How Big Is the Federal Government?

I’d been meaning to work this little fact into a post but I’m tired of saving the link so I’ll put it into a post of its own. Why do people insist on measuring the size of the federal government in terms of how many federal employees there are? We don’t measure companies by how many employees there are or states by how many people they employ. According to Fortune Magazine, the largest company in the United States is Exxon-Mobil with revenues of $453 billion. Wal-Mart (Fortune’s second largest company with revenues of $447 billion) has the largest number of employees.

Federal spending, of course, is higher every year. Yes, the number of federal employees isn’t nearly as large as it was once upon a time. However, the federal payroll is higher than ever:

The size of the executive branch’s payroll is expected to near a record $177 billion in fiscal 2012 — almost $35 billion more than the compensation costs for fiscal 2008.

And even with the Obama administration’s two-year freeze on some pay raises for executive branch civilians, their direct compensation for 2012 is expected to be $9 billion — or 5 percent — more than in 2010. Much of this increase would result from a plan to grow the federal full-time workforce by 15,000 in 2012. Direct compensation includes base pay, premium pay such as overtime, locality pay, recruitment, retention and relocation bonuses, performance awards, and cost-of-living and overseas allowances.

That 5 percent two-year increase is lower than previous two-year periods. For example, between 2008 and 2010, direct compensation costs increased by $25 billion, or 18 percent.

When benefits such as health insurance, life insurance and retirement fund contributions are included, total executive branch personnel costs are projected to top $242 billion in 2012, about $12.7 billion, or 5 percent, higher than in 2010.

The government’s total personnel costs — including the legislative and judicial branches, the U.S. Postal Service and military service members — are expected to reach a record $461 billion next year.

I have no idea which U. S. company has the highest total payroll in United States or the highest median wage. It would be interesting but it’s hard to ferret out.

I do know that you can’t determine the size or influence of the federal government by counting heads.

28 comments

Personal Computers Aren’t Too Good

They’re just good enough. The other day the Wall Street Journal reported, rather breathlessly, that “PC sales are in free fall”:

The personal computer is in crisis, and getting little help from Microsoft Corp.’s Windows 8 software once seen as a possible savior.

Research firm IDC issued an alarming report Wednesday for PC makers such as Dell Inc. and Hewlett-Packard Co., saying world-wide shipments of laptops and desktops fell 14% in the first quarter from a year earlier. That is the sharpest drop since IDC began tracking this data in 1994 and marks the fourth straight quarter of declines.

Gartner Inc., a rival research firm, estimated global shipments sank 11.2%, which it called the worst drop since the first quarter of 2001. Gartner blamed the rise of tablets and smartphones, which are sapping demand for personal computers.

Will Oremus says it’s because “they’ve gotten too good”:

It’s certainly true that people are increasingly spending money on new tablets and smartphones rather than new computers. But reports of the PC’s demise are grossly exaggerated. If the PC is dead, what am I typing this on? If the PC is dead, what are office-workers all over the world sitting in front of all day while they work? The reason people aren’t buying new PCs isn’t that they don’t need a PC. It’s that, for the most part, they’re getting along just fine with the one they already have.

I agree that various other kinds of computers including smartphones and tablets are eating into PC sales. I also agree that “they’re getting along just fine” with the PCs they already have.

However, to really understand why the market for desktop and notebook computers has declined you need to go back about twenty years. From the early 90s to the early Aughts many businesses replaced their desktop and portable computers roughly every three years. Generally, that wasn’t because they weren’t working or not able to perform the tasks they were needed for. It was to suit Microsoft’s development cycle. At that point Microsoft was releasing new major revisions roughly every three years: Windows 95, Windows 98, Windows XP (released in 2001). Each of those major revisions preserved the investment in training and ancillary software of its predecessors while being so much more reliable, secure, or capable that sticking with the old version could hardly be justified.

Gauging its new releases to suit its revenue goals rather than the needs of its customers is nothing new for Microsoft. However, I think that Microsoft has made a titanic miscalculation with Windows 8. Windows 8 takes just too much retraining and as well as I’ve been able to tell gives Microsoft’s corporate customers nothing they particularly want. Why should they replace their inventories of Windows 7 desktops and laptops like good little soldiers to further Microsoft’s needs rather than their own?

I suspect that Microsoft sees Windows 8 as sacrificing a knight to gain the opponent’s queen. I doubt that it will work out that way.

Microsoft released Windows 95, appropriately enough, in 1995. That was just as the tidal wave that was Internet connectivity was just beginning to crest. Windows 95 did not include either a web browser or TCP/IP as built-in parts of the operating system (although they were available as add-ons). In 1996 in a move of great agility for a company that had been pooh-poohing the Internet for years, Microsoft released Windows 95 SR 1 and that did, indeed, include Internet Explorer 2.0 and TCP/IP as standard parts of the operating system.

That was nearly twenty years ago. We’ll see if Microsoft still has the ability to recover from major strategic errors.

PC sales aren’t in free fall. They’re just seeking their natural level without the planned obsolescence that affected the market for so long. The PC market is a mature one. There will continue to be millions even billions of people huddled behind display devices at the keyboards of their desktops and notebook computers and that will be the case for the foreseeable future. For reading their email or surfing the web more and more people will use tablets or their phones.

One more note: nobody ever bought a smartphone or tablet to play first person shooters and recently the PC game business has been doing better than the game console business. PCs are far from going the way of the punched card or even the 3.5 inch diskette. The computer ecosphere is just getting more diversified.

17 comments

Borrowing Too Little?

There’s a fascinating post from David Andolfatto of the St. Louis Fed I want to draw to your attention. The comments are genuinely worth reading. Is it possible that the Treasury is not selling enough bonds? Is it the case?

1 comment

Gross Domestic Product (Expenditure Method)

Over the last week I’ve shown a series of charts depicting

Personal consumption
Business investment
Government spending
Exports
Imports

Using what’s referred to as the “expenditure method”, gross domestic product, a measure of economic activity, is calculated

GDP = C + I + G + X – M

where

C is personal consumption
I is business investment
G is government spending
X is exports
M is imports

Policy for many years but particularly over the last dozen years has been intended to increase personal consumption. Given that the U. S. economy already depends more highly on personal consumption expenditures than any other developed economy, I doubt that personal consumption can be goosed much more than it already has been.

Government spending is already at historic levels as a proportion of GDP. All non-federal government spending is derived from one of two sources: taxes or borrowing. State and local governments are already strapped; they have taxed as much as has been politically possible and their increased borrowing has resulted in loss of credit rating, i.e. borrowing is become increasingly expensive for them.

The federal government has another arrow in its quiver not available to state and local governments. In addition to taxing or borrowing the federal government can simply print money or, if you would prefer, extend credit. Doing so will ultimately produce inflation or, possibly, hyperinflation. The absence of high inflation at the level of the ordinary consumer suggests that there’s still some headroom for this. My own suspicion is that asset inflation and, due to the perverse nature of our system, commodity inflation in the things that rich people buy are already upon us. I consider the print money/extend credit strategy pretty risky and, indeed, uncontrollable. You won’t know that you’ve created a problem until it’s too late to do anything about it.

I’ve already expressed my opinion of exports as a major source of economic growth for the U. S. I think we’re too big and too rich to have an export-driven economy.

Our imports, which by definition reduce economic activity, come in two flavors: oil and other. We are already reducing our imports of oil and I expect that trend to continue, at least for the near future. That will help a bit. I think we need to reduce our “other” imports. Having worked for a foreign company, I think that our imports are drastically underestimated. For example, intra-company transfers are not considered to be imports.

Domestic business investment has received far too little attention over the last half dozen years. Business investment in real estate, where much has been focused, doesn’t do much to produce the products, services, and industries of tomorrow. I’ve frequently heard it said that “we just aren’t as rich as we thought we were” and that’s probably true. What’s also true but has largely gone unrecognized is that the return on investment wasn’t as high as we thought it was. Or, said another way, the world is a riskier place than we thought it was. Businesses became accustomed to unrealistically high and improbably safe rates of return. Now they’re gun-shy.

I think the emphasis of policy needs to turn to increasing domestic business investment in something other than real estate and reducing imports. Or, alternatively, we can just shamble along at our below 2% GDP growth and let the unemployed stay that way.

29 comments

Government Spending

The graph above depicts federal, state, and local government spending from 1946 to the present. As I think is apparent, there are a number of inflection points, notably in the 1990s where the rate of increase declined, around 2000 where it increased again, and recently during the Great Recession when it very nearly went vertical which I presume is the influence of the ARRA.

Here’s the same graph in log form:

3 comments

Imports

Here’s a graph of imports of goods and services since 1960. The original graph produced by FRED illustrates imports as negative, presumably since they decrease GDP. I’ve rectified the graph to show them as positive so that imports can be compared visually more easily to the other factors I’ve highlighted. Here’s another one that shows imports of goods and services excluding oil, also rectified.

5 comments

Foreign Policy Blogging at OTB

I’ve just published a foreign policy-related post at Outside the Beltway:

The Most Anti-China Article You’ll Read Today

What’s the most serious issue in the world today? North Korea’s nuclear weapons? Iranian nuclear weapons development? Education? U. S. fiscal policy?

I think there’s a good argument to be made that the most dire problem in the world today is environmental degradation in China. Over at OTB I take brief note of an article over at Foreign Affairs addressing that very topic.

1 comment

Exports

The graph above illustrates U. S. exports of goods and services from 1929 to the present.

This might be a good time to repeat an observation I’ve made before: only the math-challenged and fantasists can believe that future U. S. economic growth can be driven primarily by exports. There are any number of reasons for this but the most important are that if U. S. global market share increased to the level that would be required it would be genuinely alarming to our trading partners who would surely take remedial action and, frankly, we’re too rich and the rest of the world isn’t rich enough.

Can exports grow? Sure. But the U. S. economy can never be as export-driven as China’s, Japan’s, or even Germany’s.

Comment.

For log fans:

5 comments

Is the Divorce Complete?

The late Sen. Daniel Patrick Moynihan is said to have remarked that “Everyone is entitled to his own opinion but not his own facts”. The last dozen or so years have proved him wrong. Everyone does now have his or her own facts and are frequently completely unaware that there may be other, contradictory facts.

This morning in my meanderings through the media and the blogosphere I was astonished at the remarkable separation between the stories that are being covered by the left and right sides of the media and blogosphere.

I’m used to different opinions on the same story. So, for example, when Margaret Thatcher died I wasn’t surprised to hear some extolling her as a near-saint while others castigated as an historic villainess. After all, where you sit is where you stand. But it does surprise me that the stories being commented on are so distinct. On one side there’s outrage over President Obama’s proposal to use “chained CPI” in the formula for calculating cost of living adjustments in Social Security. BTW, contrary to what you might be reading, doing so would reduce no one’s social security benefits. It would only potentially reduce the increases in benefits below what they might otherwise be. Any number of Democratic senators have drawn themselves up to the full heights and condemned this as a cut in Social Security benefits which was completely and permanently unacceptable, a canard.

On the other side you’ll read harsh denunciations of North Korea’s saber-rattling. I think that’s premature.

It’s not that what’s being talked about isn’t newsworthy. It’s that what they’re deeming newsworthy is so distinct.

12 comments

Direct

The escalating situation on the Korean peninsula, if not the most significant story of the day, is certainly one of the most significant stories:

(CNN) — The Obama administration calculates it’s likely North Korea may test fire mobile ballistic missiles at any time, based on the most recent intelligence showing Pyongyang probably has completed launch preparations, a U.S. official said Tuesday.

The administration believes a test launch could happen without North Korea issuing a standard notice to commercial aviation and maritime shipping warning them to stay away from the missile’s path, according to the official, who declined to be named because of the sensitivity of the information.

He cautioned most of the information comes from satellite imagery, so it’s impossible to reach a definitive conclusion because the United States has no means to gather information on the ground.

Here’s the part that took me up short:

Also Tuesday, the top U.S. commander in the Pacific called repeated North Korean violations of U.N. Security Council resolutions forbidding the “building and testing” of long-range ballistic missiles and nuclear weapons “a clear and direct threat to U.S. national security and regional peace and stability.”

Is that really the case? Or does the general mean “direct” in the sense of “indirect”, as some people say “literally” when they mean “figuratively”?

I think that the North Koreans’ statements and actions comprise a direct threat to the troops we have stationed in South Korea. There is a simple remedy to that threat: remove them. I think that the North Koreans’ words are, obviously, a direct threat. Threatening us with nuclear annihilation meets just about anybody’s definition of “direct threat”. I don’t know that anybody takes that threat seriously, however. Saying something is one thing. Having the ability to carry it out is something else entirely again.

I think that the North Koreans’ statements and actions comprise a direct threat to our allies in the area. But those are not a direct threat to us. They’re indirect ones.

16 comments