How High Is Up?

In a recent post at OTB, Steven Taylor, in a post on measuring the size of the federal government, includes a graph illustrating the number of federal civilian employees, remarking:

Now, this is just one metric of the size of government, but it is interesting to note that despite the narrative of uncontrolled growth, on this measure the government can be seen to be either relatively steady (in absolute terms) or actually smaller (in terms of employees as a function of the US population).

The obvious retort to this is that the figures used in the graph are derived from agency 113-A monthly reports. Here’s who that does not include:

The 113-A and 113-G reports must reflect Federal civilian workforce statistics and must not include private sector contractors.

In other words, the effective size of the federal government, as measured in workers, is no lower than the figure reported and might be two, three, or ten times as high when private sector contractors have been included. There’s no way to tell from the information supplied. Furthermore, I’ve tried to determine how many full-time, part-time, and temporary private sector contractors are employed by the federal government. The task is non-trivial and may even be impossible.

Additionally, does counting heads really determine the size of the federal government? If the you measure the size of government by percentage of GDP disbursed by government at all levels, that’s been increasing quite rapidly, particularly in recent years and right now it’s just around 40%. At the state and local level, much of that is spending on education. At the federal level, nearly all of the increase in spending can be explained by military spending and healthcare spending.

Rather than enter into the food fight that predictably erupted in the comments section of Steven’s post, I’ll ask a question. I think it’s obvious that zero percent of spending devoted to the government would not be conducive to optimal general welfare while 100% of spending disbursed by the government wouldn’t, either. If it were, people would have been breaking down doors to get in to the Soviet Union rather than the other way around.

That implies it’s a Goldilocks problem: 100% would be too hot, zero would be too cold, somewhere in the middle (not necessarily a single equilibrium point) is just right. I also think it’s reasonable to speculate that at some points between 0 and 100 spending more would be better while at others spending more would be worse.

Here’s my question: where are we now? Would spending more be productive or counter-productive?

This is actually a pretty complicated subject, touching on things like Ricardian equivalence (essentially, the observation that government spending either comes from taxes or future taxes), whether increasing nominal GDP will boost real GDP, and any number of other thorny subjects.

My view is that the web of government subsidies is now so thick it is impeding economic growth pretty substantially and that increasing the thickness of that web isn’t likely to help much. This is not to say that I think that government is bad—far from it. I think we need to make better choices.

8 comments

The Academy Awards

It was not a Lincoln night.

I thought that Seth MacFarlane was occasionally funny but too often simply crude. He’s a nice-looking kid with a pleasant singing voice.

I thought the high point of the evening was Ben Affleck’s masterful put-down of MacFarlane, clearly unscripted and born of real irritation.

19 comments

Predicting the Oscars

I just noticed that I never managed to cobble together my predictions for 2013. No great loss, really. I will, however, go on record for my predictions for the Academy Awards:

Best Picture: Lincoln
Best Director: Steven Spielberg for Lincoln
Best Actor: Daniel Day-Lewis for Lincoln
Best Actress: Jennifer Lawrence for Silver Linings Playbook
Best Supporting Actor: Tommy Lee Jones for Lincoln
Best Supporting Actress: Anne Hathaway for Les Miserables

Most of these are conventional wisdom with the exception of my Best Picture pick. The smart money seems to be on Argo. Here’s my thinking. There’s a kind of “herd mentality” in the Academy and I’ve noticed that in the past it’s been pretty common for a movie to “have a night”. The awards are inter-related, not isolated from one another. It’s hard for me to see the Best Director, Best Actor, and Best Supporting Actor categories turning out the way I’ve predicted without seeing Lincoln take best picture, too.

If it turns out not to be a Lincoln night, there could be a lot of surprises. I don’t see how Daniel Day-Lewis can miss for Best Actor but there is one reason he might: he’s already won two Academy Awards as Best Actor. No actor has ever won three. To the best of my knowledge only one actress, Katharine Hepburn, has won three Best Actress Academy Awards and, indeed, she won four (if you count Morning Glory).

8 comments

The Father of the Sequester

Bob Woodward has joined the scrum in pointing out that the White House actually proposed the sequester that President Obama is complaining so much about lately. There’s one more tidbit of information in Mr. Woodward’s WP op-ed: apparently, Jack Lew, now on deck to replace Tim Geithner as Treasury Secretary, was one of the original architects of the sequester:

My extensive reporting for my book “The Price of Politics” shows that the automatic spending cuts were initiated by the White House and were the brainchild of Lew and White House congressional relations chief Rob Nabors — probably the foremost experts on budget issues in the senior ranks of the federal government.

Obama personally approved of the plan for Lew and Nabors to propose the sequester to Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.). They did so at 2:30 p.m. July 27, 2011, according to interviews with two senior White House aides who were directly involved.

So, hats off to the White House! They’ve successfully pinned the blame for the sequester on the Republicans when it was the White House’s proposal in the first place. That’s great political maneuvering if you can pull it off and, judging by the recent polls, they have.

I also note that it continues President Obama’s streak: when somebody really screws up royally the right thing to do is make him Secretary of the Treasury.

5 comments

Matt Mattox, 1921-2013

Matt Mattox, veteran Broadway and screen dancer and renowned dancing teacher, has died:

Hollywood considered Matt Mattox one of the best dancers in the country when he was cast to dizzying effect in “Seven Brides for Seven Brothers,” the 1954 Oscar-winning film celebrated for its imaginative and masterful dance moves.

Billed as one of the “frontier Romeos” in the musical set in the American West, the classically trained Mattox memorably vaults over a sawhorse, pirouettes on a plank and poetically wields an ax in striking choreography by Michael Kidd.

“Everyone on the movie set agreed that he was the best dancer of all,” Jacques d’Amboise, who was a leading figure in American ballet when he danced alongside Mattox as one of the film’s rowdy brothers, said this week in a French media report. “He’s up there on Mt. Everest with Fred Astaire and Gene Kelly.”

On Broadway he originated the parts of Harry Beaton in Brigadoon and Jester in Once Upon a Mattress. To most people he’s probably best known for portraying Caleb, one of the backwoods Pontipee brothers, in the Hollywood musical Seven Brides for Seven Brothers, considered by many (including me) to be the best movie musical of all time.

His real lasting contribution may be as a teacher:

Mattox, 91, who developed an influential method of teaching jazz dance, died Monday in France, his family announced. He had lived in southern France since 1980.

“He was superhuman. This guy could do anything,” said Bob Boross, a dance professor at Radford University in Virginia who studied with Mattox at a rare U.S. workshop he gave at UCLA in 1986 and later wrote his graduate thesis on him.

He called his method “freestyle dance”.

Note Mr. Mattox’s great longevity. There’s a lesson to be learned here. Of the “seven brothers” he is the first of those those who were actually dancers to die. Howard Keel and Jeff Richards, both non-dancers, died at considerably earlier ages. The remainder are all alive. It’s understandable that Russ Tamblyn and Jacques D’Amboise are still kicking. They were in their early twenties when Brides was made. But Tommy Rall is still alive, too, at 84 and Marc Platt, the oldest of the principle dancers, turns 100 this year. He danced “Dream Curly” in the original Broadway production of Oklahoma back in the 40s. Great physical activity in youth and a life of high physical activity continuing into old age clearly contributes to a long and healthy life.

2 comments

Emanuel and the Peter Principle

Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel’s approval rating, never much more than barely enough to get him elected, has descended to dangerous levels:

In Chicago itself, voting-age adults aren’t nearly as negative as other Illinois residents. But as he nears the middle of his four-year term, Mr. Emanuel’s standing has slipped, though most of his loss of support has gone into the “mixed feelings” or undecided category, rather than to disapproval.

Specifically, just 2 percent of Chicagoans surveyed said they strongly approve of the mayor’s job performance, with 12 percent somewhat approving and 5 percent leaning that way. At the opposite end, 13 percent strongly disapprove, 9 percent somewhat disapprove and 13 percent lean toward disapproval.

In Chicago, that gives Mr. Emanuel a net minus 16 rating, down from the plus 4 he had in September, when 37 percent approved and 33 percent disapproved.

In Illinois outside Chicago his approval rating is even lower.

Not long ago I had a back-and-forth with a numbskulled commenter at OTB who, in response to a wisecracking comment from me critical of Mayor Emanuel, angrily retorted that “we” in Chicago like him just fine. Now we have a quantitative result to consider. Just 2% of Chicagoans “like him just fine”. My views, on the other hand, are well within the mainstream of Chicago opinion.

More on this subject at the NBC Chicago political blog.

In Chicago being able to raise enormous amounts of money, mostly from non-Chicagoans, having friends in high places, being energetic, and hating Republicans isn’t enough to make an effective mayor. I don’t think that Mr. Emanuel has much else going for him.

12 comments

Reasons and Pretexts

You might want to check out Robert Kaplan’s interesting essay on Thucydides, Hobbes, and the distinction between the pretexts for war and its reasons especially as it applies to the tense situation in the Far East.

It also presents me with an opportunity for returning to a subject I’ve commented on before here. There is no single, authoritative manuscript for Thucydides’s The Peloponnesian War and, importantly, no contemporaneous one. What we have has been pieced together from fragments, most of low quality in completeness, accuracy, and integrity over the period of more than a millennium by a variety of unknown editors. We have very little idea of what the original work was actually like.

It is wrong to think of The Peloponnesian War as history. It’s a group essay.

10 comments

How to Turn an Oil Tanker

I’m afraid the Denver Post’s editorial on Chinese hacking is an exercise in wishful thinking:

The Obama administration responded to the report with a strategy white paper outlining approaches to the problem. It includes putting offending countries on “watch lists” and urging other countries to join in pressuring bad actors to stop their hacking activities. It also, as one critic quoted in The Washington Post noted, refers to strategies already in play. It includes the word “continue” more than 20 times.

The question, then, is what more can be done to combat such activity. We hope the administration is privately pressuring China to cease and desist. But there are other ways, including denial of visas to officials from companies that benefit from the theft, or students and researchers from universities connected to hacking activities. There also is room for more aggressive prosecution of cyber-espionage cases against perpetrators, regardless of who they may be.

I’m afraid the Post’s editors are wrong. It’s not a “delicate matter”. If changing U. S. policy is like turning a battleship, changing Chinese policy is like turning an oil tanker. It can be done but it won’t be fast and subtlety or half-measures won’t be effective.

I’ve already proposed a few measures which may seem drastic but are really quite tame. Here are some more.

Public humiliation. Don’t engage in private diplomacy. Bring it out in public. Condemn the Chinese government’s abuse of civil rights loudly and harshly. Complain about low quality and outright fraudulent products. Seat their diplomats by the kitchen on chairs that are too small and have one leg shorter than another and say why you’re doing it.

Pay bounties to hackers who bring down Chinese networks and can prove they did.

Impose penalties on U. S. companies that collaborate with the Chinese authorities in oppressing and controlling the Chinese people.

Gentle, subtle, polite chiding will get nowhere.

2 comments

The Politics of Feeling Good

Rather than doing good. I think that Robert Tracinski’s characterization of subsidies for electric cars as “green paternalism”:

Electric cars never really made any sense. They are cloaked in the sanctimony of the green movement, because they don’t use nasty fossil fuels like gasoline. Instead, they use electricity, which is sent out through power lines from big power plants, which generate this electricity—how? Oh yes, by burning fossil fuels like oil, coal, and natural gas. This is known as the “long tailpipe,” which goes from the car charging up in your garage all the way back to the smokestack of a coal-fired power plant. And don’t forget, electric cars also have giant batteries made from nasty toxic metals like lithium and cobalt, the manufacture of which frontloads carbon dioxide emissions.

So the electric car was always more an exercise in green paternalism—it is the future, as selected for us by our betters—than a serious attempt to solve any real or imagined problem.

isn’t quite correct. Electric cars are perfect for people who want to feel virtuous without actually being virtuous.

An alarming number of the agenda items on the table today fit into that category. Bans on assault weapons (especially bans that “grandfather in” weapons already purchased) will have very little effect on mass murders. Raising marginal tax rates (as opposed to effective tax rates) on the highest income earners won’t raise a lot of additional revenue. Continuing the Head Start program (which I supported for years) won’t give underprivileged children the “head start” it promises because its benefits fade very rapidly. “Cap and trade” or even a gasoline tax won’t do much about global warming. The list is practically endless—feel free to contribute your own examples.

The purpose of these laws is symbolic rather than practical. They’re primarily intended to allow their supporters to signal how virtuous they are without taking the much more difficult steps that would reduce the number of mass murders, increase tax revenues, improve the educational prospects of kids from poor families, or stave off global warming. They’re the equivalent of Ted Turner’s driving his Prius to the tarmac where his personal jet is waiting.

12 comments

Annals of Incorporation

Paul Castiglione, policy director of the Cook County State’s Attorney’s Office, caused some stir when he observed that the federal circuit court of appeals ruling against Illinois’s ban on concealed carry of firearms was not binding on the state legislature:

There was one surprise to come from Tuesday’s hearing for some lawmakers. It came when Paul Castiglione, with the Cook County State’s Attorney’s office, said his office believes the federal appeals court doesn’t have jurisdiction over the state legislature.

“Only the Illinois Supreme Court can declare a law, a statute from this body of this state to be unconstitutional,” Castiglione said at the hearing.

That was news to State Rep. Michael Zalewski.

“You kind of dropped a pretty big rhetorical bomb on some of us here,” Zalewski said.

If my understanding of the law is correct, Mr. Castiglione is correct on the general principle although probably incorrect in his articulation of it. Rulings of the U. S. Supreme Court are mandatory for all inferior courts, including state courts under the principle known as “incorporation”. Decisions from lower federal courts, including federal appeals courts, however, are not binding on state courts. The issue here is the hierarchy. Federal courts and state courts function within different hierarchies. Federal appeals court decisions are binding on other federal courts within their circuits. They are not binding on state courts.

I am not fanatical with respect to the Second Amendment. I’d be just as happy if it were replaced with a narrower statute. However, it is the law of the land and IMO Chicago, Cook County, and Illinois legislators and state’s attorneys offices have been incompetent in this matter. That doesn’t mean that Mr. Castiglione is wrong; it means that Illinois’s laws are likely to be declared unconstitutional if and when they make it to the U. S. Supreme Court and it would be better if all of the expense involved were spared by re-writing Illinois’s laws to meet constitutional muster.

3 comments