With President Obama expect to speak about immigration reform in his 2013 State of the Union speech, this might be a good time to revisit the findings of the Jordan Commission on Immigration from back in 1997. Their recommendations still look pretty fair to me and, indeed, a lot better than what I’ve been hearing lately. The quick summary might be more immigrants that are needed, fewer that aren’t needed, and a better job enforcing the law and monitoring the results.
I’ve made my suggestion many times before: I think there should be a central, online clearing house for jobs for which H1-B visas are being sought.
As long as the battle lines are drawn between nativists and proponents of open borders, progress will be very, very difficult. I would prefer that the guiding principle be national interest. Too much to hope for, I guess.
You might want to take a look at the intriguing post from Garrett Jones on the breakdown of the historic relationship between capacity utilization and GDP growth:
It’s not just that the relationship between capacity utilization and growth is noisier than it used to be before the crisis: It’s that growth has consistently been less than you would’ve expected based on how many unused machines got turned back on in 2009 and 2010.
I think this is actually pretty easy to understand. Capacity utilization has a drastically different meaning in a service economy with rapid technological change. After a year or so the old “capacity”, whether human or machine, just isn’t as productive as it used to be.
This will be really terrible news for the “aggregate demand” crowd.
Bruce Krasting has noticed something interesting. In a footnote in a recent CBO report on the economy and the Social Security trust funds there’s this breadcrumb:
CBO projects that the DI trust fund will be exhausted during fiscal year 2016. Under current law, the Commissioner of Social Security may not pay benefits in excess of the available balances in a trust fund, borrow money for a trust fund, or transfer money from one trust fund to another. However, following rules in the Deficit Control Act of 1985 (section 257(b)), CBO’s baseline assumes that the Commissioner will pay DI benefits in full even after the trust fund is exhausted.
Said another way, the Congressional Budget Office is assuming that the Social Security Administration will divert money from the old age benefits fund, what most of us think of as Social Security, to the disability insurance side to prevent the disability side of the ledger from being unable to pay benefits. This, however, will hasten the OASI’s own point of insolvency.
OASI’s trust fund is already being drawn down, earlier than expected, and the CBO’s most recent projection is that it will be exhausted in 2033. That doesn’t take into consideration the amounts that will be tapped in coming years to make up for the shortfall in DI. Think much, much sooner for OASI’s trust fund to be exhausted. My thinking has been within the next five years, certainly within the next ten years.
What I think should happen is that the fiction of the trust funds should be abandoned and full benefits paid from general revenues, paid for by decreases in discretionary spending. Very few people other than Social Security recipients like any part of that prescription. I also think that the Social Security retirement age should be increased and that it should be means-tested in, essentially, the same way it is now. I’m an equal opportunity ox-gorer.
I don’t find either of the other alternatives—increasing the payroll tax or reducing benefits to match revenues—poliically credible. We can kick the can down the road, as Mr. Krasting suggests that we most likely will, but there isn’t a lot of road left.
President Obama’s inaction has cost the region plenty. It has permitted a humanitarian calamity to metastasize — 5,000 refugees a day, according to the United Nations. It has allowed the most radical of the insurgents to come to the fore and has flooded nearby countries with refugees, upsetting carefully calibrated ethnic balances. Jordan, a nation of 6.5 million people, has more than 250,000 Syrian refugees; Lebanon has nearly as many. The size of the influx could overwhelm these small and contrived nations.
Obama, of course, has been asked about his policy. The answer he provided the New Republic recently is troubling: “How do I weigh tens of thousands who’ve been killed in Syria versus the tens of thousands who are currently being killed in the Congo?†The statement is disingenuous, suggesting that the inability to do everything excuses the unwillingness to do anything. It also prompts the question of why he militarily intervened in Libya, the Congo civil war notwithstanding.
Clearly, the president is disappointing liberal interventionsts. Contrariwise, I think the president’s policy with respect to Syria has been about right. I believe it’s far more difficult to distinguish the good guys (if any) in Syria from the bad guys than Mr. Cohen surmises. Do we really want to be arming people who will turn around and use those weapons against us? Syria is not Libya. I’m not even sure we have the ability to produce the sort of “no-fly zone” in Syria that we did in Libya. I seem to recall that the “no-fly zone” we enforced in Iraq didn’t prevent Saddam Hussein from using helicopters against his own people.
I do believe that the president’s decisions with respect to Syria which, as has been widely reported, are completely his own reveal the complete vacuity of the “responsibility to protect”. It’s another theory cast on the dustbin of history.
Gordon Chang notices that all of the Far Eastern powers are actively devaluing their currencies:
“I can’t recall a move in currencies that has been so deliberate and so linear without any apparent real change in fundamentals,†said ANZ’s Richard Yetsenga on CNBC Asia’s “Squawk Box.†“The yen’s move has largely been on the basis of an apparent move in government policy and the market is front-running that.â€
Of course, everyone has noticed Tokyo’s new currency policy. Europe and South Korea in particular have complained, but China by and large has not.
Why complain when you can engineer the value of your currency? Beijing has been manipulating the yuan downward, and Seoul has been fiddling with the won. The South Korean currency is down 2.53% against the dollar since the end of December. At the same time, the Taiwan dollar is off 2.37% against the greenback. From all outward appearances, countries in Asia are now engaged in competitive devaluations.
So far, Beijing has escaped blame for starting the race to the bottom. “Has China Quietly Joined the Currency War?†CNBC asked on Thursday. That is not the right question because it is not possible for China to join the conflict. China, unfortunately, started it, at least a decade ago in fact.
All three of the countries mentioned—China, Japan, and South Korea—hold dollar reserves beyond their needs and in excess of international agreements to which they are parties. We should complain to the WTO over their predatory weak currency policies and, in the absence of action, impose tariffs unilaterally.
Meanwhile, an Asian currency war, a race to the bottom, will nullify either monetary or fiscal remedies for our own ailing economy.
In an era in which many businesses that pay high wages have been shedding jobs, the wide-ranging employment category of professional, scientific and technical services has been a relatively stellar performer, expanding some 15% since 2001. In contrast, employment dropped over 20% in such lucrative fields as manufacturing and information-related businesses (media, telecom providers, software publishing) over the same period, and finance and wholesale trade experienced small declines.
With an average annual wage nearing $90,000, this category — which includes computer consulting and technical services, accounting, engineering and scientific research, as well as legal, management and marketing services — increasingly shapes the ability of regions to generate higher-wage jobs. In order to determine which metropolitan areas are doing best, Mark Schill of Praxis Strategy Group compiled rankings based on both long and short-term growth, as well as the extent and growth of each region’s business service economy compared to the national average.
Notably absent from the top 10 are Chicago and the big metropolitan areas of the Northeast and California that have traditionally dominated high-end business services. The only exception is the third-ranked San Francisco-Oakland-Fremont metropolitan statistical area, which has logged 21% growth in this sector since 2001, while expanding the proportion of such jobs in the local economy to nearly twice the national average. Over the past year alone the region added 22,000 professional and business services jobs, which was more than a quarter of all new positions during that period.
Just a quick temperature check. Would you rather live in San Francisco or Chicago?
Shorter Lawrence Summers: everything that the administration whose policies I helped to create is doing is wrong
First, as the president has recognized, the budget cuts implicit in the sequester scheduled to begin in March should not be reduced but spread over time. The economy is already taking a significant hit from increases in payroll taxes. Sudden across-the-board slashing of military and civilian spending will hurt the economy and seriously damage military readiness.
Second, the president and Congress should fix a firm year-end deadline to address the international aspects of corporate tax reform. We are in the worst of all worlds: U.S. companies have nearly $2 trillion in cash sitting abroad because of tax burdens on bringing it home and the perception that relief may be on the way. Ideally, the international tax system should be reformed in a way that is revenue-neutral but increases the attractiveness of bringing foreign profits home. This would be accomplished by replacing the current high rate of tax levied only on repatriated profits with a much lower tax levied on all global profits. If such reform is not going to happen, this should be clarified so business does not keep planning for an amnesty that will not come.
Third, no American, regardless of his or her ideology, should be satisfied with the way the nation’s housing finance system is working. After a period when cheap mortgages were too available, the pendulum has swung too far; a lack of finance is holding the economy back. The clearest evidence is the growing number of lower- and middle-income families paying rents to the private-equity firms that own their homes at rates far above what a mortgage would cost.
Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, the government-sponsored housing enterprises, have historically provided support to the mortgage market in difficult times. It is high time they be forced to step up and support would-be lenders. Ultimately, government support for owner-occupied housing should be curtailed, but now is not the time.
Fourth, the transformation of the North American energy sector needs to be accelerated. This will have economic and environmental benefits. Those who will decide whether to approve the Keystone XL pipeline, which would run between the tar sands of western Canada and Nebraska, need to recognize that Canadian oil not flowing to the United States will probably flow to Asia, where it will be burned with fewer environmental protections.
I find these prescriptions have an eerie, otherworldly quality to them, as though the last four years had never taken place. Why is there a sequester? The President proposed it. Who wants to increase corporate income taxes? House Democrats. What did the Obama Administration do, during the two years in which Democrats not only held the White House but controlled both houses of Congress or the two years since then, about how the housing finance system works? What did Dr. Summers urge on him in that regard? Not much. What is the main barrier to expansion of the energy sector? The White House.
Don’t get me wrong. You can support the measures that Dr. Summers is urging or oppose them. However, as an old business partner of mine once said “I agree with what you say but I will deny to the death your right to say it.”
As I’ve written before, there are several different reasons to write a post. Posting a hip-shot reaction. Exploring a subject in some depth. Just having a place for handy links is another. This post was written for yet another reason: sometimes there are points of such general applicability it’s nice to be able to return to a specific post for the point.
Here’s the point of this point. Inputs don’t really matter. It’s the outputs that count. When you’re driving between Chicago and Cleveland, how much the car cost or how much gas you used is really just not that important. What’s important is whether you got to Cleveland.
It’s not important how smart the diplomats were or what schools they attended or how hard they worked at negotiating. What’s important is whether they arrived at a worthwhile agreement, whether they accomplished the objective.
It’s not important how smart your economic advisors were or what schools they attended or how wonderful the economic models they used were. What’s important is whether more people got jobs, more wealth was created, more companies were formed and prospered.
Similarly, production costs are only tangentially related to prices. If people won’t buy what you’re selling, it really doesn’t matter how much it cost you to produce it. You either cut your prices or you don’t sell.
When I say that we need to reduce healthcare spending, don’t tell me how much med school costs. That’s only relevant to whether the people who attended med school bet right.
This is the point that underpins what I’ve been saying here about healthcare, about education, about defense, about infrastructure spending, about any number of other subjects.
It’s not the inputs but the outputs. Don’t think that when you add layers of bureaucracy it inherently adds to the value. It’s not the production cost but what people are willing to pay.