Getting Congress to Move

James Taranto uses this:

The idea behind furloughing air traffic controllers was to inflict pain on ordinary Americans–or, as Klein calls them, “the politically powerful”–so as to pressure Republicans to raise taxes and to forgo cuts in inessential spending–or, as Klein calls it, “programs that affects [sic] the politically powerless.” Instead it was Democrats who felt pressure. The House vote on the Reducing Flight Delays Act was 361-41, with just 29 Democrats and 12 Republicans in dissent. The Senate didn’t even bother with a vote, passing the bill by unanimous consent.

as a point of departure for remarking on how the tactics of a community organizer can fall flat. I take a different lesson from it: despite the sharp ideological polarization in today’s Congress it’s still able to reach nearly unanimous interest with astonishing rapidity when it’s in their interest to do so.

That’s why I continue believe that some combination of persuasion, moral suasion, loyalty, friendship, threats of primary challenges, logrolling, and outright payoffs—the traditional political arsenal—would enable the president to accomplish more with the Republicans in Congress than he has to date.

It just takes one example to prove that something is possible. Over the last five years there have been hundreds, some trivial, some more important. It’s worth a try.

4 comments

How Keynesian of Me

Just a reminder. My view on fiscal stimulus is that governments should pay down debt during recoveries to that they are able to engage in fiscal stimulus during economic downturns without having an adverse effect on growth. I also think it is better for governments to serve as the employer of last resort than as the consumer of last resort.

Somehow, mysteriously, the provision of services on behalf of those in need always seems to transmogrify into benefits for those providing services while largely ignoring the conditions of those actually in need.

11 comments

Perseveration

If you’re not familiar with the word, “perseveration” means the repetition, continuing, or prolongation of an action long after its initial stimulus and beyond a reasonable point. It seems to me that today’s opinion journalism largely consists of perseveration.

What they’re perseverating about today: ObamaCare, Syria, debt, and how awful the Republican Congressional leadership is.

1 comment

There Will Be Social Deviants

If you’ve never read it or if it’s been a long time since you’ve read it, I’d encourage you to read Daniel Patrick Moynihan’s famous article, “Defining Deviancy Down”. It can be found online here.

He opens by noting that the number of deviants recognized by a society is quite stable over time (“the Durkheim constant”), expands on this with an analysis of how societies promote stability by defining deviancy with a particular focus on marriage, child-rearing, and violent crime, and concludes with this:

The hope—if there be such—of this essay has been twofold. It is, first, to suggest that the Durkheim constant, as I put it, is maintained by a dynamic process which adjusts upwards and downwards. Liberals have traditionally been alert for upward redefining that does injustice to individuals. Conservatives have been correspondingly sensitive to downward redefining that weakens societal standards. Might it not help if we could all agree that there is a dynamic at work here? It is not revealed truth, nor yet a scientifically derived formula. It is simply a pattern we observe in ourselves. Nor is it rigid. There may once have been an unchanging supply of jail cells which more or less determined the number of prisoners. No longer. We are building new prisons at a prodigious rate. Similarly, the executioner is back. There is something of a competition in Congress to think up new offenses for which the death penalty is seemed the only available deterrent. Possibly also modes of execution, as in “fry the kingpins.” Even so, we are getting used to a lot of behavior that is not good for us.

The article contains plenty of the aphorisms for which Sen. Moynihan was famous, e.g. “There is good money to be made out of bad schools.” Although the article is more than twenty years old now, I find much of it as fresh and applicable now as it was then. We could use public intellectuals of his sort again.

0 comments

Hot Presentation/Cool Presentation

My wife pointed out an Apple app, Explain Everything, to me. Here’s their presentation:

Marshall McLuhan used to talk about “hot media” and “cool media”. Using those terms a PowerPoint presentation is “hot” relative to an “Explain Everything” presentation which I think is cool by practically any standard.

7 comments

Foreign Policy Blogging at OTB

I’ve just published a foreign policy-related post at Outside the Beltway:

Why China and Russia Don’t Do Soft Power

Joseph Nye, who very literally wrote the book on soft power, explains why it’s not so effective for Russia or China.

0 comments

The Domestic Use of Drones

There’s a good article at RealClearPolitics on the domestic use of UAVs, drone aircraft. I think that increasingly this will be a hot button issue. RCP summarizes it this way: “Crops may not care if they are silently watched from the skies, but many people do.”

I can also think of a half dozen potential counter-weapons and I strongly suspect that those will become increasingly sophisticated fast.

0 comments

What If Fairies Are Real?

Paul Krugman, Noah Smith, and others have written derisively about the “Uncertainty Fairy”, alternatively the “Confidence Fairy”. What if fairies are real?

Three economists, Stanford University’s Nicholas Bloom and Scott Baker and the University of Chicago’s Steven Davis, have done invaluable work measuring the level of policy uncertainty over the past few decades. Their research (available at policyuncertainty.com) shows that, on average, U.S. economic policy uncertainty has been 50% higher in the past two years than it has been since 1985.

Based on that research, our economists at Vanguard isolated changes in the U.S. economy that we determined were specifically due to increases in policy uncertainty, such as the debt-ceiling debacle in August 2011, the congressional supercommittee failure in November 2011, and the fiscal-cliff crisis at the end of 2012. This gave us a picture of what the economy might look like if the shocks from policy uncertainty had not occurred.

We estimate that since 2011 the rise in overall policy uncertainty has created a $261 billion cumulative drag on the economy (the equivalent of more than $800 per person in the country). Without this uncertainty tax, real U.S. GDP could have grown an average 3% per year since 2011, instead of the recorded 2% average in fiscal years 2011-12. In addition, the U.S. labor market would have added roughly 45,000 more jobs per month over the past two years. That adds up to more than one million jobs that we could have had by now, but don’t.

I think that one of Bill Clinton’s unnoted accomplishments was his ability to act as cheerleader for the American economy and one of George W. Bush’s greatest weaknesses his lack of ability to create similar confidence. There was a sharp drop in the Dow when Bush took office. I attribute at least some of that to the Clinton effect. I have repeatedly questioned President Obama’s talking down of the economy, something that began even before he took office.

I’m not saying that the president should be engaging in happy talk in the face of disaster. What I think is that it’s possible to strike a balance. Read some of Franklin Roosevelt’s “fireside chats”.

And I don’t disagree that faster economic growth would have dispelled some of the uncertainty. However, if you don’t know how to produce growth (or are unwilling or unable to do what it takes to produce growth), there are other ways of fostering greater confidence. Why not try that for a change?

34 comments

Illinois Is Not Bankrupt

I take exception to this headline at Illinois Watch:

“Deadbeat, bankrupt Illinois now in charge of high-speed rail buying spree”

Illinois is arguably deadbeat but it is certainly not bankrupt. Bankruptcy is defined as the legal status of a individual or organization that is unable to pay the debts it owes to creditors. That isn’t Illinois’s problem. Illinois continues to be able to pay its bondholders even at the increased rates required by Illinois’s falling credit rating.

Illinois’s problem is that the increases in wages and benefits it has promised are not being matched by increases in Illinois’s revenues. I have argued that it will be difficult for Illinois to increase its revenues to cover those commitments, predicated as they were on very different expectations than now appear to be the case. What Illinois needs to do is bring its commitments into line with what it can expect to receive in revenues. Illinois’s elected officials have steadfastly refused to do that because they don’t want to take the consequences.

Here in Chicago the Chicago Public School teachers were granted a whopping raise for which the city’s ability to pay is in very serious doubt. The city’s solution to its problem is to trim the number of teachers which the teachers, understandably, object. Chicago’s politicians do not have the moral fiber to face the hard truth.

The most significant public bankruptcy in Illinois is the moral bankruptcy on the part of its elected officials.

Four of Illinois’s last nine governors have served time in prison, in all but one case on charges of corruption in office.

2 comments

There Will Be Consequences

I think that Robert Samuelson’s column in the Washington Post can be summarized in the four word title of this post. In the column he describes how public and private safety nets have eroded over time, how our expectations in what services government would provide and what we’re willing to pay for them have not been fulfilled, and how the implications of the choices we’ve made for how we live our lives weigh on the society in which we live those lives. He characterizes those things as “entitlements”. I think that a better characterization would be foreseeable and non-foreseeable consequences.

I think he concludes the column on a not terribly realistic note of optimism. I think the lesson that is most likely to be learned from the experiences of the last several years is why work if you don’t particularly enjoy what you’re doing and the rewards will be determined not by your hard work or ingenuity but by your ability to secure benefits from government at some level.

5 comments