What’s a Capital Gain?

I think it makes sense to tax capital gains at a lower rate than ordinary income. However, that does lead to the question what is a capital gain? In an op-ed in the Wall Street Journal John Gordon Steele argues that carried interest is not a capital gain and, consequently, should be taxed as ordinary income:

To defend the favored treatment of carried interest, private-equity and hedge-fund owners argue that their share of the customers’ gains is analogous to “founders stock,” which is granted to the founders of a company when it goes public, even though they may not have personally invested money in the venture.

This analogy is bogus when the companies in which a fund is invested are not actively managed. A founder has a bright idea. He works hard to convince others of its worth so that they will invest in it. He works hard to get the company off the ground, investing his time and his sweat equity in the business (not to mention the forgone income from the 9-to-5 job he could have had instead). He is risking a lot: a substantial portion of his working life, his reputation, his potential current income, etc.

What does a hedge-fund manager risk? His is an on-going business, not a start-up. His business is, in effect, giving investment advice to clients. If his advice nets to a profit he is rewarded with a portion of the gain. How does that differ from, say, a lawyer taking a case on a contingency basis and sharing in the award when the case is successfully settled or won? The lawyer is giving legal advice and being compensated for giving good advice. But that compensation is taxed as ordinary income.

This returns to a point we should keep in mind: in terms of how much tax is paid the marginal rate is a lot less important than how you calculate income. And, since not all income is taxed at equal rates, how the income is classified.

10 comments

A Tale of Two Californias

It was the best of times, it was the worst of times, it was the age of wisdom, it was the age of foolishness, it was the epoch of belief, it was the epoch of incredulity, it was the season of Light, it was the season of Darkness, it was the spring of hope, it was the winter of despair, we had everything before us, we had nothing before us, we were all going direct to Heaven, we were all going direct the other way – in short, the period was so far like the present period, that some of its noisiest authorities insisted on its being received, for good or for evil, in the superlative degree of comparison only.

Charles Dickens, A Tale of Two Cities

Dueling opinion writers have taken to the pages of their respective journals to debate what’s happening in the Golden State. For Paul Krugman a California renaissance is on the horizon:

When the national housing bubble burst, California was hit especially hard, and the combined effects of the plunge in home prices and the economic downturn led to sharply reduced revenue. Once more there were gleeful pronouncements of imminent doom: California, declared one pundit after another, is America’s Greece.

Again, however, reports of the state’s demise proved premature. Unemployment in California remains high, but it’s coming down — and there’s a projected budget surplus, in part because the implosion of the state’s Republican Party finally gave Democrats a big enough political advantage to push through some desperately needed tax increases. Far from presiding over a Greek-style crisis, Gov. Jerry Brown is proclaiming a comeback.

while things don’t look nearly as rosy to California native Victor Davis Hanson:

We don’t know the full effects of the latest hikes in income, sales, and gasoline taxes, or the longer-term aftershocks from such a poorly schooled younger generation, or the ripples from looming bankruptcies among our cities, or the full costs of bailing out pension funds, or whether the fiscal assumptions of the budget really will result in a balance.

Millions of us will stay, but thousands of Californians who have enriched the state may not. Sadly, the California legislature operates on the principle that the climate, hip culture, and beautiful panoramas of California will always keep enough high-earners from leaving, and that Napa Valley, Silicon Valley, Central Valley agriculture, the gas-and-oil industry, our great research universities, and Hollywood will continue to thrive, even with the high taxes, ever more regulations, the failed public-school system, soaring outlays in social services, and problems from years of massive illegal immigration. It is as if the current generation of politicians can extract a premium for something that they did not create, but have done their best to destroy.

I think that RealClearPolitics’s Steve Malanga may have it right. There is more than one California economy and they are heading in different directions. After noting the city of Stockton’s municipal bankruptcy and Jerry Brown’s optimistic proclamation, mentioned in both of the posts above, he remarks:

The woes of California’s Central Valley, or its Inland Empire, where unemployment is about 12 percent, are similarly often obscured by the hotter, more appealing economies of places like Silicon Valley. It’s not surprising that the state’s two big municipal bankruptcies right now, in Stockton and San Bernardino, are located in the valley and the empire.

It’s clear where the policy initiatives come from in both states. Though California and New York have ample energy resources buried beneath the surface, each state has declined to pursue them, in the process missing out on the energy-led revival in blue-collar jobs we have seen in places like Texas, North Dakota, West Virginia and Pennsylvania. One recent study by the University of Southern California schools of engineering and public policy estimated that tapping California’s Monterey Shale, which stretches from Modesto in the north to south of Los Angeles, could generate more than 2 million jobs in California. Much of untapped potential is in places being left behind by the budding California recovery, like Stanislaus and Merced counties.

California is big enough and geographically diverse enough to generate a revival that still leaves behind whole swathes of the state. The state may already be there.

Is that what’s happening in California? Two distinct economies and populations that rarely see each other? Is that’s what’s happening in the United States more generally?

The fact that supports that view is the very large number of individuals who remain unemployed, underemployed, or who are so discouraged about their prospects that they’ve stopped looking. Their numbers run into the tens of millions. Contrast them with those in the financial sector and public employees, both of which groups are getting raises. Wall Street bonuses are higher than they were a decade ago, far outstripping Wall Street performance. Here in Chicago the CPS teachers were just awarded a raise substantially in excess of inflation and beyond anything that the performance of the Chicago Public Schools could possibly warrant. Divergence, indeed.

40 comments

Chicago’s “Flash Mob” Violence

The big news in Chicago over the weekend was the several incidents of mob attacks that occurred in the city on Saturday and Sunday:

A 27-year-old woman said she was returning home with her mother Saturday night on the Red Line after a dim sum dinner when a group of girls got on the train at the Monroe station and appeared to want to pick a fight.

“This girl started blowing smoke in my face, and she flicked her cigarette ashes at me,” said the woman, who asked not to be identified. “I said: ‘You need to put that out,’ and the next thing I know there’s all these girls that jumped on top of us.”

They began punching her face and then went for her hair. She believes their attackers had knives or box cutters and padlocks possibly placed inside socks.

“I put my head down between my legs so they would stop beating me in the face, but they were trying to pull my face up and hit me more,” she said. “They ripped out chunks of my hair, and I’ve got a black eye and bruises on my face, and all over my back and shoulder.”

The 11 teenagers arrested in that incident at the CTA’s State/Lake station in the Loop about 6:35 p.m. were among a total of 28 people arrested downtown Saturday night for disturbances that ranged from bumping into passers-by on sidewalks to the attack on the CTA train, authorities said.

The attacks that took place on Saturday were said to have involved as many as 500 people:

Seventeen arrests were made after officers arrived near Chicago and Michigan about 6 p.m. Saturday to find “a number of kids fighting amongst themselves,” Chicago Police News Affairs Officer Amina Greer said.

Marquell Hicks, 18, of the 3200 block of West Diversey, and Bobby K. Rhodes, 19, of the 1100 block of North Cambridge, were each charged with one count of misdemeanor reckless conduct, police said. So were 15 additional juveniles.

Meanwhile, police said Stephanie M. Hosch, 18, of the 1300 block of North Central, and 10 juveniles attacked a group of women aboard a CTA Red Line train about 6:30 p.m. Saturday.

Hosch and the juveniles were each charged with battery. Two juveniles also were charged with strong-arm robbery, police said.

In related news Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel has been promoting Chicago as a tourist destination. I’m sure that these attacks, on top of the widely-publicized homicide rate, will do wonders for Chicago tourism. Maybe a thrill-seekers’ package: visit Chicago, then tour Egypt.

I’m surprised that the conspiracy angle of this story isn’t getting more attention. It’s being said that the young people involved in these attacks organized their group efforts through Facebook. If so, there are records that can be subpoenaed and, if it can be determined that they were planning criminal action, it doesn’t make much difference who was throwing the punches. Even Facebook could get involved. Think that what you don’t know can’t hurt you? Consider the case of Alfred Anaya. I wonder how far that line of thinking can be pushed?

54 comments

Easter Dinner

I didn’t want to make an elaborate meal tonight but I did want to make something festive so I prepared a forestière of ham and mushrooms, pictured above. That’s Will in the background.

It turned out nicely. If I’d wanted to go the whole nine yards, I’d’ve served it with a mornay sauce but, honestly, we don’t need either the salt or the fat so I stopped there.

1 comment

The End of Service, Support, and Reliability

Although both my wife and I have cell phones, we also have a conventional AT&T land line in our home. POTS.

There are any number of good reasons for this. For one, the phone company maintains its own power system and, if you have an old-fashioned dial handset (we do), you can generally make calls on it even during a power outage and when cell phone service has been lost.

This week we began to get complaints from friends calling us on the house phone that our line was always busy. On Thursday we noticed that we had lost dial tone. When we called our house phone from our cells, we got a message saying that the line was busy.

I called AT&T. Hacking my way through the underbrush of AT&T’s voice response system, like Stanley seeking Livingston, I finally reported the outage. The system performed an automated test, found nothing, and asked me to test my phone and call back if I still had a problem without offering me an alternative to schedule service. I had already tested my phone, demonstrating with pretty fair confidence that the problem wasn’t inside the house, and the automated test hadn’t changed anything. I called back and this time was allowed to speak to an actual human support representative. The support representative told me that a service call had been scheduled for the next day afternoon.

The afternoon came and went. Still no dial tone.

I called the support line again. Got a support representative again. This support representative told me she had no record of a previously scheduled service call and told me I could expect a service call some time on Monday. I asked for a written confirmation of that. That flustered her. Apparently, it was off-script. She asked if I wanted to talk to a supervisor. I did. After waiting on hold for about ten minutes, I was told that a supervisor would call me back. Click.

An hour later I received a call from someone identifying herself as an AT&T support supervisor. I repeated the whole rigmarole again. She gave me the URL of a site where I could check the status of my service call, something not apparent from AT&T’s outwards-facing web site. Click.

The next morning (Saturday) at around 9:00am I received a call on my cell, the contact number I had given AT&T. The person on the other end identified himself as an AT&T support technician and said he was about twenty minutes away. Five minutes later he arrived. He checked the line connection box (the Network Interface Device) on the exterior of the house. No problem there. He systematically checked the line backwards from the NID to the pole and from the pole to the phone company’s local switches.

After about an hour he returned, said he’d fixed a few things, gave me his office telephone number (he acknowledged that calling AT&T Customer Care was at best frustrating and at worst useless), and left.

So far, so good. After about 30 hours we’ve still got a dial tone. If I had the inclination in a couple of hours I could jerry-rig a system to verify more-or-less continuous service. I don’t have the inclination. We’ll see.

If AT&T stopped offering landline service tomorrow, I’d be sad. When AT&T continues to bill me for service they’re not providing, it makes me angry. I’m not paying them for intermittent service. I’m paying them for reliability. No reliability—no landline and, make no mistake, they’d lose my business.

My prospective conclusion from all of this is that AT&T doesn’t really care about landline service any more.

13 comments

The Debbie Reynolds Studio Store

This morning on CBS’s Sunday Morning program they interviewed Debbie Reynolds. In the course of the interview they mentioned that she was selling off her significant collection of Hollywood memorabilia. It’s a really remarkable collection, ranging from movie posters and programs to costumes, props, even old movie cameras.

What they didn’t mention is that you can see the collection online including both things that are still available for sale and things that have already been sold. It’s really quite interesting. Take a look, in particular, at the women’s wardrobe which includes outfits worn by Debbie, Ann Blyth, Betty Grable, and Grace Kelly. Just to name a few. I suspect that not many of today’s movie actresses could squeeze into a lot of them even if they were corseted.

The dress at the left was worn by Jennifer Jones when she played Elizabeth Barrett in The Barretts of Wimpole Street. It was designed by Elizabeth Haffenden, who won Academy Awards for Costume Design for Ben-Hur and A Man for All Seasons.

7 comments

The Biggest Ignored News

I’m surprised that this story isn’t getting more attention. The Chinese official reference rate for the yuan is now higher relative to the dollar than at any time since the Chinese authorities began pegging their currency to the dollar 19 years ago:

China’s yuan rose to a 19-year high after the central bank raised its daily reference rate to the strongest level in more than 10 months.

The People’s Bank of China increased the fixing by 0.08 percent to 6.2689 per dollar, the highest since May 2, 2012. The currency is allowed to trade 1 percent either side of the rate. The Purchasing Managers’ Index for manufacturing in March will be 51, indicating a sixth month of expansion, according to the median estimate in a Bloomberg News survey of economists before official data on April 1. President Xi Jinping is on his first foreign visit since taking over earlier this month and has held meetings with the heads of the so-called BRICs nations of Brazil, Russia and India as well as African countries.

I attribute a lot of the loss of manufacturing jobs in the United States as well as the remarkable level of asset inflation over the last several decades to the Chinese government’s management of the yuan.

It’s been suggested that this particular revision is politically motivated, something Xi Jinping can point to in his meeting with foreign leaders. I can’t help but wonder if it also suggests that the Chinese authorities think that the yuan is so undervalued now that letting it rise a bit won’t hurt them much. Or maybe they think that the dollar is weakening, which I’d find surprising since the more uncertainty there is in Europe the more I’d expect the dollar to strengthen.

2 comments

Not Well At All

A comment that was made in a thread here last week to the effect that most people who comment here seemed to be doing all right touched a nerve. My business is not doing all right. I don’t have a huge number of clients and the client I’ve billed the most for many years has cut back drastically. That means my income will fall substantially this year.

We’re not in trouble. My wife has a job she excels at and she earns a good income.

My situation is only related to the stagnant economy very indirectly. It’s a combination of my own darned fault and bad decisions (against my advice) made by my client.

About 15 years ago I stopped prospecting as hard as I should have. I had plenty of business, as much as I cared to do. I even turned down some work. I knew better than that but I did it anyway. Now the hole in my schedule that used to be filled by that one client looks a lot larger.

I’ve never planned on retiring. I still don’t. Right now what I’m doing looks a lot more like retirement than like working. Unfortunately, most of my contacts are dead or retired and, well, the world has changed. To bring in the business that I want I’ll need to work a lot harder than I’m accustomed to. It wouldn’t be what a friend of mine calls my “highest and best use” but stocking shelves at Whole Foods looks better all the time.

18 comments

Your Cheery Reading for Today

After explaining that when you deposit money in a bank, it becomes the bank’s property which they’ve historically been required to surrender on demand, Web of Debt outlines the revised process that the FDIC and the Bank of England have been discussing:

Under the FDIC-BOE plan, our IOUs will be converted into “bank equity.” The bank will get the money and we will get stock in the bank. With any luck we may be able to sell the stock to someone else, but when and at what price? Most people keep a deposit account so they can have ready cash to pay the bills.

[…]

No exception is indicated for “insured deposits” in the U.S., meaning those under $250,000, the deposits we thought were protected by FDIC insurance. This can hardly be an oversight, since it is the FDIC that is issuing the directive. The FDIC is an insurance company funded by premiums paid by private banks. The directive is called a “resolution process,” defined elsewhere as a plan that “would be triggered in the event of the failure of an insurer . . . .” The only mention of “insured deposits” is in connection with existing UK legislation, which the FDIC-BOE directive goes on to say is inadequate, implying that it needs to be modified or overridden.

If our IOUs are converted to bank stock, they will no longer be subject to insurance protection but will be “at risk” and vulnerable to being wiped out, just as the Lehman Brothers shareholders were in 2008.

Read the whole, depressing thing. Hat tip: Angry Bear

As a thought experiment, consider why banks are of public concern at all. In truth they shouldn’t be any more than we’re worried about a furniture store going out of business. The concern that most people have about banks is the security of their deposits. Now remove that security. Who benefits directly from banks being held safe regardless of their behavior? Indirectly?

On the bright side, going long on manufacturers of rope, guillotines, and ammo looks better every day.

14 comments

Me and Self-Checkout

The first time I ever encountered self-checkout was, amazingly, nearly twenty years ago in a supermarket in Scotland. My immediate reaction was that the idea would have difficulty in the States because of shrinkage. U. S. stores have fixed that by having sales clerks who are notionally watchful for walk-outs but who also render the whole point sort of moot.

Self-checkout is perfect for me. I’m a daily shopper, rarely if ever buy more than a handful of items at a time, and really, really understand how to use POS terminals (I was integrating them into store operations at one point in my career—I know almost too much about them).

My beloved Happy Foods, where I do most of my shopping, does not have self-checkout. It has young, cute, pleasant, cheery young cashiers who, since they see me every day, know who I am, in some cases addressing me by name.

2 comments