Benedict Resigns

Citing physical frailty Pope Benedict has resigned:

ROME (Reuters) – Pope Benedict surprised the world on Monday by saying he no longer had the mental and physical strength to cope with the demands of his ministry, becoming the first pontiff to step down since the Middle Ages and leaving his aides “incredulous”.

The 85-year-old German-born Pope, hailed as a hero by conservative Catholics and viewed with suspicion by liberals, said he had noticed that his strength had deteriorated over recent months.

A Vatican spokesman said the Pope had not resigned because of “difficulties in the papacy” and the decision had been a surprise, indicating that even his closest aides were unaware that he was about to quit. The Pope does not fear schism in the Church after his resignation, the spokesman said.

The text of the announcement is here. This is the meat of it:

I have come to the certainty that my strengths, due to an advanced age, are no longer suited to an adequate exercise of the Petrine ministry. I am well aware that this ministry, due to its essential spiritual nature, must be carried out not only with words and deeds, but no less with prayer and suffering. However, in today’s world, subject to so many rapid changes and shaken by questions of deep relevance for the life of faith, in order to govern the bark of Saint Peter and proclaim the Gospel, both strength of mind and body are necessary, strength which in the last few months, has deteriorated in me to the extent that I have had to recognize my incapacity to adequately fulfill the ministry entrusted to me.

The last pope to resign was Gregory XII in the 15th century, six hundred years ago. Although I’m inclined to take this resignation at face value, it comes at a time that the church is wracked with guilt over the scandal of child sexual abuse by priests and that was concealed by higher-ups that has come to light in the United States and Europe.

I hope that the conclave that is to come is an opportunity for a self-examination of conscience on the part of those in attendance. The article cited above points to the various scandals that have come to light during Benedict’s reign as pope. I believe that the church hierarchy is having difficulty coming to terms with the modern world and the openness of that world. Although I recognize that he is much-beloved by many, both Catholics and non-Catholics, I think that John Paul II, Benedict’s predecessor, did enormous damage to the church. Much of the abuse and the concealing of the abuse took place on his watch. He made Opus Dei into a personal prelature. He slammed the door on the ordination of women. He appointed or promoted extremely conservative bishops, including Joseph Ratzinger whom he named Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith and Dean of the College of Cardinals, setting the stage for Cardinal Ratzinger’s election to the papacy. Pope John Paul II may have seen that as a return to the faith but the effect of it in the United States has been to drive many Catholics out of the church.

7 comments

Book Report

Just finished reading The One and Only Ivan. Very touching. Very poignant. Highly recommended. I especially liked the way that Kay gave Ivan a very distinctive and convincing voice.

One thing I objected to: humans are not feeble hunters. Just ask any dog. We never come back empty-handed. After going out hunting we return home, the great Kibble-Beast slung over one shoulder.

2 comments

Beer Is Healthier Than Water

Something that many of us already know: science has determined that beer is healthier than water. Fish don’t, er, mate in it, for one thing.

5 comments

China vs. Japan

As I read this article questioning whether the People’s Liberation Army is still under control of the Chinese Communist Party, noting the tension between China and Japan over the Senkaku/Diaoyu islands, I began to wonder. What would happen in a military confrontation between China and Japan? I don’t think the outcome is a foregone conclusion by any means. Unless, that is, you believe the Chinese will use nuclear weapons.

It seems to me that Chinese use of nuclear weapons against Japan would be very, very dangerous. They’d be incentivizing a very harsh response from Russia, the United States, or both.

1 comment

Noah Feldman on Targeted Killings and Due Process

You might want to take a look at Noah Feldman’s op-ed at Bloomberg on the Obama Administration’s white paper on targeted killings. If Dr. Feldman’s reading is correct, the administration’s views on the subject have important intrinsic contradictions. Unlike some of the supporters of the administration’s actions who believe that in war all rules are discarded, the administration apparently accepts the requirement for due process. They just won’t say what the requirements of due process are:

Astonishingly, the white paper follows its summary of these decisions with the bald assertion that a citizen outside U.S. territory can be killed if a high-level official determines that he poses an imminent threat, it would be unfeasible to capture him and the laws of war would otherwise permit the killing.

The non sequitur is breathtaking. Awlaki wouldn’t receive notice, the opportunity to be heard or a hearing before a decision maker. In other words, he would receive none of the components of traditional due process — not even one. How the absence of due process could be magically transformed into its satisfaction is never stated or explained. All we get is the assertion that a target’s interest in life must be “balanced against” the government’s interest in protecting other Americans. On this theory, no due process would be due to those accused of murder, because their lives would have to be balanced against the government’s interest in protecting their potential victims.

Feldman goes on to catalogue the Obama Administration’s denial of due process in the case of Anwar al-Awlaki.

Update
More on the same subject and in a similar vein from Small Wars Journal. Hat tip: frequent commenter Andy.

6 comments

The Next Shoe: the Chicago Police

While we’re on the subject of police officers, as I predicted when the CPS teachers received their raises, Chicago’s Fraternal Order of Police is demanding a whopping raise for its members:

City Hall has enough money to give Chicago police officers 12 percent raises over two years and still hire more cops to bolster the size of the force, the head of the city’s Fraternal Order of Police said Thursday in defending the union’s contract proposal.

Union President Michael Shields said it’s simply a matter of Mayor Rahm Emanuel making public safety a priority. In addition to 6 percent yearly raises, the union wants $3,000 yearly “cost of living in Chicago” stipends for police to help defray the expense of the requirement that they live within city limits.

The FOP proposal is an early contract offer in negotiations that could drag on for some time before eventually going to an independent arbitrator for a ruling, as was the case with the last police contract in 2010. Union representatives are distributing the offer to police officers this week.

Asked whether the union proposal is realistic, the mayor said Thursday that he doesn’t want to negotiate in public.

“In whatever conversation I’ve had, or negotiations, I represent the taxpayers and what they can afford. That’s my perspective,” Emanuel said at a news conference to announce that the city will put more money into programs designed to keep at-risk youths out of trouble.

Ald. Patrick O’Connor, who is Emanuel’s City Council floor leader, noted the city’s financial struggles.

“Anybody that’s been observing city government for the last several years knows we do not have a lot of money for the essentials, never mind raises and increases and benefits to a group that basically already has one of the best deals of all the unionized workers in the city of Chicago,” said O’Connor, 40th. “But I can understand where they would want to carve out this territory, because the strategy must be, ask for significantly more than they think they’re going to get, and maybe it will level off at an area that’s acceptable to them.”

As I said back during the negotiations over teachers’ salaries, the issue is not whether they want more or deserve more. The issue is whether they are regulating their desire for more money to the capabilities of the community they serve. I think the answer is “No”.

As I’ve documented here before, Chicago police officers are compensated well by the standards of big city police departments. The typical Chicago cop has W-2 income of around $80,000 plus generous benefits. That’s for a job that requires only a high school education. Some might point to the danger of being a police officer. Statistically, it’s more dangerous not to be a police officer in Chicago than it is to be a police officer.

Something that I think should be a subject in any negotiations with the FOP is police misconduct. My back-of-the-envelope calculations suggest that Chicago will be shelling out $50 million this year alone settling clear cases of police misconduct. The taxpayers of Chicago will be bearing those costs. Why shouldn’t the Chicago police bear some or all of the burden?

6 comments

Puzzle of the Day

What in the world is going on in Southern California? As best as I can tell from the reports on the Christopher Dorner story a guy who was discharged several years ago from the Los Angeles Police Department is being pursued very aggressively by the Los Angeles Police Department. The guy made some very inflammatory statements about the LAPD. Somebody killed somebody else. Could somebody explain it to me? Preferably, separating what’s known from the press releases, slants, and spin. I’d really like to know. Is this guy going around killing people? Is it a police rampage? What?

Update

This is best summary I’ve found so far but even it has room for multiple interpretations.

86 comments

Jesse Jackson, Jr. to Take Plea?

More Chicago news. NBC Chicago is reporting that Jesse Jackson, Jr. has signed a plea deal in a corruption charge:

It’s been nearly three months since Jesse Jackson Jr. resigned from Congress, but now NBC News confirms that Jackson has signed papers in a plea deal within the past several days.

Jackson’s case is being handled by the US Attorney’s office in Washington DC. While no public announcement is expected today, those with knowledge of the investigation believe the loose ends now deal with Jackson’s wife, former Alderman Sandi Jackson, and whether or not she is ultimately charged.

Under the terms of the deal Jackson signed, he pleads guilty and his fate – as to jail time – would be in the hands of a federal judge, not yet assigned.

He would repay the government hundreds of thousands of dollars – for items like the $40,000 Rolex watch, travel expenses for a woman he described as a “social acquaintance” and furniture purchased for his home.

I think it’s terribly, terribly sad. Here was a man who really was on top of the world. His seat in Congress was, essentially, a job for life complete with a platform for national influence. Like so many he couldn’t resist the extra, illegal perks of the job.

I’m not surprised at the corruption but I am a bit surprised at the speed of the plea deal. I would have thought he had the makings of a diminished capacity defense.

Next in line: his wife.

5 comments

Well, Well, Well

Do you remember how I wondered whose brother-in-law was in the camera business when Chicago put in its stoplight cameras? Apparently, I wasn’t that far from the mark:

The chairman of the Australian company behind Chicago’s red-light program resigned this week and trading in the company’s stock was suspended amid an intensifying investigation into allegations of corruption in its Chicago contract.

Redflex Holdings Ltd. announced the extraordinary actions just days after board members were briefed by an outside legal team hired to examine ties between the company’s U.S. subsidiary and the city official who oversaw its contract, a relationship first disclosed in October by the Tribune.

In a brief statement Thursday to the newspaper, the company also revealed for the first time that it is sharing information with law enforcement authorities.

The internal probe found that company executives systematically courted former city transportation official John Bills with thousands of dollars in free trips to the Super Bowl and other sporting events, sources familiar with the investigation told the Tribune. The company also hid the extent of the improper relationship from City Hall after the newspaper’s reporting last year forced Redflex to partially reveal its ties to Bills, sources said.

Now, I realize that practically nothing gets done in Chicago without clout. But the harder the internal sales job the more obvious it is that somebody is getting something for it.

One of the arguments advanced in favor of paying, er, civil servants handsomely is that it reduces the incentives for corruption. I think that notion reflects a fundamental misunderstanding of the nature of avarice. One of reasons that it’s one of the Seven Deadly Sins is that it has no bounds.

Basically, I think we should do the opposite—make them bid for their jobs, as waiters in some top New York restaurants do.

0 comments

Why Not Have the Intelligence Agencies…

you know, gather intelligence? The editors of the Washington Post come down on a side reasonably close to my position, touched on here and here:

Threaded through many of these issues is question of whether the CIA, rather than the military, should be carrying out acts of war. In the immediate aftermath of Sept. 11, 2001, there was some reason to rely on the agency’s paramilitary activities. But with the expansion of the military’s special operations, the justification for such CIA activity, which feeds the secrecy problem, is no longer apparent. Mr. Brennan should be asked why he should not refocus the agency on intelligence collection and leave military operations to the generals.

There’s another question I have about the use of drones. If their use against targeted individuals in Pakistan, Yemen, Somalia, or Mali is necessary for national security, would their use against those same individuals within the borders of the United States be equally necessary? Would the use of armed drones by those who are being targeted by them against our president be legitimate?

I’d actually like to see some quantifiable measurement of national security but anything other than tiger repellent appears to be beyond the state of the art.

12 comments