More Than Half

One more point on the jobs report before I stop perseverating on it. The number of jobs created was around 250,000. The number of people who were no longer counted as unemployed because they had stopped looking for work was 300,000. That means that if you hail the decrease in the unemployment rate from 7.8% to 7.7% you are objectively endorsing the increase in the number of discouraged workers as the solution to our problems. Discouraged workers were a more significant factor than more jobs.

11 comments

What’s Wrong With the Recovery?

Yesterday I pointed out the dog in the manger on the BLS’s most recent jobs report: that at the present rate it would take an unconscionably long time to bring unemployment to where it was when the recession began and even when it does an enormous amount of harm will have been done. On the NPR blog Jacob Goldstein has produced a graph, reproduced above, comparing employment growth following the late recession with other post-war recessions that may differ somewhat from the one you may be familiar with and which Bill McBride of Calculated Risk regularly updates.

As you can see, employment is recovering far too slowly, virtually the definition of an “L-shaped recession”. To their credit some of the Left Blogosphere blogs have latched on to this graph. Daily Kos front page regular Meteor Blades, whose work I’ve frequently liked, remarks:

A lot of people lost their homes. Spent all their savings. Exhausted their unemployment benefits. Graduated and couldn’t find a job right away—a delay that analysts say will have an negative impact on their wages from now until they retire. Took a job exactly like the one they were laid off from but that pays less and provides fewer benefits than before. Retired early because they couldn’t find a job and needed that Social Security check to survive, which as a result will now be smaller for the rest of their lives than it would have been had they been able to wait until full benefits kicked in.

Twelve million Americans are officially unemployed. Eight million are working part-time jobs not out of preference, but because they can’t get the full-time jobs they need. Another 6.8 million are no longer in the labor force but say they want a job. All told, 26.8 million Americans either unemployed or underemployed.

Even if the same 236,000 new jobs were created each month from now on, it would take (depending on how you count) from today until somewhere between October 2017 and July 2019 to recover where we would have been if the recession had not occurred.

very much echoing what I wrote yesterday.

Some, like David Adkins at Hullabaloo attribute the shortfall in jobs to weak aggregate demand:

Why is this happening? Well, we know it’s not because the rich “job creators” don’t have enough money. We know it’s not because corporations don’t have high enough stock valuations, or because they don’t have enough profits. We know it’s not because labor has too much power in the marketplace.

The answer is pretty simple: it’s a matter of weak aggregate demand.

He goes on to quote Paul Krugman. As should be clear from my previous posts, I’m skeptical of that explanation. I think the essence of a “bubble economy” is a sudden, dramatic decline in production due to the sharp drop in prices of the bubble commodity. Productive capacity is measured in dollars, not houses, bushels of wheat, or iPads. Keynesian stimulus isn’t a strategy to boost productive capacity. It’s a strategy to boost “aggregate demand” to fill the gap between that demand and productive capacity. No excess production—no gap. We need to increase production and fiscal stimulus may or may not do that. It depends on how the money is spent and the ARRA may have made some people very rich but it didn’t do nearly enough to increase production because it was predicated on shaky premises.

Our problems didn’t start in 2013 or in 2009 or 2007 or even in 2001. They started long, long before than and are now structural in nature. It will take structural reform to correct them. Areas ripe for structural change include government and its handmaiden industries: healthcare, education, finance.

In the meantime I should remind you that the Forbes Index of the Cost of Living Extremely Well has been rising very sharply over the last decade, more than tripling relative to the CPI. If you’re wondering why all of the Fed’s efforts at pumping money into the system haven’t produced inflation, it’s because you don’t buy the stuff that’s being inflated.

46 comments

Yes, We Have No Bananas

When I was a kid bananas tasted better than they do now. I know that old ladies are always reputed to say that but in the case of bananas it’s actually true.

Sixty years ago the predominant variety of banana grown commercially, shipped internationally, and that you were most likely to see in your local supermarket was the Gros Michel (pronounced “grow miSHELL”). The Gros Michel had a tougher skin and, consequently, was easier to ship and handle and, frankly, it tasted better than the Cavendish that you see in the store today. The Cavendish is bland and tasteless by comparison.

In the 1950s the Gros Michel began to succumb to a fungus called “Panama disease”. By the 1960s it had become commercially nonviable. It’s still grown, just not commercially in large scale cultivation. IIRC Chiquita (United Fruit Company) was the last holdout against the Cavendish but it stopped cultivating the Gros Michel in the 1960s. During that period we actively sought out Chiquita bananas. They just tasted better than the bananas from other producers. The Cavendish was selected because it was resistant to Panama disease and could be shipped.

Roughly ten years ago a strain of Panama disease to which the Cavendish banana is susceptible was identified in Asia. The fungus has now spread throughout East Asia and to Australia. Panama disease Race 4, as it is called, has wiped out plantations in Indonesia, Malaysia, Australia and Taiwan, and it is now spreading through much of Southeast Asia. It’s just a matter of time before it makes its way to the New World.

Once that happens the Cavendish is doomed and there is presently no ready alternative. When this new strain of Panama disease struck it wiped out Malaysian plantations in just five years. It’s not that there are no other varieties of bananas. It’s that there are no other varieties that are palatable and suitable for shipping long distances waiting in the wings to substitute for the Cavendish.

Banana growers are trying to develop a commercially viable substitute for the Cavendish both by natural means and by genetic modification but it’s quite possible than in just five years bananas will be as rare in American stores as they were in the 1880s when they were first shipped here in quantity.

5 comments

Jobs, Jobs, Jobs

There’s some rejoicing over the Labor Department’s most recent jobs report:

The U.S. economy added 236,000 jobs in February, according to a Labor Department report released Friday. That’s much stronger growth than in January, when employers hired a revised 119,000 workers.

The gains were broad-based as offices, restaurants, construction firms and hospitals all added jobs.

Meanwhile, the unemployment rate dipped to 7.7%, as 12 million workers were counted as unemployed. The drop was partly because more people said they got jobs, but also because 130,000 people dropped out of the labor force.

Well, that’s good. All that’s needed now is to repeat that amount of job growth every month over the period of the next six years. Assuming that the job market is last in-first out, i.e. the first fired will be the last rehired, some of those people will have been unemployed for ten years by the time they’ve found new jobs. If they lost their jobs when they were 45, they’d be 55 when they went back to work and would have lost ten of what should have been their most productive years. Expect an increasing number of people to continue working well into their 70s.

In the interest of contributing to the project of job creation let me propose a few broad principles for promoting job growth:

1. Encourage the creation of “brown jobs”.

We need more jobs in mining, manufacturing, farming, lumber, and oil and gas production, not fewer. Those industries are dirty, hence “brown jobs”. Go ahead and regulate them but don’t try to regulate them out of existence. Solar power is a declining industry in the West not a growing one—both Siemens and BP have gotten out. They can’t beat the huge subsidies the Chinese government is pouring into their own “green jobs” companies.

2. Negotiate more bilateral free trade deals.

The freer, the better. Remember that you can write a free trade deal on the back of a napkin. When it runs into thousands of pages, it’s managed trade, not free trade.

3. Insist that China play by the rules it agreed to.

China has been violating foreign currency reserve limitations, intellectual property laws, and subsidizing its own industries in violation of international agreements to which it is party for more than a decade now. It has also failed to open its banking sector to foreign competition as it agreed to when it was admitted to the WTO. It is more than five years behind schedule in honoring those commitments. If China refuses to play by the rules it agreed to, throw it out of the WTO. Remove its “Most Favored Nation” trading status. And so on.

4. Keep the tax code simple.

Our tax code is long overdue for an overhaul. Our present byzantine tax code benefits companies that have the money to work the tax code at the expense of its competitors who don’t. The tax code is there to raise revenue, not modify behavior or function as a method of preventing upstart competition.

I could add to that list but that’s a start. Feel free to contribute you own ideas.

17 comments

Uninterested in Politics

Registered voters in Los Angeles give new meaning to the words “uninterested in politics”:

Mark the date, remember the day.

On March 5, 2013, Los Angeles redefined apathy.

A measly 16% of the city’s registered voters — or perhaps around 20% once all the mail-in ballots are counted — turned out in an election with the following things at stake:

How much we pay in sales tax, who controls the nation’s second-largest school district, who might fill nine City Council seats and three community college board positions, and who will serve as city attorney, city controller and mayor.

This is late-night TV joke territory, as in:

“Election officials were stunned in Los Angeles on Tuesday when 16% of the city’s voters cast ballots. They couldn’t believe that many people knew there was an election.”

You could spin it, I suppose, and say it’s not that we’re disengaged, we’re just laid back. A whole metropolis of Big Lebowskis, dude.

I think this provides some evidence for a point I’ve made before. Our problem is not that not enough people show up to vote. It’s that the franchise has been extended too far. If every single human being living in the city of Los Angeles were eligible to vote, I strongly suspect the rate of voter turnout would fall below 5%.

9 comments

The Big Die Young

In nature large animals tend to have longer lifespans than small ones. Elephants, for example, can live as long as 70 years while mice are doing pretty well if they make it to 4. In domestic dogs the situation is reversed: large breeds tend to have shorter lifespans than small breeds. The average lifespan of a Great Dane is 6 to 8 years. Schipperkes (little black dogs) average 13 to 15 years but living into their 20s isn’t that unusual and there have been cases of Schips living as long as 28 years. Why?

Big dogs apparently die younger mainly because they age quickly, researchers say.

These new findings could help unravel the biological links between growth and mortality, the scientists added.

[…]

To shed light on the possible tradeoffs of large size, researchers analyzed ages at death in 74 breeds, using data from more than 56,000 dogs that visited veterinary teaching hospitals. The researchers focused on why large dogs lived shorter lives on average.

“My main scientific interest is life-history evolution. I’m also a bit of a dog nerd in private life,” said researcher Cornelia Kraus, an evolutionary biologist at the University of Göttingen in Germany.

The scientists found that large breeds apparently aged at faster rates; the speed at which the risk of death increased with age was greater with larger breeds than smaller ones. Indeed, among dog breeds, an increase of 4.4 pounds (2 kg) in body mass leads to a loss of approximately 1 month of life expectancy.

The implication is that the same factors that cause them to grow rapidly cause them to die early. I wonder how true that is.

In Great Danes the primary causes of death are bloat (gastric volvulus)—22.8%, cardiovascular problems—13.5%, and cancer—12.3%. Generalized “old age” is below 10%—9.9%.

Bloat is a puzzling condition (I’ve had two dogs die of it). No one really knows what causes it. I suspect it’s structural in nature. It’s known, for example, that large, broadchested breeds are more predisposed to bloat than others. I think that many cardiovascular problems are structural, too. The system just isn’t strong enough to handle the load that’s being placed on it.

Everything dies of something but it seems to me that if you eliminate the major causes of death that the odds of living a longer life will increase.

Next month our Tally will turn 15. She’s the longest-lived Samoyed we’ve ever had and has lived longer than her father, her mother, her littermate, her brothers and sisters, her grandparents, even her nephews and nieces. I think it’s because she was structurally sound, we’ve kept her weight down, she’s had great healthcare, and we’ve treated every health condition that she encountered promptly and prudently. I think she escaped the bloat that took her mother largely because of good luck—I attribute it to abdominal surgery she had earlier in life.

6 comments

The Synthesis

In his most recent column Michael Barone produces an interesting synthesis of several ideas I’ve explored around here over the years. Read the whole thing. Otherwise I’d need to excerpt the whole column and that goes well beyond “fair use”.

In summary, Mr. Barone suggests we may be in for an extended period of slow or no growth because a) U. S. population isn’t growing as quickly as it did 50 years ago and b) technological advancement isn’t producing the productivity gains it did 50 years ago. Our government education, labor, healthcare, and welfare policies all assume things as they were 50 years ago and those assumptions just don’t hold true any more.

A year or so ago I produced a lengthy series of posts which explained slowing growth as an artifact of the aging of the Baby Boomers. You can search for the posts if you care to. I’ve also posted on the subject of the realities of technological advancement.

This might be a good time for me to give an example of why I think that technological advancement isn’t being reflected in the sorts of productivity gains it resulted in decades ago.

Governments at all levels are subsidizing healthcare to the tune of well over $1 trillion per year. The federal government’s share of those subsidies alone is more than $800 billion. Those subsidies are expected to continue, increasing even, for the foreseeable future. That means that capital investment in healthcare including healthcare research is seen as a sure thing by investors. It constitutes about 25% of all R&D investment and I suspect it would be even more if its results weren’t so weak.

Here’s the point: nearly all of the results of that subsidy and investment is retained by producers as producer surplus. Check out nearly any statistic you care to. Outputs, however measured, are declining relative to inputs, not increasing. Said another way, healthcare R&D doesn’t result in increased productivity.

That could be changed but the social costs of making the change would be so high that I don’t expect the changes to be made. Unless we do, the more money we put into healthcare the worse the overall economy will get.

Back to the policies. What education, labor, healthcare, and welfare policies make sense during a period of slow or no growth? I’ll tell you one that makes very little sense: large public employee pensions. Illinois Gov. Pat Quinn’s 2014 budget proposal (which I may complain about later in the day) calls for the state to devote 25% of its budget to public employee pensions.

17 comments

The Unreal Economy

One of the biggest stories of the day is the record set by the DJIA yesterday:

The Dow Jones Industrial Average surged to its highest closing level ever, finally overcoming the losses tied to the financial crisis on the back of a tenacious stock rally that began in March 2009. And the blue chips did it with an exclamation point–a 125.95-point blast that left the old record in the dust.

The previous record had been set in October of 2007. All is not skittles and beer, however. From a New York Daily News editorial:

It’s a fabulous irony that Obama, who has dined out politically by vilifying big business, finds himself the master of a rich-get-richer universe. All the more astounding: No one invited Obama’s ardently championed “hardworking Americans” to the feast — except if they were lucky enough to have the remains of a 401(k) retirement savings plan and the stomach to play stocks.

With unemployment stuck around 8%, and with millions of people forced into part-time or low-paying jobs, corporate earnings have climbed 20% a year since 2008 while disposable incomes edged up 1.4% annually, according to Dean Maki, chief U.S. economist for Barclays.

Oh, how the Democrats would flay a Republican who presided over such a have-and-have-not economy. They spare their man because, well, he’s their man. They’re sure Obama’s heart is in the right place, and they blame the GOP for preventing him from lifting the fortunes of the working and middle classes.

and from Thomas Pascoe in The Telegraph:

Strong stocks and strong bonds are an unusual mix. Theoretically and historically, money has washed from one to the other causing rises and falls along the way. What is unusual about the present climate is that so much money has been created by central banks that there is sufficient available to create a bubble in, well, everything.

This has a lot to do with how QE operates. Unlike straight money printing, it is designed to transfer money to banks, not to the consumer or to the government. The banks swap their existing government bonds for newly printed money. In theory, the banks now lend this cash on the high street to consumers and businesses. In reality, that has been a problem. Burnt by the financial crisis, banks have imposed tougher lending criteria at a time when creditworthiness is impaired. As such, they cannot lend. Instead the money ends up in the trading account. It gets spent on financial instruments in proportion to the greed (equities) or fear (bonds) of the institution in question. The main reason that QE has not been catastrophically inflationary is that so little of it has filtered down to the high street. For the most part, it has simply pushed up values across the board in the financial markets.

There’s more than one way to look at this. In one view the Powers-That-Be are desperate to improve the state of economy but don’t know how. Poor, powerless Powers-That-Be. In another view the enormous explosion of asset inflation is exactly what the Powers-That-Be want to happen.

I don’t think that I hold either one of those views. I’m more with Josh Billings who said “It ain’t what you don’t know that will hurt you but what you do know that just ain’t so.” The Powers-That-Be know too much that just ain’t so and it’s hurting the rest of us.

While I’m on the subject doesn’t the new record lend a certain amount of support to a point I’ve made before: that the DJIA is increasingly disconnected from the real economy, you know, the one in which you and I work and buy and sell goods and services? I might add that it’s quite possible to construct an index of stocks that always goes up, always setting new records. The trick is changing which stocks go into the index while retaining credibility at the same time.

24 comments

How to Optimize Federal Spending

This post is in reaction to a comment that was left yesterday. Besides, I think it’s helpful to remember every so often where the federal government is spending money.

As you can see almost 2/3s of all federal spending (Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid, Interest on the Debt, and Other Mandatory—mostly military pensions) consists of transfer payments. There’s nothing much to optimize there without changing the structure of those budget categories.

Where there is something to optimize and where an “ethic of cost containment” can have some effect is in the other two primary budget categories, Defense and Discretionary.

Right now our outlays exceed income by about 40%. That means that if you cut both defense and other discretionary spending to zero, we’ll still be borrowing to finance the federal government. Obviously, we’re not going to cut them to zero. That means we need to look to the mandatory spending categories, the ones that require structural changes, for real deficit reduction.

Social Security is the biggest slice of the pie but it isn’t Social Security that’s driving all of the spending beyond what we’re taking in. Last year Social Security paid out in benefits about 8% more than it took in. Nominally, that draws down the Social Security Trust Fund—the amount by which revenues from FICA have exceed the Social Security outlays over the years. That gap could be reduced by raising the retirement age, increasing FICA max, further graduating the schedule of benefits, or some combination of the above.

What’s really driving all of the spending beyond our means is healthcare spending and optimization isn’t the key there. Reducing costs is, whether by getting more for the money we’re spending (my preference) or reducing the benefits paid by any number of means, e.g. raising the Medicare eligibility age, graduating the reimbursement rate based on income, or any number of other schemes (which I believe will become decreasingly effective over time).

That pie chart is the reason I keep harping on defense spending and healthcare spending. It’s a fundamental principle of optimization that you optimize where there’s something to optimize and defense and healthcare spending are where the action is.

8 comments

Where the Money Is

I stumbled across the graph above and found it interesting. It ain’t the Apples, Motorolas, Samsungs, or app developers of the world that are making the big bucks from the mobile device gold rush. It’s the operators—the ATTs, Verizons, and so on.

I expect the complaints about the operators to start mounting to the point where political pressure is re-applied.

Update

The total sales of all of the hundreds of thousands of apps is estimated to be around $7 billion in 2013. I’ll leave it to the interested reader to place that on the graph above.

I was going to write a post on this subject a while ago, did the research, and never got around to writing the post. Most apps don’t even make back their cost of development.

9 comments