One-Way Globalization

I think there’s something that Robert Samuelson doesn’t recognize in his lament over the death of globalization in the Washington Post today:

One fateful question for 2013 is this: What happens to globalization? For decades, growing volumes of cross-border trade and money flows have fueled strong economic growth. But something remarkable is happening; trade and international money flows are slowing and, in some cases, declining. David Smick, the perceptive editor of the International Economy magazine, calls the retreat “deglobalization.” What’s unclear is whether this heralds prolonged economic stagnation and rising nationalism or, optimistically, makes the world economy more stable and politically acceptable.

It’s that globalization as we have known it for the last thirty years has been a very lopsided proposition. Countries like China and India have abandoned their official policies of autarky, economic self-sufficiency, with one of partial autarky in which they’re exporting a lot but not importing much. Other than oil and the machinery for their factories, a process which will almost certainly come to an end soon, much to their vendor countries’, i.e. Germany’s, dismay. There’s a simple equation:

Foreign trade + currency manipulation + export subsidies + import barriers = unsustainable condition

Anything that’s unsustainable won’t be sustained and far from being a mark of deglobalization an increase in manufacturing in the United States is merely an indication that what was happening was unsustainable all along. What will China or India do? Return to their previous policies of autarky? Only if they want even more of their people to starve than already are.

The solution to the problems created by the phony baloney globalization we’ve experienced over the last couple of decades isn’t less foreign trade but genuine globalization. China needs to drop its export subsidies and trade barriers and import more. We’ve got to consume less and export more. As long as our main export is financial instruments income inequality here will grow and our real economy will languish.

0 comments

The Healthcare Sector Is Different

I urge you to read the interesting, graphics-rich post at Business Insider on spending, deficits, and growth. Rather than analyzing the post in detail I encourage you to read it in full. Here’s the quick summary:

Pain is entirely the wrong way to think about closing the deficit. If it’s important to make it go away, we need to find a way of doing the exact opposite, putting people to work and making the economy grow.

I think that we can all agree that putting people to work and making the economy grow are by far the best way to reduce the deficit. Here’s where I disagree:

As the economist James Galbraith explained in an interview with Business Insider, there’s an inherent contradiction to these charts in that they assume that medical costs will grow and inflate like crazy, and yet actual GDP growth will remain stable. If medical costs boom as the CBO (and others) expect, it’s likely that GDP and especially nominal GDP will be higher than people expect, meaning the ratios won’t be as dramatic as people expected.

I think that’s completely wrong and, quite to the contrary, I think that healthcare is different from other sectors of the economy. One of the more significant ways in which healthcare is different is that growth in the healthcare sector comes at the expense of growth in other sectors. Its relationship to low GDP growth in the non-healthcare economy and income inequality are causal.

Rather than doing extensive research of my own to prove this I’ll just point to a few key facts. First, employment, a reasonable first order approximation for growth in a sector, has grown monotonically over the period of the last twenty-five years. It has grown independently of the business cycle, in recessions and in recoveries. Second, total employment has been more or less flat over the last fifteen years. Noisy but flat. You can either take the position that employment is not even a first order approximation of growth or that the healthcare sector is growing at the expense of other sectors. I do the latter.

Another observation supporting my claim is that the government is responsible for between 60% and 70% of all healthcare spending. In an environment in which 25% (or more) of that spending is borrowed, that means that healthcare spending is increasing the national debt load. Debt overhang has been demonstrated to result in slower growth than would otherwise be the case.

So, no, I don’t think that a healthcare sector growing rapidly necessarily means an overall economy that’s growing. Quite to the contrary I think that for a healthy, growing economy we need a smaller healthcare sector. Just as we need a smaller financial sector and a smaller education sector.

One more way in which the healthcare sector is different from other sectors. The healthcare sector grows as care increases; economic welfare, i.e. happiness, grows as health increases. Is the national health really increasing that quickly? By what measure? As has been pointed out about healthcare, outputs per input has been decreasing for decades in the sector.

20 comments

Fiscal Cliff—Not So Bad

Maybe it’s just me but I seem to see a rising tide of conventional wisdom suggesting that going over the “fiscal cliff” wouldn’t be so bad after all. Here’s its incarnation from the Wall Street Journal:

We should add that the one part of the cliff not to worry about are the automatic spending cuts (the “sequester”) that will start to hit on January 1. The Keynesians who believe that government spending is the main source of growth are portraying this as a calamity. But when has Washington ever seriously cut spending other than after a war?

The sequester would cut a mere $109.4 billion in 2013, with half from defense and half from domestic (mostly non-entitlement) accounts. It would be smarter to decide which programs to eliminate, rather than cut across-the-board. But the size of these cuts are small in a nearly $4 trillion budget. And to the extent that they signal at least some spending restraint, they would help the economy by reducing the need for future tax increases.

and here’s the version from Politico:

Washington’s Democratic and Republican power brokers have sent the message to the nation that going over the fiscal cliff is a worst-case scenario. But they’re not acting that way, not at all.

Instead, many of them have calculated that it’s better to go over the cliff — at least temporarily — than swallow a raw deal.

As I have said any number of times before, I opposed the “Bush tax cuts” in 2001, I opposed them in 2003, and I opposed them when the Democratic Congress voted to extend them in 2010. I have no particular attachment to them now. I do, however, have some questions that I wish someone would answer:

  • Why is President Obama so committed to a tax increase on the top 1% of income earners that will do next to nothing to solve the country’s fiscal problems? Is it purely symbolic?
  • If you’re going to increase taxes which, presumably, is anti-stimulus and increase spending which, presumably, is stimulus, why not just leave things as they are? Because you’re a better judge of how to spend the money?
  • The economy has been in recovery for two and half years. If you believe in short term counter-cyclical stimulus in opposition to a shortfall in aggregate demand, when does the short term end? Aren’t our problems structural now? Where are the solutions for structural problems rather than a shortfall in aggregate demand?

Update

Here’s another version of the same thing from Jonathan Kohn at The New Republic:

Let’s review what happens on January 1, at least officially, if Congress and President Obama don’t act:

Tax rates on all incomes would return to what they were during the Clinton era, before the Bush tax cuts reduced rates. Automatic spending cuts to a wide variety of agencies, including the Pentagon, would take effect—a punishment Congress imposed upon itself, by failing to find alternative spending cuts that it had vowed, in 2011, to find. Extensions of refundable tax credits for the working poor, families with children, and people paying college tuition would expire, as would an emergency federal program that provides extra unemployment benefits and a temporary reduction in payroll taxes. Medicare would reduce what it pays doctors and income tax filers would have to consider whether they fall into the “alternative minimum tax,” resulting in substantially higher liabilities.

Lots of people would feel the impact personally—their paychecks would shrink, government services would become less available, and so on. In addition, the policies as a whole would reduce the money going into the economy, causing it to slow down and quite possibly fall back into recession. That’s obviously not an outcome anybody wants.

But would all of these things happen right away? Is January 1 truly the make-or-break date that so many politicians and pundits seem to think? That’s a lot less clear.

That’s an interesting view of events. As I read him companies and individuals never make plans based on expectations of what will happen but only act in response to things that have already happened.

20 comments

Site Update

Yesterday I was notified by my web hosting company that my site had been hacked. I performed some cleanup and a long-postponed update to my content management software and plug-ins.

I have now updated to the latest software versions. If anyone experiences any peculiarities in the behavior or display of The Glittering Eye, I would appreciate it if you left reports in the comments to this post. In your reports please include the browser you are using and its version.

The browser I typically use is Opera but I have also done some cursory checkout with Internet Explorer and Firefox. So far I have found no problems and to my admittedly weak eyes the display of the blog under all three browsers is better than it was under the old version. That could be an artifact of my monitor, an Asus PB238Q, with which I am delighted.

I may be tweaking things for a while so I ask for your indulgence.

Update

Some of you may have encountered a problem when attempting to enter comments. I identified a problem when entering comments via Internet Explorer only. No problems entering comments via Firefox or Opera. I have isolated the problem to one plug-in. I’ll keep that plug-in deactivated until I’ve found a permanent solution.

11 comments

We Have a Social Disease

I will put Chaos into fourteen lines
And keep him there; and let him thence escape
If he be lucky; let him twist, and ape
Flood, fire, and demon — his adroit designs
Will strain to nothing in the strict confines
Of this sweet order, where, in pious rape,
I hold his essence and amorphous shape,
Till he with Order mingles and combines.
Past are the hours, the years of our duress,
His arrogance, our awful servitude:
I have him. He is nothing more nor less
Than something simple not yet understood;
I shall not even force him to confess;
Or answer. I will only make him good.

Edna St. Vincent Millary

Like many people, I’ve been reflecting on the horrible murders that took place at Sandy Hook Elementary School not quite two weeks ago. There’s a natural human need to search for order in the chaotic, to winnow morals from events, to devise solutions to problems and the reactions to these murders reflect that need. For many, having formed their opinions long since, the murders are nails, waiting for a hammer they’ve long had at the ready.

I think the reality is discouraging. Considered narrowly, a “pseudocommando” spree killer who expects or even intends to die in an attack on a soft target, clearly the situation in Newtown, probably cannot be stopped.

Considered more broadly, the intentional homicide rate in the United States is appallingly high—according to the United Nations Office of Drugs and Crime the highest among major developed economies at 4.2 per 100,000 population per year. I don’t believe that the solutions that are being proposed are well-suited to the problem but they do provide some insights into the views of those proposing them.

One point-of-view is that the problem is just too many guns. I don’t believe that view stands up to scrutiny for a number of reasons. If it were true, I would think that as the number of guns increases, so would the number of gun homicides. That isn’t the case:

The number of guns in the U.S. surged from 192 million in 1994 to 310 million in 2009. That includes 114 million handguns, 110 million rifles and 86 million shotguns. There are now about as many firearms in the U.S. as people. These stats have been widely reported. What has not been so widely reported is that the number of firearm-related homicides fell from 17,073 in 1993 to 9,903 in 2011 (up slightly from 9,812 in 2010). Per capita, the gun-related murder rate has dropped by more than 50 percent over the past two decades.

Additionally, I would think that, since gun ownership by whites in America is nearly twice that by blacks, that homicides by whites would be higher than by blacks. That isn’t the case, either. Indeed, despite African Americans constituting a far smaller proportion of the population than whites, there are approximately as many black homicide offenders as there are white each year.

The nature of victims, too, differs by race. Whites are more likely to kill their wives, kids, or coworkers. Homicides by blacks are more likely to be drug-related.

The homicide rate with white offenders is about the same in the United States as it is in Switzerland or Germany. If the homicide rate with black offenders were only to fall to the same level as the homicide rate with white offenders, our homicide rate would be about the same as New Zealand, Australia, or Canada.

If white Americans are arming themselves in fear of attack by black American, they are mistaken. Murder is almost exclusively intraracial and property crimes increasingly so. White murder victims are likely to have been killed by other whites; black victims have almost certainly been killed by other blacks.

I am emphatically not saying that I think that our high rates of homicide or gun homicide are intrinsically racial. I am saying that we have a social problem and that social problem is racial.

Whether the reason for high homicide rates is due to poverty or income inequality is controversial:

While cross-sectional regressions exhibited a positive relationship between the Gini coefficient and crime rates, first differencing regressions found negative or insignificant coefficients for this variable. These divergent results suggest either that 10-year time-series changes are different from long-term equilibrium cross-sectional relationships (which seems unlikely), or that coefficient estimates are biased in both regression specifications. Whether the biases offset each other, resulting in a null hypothesis, is not known. Nevertheless, these results suggest that greater attention should be given to identifying the many factors affecting crime before one concludes that income inequality is the culprit.

Translated from the sociologese: income inequality is not the first place to look for high homicide rates. See also here.

My own view is that Pat Moynihan was right many years ago and the disintegration of the black family has had serious implications for society as a whole. The large number of households headed by single women and the difficulty young black men encounter in finding jobs may lead them to seek social support and affirmation from gangs that support themselves through criminal activity (a very high proportion of homicides by young black men are drug-related).

So, I agree with Newark Mayor Cory Booker. Let’s tighten up on guns sales in the secondary market. But, while we’re thinking about how to reduce the number of people be murdered in the United States, let’s be more frank about the actual sources of our problems. We have serious social problems and it’s about time we addressed them.

90 comments

Would You Rather Be Shot or Hanged?

Assuming nominal GDP growth of 2% per year and inflation of about 2% a year, which of the following would be better:

  1. Federal deficit spending of 2% of GDP per year for the foreseeable future
  2. Federal deficit spending of 5% of GDP per year for the foreseeable future
  3. A balanced federal budget, i.e. no deficit spending, until growth picks up
  4. Federal deficit spending in excess of 5% of GDP per until growth picks up
  5. There’s no way to tell
  6. None of the above

The first is the CBO baseline projection, i.e. what would happen if we go over the “fiscal cliff”. The second is the CBO “alternative fiscal projection”, i.e. what would happen if President Obama’s proposals are adopted in full.

Over at Forbes there’s one take on the question.

13 comments

Christmas, 2012

The picture above, taken by one of my nieces, was our Christmas card this year. My industrious and creative wife always makes our Christmas cards.

The picture is, of course, a close-up of Will.

Last night we attended Christmas Eve Mass at Queen of All Saints. The congregational music program was the same as it’s been for 25 years. Before Mass the choir sang Benjamin Britten’s A Ceremony of Carols, a very ambitious piece. It’s a beautiful piece of work. They did an okay job with it. The harp was glorious.

After Mass we returned home for our traditional Christmas Eve dinner—a dish of spinach, white beans, and potatoes, anchovies on the side. While I was shopping for the ingredients the grocery store owner, looking at my cart, asked what I was making. When I told her she looked at me skeptically and asked, “Are you Italian?”. I responded that, no, I was not Italian but I had some old friends who were and I had adopted their Christmas Eve custom as my own many years ago. I always think of them when I make the dish.

We slept in late this morning—all the way to 7:30. After feeding the dogs we gave them their Christmas presents: elk antlers to chew on. Now they’re delightedly busy.

Vince Guaraldi is on the CD player. In a bit we’ll open our presents. My wife is studying up and preparing to make my birthday cake, the Reine de Saba from Julia Child’s Mastering the Art of French Cooking. A few hours from now the daughter of dear old friends, her boyfriend, and her boyfriend’s brother will join us for brunch.

Although I plan on posting again on non-Christmas subjects later in the day, this post will remain at the top. I’ll update it as the day goes on.

Merry Christmas to all!

28 comments

Is Flatulence a Disability?

The Smoking Gun reports a case of a federal employee being reprimanded for flatulence:

DECEMBER 21–A federal employee was formally reprimanded this month for excessive workplace flatulence, a sanction that was delivered to him in a five-page letter that actually included a log of representative dates and times when he was recorded “releasing the awful and unpleasant odor” in his Baltimore office.

In a December 10 letter accusing him of “conduct unbecoming a federal officer,” the Social Security Administration employee was informed that his “uncontrollable flatulence” had created an “intolerable” and “hostile” environment for coworkers, several of whom have lodged complaints with supervisors.

The worker, a 38-year-old Maryland resident, reportedly provided evidence that he suffered from “some medical conditions” that, at times, caused him to be unable to work full days. But a SSA manager noted in the reprimand letter that, “nothing that you have submitted has indicated that you would have uncontrollable flatulence. It is my belief that you can control this condition.”

The article goes on to recout, in odoriferous detail, the catalogue of incidents of flatulence maintained by the employee’s co-workers or management.

My immediate reaction to this report was that the man might have a cause of action under the Americans With Disabilities Act. Was the manager qualified to determine whether it was a controllable behavior? I’ve had employees who were frequently flatulent and have been known to pass gas occasionally myself. I strongly suspect that most of us have. The idea of reprimanding them for it never occurred to me. I just gave them a wide berth. Has Dilbert ever dealt with this subject? It might be a problem that is particularly aggravating in Cubicle World.

I have a vivid recollection of a flight from Chicago to Huntsville, Alabama. My seatmate was a large man, well over 6′ tall and undoubtedly weighing more than 300 lb. He had obviously eaten the breakfast burrito that morning, gave no obvious signs of having bathed since the Kennedy Administration, and entertained me during the flight by showing me his scars and explaining how he got them. Suing the airline never occurred to me. Not the most pleasant experience but it was just one of those things.

10 comments

Weapons, Killers, and Culture

I tend not to read Charles Krauthammer’s columns because they typically make me furious. I think his column today, in which he reviews the reasons that no measures that would be effective in reducing incidents like the Sandy Hook horror will recur are likely to be implemented, is very likely correct.

46 comments

Trending

Sean Trende reviews what the changing populations of the various states could mean for the 2020 reapportionment:

The numbers are now out, and the shifts again confirm what we already mostly knew about population trends: The Northeast and Midwest grew very slowly, the West grew at a modest pace, and the South grew about 3.5 times as fast as the Northeast and Midwest combined. The pace of immigration picked up slightly, but the overall pattern remains the same: relatively slow population growth, accompanying slow economic growth.

The balance of his analysis suggests that California, Colorado, Florida, North Carolina, and Oregon will each pick up one seat, Texas will pick up more (either two or three) while Illinois, Michigan, Minnesota, Ohio, Rhode Island, and West Virginia are each likely to lose one.

My own view of the changes in population tends to make me unpopular. I think that states that receive net federal subsidies tend to grow while states that produce net federal revenues tend to shrink. In other words, I don’t think the changing populations of the states has much to do with the policies internal to the states themselves. There’s a simple way to test this: stop subsidizing the states that are growing. Alas, that will prove politically impossible since the growing states have ever greater political power.

I also suspect that the population story of the next decade will be our internal migrations. That’s very unlike the past thirty years during which immigrations from abroad were more significant. The persistence theory (which Mr. Trende’s analysis presupposes) won’t hold with respect to immigration from Latin America and the Caribbean for demographic reasons as well as economic ones.

2 comments