The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The Watcher’s Council post is here.

0 comments

Jesse and the Deadly Embrace

The Chicago Tribune in commenting on the conviction of Jesse Jackson, Jr. and his wife on corruption charges notes the intimate relationship between the creation of “safe seats” by creating favorable district boundaries and official corruption:

To the humiliation that Jesse Jackson Jr. and his wife, Sandi, imposed on Illinois, you can add a political indictment: This state’s egregious gerrymandering aided and abetted the Jacksons’ long crime spree. If Jackson had been running for office in a competitive district — rather than in one of the nation’s most overwhelmingly Democratic — the couple arguably would have had to spend campaign funds on needs more urgent than Build-a-Bear toy animals, what the feds delicately call Costco “undergarments” and the goofy mounted elk heads.

Instead, Jackson throughout his career has been one among hundreds of congressional candidates of both major parties, running for seats in both houses, who raise bushels of campaign money that they don’t need.

They go on to enumerate ways in which the situation is corrupt. It may bear mentioning that the Democrats’ point man in the House on immigration reform represents what is possibly the most gerrymandered district in the country, as I have previously mentioned.

Better late than never, I guess. The Trib endorsed Jackson in 2008, only “withholding” their endorsement after news of Jackson’s corruption was brought to light—not by them. It used to be that newspapers tried to discover and report the truth. Whatever happened to that?

6 comments

You’ve Been Penetrated

Speaking of distressing articles, this one at the Washington Post, a continuation of the story on state-sponsored Chinese hacking, is extremely disturbing. The one sentence summary is that everything in Washington that’s worth hacking has already been compromised:

“The dark secret is there is no such thing as a secure unclassified network,” said James A. Lewis, a cybersecurity expert at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, which has been hacked in the past. “Law firms, think tanks, newspapers — if there’s something of interest, you should assume you’ve been penetrated.”

The rising wave of cyber-espionage has produced diplomatic backlash and talk of action against the Chinese, who have steadfastly denied involvement in hacking campaigns. A strategy paper released by the Obama administration Wednesday outlined new efforts to fight the theft of trade secrets.

Cyberspying against what could be called the “information industry” differs from hacks against traditional economic targets such as Lockheed Martin, Coca-Cola and Apple, whose computer systems contain valuable intellectual property that could assist Chinese industrial or military capabilities.

Instead, journalists, lawyers and human rights workers often have access to political actors whose communications could offer insight to Chinese intelligence services eager to understand how Washington works. Hackers often are searching for the unseen forces that might explain how the administration approaches an issue, experts say, with many Chinese officials presuming that reports by think tanks or news organizations are secretly the work of government officials — much as they would be in Beijing.

If you don’t like my “Chinese takeaway” suggestion for retaliation, here’s another one. Cut China off from the Internet. It can be done. There are only a handful of Tier 1 providers. It would take some effort and some vigilance but it can be done. And probably a lot more cheaply than hardening networks enough to withstand systematic, industrial-scale attacks of the sort that are underway. And the other countries we’d need cooperation from have been victims of state-sponsored Chinese hacking, too.

4 comments

More “It’s the Prices, Stupid”

If you have the stomach for it you can read Steve Brill’s lengthy and distressing article at Time on why we pay such high prices for healthcare here in the United States. If you don’t, I’ll summarize it in one sentence for you. We pay more for healthcare than anybody else in the world due to overcharging, too much treatment (AKA “churning”), and inefficient care.

Attributing our high costs to the cost of technology is laughable. Such high technology costs are not reflected in the balance sheets of hospitals and other healthcare providers. Further, other countries where technology is used even more extensively than it is here do not pay nearly as much as we do. The high prices go to wages.

18 comments

Just the Facts, Ma’am

It is a fact that President Obama originally proposed the sequester. It is a fact that Congressional Republicans voted in favor of it.

Why don’t they stop the posturing, finger-pointing, and counting coup and, if they don’t like the sequester, change it?

The question is practically self-answering. Because posturing, finger-pointing, and counting coup were always the point of the sequester.

Meanwhile, can someone explain to me how increasing taxes by $160 billion a year does no economic harm while cutting spending by $85 billion per year will precipitate a recession?

19 comments

The Simple Alternative

Characteristically, now that Chinese hackers have demonstrated their willingness and ability to threaten Western intellectual property, the Wall Street Journal has pricked up its ears:

We hope China’s behavior proves self-defeating. Economic transactions are about mutual benefit, and nobody should continue doing business with a counterparty who continually rips them off. The signs are that the U.S. government may finally be getting up the nerve to respond with more than quiet, feckless pleading.

Better defenses are imperative. Naming and shaming the Chinese entities responsible, as Mandiant has done, are also important, and targeted sanctions against individuals and institutions will probably be needed. Chinese officials need to understand that if they want their current economic relationship with the U.S. to continue, they must stop their cyberattacks.

I honestly have never understood the idea of equating “intellectual property” with tangible property. However, if you take that idea seriously isn’t the effective response to the Chinese government’s either allowing or actively aiding its citizens in stealing property that belongs to Americans and there is no other means of enforcing those property rights, letting Americans steal Chinese property? One day a week could be “Steal Chinese” day. It would give an entirely different meaning to “Chinese takeaway”.

Update

To illustrate why I think that the mild, temperate remedies suggested by the WSJ are meaningless nonsense, let me ask one straightforward question: why is Apple still doing business with Chinese companies?

7 comments

International Rules Governing Cyberwarfare?

The Christian Science Monitor has an editorial urging the adoption of international rules to govern cyberwarfare:

Global rules now restrict the use of nuclear, chemical, and biological weapons. They also help safeguard civilians and prisoners of war. What the Mandiant report shows is that the world may be losing the struggle to come up with rules for cyberspace behavior.

The scale of the Chinese cyberthreat is now so massive that it might lead to a rush to imitate rather than a campaign to prevent a cyber blow-for-blow. One of the unusual aspects of cyberweapons is that once they are used, they can be easily replicated for a return attack.

Coming up with such rules will not be easy. For starters, simply defining what is a cyberweapon or a cyberattack could be a problem. Even if that issue is settled, how can an attack’s originator be correctly identified? And given the speed of digital technology, the distinction between defensive and offensive capabilities can be easily blurred.

The CSM’s editors err. They are thinking of the Internet, in particular, in the wrong way. It is not an old-fashioned European city, relatively orderly and law-abiding. It is not even Chicago. It is the Wild West. The solutions required are Wild West solutions.

Rather than laws that might be effective in making Berlin or Brussels more peaceful and orderly we need the digital equivalent of “Wanted Dead or Alive” posters, bounty hunters, and circuit-riding marshalls who mete out justice at the point of a six-shooter.

One thing we can do is to stop government funding of the creation of malware in the United States to whatever extent we’re funding it. Putting the vast resources of the state behind creating bigger, more effective, and more destructive computer malware is suicidal for us. Nuclear weapons are a poor analogy for cyberweaponry. A better analogy would be A-bombs left sitting on a street corner along with instructions for building them and a stack of refined uranium.

10 comments

The Incidence of the Corporate Income Tax

Bruce Bartlett has an interesting post on the incidence of the corporate income tax over at the NYT Economix blog. Among the candidates he considers are consumers, shareholders, and workers. Here’s his conclusion:

Finally, four Treasury Department economists detail the method the Treasury uses to allocate the corporate tax in distribution tables. They have the advantage of access to actual corporate tax returns and far greater detail on corporate finances than available to private researchers.

The Treasury economists conclude that 82 percent of the corporate tax falls on capital and 18 percent on labor. This is very close to the methodology of the private Tax Policy Center, whose analyses are frequently cited in policy debates. It assumes that 80 percent of the corporate tax is borne by capital and 20 percent by labor.

One thing not mentioned by Mr. Bartlett is that not all C corporations are on an equal footing with respect to their tax bills. Just as the effective tax rate of the top .1% of earners is significantly lower than the nominal rate, e.g. Warren Buffett’s effective tax rate is 11.6% compared with the nominal topmost personal income tax rate of 39.6%, the very largest corporations pay a lot less of their income than smaller ones do. General Electric, for example, has a tax department of 1,000 people and lobbies aggressively. Consequently, it has an effective global tax rate of 9% and, by some accounts, a U. S. effective tax rate of 0. Those aren’t alternatives open to smaller companies, whose tax department consists of the president of the company and whose lobbying efforts consist of occasional calls to its Congressman and, possibly, a small political donation or two. In other words GE’s smaller competitors probably pay taxes while GE does not. The tax code is, therefore, a competitive advantage to GE.

Taxing capital and labor does not encourage new job formation. If anything, it discourages it. Taking the corporate income tax as an article of faith requires:

  • Animus against shareholders and workers.
  • Indifference to shareholders and workers in the light of all of the grand things the federal government will do with the money.< ?li>
  • Animus against small companies.
  • Animus against new companies (more likely to produce new jobs).
  • Indifference to small or new companies in the light, etc.
  • Fondness for the largest companies. The largest companies have been shedding jobs at a furious rate for the last several decades.
  • Ignorance
  • Some combination of the above.

One thing I think was can say with some confidence is that wanting to increase the corporate income tax on the one hand while wanting to create more jobs on the other is cognitive dissonance at the very least.

More efficient would be abolishing the corporate income tax and adding a new, higher multi-millionaire bracket for individuals with incomes of more than $10 million per year. More efficient yet would be abolishing both the corporate and individual income tax and imposing a consumption tax.

16 comments

Hypothetical of the Day: Chinese Hacking

Let’s consider a hypothetical question. Let’s say, just for the sake of argument, that the Chinese military is actually behind the security breaches that have affected U. S. sites from the New York Times, Washington Post, and Wall Street Journal to military contractors. What should our response be?

Update

Apparently, the same group of hackers has hacked Apple:

Apple acknowledged Tuesday that hackers had infiltrated a small number of the company’s computers.

No user information was compromised in the attack, according to the tech giant, which said it had fallen victim to the same hackers that targeted Facebook last month.

The malware found its way onto Mac computers through a vulnerability in an Internet browser plug-in developed for Oracle’s Java program. Apple said it will release a software patch Tuesday to prevent the problem from spreading.

“The malware was employed in an attack against Apple and other companies, and was spread through a website for software developers,” according to company statement given to The Washington Post. “We identified a small number of systems within Apple that were infected and isolated them from our network. There is no evidence that any data left Apple. We are working closely with law enforcement to find the source of the malware.”

The company did not specify how many computers had been impacted, when the attack had occurred or what kind of information the hackers were seeking.

Apple has not shipped computers with Java installed since the introduction of OS X Lion (version 10.6), and the company’s computers automatically disable Java in browsers if it has not been used in more than 35 days.

The hackers who attacked Apple have been linked to the same Chinese-based group that infiltrated Facebook’s network in January, according to Reuters, which first reported the Apple attack.

High-profile cyber attacks linked to Chinese hackers have also hit news organizations, including The Washington Post and the New York Times.

9 comments

Desperation

The title of this blurb from the Gallup organization, “Democrats Push U.S. Satisfaction Up to 27%”, has a palpable air of desperation. The facts reported are:

  • 73% of Americans, nearly three quarter, are dissatisfied with the way things are going.
  • Democrats are more likely to be satisfied with the way things are going than are Republicans or independents.
  • A majority of Democrats, 53%, are dissatisfied with the way things are going.

Nothing is said about the nature of the dissatisfaction although I could make a few guesses and I suspect that Democrats, Republicans, and independents differ pretty markedly in what they think would constitute a better direction.

How do I reconcile this result with the election results in November 2012? The president won re-election by an extremely narrow majority of the voters. They didn’t think he was good; they just thought he was better than Romney.

73 comments