imputed motive.

6 comments

Perseverating

Perseverating on the lacklustre deal that the President and Speaker are inching towards, I see that Nick Gillespie and Veronique de Rugy have pointed out the elephant in the room:

In a paper released this year, economists Carmen M. Reinhart, Vincent R. Reinhart and Kenneth Rogoff said that periods of debt overhang — when accumulated gross debt exceeds 90 percent of a country’s total economic activity for five or more consecutive years — reduce annual economic growth by more than one percentage point for decades.

Over 20 years, the authors write, there can be a “massive cumulative output loss” that reduces gains by 25 percent or more. The U.S. went over the 90 percent threshold after the 2008 financial crisis. At $16.3 trillion, our current gross federal debt represents more than 100 percent of 2012’s total economic activity or gross domestic product.

The challenge therefore is to produce real economic growth in excess of 2% per year without adding to the debt. I remain unconvinced that simply spending the money for additional spending into existence will not produce far worse consequences than slow growth.

When borrowing is counterproductive and just spending is intolerably dangerous, what can you do? My answer, as it has been some time, is to bite the bullet and stop doing things known to be economically inefficient in favor of doing things that at least have a chance of being more efficient. I’ve given examples of that in the past.

We’re not in this fix because of the 2008-2009 recession. We’re in it because spending has exceeded revenues by too large a proportion of GDP over the period of the last forty years and, when a severe recession actually emerged and timely, prudent, counter-cyclical spending might have done some good we a) already had too much debt; b) didn’t produce a timely stimulus; and c) didn’t spend prudently.

10 comments

Dysergy

President Obama and Speaker Boehner are, apparently, approaching an agreement on the “fiscal cliff”:

WASHINGTON — President Obama delivered to Speaker John A. Boehner a new offer on Monday to resolve the pending fiscal crisis, a deal that would raise revenues by $1.2 trillion over the next decade but keep in place the Bush-era tax rates for any household with earnings below $400,000.

The offer is close to a plan proposed by the speaker on Friday, and both sides expressed confidence that they were closing in on a major deficit-reduction plan that could be passed well before January, when more than a half-trillion dollars in automatic tax increases and spending cuts would kick in.

There’s an example I’ve given before of the shortcomings in mechanical compromise, the sort where one side stakes out a position, the other stakes out a position, and they agree on a middle point that makes no sense whatever from either point of view—they agree for the sake of agreeing. Let’s say one group wants to build a bridge across the river while the other group doesn’t. The mechanical compromise is building the bridge halfway across the river. It’s an agreement; it’s in the middle; it’s nuts.

Whether you’re a fiscal hawk concerned about balancing the budget or a folk Keynesian interested in more stimulus spending (or, at the very least, not reducing present spending), the agreement described in the article cited above doesn’t cut it. It’s an agreement; it’s in the middle; it’s nuts.

I don’t understand the obsession with nominal tax rates. Increasing the marginal tax rate won’t necessarily raise more revenue. If you want to raise revenue, we should be increasing the effective tax rates rather than the nominal ones. Increasing the marginal rate on the top 1% of income earners may raise revenue little or not at all.

The present effective tax rate on people in the top 1% of income earners is estimated as 27.5%. The estimated effective tax rate in 1960, the halcyon days of 90% marginal tax rates for the upper crust, was 31.2%.

Another thing to take into account: it doesn’t matter what the marginal rate is. What matters is how you calculate income.

And, of course, if your concern is stimulating the economy, the proposed agreement will, if anything, slow growth farther.

The proposed antonym of synergy, the condition in which the whole is greater than the sum of its parts, is dysergy. The proposed agreement sounds very much like dysergy to me.

It sounds even more like my favorite Soviet era wisecrack. Seen in a sign in a factory: we pretend to work, they pretend to pay us.

10 comments