Foreign Policy Blogging at OTB

I’ve just published a foreign policy-related post at Outside the Beltway:

War on Terror Status Report

Walter Russell Mead presents a sitrep on the War on Terror at The Wall Street Journal. He warns of continuing risk but in my view he’s actually too sanguine. In paraphrase of what he says in his op-ed, the terrain of the War on Terror has always favored our enemies. That’s what Fourth Generation Warfare is about. Due to confused priorities we have largely avoided fighting on terrain that’s more favorable to us.

The “drone war” in which we’re now engaged and which, apparently, we’re expanding into North Africa does capitalize on our strengths but for how long? In addition I remain unconvinced that it is not counter-productive.

7 comments

Economic Growth Be Damned

After a depressing if one-sided account of the economic policies of the Obama Administration to date, Michael Boskin, Stanford economist, presents his alternative case:

Since World War II, OECD countries that stabilized their budgets without recession averaged $5-$6 of actual spending cuts per dollar of tax hikes. Examples include the Netherlands in the mid-1990s and Sweden in the mid-2000s. In a paper last year for the Stanford Institute for Economic Policy Research, Stanford’s John Cogan and John Taylor, with Volker Wieland and Maik Wolters of Frankfurt, Germany’s Goethe University, show that a reduction in federal spending over several years amounting to 3% of GDP—bringing noninterest spending down to pre-financial-crisis levels—will increase short-term GDP.

Why? Because expectations of lower future taxes and debt, and therefore higher incomes, increase private spending. The U.S. reduced spending as a share of GDP by 5% from the mid-1980s to mid-1990s. Canada reduced its spending as share of GDP by 8% in the mid-’90s and 2000s. In both cases, the reductions reinforced a period of strong growth.

An economically “balanced” deficit-reduction program today would mean $5 of actual, not hypothetical, spending cuts per dollar of tax hikes. The fiscal-cliff deal reached on Jan. 1 instead was scored at $1 of spending cuts for every $40 of tax hikes.

Keynesian economists urge a delay on spending cuts on the grounds that they will hurt the struggling economy. Yet at just one-quarter of 1% of GDP this year, $43 billion of this year’s sequester cuts in an economy with a GDP of more than $16 trillion is unlikely to be a major macroeconomic event.

I sincerely wish that those proposing more Keynesian stimulus would produce more actual data-based evidence for their prescriptions. I’ve seen the models. I want to see the evidence. I want them to explain Japan.

My view, as I have said before, is that I continue to believe that a properly timed and structured fiscal stimulus can increase economic growth in the short term and kick-start the “animal spirits” necessary for the private sector to take over and for the economy to grow on its own. Fiscal stimulus need not do so but it can. I also believe that the ARRA was neither properly timed nor structured and that representative democracies may be incapable of such swift and prudent action. I wish that we would return to a more truly Keynesian view of the government as the employer of last resort rather than as the consumer of last resort. But that’s another subject. I also think that billing wage subsidies for teachers, police officers, and firefighters as fiscal stimulus is loopy but that, too, is another subject.

Meanwhile, when does the short term, during which Keynesian stimulus can be effective, become the long term, when structural changes are needed? Are we there yet?

19 comments

The New Conventional Wisdom

From the Washington Post, the voice of the conventional wisdom, Eugene Robinson says what I suspect is becoming that conventional wisdom:

What I really hate about the sequester is the way it confirms the conventional wisdom that “both sides are wrong.” This is usually the kind of lazy pseudoanalysis that drives me up the wall. But it took both Obama and the Republicans to get us into this mess — and nobody has a clue how to get us out of it.

How big a distance is it between hating something because it’s false or lazy and hating it because it’s true?

I think we need to recall that representatives in the House are elected by district, senators are elected by the voters of a state, and the president is elected at large. What are you asking for if you demand that House members do something other than what their constituents elected them to do? If you demand greater statesmanship of them, doesn’t that impose an obligation to show greater statesmanship yourself?

What do I think should be done? My opinion is that the folk Keynesian ship sailed long, long ago. Four years ago. The short term has become the long term and we should be debating the structural changes we need to make that are necessary for robust growth and putting people back to work. This is incredibly likely because the Powers That Be are virtually by definition completely committed to Things As They Are.

4 comments

U. S. Income Distribution—a Chart to Contemplate

The chart above, courtesy of Census Bureau data, illustrates household income distribution in the United States based on the most recent information available. You can click on the chart for a larger version. I find this chart interesting for any number of reasons. Note that it illustrates in one compact form the distribution of income, median income, the five income quintiles, and the incomes of the top 10%, 5%, and 2% of income earners.

There are any number of observations I could make about this chart. I’ll limit myself to just four.

  • Why aren’t there more households to the left of the highest bar in the chart?
  • Why is the highest bar in the chart, representing 6% of households, the $15,000-$20,000 bar?
  • What’s with the two bars at the far right of the chart, the highest income earners?
  • How has the chart changed over time?

Last question first. The first time I saw a chart like this was a little over 40 years ago. I found it a bit shocking back then. It was actually pretty similar to this chart other than that the income numbers were all smaller. The biggest change I can recall is that those two bars at the far right are both higher than they used to be and, if I remember correctly, the several bars just to the left of them are lower.

Now, why aren’t there more households to the left of the highest bar? I think that’s an artifact. It’s been created by policies like the minimum wage and various policies that produce non-wage and non-taxable compensation, e.g. Medicaid. Below a certain level earning taxable income doesn’t make any sense since it lowers non-wage, non-taxable income. It also might be an artifact of reporting.

I think it’s pretty clear why the highest bar in the chart is where it is: essentially, that represents household with one wage earner, working full-time, earning minimum wage. They don’t comprise a vast number of household but there are enough of them to make it the highest bar. I also think that the several bars just to the right of that one largely consist of households with more than one wage earner, both earning minimum wage or, possibly, slightly above minimum wage.

That brings us to the real question. Why are those two bars at the far right of the chart so high? Beats me. I can’t think of any likely natural explanation. Note that the second bar from the right should actually be thought of as ten bars. Each of those bars would be quite a bit lower than that single bar but as depicted it neatlly illustrates a point I’ve made around here fairly often around here: you’ve got to think beyond the top 1% of income earners.

As I say although I can’t think of any likely natural explanations I can think of explanations. It isn’t intelligence. Intelligence isn’t distributed in the population that way and after you get beyond two standard deviations the correlation between income and intelligence just isn’t that close. The explanations I can come up with include inherited wealth and various other forms of rent-seeking. There are about 115 million households in the United States. 1% of that is 1.15 million households. 2% of that is 2.3 million households.

Remember that the tail on the right is actually very, very long. To my eye that still doesn’t explain why the second bar (actually ten bars combined) is as high as it is. Even if you divide it by ten it’s still too high as is the bar on the right which is actually many, many more bars.

There are roughly a half million physicians in the country. Nearly all of them are in those last two bars in the chart. My inference is that although they comprise a big chunk of those bars they don’t comprise all of them. Lawyers who graduated from the top 15 law schools comprise another chunk of those two bars as do middle and upper level managers of medium-sized and large companies and some top managers at small companies.

How much of what’s being illustrated by those two rightmost bars is the distortionary effect of our outsized financial sector?

37 comments

It Ain’t Necessarily So

Scott Rasmussen has posted a reaction to Pew Research’s finding that a majority of Americans don’t want the federal government to make any cuts. His point? That the finding reveals a language problem:

On the surface, those results appear to support the Political Class conceit that voters like spending cuts in the abstract but not in specific programs. That’s the way it was reported by most media outlets.

But the reality is quite different. The Pew results actually show support for what official Washington would consider massive spending cuts.

Just to be clear, there is absolutely nothing wrong with the Pew poll questions or results. The raw numbers are similar to what we find at Rasmussen Reports. The problem is with the way the numbers were reported.

The questions were asked using the language of America, but they were reported using the language of the Political Class.

To most Americans, maintaining spending at current levels would mean spending the same amount in 2013 as we spent in 2012. However, to those experienced in the mysterious ways of Washington, maintaining spending at current levels means spending $3.5 trillion this year and $4.5 trillion in five years. To most Americans, that’s a trillion dollars in spending growth.

The Political Class, on the other hand, would consider holding spending unchanged at current levels to be a massive spending cut. Why? Because it wouldn’t allow for the trillion dollar spending growth that is already built into the budget.

With this understanding, the numbers from Pew take on an entirely different tone. Consider the Pew numbers for roads and infrastructure projects: 38 percent want more spending, and only 17 percent favor a spending cut. But a plurality (43 percent) wants to hold infrastructure spending steady. Since the Political Class would consider holding spending steady to be a “cut” in spending, 60 percent in the Pew poll favors what official Washington calls cuts.

In my view the question they should be asking is whether most Americans want to pay 40% more in federal taxes? If the answer is “No”, that either implies that they want federal spending to decrease, they want to keep borrowing/inflating the money supply (something that will become increasingly and uncontrollably dangerous), or they want somebody else to pay the freight. I’m guessing it’s the last alternative and it should be viewed with some suspicion.

Over the period of the last forty years or so there has been substantial sorting of the political parties. Two “catch-all” parties have become substantially more ideological, more programmatic in their nature. Although the Democratic Party has become increasingly progressive, progressives still don’t comprise a majority of Democrats. The Republican Party has become much more socially conservative but social conservatives don’t comprise a majority of Republicans. And there’s a large body of independents, many of whom are dissatisfied with either party.

The apparent paradox can be resolved by recognizing that the American people by and large are more pragmatic than ideological while their political parties are increasingly ideological rather than pragmatic. Modern political fund-raising practically assures that outcome. And assures that more people become disaffected with the political parties.

Yesterday on ABC’s This Week Republican rising star Mia Love made the observation that the United States was ripe for a populist resurgence. I think that’s right but it won’t take place in Washington. It will take place in the state and local governments.

5 comments

The Conclave

Presumably, you’re aware that cardinals of the Catholic Church are convening in Rome to elect the next pope:

(CBS News) Catholic cardinals are holding the first of their official meetings on Monday since the retirement of the former pope Benedict, now known as Pope Emeritus.

During those meetings, the cardinals will set a date for their conclave to choose a new pope. The cardinals have begun to meet, but before they get down to the business of choosing a new pope, they’ve got plenty of other business to discuss.

The Catholic Church has been hit by the combined earthquakes of a retired pope, and the child abuse and other scandals. Its response has been deliberate and traditional, and will be a major topic of discussion in the coming days.

I don’t plan to post much on this story and, indeed, this may be my only post on the subject. That doesn’t minimize how important a story it is. How important?

Roughly one sixth of all human beings are Catholics. Not Christians. Catholics. It makes no more sense to ignore their existence and their faith than it did to ignore China in 1970. Most of the comments I see about Catholicism are astonishingly and virulently bigoted. Disparaging Catholicism is no more adequate a view of it than disparaging China was 40 years ago.

Here’s my sole observation. Look to the conclave as a weathervane of what the cardinals believe to be the primary challenge facing the Church and for the tenure of the next pope. It was no coincidence that a Polish bishop was elected to the papacy in 1978. The Eurocentric college of cardinals envisioned a communist world and the challenge was to keep the Church alive in that world. What pope could do so better than a bishop who had confronted such a world successfully on a daily basis for many years?

In my view the election of Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger was an engineered one (by Ratzinger himself). Despite that I think it’s clear that the cardinals saw a more assertive Islam as a primary challenge to the Church’s survival and the overtures made by Benedict XVI early in his papacy are evidence of that. They were peculiar and ineffectual overtures to be sure but overtures nonetheless.

There is no comparable “pope-in-waiting” today so whomever is elected by this conclave will constitute a surer signal of where the cardinals see today’s challenge. The College of Cardinals remains alarmingly Eurocentric. Of the 117 electors from 50 countries 61 are Europeans even though Europeans only comprise about 27% of Catholics with their numbers dwindling every day.

Half of all Catholics live in the Americas; 40% in Latin America. 12% live in Africa; 10% in Asia.

The last non-European pope was Gregory III in the 8th century. I would like to see a Latin American pope, if only because it would underscore the Church’s commitment to a “preferential option for the poor”, an essential component of modern Catholic social teaching. A North American pope would be a very long shot and I’m not convinced a desireable one.

If the next pope is a European or, worse, a member of the Curia or other portion of the Vatican bureaucracy it will be a signal that the cardinals are circling the wagons. I view that, unfortunately, as pretty likely. IMO what is needed is a radical shakeup of that bureaucracy.

17 comments

Incentives Matter

Reihan Salam makes a very important point, that the incentives we’ve put in place have the perverse effect of creating fewer jobs than might otherwise be the case:

As it turns out, the U.S. tax code does give large incumbents an enormous advantage over start-ups by subsidizing corporate debt. When businesses want to raise money for operations, they can pour their profits back into the business, they can sell shares or they can borrow. In an ideal world, we’d want business enterprises to make these decisions on the basis of what makes the most sense based on underlying economic conditions. But in the United States, we allow companies to deduct interest expenses from their taxes but not dividends on their stocks. This makes it far cheaper for companies to raise money by borrowing than by selling shares.

One reason this debt bias is a problem is that it leads companies to take on large amounts of debt, which raises the risk that they will go bankrupt. Yet there is another problem: It is much easier for some companies to borrow than for others. Specifically, well-established firms ‑ for example, large incumbents with pricing power that have been around for years ‑ find it much easier to borrow than new, unproven firms with high-growth potential, which have little choice but to rely on selling shares to finance investment. And so the tax-deductibility of interest expenses and not dividends gives the entrenched corporate Goliaths that have the option to borrow a big boost, while doing nothing for the would-be corporate Davids eager to take them on.

He goes on to propose imposing a cap on the amount of interest a company could deduct for purposes of calculating its corporate income tax. That should be an approach that would be acceptable for those for whom the moral necessity of increasing the amount of revenue derived from the corporate income tax is an article of faith. There is, however, an even simpler, less distorting, and more effective strategy for realigning the incentives that favors more growth and more employment: abolish the corporate income tax completely.

49 comments

Labor of Love

I saw the movie, It’s a Mad, Mad, Mad, Mad World when it first came out in 1963 at the drive-in. Subsequently, I saw it twice more in the theater and have seen it several times on television and once or twice on DVD. I could probably recite it from memory at this point so I think I love the movie as much as the next man.

Or, at least, I thought so until today. Cruise on over to this web site. There the owner has painstakingly compiled a list of the locations used in the filming of the picture with recent photographs of what those locations look like now. Or this site where the owner has, quite literally, hundreds of such match-ups. Practically a frame by frame recreation of the entire movie in present-day photographs.

I wonder whether young people today find IAMMMMW as funny as I did and still do? I’m guessing that they don’t have the patience for it but that’s just a guess. Whatever you think of it, it remains a great document of the greatest comedy performers of the twentieth century from about 1920 to 1963. I don’t think it’s the material but the raw talent of the people who made the picture that makes it funny.

Remarkably, considering that the picture turns 50 this year and most of the cast was, well, mature when it was made, a number of the major and featured cast members are still alive. By my reckoning as of March 2013, Mickey Rooney, Sid Caesar (the dentist trapped in the basement of the hardware store), Jonathan Winters (truck driver Lenny Pike), Marvin Kaplan (one of the owners of the desert filling station destroyed by Lenny Pike), Jerry Lewis (cameo as driver who runs over Capt. Culpepper’s hat), Barrie Chase (bikini-clad woman dancing with Dick Shawn in his beach house and Fred Astaire’s dancing partner on TV), Carl Reiner (in the airport control tower, seminal writer of early television), and Stan Freberg (also in the airport control tower, best known for radio humor).

2 comments

The Ceremonial Start of the 2013 Iditarod

My wife and I are waiting, eagerly, for the ceremonial start of the 2013 Iditarod. If you’re interesting in watching, you can do so by going to the Iditarod official web site. The ceremonial start is in about 45 minutes.

While you’re there check out the biographies of some of the competitors. They’re mostly from Alaska, of course, but there’s one local guy (from Addison, Illinois in suburban Chicago) and competitors from Canada, Norway, Russia, New Zealand, and, remarkably, from Jamaica and Brazil.

0 comments

Taranto on Woodward

James Taranto’s take on the kerfuffle about Bob Woodward and Gene Sperling seems pretty credible to me:

The email does seem at odds with Woodward’s description of it, but that disparity is one of tone. Woodward’s description of the email exchange made it sound hostile and combative, whereas the tone of the actual emails is reasonable and conciliatory. But Sperling’s email makes clear right off the bat that there is a context to which outside observers are not privy: The emails were preceded by a “conversation” in which Sperling “raised my voice” to such an extent that he felt it necessary to apologize in writing.

Our surmise is that the email exchange was an exercise in rationalization rather than candor–that both Sperling and Woodward were concealing their anger in an attempt to come across as reasonable to each other and to themselves. In the CNN interview, by contrast, Woodward failed (if he attempted at all) to hide his feelings and thus gave an emotionally more accurate portrayal of his exchange with Sperling, even if the inference that there was a threat involved turned out to be mistaken.

You’ve got to consider the context and the context was Bob Woodward being yelled at by Gene Sperling for an hour. Maybe Woodward was yelling back but to the best of my knowledge there isn’t any documentation of that.

27 comments