The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

Is the Market for Smartphones Mature?

That’s what Jason Perlow is saying here:

The bottom line is that the buying public has certain basic expectations of what needs to be in smartphones, and that water mark is already pretty high, and may have been reached as much as two years ago.

So that we aren’t treating the mainstream reviews as those that are anomalous, Mossberg and Pogue’s S4 viewpoints and commentaries are consistent with reviews that have been published on numerous technology reporting sites and enthusiast blogs, ZDNet included.

The smartphone device category is well-defined even within the sub-classifications such as phablets. You expect performance to be snappy regardless of how many cores are on the SoC that the phone uses, you expect the latest OS build.

You expect the rear-facing camera to take high-quality stills and video, you expect a front-facing HD camera for doing video chat, and you expect the device to have a high-resolution screen regardless of size that produces sharp, crisp video and has excellent color saturation and luminosity. And you expect the phone to be 4G LTE capable.

In the United States people upgrade their smartphones to the rhythm of their contract renewal with their carriers. In a mature market the way you get new customers is by convincing a customer who is using a competitor’s product to use yours. With smartphones the opportunity to do that occurs roughly every two years.

If this year’s phones have roughly the same performance and features that those two years ago did, it looks very much as though innovation in smartphones has slowed to a crawl or ended. IMO the next real innovation in smartphones will be form factor. Why, for example, are smartphones rectangular?

8 comments

Diversification

John Carney has a puzzle. Why are stocks booming despite a lackluster economy? He may have found part of the answer:

Another lackluster quarter of economic growth is likely to have the same impact on the market as its predecessors—which is to say, not much.

Despite a prolonged period of weak improvement in gross domestic product, stocks have continued on a progressive, albeit bumpy, ride higher.

The 136 percent stock market surge over the past four years has come despite the weakest recovery since the Great Depression, and more recently signs that those expecting a period of stronger growth will be disappointed.

No matter, though, as investor—riding a wave of Federal Reserve liquidity and sentiment that the U.S. remains a safer store of money than its troubled global competitors—keep buying despite the slow economy.

The folks at BusinessWeek expand on that:

In a survey of 60 central bankers this month by Central Banking Publications and Royal Bank of Scotland Group Plc, 23 percent said they own shares or plan to buy them. The Bank of Japan, holder of the second-biggest reserves, said April 4 it will more than double investments in equity exchange-traded funds to 3.5 trillion yen ($35.2 billion) by 2014. The Bank of Israel bought stocks for the first time last year while the Swiss National Bank and the Czech National Bank have boosted their holdings to at least 10 percent of reserves.

If I understand things correctly the central banks issue credit to themselves, use the credit to purchase equities, the value of stocks rise, and the dealers in equities take commissions and pay themselves bonuses.

Now on to the next puzzle. Why is the inequality in incomes increasing?

19 comments

What If We’ve Been Growing Faster Than We Thought?

I’ve been thinking about the Bureau of Economic Analysis’s plan to change how they calculate real GDP by adding R&D and intangible property of the class known “entertainment, literary and artistic originals” to business investment while treating promised pensions as liabilities. Keep in mind what I’ve mentioned before: that GDP is personal consumption expenditures plus business investment plus government spending plus exports less imports.

Imagine that the Great Recalculation results in real GDP growing substantially faster over the period of the last 30 years than we had previously thought. I’m not saying that’s the case, I’m just saying “imagine”. That would scuttle Okun’s Law.

“Okun’s Law” is the rule of thumb that employment grows with GDP (or, possibly, vice versa) or, more accurately, for every 1% increase in the unemployment rate, a country’s GDP will be roughly an additional 2% lower than its potential GDP. If real GDP increases sharply while unemployment also increases, that’s another nail in Okun’s Law’s coffin.

What if there’s no empirical relationship between employment or unemployment and real GDP? I’m not saying it’s the case but what if it is? What if the rule of thumb has worked in the past but no longer holds today? I think it would mean that the policies of the past have become inoperative. We’d better hope that’s not the case.

20 comments

Apocalypse…Now and Then (a Supplement)

A recent post by fellow Watcher Hube on movies with an apocalyptic theme caught my eye so I thought I’d contribute to the project by adding a few notable movies with an apocalyptic theme that Hube missed. I’ll use the same basic format as Hube used but contribute a few thoughts of my own.

The Movie: Things to Come (1936)
Cause of Apocalyse: War then plague
The Threat: Luddism
The Hero: Raymond Massey in two roles
The Payoff: “And if we’re no more than animals, we must snatch each little scrap of happiness, and live, and suffer, and pass, mattering no more than all the other animals do or have done. It is this, or that. All the universe or nothing. Which shall it be, Passworthy? Which shall it be?”
Classic Moment: Ralph Richardson’s scenery-chewing performance as “the Boss”.

A William Cameron Menzies adaption of H. G. Wells’s novel of the future. Its special effects look pretty laughable now but in 1936 they were state-of-the-art.

The Movie: The War of the Worlds (1953) and (2005)
Cause of Apocalyse: Invaders from Mars
The Threat: Invaders from Mars
The Hero: Gene Barry/Tom Cruise
The Payoff: Martians get a cold
Classic Moment: Paul Frees’s opening voiceover

Effective George Pal special effects.

The Movie: The World, the Flesh, and the Devil (1959)
Cause of Apocalyse: Radioactive dust
The Threat: One woman; two men; one of the men is black.
The Hero: Harry Belafonte
The Payoff: Ménage à trois
Classic Moment: Aren’t Harry Belafonte and Inger Stevens gorgeous? Mel Ferrer is no slouch, either.

Movie adaption of M. P. Shiel’s remarkable novel, The Purple Cloud, with a soupçon of 1950s race relations, this time with Harry Belafonte in the Sidney Poitier role.

The Movie: Beyond the Time Barrier (1960)
Cause of Apocalyse: Cosmic plague
The Threat: Violent mutants
The Hero: Robert Clarke who had an extensive career as a bit player, a B movie hero, and in television. Probably best known for his recurring roles in both TV versions of Dragnet
The Payoff: Our hero returns to our own time, not entirely whole
Classic Moment: The director’s daughter as Arianne channels Laurence Olivier’s Henry V in a speech inciting the mutants to revolt.

A movie with incredibly low production values that takes itself and its subject remarkably seriously.

The Movie: Day of the Triffids (1962)
Cause of Apocalyse: Meteor shower-induced blindness
The Threat: Carnivorous plants
The Hero: Howard Keel
The Payoff: They find a rather disappointing way of defeating the triffids in an echo of War of the Worlds
Classic Moment: Janette Scott fighting triffids.

A not particularly faithful adaptation of John Wyndham’s novel. The first part of the movie in which people are struggling to survive their new blindness is by far the most effective. Try as you might you will never get the tune they use to lure the triffids out of your head.

The Movie: The Last Man on Earth (1964)
Cause of Apocalyse: A plague that kills most of humanity or turns them into zombie-vampires
The Threat: Loneliness and being killed by the zombie-vampires, in that order
The Hero: Vincent Price
The Payoff: It doesn’t look too good for the human race—the remnants would rather kill than be cured.
Classic Moment: Vincent Price’s dying speech

This is by far the most atmospheric of the adaptations of Richard Matheson’s I Am Legend. The black and white photography and Vincent Price in one of his best performances convey an overall sense of foreboding unmatched in the later adaptations (which Hube did list). This is a highly influential motion picture, the immediate inspiration for George Romero’s Night of the Living Dead. It’s pretty clearly the first “flesh-eating zombie” picture.

The Movie: Children of Men (2006)
Cause of Apocalyse: Female infertility of unexplained origin
The Threat: Social and economic collapse, extinction of the human race
The Hero: Clive Owens
The Payoff: A baby is born to a West African refugee
Classic Moment: The crowd parts in wonder at the sight of a baby

Although allegedly a loose adaptation of P. D. James’s novel Children of Men, it also borrows liberally from Brian Aldiss’s Greybeard.

14 comments

The Great Doldrums

In the first quarter of 2013 real GDP increased at the annualized rate of 2.5%. Based on the text of the announcement I infer that they’re still using the old method of calculating GDP rather than the new one. I wonder how the calculation would come out if the new method were used.

2.5% is roughly the historical average. That’s too slow to bring the unemployed back to work. Most of the increase is due to an increase in personal consumption expenditures while personal income declined. If you believe that we’ve been through a “balance sheet” recession, this is terrible news. We’re not deleveraging at all.

I note that consumption of services increased at an annualized rate of 3.1% compared with an increase of .6% in the previous quarter and I suspect that much of that is healthcare, that may take some of the wind out of the sails of those who had thought that we’d gotten the problem of rising healthcare costs licked.

Essentially, it’s better news than if growth were slower but not nearly as good as we really need.

11 comments

Rocking the World

I strongly recommend that you read the article at The Atlantic on methane hydrate and how it might rock the economics and politics of the world, much as petroleum did when it supplanted coal in the 20th century. Here’s a sample of how high the stakes are:

If methane hydrate allows much of the world to switch from oil to gas, the conversion would undermine governments that depend on oil revenues, especially petro-autocracies like Russia, Iran, Venezuela, Iraq, Kuwait, and Saudi Arabia. Unless oil states are exceptionally well run, a gush of petroleum revenues can actually weaken their economies by crowding out other business. Worse, most oil nations are so corrupt that social scientists argue over whether there is an inherent bond—a “resource curse”—between big petroleum deposits and political malfeasance. It seems safe to say that few Americans would be upset if a plunge in demand eliminated these countries’ hold over the U.S. economy. But those same people might not relish the global instability—a belt of financial and political turmoil from Venezuela to Turkmenistan—that their collapse could well unleash.

On a broader level still, cheap, plentiful natural gas throws a wrench into efforts to combat climate change. Avoiding the worst effects of climate change, scientists increasingly believe, will require “a complete phase-out of carbon emissions … over 50 years,” in the words of one widely touted scientific estimate that appeared in January. A big, necessary step toward that goal is moving away from coal, still the second-most-important energy source worldwide. Natural gas burns so much cleaner than coal that converting power plants from coal to gas—a switch promoted by the deluge of gas from fracking—has already reduced U.S. greenhouse-gas emissions to their lowest levels since Newt Gingrich’s heyday.

Yet natural gas isn’t that clean; burning it produces carbon dioxide. Researchers view it as a temporary “bridge fuel,” something that can power nations while they make the transition away from oil and coal. But if societies do not take advantage of that bridge to enact anti-carbon policies, says Michael Levi, the director of the Program on Energy Security and Climate Change at the Council on Foreign Relations, natural gas could be “a bridge from the coal-fired past to the coal-fired future.”

Interesting times.

6 comments

Learned Nothing, Part II

When the history of the Boston Marathon bombings is written (as it most surely will be), it will be one of strong people and weak institutions:

Thousands of videos, tweets, and other bits of information from citizens came together in a wealth of evidence and reporting.

Then thousands of people turned out for a healing service held by multiple faiths and attended by three levels of government – the mayor, the Massachusetts governor, and President Obama.

And on the one-week anniversary of the blasts, throngs of Boston-area residents joined in a moment of silence near the bomb site and elsewhere. People are still bonding in a “Boston Strong” campaign, such as soliciting donations for the victims and their families.

The 9/11 Commission Report brought into sharp focus the role of flaws in inter-agency communication in the attacks. Communication between the CIA, FBI, FAA, and local police forces and governments were choked with dense thickets of bureaucracy, inter-agency rivalry, and turf protection.

We have, apparently, learned nothing in this regard. We now know that both the FBI and CIA were warned by the Russian authorities about Tamerlan Tsarnaev repeatedly and years before the tragic bombing of the Boston Marathon. Equally apparently the standards of proof required by the two agencies were different and neither saw a need to involve the Boston authorities.

Writing in the Wall Street Journal, Judith Miller speculates that if the Tsarnaev brothers lived in New York there would have been a different outcome:

In August 2007, Mr. Silber and Arvin Bhatt, then also an NYPD analyst, wrote what was then considered a controversial police-department report arguing that with the attrition of al Qaeda’s leadership, the primary threat to New York would come from “homegrown” Muslims under the age of 35 who had become Islamists in the West.

Based on an analysis of 11 plots against Western targets between 9/11 and 2006, their report, “Radicalization in the West: The Homegrown Threat,” concluded that most of the plotters were “unremarkable” citizens who had undergone often rapid radicalization, 90% of them in the West. The analysts identified a pattern of radicalization and listed common characteristics before a person committed a terrorist act. The report also warned: “The Internet is a driver and enabler for . . . radicalization.”

Since 2007, the NYPD has looked for such warning signs among New York’s Muslim population of 600,000 to 750,000—about 40% of whom are foreign-born—as homegrown terrorist plots have increased. In 2005, there was one homegrown terrorist plot in the U.S.; by 2010, there had been 12.

Our system is decentralized, fragmented, and chaotic in the extreme. As with any other human institutions, our institutions are mired in bureaucracy and the personal ambitions of the individuals who work in them.

None of these institutions was held to account following the 9/11 attacks and, indeed, the Commission Report went out of its way to avoid doing that. None will be held accountable following this attack. The combination of ambiguity, bureaucracy, human nature, and lack of accountability is not a happy one.

32 comments

The Two Burials of Celestine Schneider

My maternal grandmother’s sister, my great-aunt Celestine Schneider, died of tuberculosis at the age of 18 in 1922. That’s her picture above. I think she looks something like my grandmother. Sadly, her story did not end there. I’d heard elements of this tale from my mom but I didn’t know the whole story until one of my siblings uncovered it.

About a month after she died and was buried grave robbers dug a neat hole and removed her body from its coffin. The story that I had been told was that her body had been stolen by a necrophile. I had wondered about medical research. The truth was apparently far stranger and it involves a man named Harry Brenn.

Harry Brenn, a veteran of World War I, had married a German “war bride” and had an infant son. He owned a garage. On the same night as Celestine’s body disappeared, Mr. Brenn had told police a bizarre story of being kidnapped at gunpoint by six men, carried off in a car, and later escaping. Around midnight that night his garage burned to the ground. In the cinders of the garage the charred remnants of a body were found.

Initially, it was assumed that Brenn had died in the fire. Closer examination of the charred remains determined they weren’t Brenn’s at all but belonged to Celestine. Brenn’s wife, Gertrude Brenn, was arrested on a charge of grave robbing but later released. The police finally concluded that Brenn had stolen Celestine’s body and burned it and the garage in some sort of insurance fraud scheme. There had been several similar and widely reported insurance fraud cases in Missouri at the time.

Apparently, Celestine’s story made national news. I’ve seen repetitions of it from upstate New York to Florida, from the East Coast to the Rockies. You can read one of them here. The second facing page is here. Don’t miss the lurid illustration on the facing page. They just don’t make newspapers like that any more.

After the medical examination the charred remains of Celestine’s body were cremated and I have found no record of what became of them. She is not listed as having been buried in Hope Cemetery, her original resting place, so I wonder if her poor ashes were just dumped in some nameless pit.

From time to time in life I’ve wondered if my family were really just like everyone else’s and our predisposition to look at everything as a story just made our history look different. Then I come across something like the story of poor Celestine Schneider’s two burials and wonder if my family isn’t pretty different after all.

4 comments

Foreign Policy Blogging at OTB

I’ve just published a foreign policy-related post at Outside the Beltway:

The Hazards of Red Lines

If Bashar al-Assad has used chemical weapons against his own people in Syria, does that require the United States to act?

0 comments