Not Likely

A few days ago I tried to get a little brainstorming going on the subject of technology as the primary explanation for the too slow rate of job creation. Obviously, either I failed to pique anybody’s interest or none of my few readers can find any supporting evidence for the idea that I didn’t.

As a follow-up, I’ll present some of the reasons why I think it’s unlikely that automation is the most significant reason for slow job growth following the Great Recession:

  • Very few significant new technologies have been deployed since 2007. The only technological developments I can think of since then are the growth of social media and smartphones gaining critical mass. Most of the decline in employment and/or decline in job growth as a result of automation had already taken place by 2007.
  • It’s not happening everywhere. Germany’s unemployment has actually declined sharply since 2007.
  • The actual decline is relatively small. Two or three percentage points. I can’t believe that automation and harnessing breakthrough technolgoies can only wring out that small a fraction of employment.
  • The number of jobs is still growing. It’s just not growing fast enough to keep up with the increase in population or bring the people who lost their jobs from 2007 to 2009 back o work.
  • There are plenty of explanations other than automation for slow job growth.

Now let’s try brainstorming the reasons that automation is not the main factor behind the too slow job growth of the last few years (or the last dozen years, for that matter).

8 comments

Personal Consumption Expenditures

The graph above illustrates personal consumption expenditures over the last roughly 50 years. For those of you who like logs, here’s the natural log of the same data:

The kink representing the late recession is pretty apparent. I also think I see points of inflection in the 1990s representing the dot-com bubble, around 1999 when it ended, and in the early Aughts which could be interpreted as the beginning of the housing bubble.

I guess there are a number of ways of interpreting this chart. Some people would say PCE should be a little higher than it is now. I don’t see how it could be much.

Comment.

2 comments

Busy Day

It’s going to be a busy day I plan on writing posts hacking away at GDP, on technology as an explanation for persistent unemployment, and on the peculiar diction of a Pentagon statement on North Korea. Maybe I’ll get around to them today, maybe not. Stay tuned.

0 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The post on the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

Sometimes a Cigar Is Just a Cigar

Am I being paranoid or does anyone else get nervous when there are reports of seismic activities near the areas in which Iran is doing its nuclear development:

(Reuters) – A powerful earthquake struck close to Iran’s only nuclear power station on Tuesday, killing 32 people and injuring 850 as it destroyed homes and devastated two small villages, Iranian media reported.

The 6.3 magnitude quake totally destroyed one village, a Red Crescent official told the Iranian Students’ News Agency (ISNA), but the nearby Bushehr nuclear plant was undamaged, according to Iranian officials and the Russian company that built it.

The news report focuses on one of the areas of concern: apparently, the Bushehr plant was undamaged. But that’s not the only concern. Was it an earthquake? Did the earthquake have some help?

It’s certainly jolly that the Iranians are dong their nuclear research in an area that seismically active.

3 comments

What Do Civil Engineers Do?

Over at Bloomberg there was a remarkably sound column on civil infrastructure. Here’s the response to those who complain about “our crumbling infrastructure”:

The nation would benefit from reordering its infrastructure priorities — away from new highways, for example, where we are already overbuilt and usage is falling for the first extended period on record. And we’d do well to take advantage of low interest rates and idle construction resources to knock out all of our future infrastructure needs.

But the idea that the U.S. has an infrastructure crisis? No. A broad, permanent increase in spending is unwarranted.

It’s in the middle of the pack. Between 2001 and 2011, annual public investment averaged 3.3 percent of gross domestic product, according to the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development. The average OECD nation spent 3 percent of GDP over the same period.

A 2011 study by Marco Percoco, a professor at Bocconi University in Italy, shows that U.S. public investment has tracked the OECD average since at least 1970. Developed nations invest between 2 percent and 3.5 percent of GDP. The U.S. is about where it should be — close to peer nations such as Canada, Germany and Australia. Nations that spend substantially more tend to be in a phase of catch-up growth, such as South Korea and Poland

I wonder if any report is more misused than the annual report card on America’s infrastructure offered by the ASCE, the civil engineers’ professional organization.

Civil engineers design roads and bridges and produce plans for building them soundly and efficiently. They do not determine which roads and bridges are worth building or maintaining. Those are the things that are determined by the political process.

In a world of infinite resources we’d bring every road and bridge up to peak condition. We don’t live in that world. In the world we do live in we need to decide whether we want to build or refurbish bridges that serve a dozen people and for which there are ready alternatives or reduce the number of kids in each school classroom (just to give an example). When the people being served by a bridge don’t think it’s worth maintaining, I’m willing to bow to their judgement. The bridge will show up in the ASCE report card anyway.

4 comments

Gross Domestic Private Investment

This is one of the components of GDP. Comment.

Update

Here’s the natural log of the GPDI over the same period:

6 comments

Thought Experiment

Imagine that the young Bill Clinton were running for Arkansas attorney general for the first time right now. Would he be running as a Democrat or as a Republican?

To make it through the Democratic primary he would need to swerve to the left. To make it through the Republican primary he would need to swerve to the right.

I don’t think he’d run at all. If you absolutely, positively demanded that I pick one or the other, I’d say that he’d still run as a Democrat because of the importance of issues of race to him but that he’d lose in the primary.

19 comments

Math Problems

Okay, you mathematicians out there. Consider these two math problems. Imagine an urn filled with 150 balls. 149 of the balls are white. 1 of the balls is black. Assuming equal odds of any given ball being drawn, in ten draws from the urn what are the odds that the black ball will be drawn?

Problem 1: What are the odds if each time a ball is drawn out it’s put back into the urn?

Problem 2: What are the odds if each time a ball is drawn it is not put back into the urn?

Note that the odds of the black ball being drawn are different in those two problems. In the probability and statistics game that’s referred to as “with replacement” (the first problem) and “without replacement” (the second). Now go back and read this post.

7 comments

Why Aren’t They Working?

Yesterday in comments I wrote the following:

Old demographic argument: the Baby Boomers’ retiring explains the decreasing labor force participation rate

New demographic argument: people aged 20-24 staying in school longer explains the decreasing labor force participation rate

I actually think there’s a kernel of truth in each of those explanation but even in combination they don’t fully explain the decrease in the LFPR.

Similarly, there’s a kernel of truth in automation as an explanation for sluggish job growth but it doesn’t explain most of it.

My candidates for additional factors: low wages for the jobs being created (immigration contributes to this), extension of benefits, multiple job families, Chinese currency manipulation, underwater on houses, taking care of elderly parents, “sticky wages” across too broad a swathe of the economy (I’m working on a post on this one), and uncertainty.

A couple of days ago in the Washington Post, an article sounded similar themes:

Perplexingly, the driving force behind the decline does not appear to be baby boomers beginning to retire, an event economists have long predicted would shrink the size of the workforce. It’s people in the prime of their working years, ages 25 to 54, who began tumbling out of the job market in the early 2000s and have continued to disappear during the recovery.

[…]

“Prime-aged people are working less, and we don’t know why,” said Betsey Stevenson, a labor economist and associate professor at the University of Michigan. “I get concerned because there are a lot of people who have useful and productive skills that could really contribute to the economy, and we’re just failing to find ways to get them involved.”

The easiest explanation for vanishing prime-aged workers is the weak job market: The economy just isn’t creating enough new jobs to keep job-seekers engaged, so many of them are getting frustrated and abandoning their search for work.

People respond to the incentives they have. That’s true whether you’re a lender, a borrower, or somebody deciding whether to enter the job market. If you don’t believe (with good justification) that you’ll find a job or, at least, a job that’s worth doing, you might elect to get more education in the hopes that a few years down the road with a bit more education under your belt you might be able to land something better. The king may die, the donkey may die, etc.

As a thought experiment let’s brainstorm one of the explanations for slow job growth: automation. That’s variously expressed as “robots” and “computers”. Let’s consider the evidence that’s actually the major factor. I’ve wracked my brain and I can only come up with two supporting arguments:

  1. Job growth has been sluggish for the last decade.
  2. Automation has reduced the number of menial jobs, high-paying repetitive jobs, and even clerical jobs.

In this exercise rather than criticizing the hypothesis let’s try to come up with supporting evidence.

Have we reached the point where work has become obsolete?

6 comments