How Far We Have Fallen

When I read the first modern State of the Union message and compare it with those of recent memory, it makes me weep.

37 comments

The First Modern State of the Union Address

Franklin Delano Roosevelt
January 3, 1934

Mr. President, Mr. Speaker, Senators and Representatives in Congress:

I COME before you at the opening of the Regular Session of the 73d Congress, not to make requests for special or detailed items of legislation; I come, rather, to counsel with you, who, like myself, have been selected to carry out a mandate of the whole people, in order that without partisanship you and I may cooperate to continue the restoration of our national wellbeing and, equally important, to build on the ruins of the past a new structure designed better to meet the present problems of modern civilization.

Such a structure includes not only the relations of industry and agriculture and finance to each other but also the effect which all of these three have on our individual citizens and on the whole people as a Nation.

Now that we are definitely in the process of recovery, lines have been rightly drawn between those to whom this recovery means a return to old methods—and the number of these people is small—and those for whom recovery means a reform of many old methods, a permanent readjustment of many of our ways of thinking and therefore of many of our social and economic arrangements. . . . .

Civilization cannot go back; civilization must not stand still. We have undertaken new methods. It is our task to perfect, to improve, to alter when necessary, but in all cases to go forward. To consolidate what we are doing, to make our economic and social structure capable of dealing with modern life is the joint task of the legislative, the judicial, and the executive branches of the national Government.

Without regard to party, the overwhelming majority of our people seek a greater opportunity for humanity to prosper and find happiness. They recognize that human welfare has not increased and does not increase through mere materialism and luxury, but that it does progress through integrity, unselfishness, responsibility and justice.

In the past few months, as a result of our action, we have demanded of many citizens that they surrender certain licenses to do as they please, in their business relationships; but we have asked this in exchange for the protection which the State can give against exploitation by their fellow men or by combinations of their fellow men.

I congratulate this Congress upon the courage, the earnestness and the efficiency with which you met the crisis at the Special Session. It was your fine understanding of the national problem that furnished the example which the country has so splendidly followed. I venture to say that the task confronting the First Congress of 1789 was no greater than your own.

I shall not attempt to set forth either the many phases of the crisis which we experienced last March, or the many measures which you and I undertook during the Special Session that we might initiate recovery and reform.

It is sufficient that I should speak in broad terms of the results of our common counsel. The credit of the Government has been fortified by drastic reduction in the cost of its permanent agencies through the Economy Act.

With the twofold purpose of strengthening the whole financial structure and of arriving eventually at a medium of exchange which over the years will have less variable purchasing and debt paying power for our people than that of the past, I have used the authority granted me to purchase all American-produced gold and silver and to buy additional gold in the world markets. Careful investigation and constant study prove that in the matter of foreign exchange rates certain of our sister Nations find themselves so handicapped by internal and other conditions that they feel unable at this time to enter into stabilization discussion based on permanent and world-wide objectives.

The overwhelming majority of the banks, both national and State, which reopened last spring, are in sound condition and have been brought within the protection of Federal insurance. In the case of those banks which were not permitted to reopen, nearly six hundred million dollars of frozen deposits are being restored to the depositors through the assistance of the national Government.

We have made great strides toward the objectives of the National Industrial Recovery Act, for not only have several millions of our unemployed been restored to work, but industry is organizing itself with a greater understanding that reasonable profits can be earned while at the same time protection can be assured to guarantee to labor adequate pay and proper conditions of work. Child labor is abolished. Uniform standards of hours and wages apply today to 95 percent of industrial employment within the field of the National Industrial Recovery Act. We seek the definite end of preventing combinations in furtherance of monopoly and in restraint of trade, while at the same time we seek to prevent ruinous rivalries within industrial groups which in many cases resemble the gang wars of the underworld and in which the real victim in every case is the public itself.

Under the authority of this Congress, we have brought the component parts of each industry together around a common table, just as we have brought problems affecting labor to a common meeting ground. Though the machinery, hurriedly devised, may need readjustment from time to time, nevertheless I think you will agree with me that we have created a permanent feature of our modernized industrial structure and that it will continue under the supervision but not the arbitrary dictation of Government itself.

You recognized last spring that the most serious part of the debt burden affected those who stood in danger of losing their farms and their homes. I am glad to tell you that refinancing in both of these cases is proceeding with good success and in all probability within the financial limits set by the Congress.

But agriculture had suffered from more than its debts. Actual experience with the operation of the Agricultural Adjustment Act leads to my belief that thus far the experiment of seeking a balance between production and consumption is succeeding and has made progress entirely in line with reasonable expectations toward the restoration of farm prices to parity. I continue in my conviction that industrial progress and prosperity can only be attained by bringing the purchasing power of that portion of our population which in one form or another is dependent upon agriculture up to a level which will restore a proper balance between every section of the country and between every form of work.

In this field, through carefully planned flood control, power development and land-use policies in the Tennessee Valley and in other, great watersheds, we are seeking the elimination of waste, the removal of poor lands from agriculture and the encouragement of small local industries, thus furthering this principle of a better balanced national life. We recognize the great ultimate cost of the application of this rounded policy to every part off the Union. Today we are creating heavy obligations to start the work because of the great unemployment needs of the moment. I look forward, however, to the time in the not distant future, when annual appropriations, wholly covered by current revenue, will enable the work to proceed under a national plan. Such a national plan will, in a generation or two, return many times the money spent on it; more important, it will eliminate the use of inefficient tools, conserve and increase natural resources, prevent waste, and enable millions of our people to take better advantage of the opportunities which God has given our country.

I cannot, unfortunately, present to you a picture of complete optimism regarding world affairs.

The delegation representing the United States has worked in close cooperation with the other American Republics assembled at Montevideo to make that conference an outstanding success. We have, I hope, made it clear to our neighbors that we seek with them future avoidance of territorial expansion and of interference by one Nation in the internal affairs of another. Furthermore, all of us are seeking the restoration of commerce in ways which will preclude the building up of large favorable trade balances by any one Nation at the expense of trade debits on the part of other Nations.

In other parts of the world, however, fear of immediate or future aggression and with it the spending of vast sums on armament and the continued building up of defensive trade barriers prevent any great progress in peace or trade agreements. I have made it clear that the United States cannot take part in political arrangements in Europe but that we stand ready to cooperate at any time in practicable measures on a world basis looking to immediate reduction of armaments and the lowering of the barriers against commerce.

I expect to report to you later in regard to debts owed the Government and people of this country by the Governments and peoples of other countries. Several Nations, acknowledging the debt, have paid in small part; other Nations have failed to pay. One Nation—Finland—has paid the installments due this country in full.

Returning to home problems, we have been shocked by many notorious examples of injuries done our citizens by persons or groups who have been living off their neighbors by the use of methods either unethical or criminal.

In the first category—a field which does not involve violations of the letter of our laws—practices have been brought to light which have shocked those who believed that we were in the past generation raising the ethical standards of business. They call for stringent preventive or regulatory measures. I am speaking of those individuals who have evaded the spirit and purpose of our tax laws, of those high officials of banks or corporations who have grown rich at the expense of their stockholders or the public, of those reckless speculators with their own or other people’s money whose operations have injured the values of the farmers’ crops and the savings of the poor.

In the other category, crimes of organized banditry, coldblooded shooting, lynching and kidnapping have threatened our security.

These violations of ethics and these violations of law call on the strong arm of Government for their immediate suppression; they call also on the country for an aroused public opinion.

The adoption of the Twenty-first Amendment should give material aid to the elimination of those new forms of crime which came from the illegal traffic in liquor.

I shall continue to regard it as my duty to use whatever means may be necessary to supplement State, local and private agencies for the relief of suffering caused by unemployment. With respect to this question, I have recognized the dangers inherent in the direct giving of relief and have sought the means to provide not mere relief, but the opportunity for useful and remunerative work. We shall, in the process of recovery, seek to move as rapidly as possible from direct relief to publicly supported work and from that to the rapid restoration of private employment.

It is to the eternal credit of the American people that this tremendous readjustment of our national life is being accomplished peacefully, without serious dislocation, with only a minimum of injustice and with a great, willing spirit of cooperation throughout the country.

Disorder is not an American habit. Self-help and self-control are the essence of the American tradition—not of necessity the form of that tradition, but its spirit. The program itself comes from the American people.

It is an integrated program, national in scope. Viewed in the large, it is designed to save from destruction and to keep for the future the genuinely important values created by modern society. The vicious and wasteful parts of that society we could not save if we wished; they have chosen the way of self-destruction. We would save useful mechanical invention, machine production, industrial efficiency, modern means of communication, broad education. We would save and encourage the slowly growing impulse among consumers to enter the industrial market place equipped with sufficient organization to insist upon fair prices and honest sales.

But the unnecessary expansion of industrial plants, the waste of natural resources, the exploitation of the consumers of natural monopolies, the accumulation of stagnant surpluses, child labor, and the ruthless exploitation of all labor, the encouragement of speculation with other people’s money, these were consumed in the fires that they themselves kindled; we must make sure that as we reconstruct our life there be no soil in which such weeds can grow again.

We have plowed the furrow and planted the good seed; the hard beginning is over. If we would reap the full harvest, we must cultivate the soil where this good seed is sprouting and the plant is reaching up to mature growth.

A final personal word. I know that each of you will appreciate that. I am speaking no mere politeness when I assure you how much I value the fine relationship that we have shared during these months of hard and incessant work. Out of these friendly contacts we are, fortunately, building a strong and permanent tie between the legislative and executive branches of the Government. The letter of the Constitution wisely declared a separation, but the impulse of common purpose declares a union. In this spirit we join once more in serving the American people.

<

2 comments

Likes and Dislikes: the Minimum Wage

Raising the minimum wage is a chestnut, a perennial. It’s a favorite proposal for some politicians, cropping up over and over again across the years. Let’s think about who likes the idea of raising the minimum wage and who dislikes the idea.

Who Likes Raising the Minimum Wage?

  • People who earn the minimum wage.
  • People who think that the demand for labor in businesses employing minimum wage workers is highly inelastic and not in competitive, low margin industries. That means that whatever the minimum wage is, they’ll pay it and be able to pass the costs on to their customers without losing business. Are there any of these?
  • People who have union contracts that specify minimum wage multiple pay rates.
  • Employers that pay above minimum wage but whose competitors pay minimum wage. Like Costco whose CEO President Obama cited as supporting an increase in the minimum wage.
  • People who work off the books. An increase in the minimum wage may increase their wages as well as make it more likely they’ll get a job since hiring someone who’ll work off the books is incentivized by an increase in the minimum wage.
  • Parents of kids who take part-time or full-time summer jobs at minimum wage. Most of these parents are middle income or above.
  • People who feel better about themselves for supporting a higher minimum wage. They care.
  • People who live in states that have their own minimum wage laws, above the federal minimum wage, e.g. Illinois, California, Florida. Unless the federal minimum wage goes over their own minimum wages.*
  • Politicians whose base of support includes any or all of the above.

Who Doesn’t Like Raising the Minimum Wage?

  • People who think that the demand for labor in businesses employing minimum wage workers is highly elastic.
  • Employers that pay minimum wage in industries with low margins and/or are highly competitive. A good example of this might be fast food franchisees. I recognize that fast food is frequently given as an example of a highly profitable business that pays minimum wage. That’s misdirection. McDonald’s is highly profitable but doesn’t really employ a lot of minimum wage workers. Its franchisees do and aren’t nearly as profitable.
  • People who earn more than the minimum wage and whose sense of self-worth is highly invested in earning more than minimum wage. Are there any of these?
  • People who don’t like the idea of a mandated minimum wage*
  • People who think the EITC is a much more efficient way to prop up living standards of low wage earners *
  • Politicians whose base of support includes any or all of the above.

Fair? Unfair? Have I missed anybody? (I’ll update the post accordingly.)

I really think that an analysis like this casts some light on the politics of the minimum wage. I’ve enjoyed this exercise so much I may even repeat it for immigration reform or some other issue.

Update

I’m coming up with all sorts of questions. Are comparisons between countries of the relationship of minimum wage to median wage important? I’m seeing claims along these lines. I’m skeptical. If employment doesn’t go down following an increase in the minimum wage, does that prove that the demand for labor in sectors employing minimum wage workers is relatively inelastic? That strikes me as a bit too simplistic. Doesn’t that assume no other exogenous factors?

Update 2

Extra credit question: why do top-ranking Republicans oppose the president’s proposal to raise the minimum wage? The first in my “don’t like” list? The third to last? Because he proposed it?

Update 3

For fans of an increase in the minimum wage: why not increase the minimum wage to $20/hour? Why not $50? I can’t think of a single reason that increasing the minmum wage to $20/hour wouldn’t be better unless you think that it will cause jobs to be lost. The implication of that is that there is some level of minimum wage above which jobs will be lost to an unacceptable degree. Why isn’t that level $7.25?

*Added as updates after the original post.

19 comments

From the Department of Huh?

The International Olympic Committee has dropped wrestling (one of the original Olympic events) and kept rhythmic gymnastics? And modern pentathlon?

11 comments

Obstructionism

With President Obama’s endorsement of means-testing of Medicare in his State of the Union message:

We’ll reduce taxpayer subsidies to prescription drug companies and ask more from the wealthiest seniors.

and House Speaker John Boehner’s earlier endorsement of it:

“Pete, I love you to death, but I don’t think the taxpayers ought to be paying your Medicare premium,” Boehner said. “And under Paul Ryan’s plan, what it says is, let’s allow the American people to decide which health care plan fits their needs. And if you’re middle-income, lower income, we are going to pay, just like we do today, for the cost of those premiums. But for people of means, there’s no reason why we should subsidize Pete Peterson’s premium. I’m sorry. He ought to pay the full cost of his premium to be in Medicare.”

do you think Senate Democrats will be condemned for obstructionism if they block means-testing of Medicare?

3 comments

All Is Proceeding As Planned

The only thing that’s recovered is the top 1% of income earners:

Emmanuel Saez, the Berkeley economist who (with Thomas Piketty, an economist at the École d’economie de Paris) first mapped the enormous 34-year run-up in income share for America’s top 1 percent, came up last year with a statistic that was widely quoted by people who care about rising income inequality. In 2010, the first year of economic recovery after the 2009-2010 recession, 93 percent of all pre-tax income gains went to the top 1 percent, which in that year meant any household making more than about $358,000. This was, I quipped at the time, a members-only recovery. No 99-percenters need apply.

Saez has now updated this statistic to include 2011. When you look at the economic recovery’s first two years, the top one percent (which by 2011 meant any household making more than about $367,000) captured 121 percent of all pre-tax income gains.

How is it even possible for the one percent to capture more than 100 percent of all income gains since the last recession? Looked at from one point of view, it’s not. It is enough to say that in 2010 and 2011 all of the recovery went to the one percent. If you were in the bottom 99 percent, as by definition nearly all of us are, you didn’t see a dime of that recovery.

And yet we keep voting in the same group of rascals election after election. I think that’s explainable only due to a perception that the only alternative is a different group of rascals.

Is the perception right or wrong?

5 comments

The Alternative State of the Union

I do not generally read John Stossel’s work or find it entertaining. I think he has only one rhetorical device: the strawman argument. This most recent column, an alternative State of the Union message is much the same but it does provide some counterpoint to last night’s proceedings. I mean the State of the Union message, not the Mardi Gras celebration in New Orleans.

1 comment

Well, That’s Cheery

Peter Orszag wants more people to get college degrees so that the incomes of people with college degrees will be reduced:

If the increase had continued at the same rate as before 1985, about half the adult population today would have at least a college degree. More graduates would mean lower inequality, because the wage premium for a college degree would be reduced by the additional supply.

I’m sure the people who’ve rung up large debts getting their degrees will find that encouraging.

8 comments

Multi-Tasking the 2013 State of the Union

I’m going to openly admit that I split my viewing time yesterday evening between watching the second night of the Westminster Kennel Club Dog Show and the 2013 State of the Union message. I watched the judging of the Working Group as the start of the SOTU ran late and after the completion of the Working Group I switched over to watching the SOTU, turning back to the dog show after the president had stopped speaking to watch the judging of the group winners and announcement of the winners.

I correctly called it for the Old English Sheep Dog as Reserve and the Affenpinscher as winner. I just had a feeling. As Chris Matthews might say I just felt this thrill going up my leg.

I felt no comparable thrill in listening to the State of the Union message. I thought it was the same, dreary wish list that recent SOTUs have become. My view of the event is that it should either have much, much more decorum or much, much less. Either it should be a highly formal event, full of pomp and circumstance, with House and Senate members, Democrats and Republicans, members of all caucuses sitting together and applauding politely as the president spoke without either leaping to their feet in uproarious applause or sitting in stony silence (depending on their political party). The president, in turn, should focus on the state of the union rather than the state of the Congress or of the judiciary.

Alternatively, the president, members of Congress, and Supreme Court justices could all throw pies at each other.

The former would be elevating, the latter entertaining.

I certainly don’t think the SOTU should be subtitled “40 Things We’ll Never Hear About Again”, too often what it has been over the last couple of decades.

I found the president’s message riddled with ironies. For example, while decrying tax “loopholes” he called for incentives, presumably a different set of loopholes. How replacing one set of economically inefficient loopholes with a different set of economically inefficient loopholes will spur economic growth is unclear to me and was never really spelled out. I was reminded of Ambrose Bierce’s wisecrack:

CONSERVATIVE, n.
A statesman who is enamored of existing evils, as distinguished from the Liberal, who wishes to replace them with others.

Here’s a radical idea: abolish the corporate income tax. That would be efficient both from the standpoint of eliminating deadweight loss but also by allowing businesses to focus on buying, selling, and making things rather than jiggering the tax code to their advantage. Eliminate the other forms of corporate welfare (like farm subsidies, for example) and we’d be getting somewhere.

I was puzzled at the plea to increase the minimum wage as a solution for unemployment. It would certainly improve the incomes of minimum wage workers who managed to hold on to their jobs but at least at the margins it would increase unemployment. The higher we raise the minimum wage, whether at the federal or state level, the more we incentivize a black market in labor, workers who’ll work off the books, frequently illegal immigrants.

Far too many of the president’s proposals were the failed solutions of the past. Electric cars have already flopped. Not only are we nowhere near the millions of them on the road that the president promised would be the case by now but the companies that produce them are easing their way out. “Cap and trade” is another such failed solution of the past. It’s failed both legislatively and pragmatically. Want to reduce carbon in the atmosphere? Impose a carbon tax. Stop subsidizing sprawl.

Who can possibly be in favor of gun violence? The issue we need to discuss is what measures will actually reduce it as opposed to just showing that we care about it. Who is opposed to “in-shoring”?

As Matt Miller noted, “governance is hard”.

Kudos To Dana Milbank for the best wisecrack about the SOTU, held, propitiously, on the evening of Mardi Gras:

There is, thankfully, less nudity in the House chamber for the president’s annual address, and (slightly) less inebriation [than at the festivities in New Orleans].

I’m actually not so sure about the latter. Did he subject the members of the House and Senate to breathalyzer tests? We might want to amend the constitution in that direction.

23 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

0 comments