Why Are Hospital Costs So High?

Holman Jenkins has a reaction piece to Steve Brill’s Time article on the high cost of healthcare. As you might expect, he disagrees with Mr. Brill’s underlying viewpoint:

Your time might be better spent reading Duke University’s Clark Havighurst in a brilliant 2002 article that describes the regulatory, legal and tax subsidies that deprive consumers of both the incentive and opportunity to demand value from medical providers. Americans end up with a “Hobson’s choice: either coverage for ‘Cadillac’ care or no health coverage at all.”

“The market failure most responsible for economic inefficiency in the health-care sector is not consumers’ ignorance about the quality of care,” Mr. Havighurst writes, “but rather their ignorance of the cost of care, which ensures that neither the choices they make in the marketplace nor the opinions they express in the political process reveal their true preferences.”

You might turn next to an equally fabulous 2001 article by Berkeley economist James C. Robinson, who shows how the “pernicious” doctrine that health care is different—that consumers must shut up, do as they’re told and be prepared to write a blank check—is used to “justify every inefficiency, idiosyncrasy, and interest-serving institution in the health care industry.”

Hospitals, insurers and other institutions involved in health care may battle over available dollars, but they also share an interest in increasing the nation’s resources being diverted into health care—which is exactly what happens when costs are hidden from those who pay them.

I think there are several prospective explanations for high hospitals costs and for the high cost of healthcare, generally. These include that physicians want to maintain their incomes at a certain level or increase them and change their behavior to accomplish those goals (“target income hypothesis”), there is uncertainty among physicians about the most effective course of treatment which results in more approaches being tried (“professional uncertainty hypothesis”), or the outcome one might expect when either or both of those factors are combined with a hierarchical bureaucracy.

9 comments

A Matter of Belief

In the comments of a recent post a frequent commenter assigned a letter grade to President Obama:

Obama is a B or B minus president. He’s neither a genius nor a fool. He’s neither a saint nor a great sinner. He’s a guy handed a mess who has done a decent if uninspired job of cleaning it up.

At first blush I thought that was fair but the more I thought about it the more confused I became. Let me try to explain why.

In the area of foreign policy I disagree with practically everything the Obama Administration has done. That’s no particular distinction—I’ve had much the same opinion of the George W. Bush Administration, the Clinton Administration, and the George H. W. Bush. Although I never voted for the man, largely on foreign policy grounds, I thought that Reagan did some things right and others terribly wrong. I thought that Jimmy Carter was the worst president from a foreign policy standpoint of any in my lifetime.

To give the Obama Administration more than a C on foreign policy it seems to me that you must:

  • Think that without the president’s influence we would still be in Iraq, the SOFA notwithstanding (I don’t)
  • Think that the Afghan “surge” was the right thing to do and that we should still have as many troops there as we do (I don’t)
  • Think that providing air support to the Libyan rebels was the right thing to do (I don’t)
  • Think that killing Osama bin Laden was strategically important (I don’t)

just to scratch the surface. There’s one aspect of the president’s foreign policy I can endorse wholeheartedly: he’s not John McCain. That’s worth a C, at least.

To give the Obama Administration more than a C on domestic policy it seems to me that you must:

  • Think that the administration’s policies saved the financial system. (I don’t)
  • Think that the administration’s handling of GM was correct and will enable the company to survive in the long term (I don’t)
  • Think that allowing the “Bush tax cuts” to stand in 2010 was the right thing to do while letting them expire in 2012 was the right thing to do (I don’t see how that circle can be squared).
  • Think that the ARRA ended the recession despite so little of the money that had been appropriated had been spent by the time the recession ended. Sort of an “Immaculate Conception” kind of thing.
  • Think that the “animal spirits” produced by the Obama Administration was enough to end the recession but there was nothing that could be done to produce a more robust recovery.
  • Think that the PPACA will pave the way for a better, more affordable healthcare system (I don’t). After all, even its supporters contend that it’s just a start.

What confuses me in all of this is how you can give President Obama a B or B- without giving President Bush a very similar grade—with the exception of the PPACA (“healthcare reform”) their policies have been remarkably similar.

I’ve realized that I can’t assign a letter grade to President Obama’s presidency. I just don’t know enough. So much is simply a matter of belief. The best I can muster is an Incomplete.

29 comments

The Virtue of Markets in Healthcare

I want to commend an interesting conversation between Megan McArdle econ prof Bart Wilson on the problems with using fiat pricing in healthcare. It’s an interesting discussion and makes a pretty good backgrounder for some of the fundamental economic issues in healthcare.

My questions are somewhat different. For one thing how can a really free market in healthcare persist in the presence of a supply bottleneck? The supply bottleneck in healthcare is maintained through licensing, limitations on accreditation of med schools, restrictions on med school class sizes, intellectual property law, and certificates of need, just to name a few of the devices. I think that in such an environment you’ll have cartel pricing rather than market pricing.

Secondly, much of the “demand” in healthcare is supplier-created. As long as that’s the case doesn’t it place nearly all of the influence in determining the market-clearing price in the hands of the suppliers?

61 comments

Never Pick a Fight With a Man Who Buys Ink By the Barrel

The story of the day in the Right Blogosphere and, possibly, in the major media outlets is the dispute between the White House and Bob Woodward. To refresh your memory, Mr. Woodward had a WP op-ed (about which I commented at the time) challenging the president’s account of who first proposed the sequester and has since remarked that a White House official whom he declined to name, subsequently revealed as economic advisor Gene Sperling, threatened him. Glenn Reynolds has a round-up. I honestly don’t see how the White House’s position on the origins of the sequester, what “balanced” means in the context of “balanced between spending cuts and revenues”, or on the purity of its conduct can be maintained. It’s becoming increasingly clear that threatening the press is a routine tactic for the White House. That has been substantiated by multiple media outlets including ABC and USA Today.

IMO the best thing for them to do right now is to shut up about it. If they’re determined to counter-punch, they may find themselves flailing at friends and enemies alike.

18 comments

Emanuel’s Wave of Support

I see that the wave of support I’ve mentioned for Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel is continuing to swell. Rick Perlstein, writing in The Nation:

Back last year when I was columnizing for the Rolling Stone website, I started explaining to the rest of the country what Rahm Emanuel’s tenure as mayor of Chicago felt like on the ground here in my hometown—and not, say, from the rarified altitude of national mainstream publications who treated the half-baked, potentially self-dealing ideas he rammed through a Kremlin-like City Council as if emanations from some sort of public policy Nirvana; unquestioningly took the mayor at his word even in his most pie-in-the-sky, pot-of-gold-at-the-end-of-the-rainbow pronouncements; and fawned over him as some sort of new-breed reformer because, well—he tells them he is some sort of new-breed reformer. I called that “Rahmpraganda.” Its most sublime practitioner proved to be Jonathan Alter, who gushed in The Atlantic: “Sitting in his cavernous office on the fifth floor of City Hall, Rahm lowers his outstretched empty palms, then raises them above his waist. ‘If you have your hands above the table you can’t deal from the bottom of the deck.’ ”

Now, it wasn’t hard for me to document the various ways Emanuel dealt from the bottom of the deck all the damned time: all I had to do was compile links of the local coverage. On how his administration all but bribed teachers to support his dubious education initiatives. Or rammed through shock-doctrine anti-protest maneuvers. Or embarrassingly manipulated statistics. Or hid his pay-for-access scheduling practices from public view. Or pleaded poverty in a laughably transparent way in order to cut services for things like libraries, while passing equivalent amounts from the city treasury to favored corporate interests. Or practiced simple old-school Chicago-style cronyism.

The passage quoted above is link-filled—go on over there to check it out for yourself.

I’m quite sure that, should Mayor Emanuel run for re-election or seek the presidency in 2016, he’ll have no problem raising the money to do it. Raising money for elections is, after all, his core competency. He might even get re-elected or, heavens forfend, elected. To date it’s pretty clear that managing the office of mayor or dealing with the politics of the office are not among his strengths. This is a guy who was born to be head of the DNC.

2 comments

It’s Not an Act

I rarely read or quote the Washington Examiner but I wanted to express my disagreement with Conn Carroll’s latest remarks there:

On Face the Nation last Sunday [ed. Education Secretary Arne] Duncan told CBS, “As many as 40,000 teachers could lose their jobs. … There are literally teachers now who are getting pink slips, who are getting notices that they can’t come back this fall.” But when pressed to identify which teachers are “literally” getting pink slips right now, Duncan could only name one country in West Virginia. And when The Washington Post followed up with the director of federal programs for that county, she said that while five to six teachers were being laid off, those layoffs had nothing to do with the sequester. In fact, they were caused by a previous White House decision to cut funding for ineffective Head Start programs.

Now newspapers across the country are all running stories directly refuting Obama’s “sky is falling” Chicken Little act.

I do not believe it is an act. I continue to believe that President Obama is poorly served by his subordinates (e.g. Arne Duncan) and, like most of the rest of us, is predisposed to confirmation bias, accepting uncritically things that support what he genuinely believes to be true.

For what it’s worth I also do not believe that the president’s reaction to the sequester that he proposed actually coming to pass is purely tactical or “taking a page out of FDR’s playbook”. I think he genuinely believe it will be bad for the country, it’s entirely the Republicans’ fault, and that, when the inevitable cyclical downturn takes place in the economy, that will be their fault, too.

I doubt it will occur to him that the fact that there is virtually no Congressional support for the budgets the White House has proposed (his budget proposal of last year was voted down 99-0 in the Senate; the previous year’s was defeated 97-0) means he should be doing something differently.

22 comments

Core Competency

Prediction on the sequester debate: Congress will stick to its core competency and do nothing.

2 comments

What If We Could Cut the Cost of a College Education…

…in half? Or more? Joanne Jacobs reports on the effectiveness of a “hybrid class” that combines online instruction with a on hour face-to-face session:

College statistics students in a hybrid class — online instruction plus a one-hour face-to-face session — performed slightly better than the control group and spent 1.7 fewer hours per week on the course, write William G. Bowen, Matthew M. Chingos, Kelly A. Lack and Thomas I. Nygren in Education Next.

“The effect of the hybrid-format course did not vary when controlling for race/ethnicity, gender, parental education, primary language spoken, score at the standardized pretest, hours worked for pay, or college GPA,” the authors report.

The lecture format used in so many colleges and universities originated in, roughly, the 13th century. It is not so perfect a technology that it cannot be improved using some of the developments in telecommunications and information technology that have come about over the last 800 years.

25 comments

Almost 50 Years Later

In 1964 documentary film maker Michael Apted interviewed 14 seven year old boys and girls from every stratum of English society about their lives and what they hoped for them. He edited the result into the rivetind groundbreaking film, Seven Up!. Over the period of the next almost fifty years he re-interviewed his original participants to see how their lives and views had progressed over the preceding seven years. The results were released as 7 Plus Seven, 21 Up, 28 Up, and so on.

Now 56 Up has been released. Of the original 14 all but one has participated in the latest installment. How have things turned out? As Clive Crook notes, it’s complicated:

It’s all so untidy. They keep defying the stereotypes they are supposed to exemplify. After the first program, you see the filmmakers lose interest in their own theory. The dignity as well as the detail of each life forbid generalization of that kind. Once you get to know these people, you don’t want to insult them that way.

One problem you might expect Apted to face doesn’t really arise. Only one of the original 14 dropped out after “Seven Up!” Others take sabbaticals for an episode or two, but “56 Up” has interviews with 13 of the original group.

Subtler problems do arise, however, and Apted skillfully deals with them. One is that the lives grow not only longer but more complicated. In “56 Up,” especially, you have a sense that more of what matters to the group has moved, as it were, off- stage — to ailing, aged parents; to their own children, now leaving home and trying to make their way; to grandchildren. The film allows the extended families their privacy. Perhaps at the group’s insistence, perhaps because doing anything else would have caused the project to collapse under its own weight, they’re shown but not studied.

Good and loving parents matter. Money matters. Dumb luck matters. An apparently innate capacity for happiness matters. Resilience matters. Most of all, a loving and supportive spouse matters.

Michael Apted was only 23 when he started this great, unique, and historic project. He’s over 70 now and I hope that the project outlives him. I look forward to viewing 56 Up and, even more, to the continuing document of the participants’ lives as they pass through the great transitions yet to come.

Nel mezzo del cammin di nostra vita
mi ritrovai per una selva oscura
ché la diritta via era smarrita.

0 comments

Blame Comcast

There’s a great op-ed from Edward Luce at the Financial Times on the baleful influence of what might be termed the “media-telecommunications-technology complex”. If Mr. Luce is correct, the reason that highspeed Internet connectivity in the U. S. lags behind that in other developed countries can be summed up in two words: blame Comcast. Here’s the beginning:

If Dwight Eisenhower had General Motors and George W. Bush had Halliburton, Barack Obama arguably has Comcast. US presidents are often linked to one or two corporations that donate a lot of money to them and then benefit from their actions. Comcast, which is America’s largest cable television and internet provider and is a near monopoly in most of its largest cities, is no exception.

I’ll give my honest opinion here. I think that Standard Oil, General Motors, General Electric, Microsoft, and other companies that have grown to greatness have been helped enormously by rent-seeking but each of them originally had some core competence at which they excelled. I see no evidence that cable companies have ever excelled at anything other than rent-seeking. Maybe that’s the wave of the future.

Every so often I get a full court press from Comcast on subscribing to a full package of cable TV, Internet service, and phone service from them. I always give the same answer. I lose cable and Internet connectivity about once a week. Over the period of the last thirty years I have lost electrical power three or four times a year. I have lost my plain old landline telephone service, briefly, twice over the last thirty years. When Comcast provides service as reliably as the phone company, I’ll consider it.

Don’t underestimate how important a story this is. Arguably, a lot of the increase in welfare over the last several decades has been in the form of consumer surplus. Companies like Comcast whose essential business plan is to capture an increasing amount of the consumer surplus for its own make us all worse off and, significantly, reduce our competitiveness with other countries.

12 comments