Bring Back the Spoils System!

I don’t know that I’ve ever heard a more cogent argument for bringing back the spoils system than some of what I’m reading in defense of the IRS’s targeting of conservative and libertarian groups.

To refresh your memory under the “spoils system” when a new administration came into office it gave its own people government jobs, right down to the clerk level. In the federal government the civil service system began to supplant the notoriously corrupt and incompetent spoils system after the Civil War. Here in Chicago it prevailed legally and officially right into the 1980s and illegally and unofficially to the present day.

To get some flavor of what I’m talking about there are some who are claiming that, obviously, any organization opposed to increased taxes deserves special scrutiny from the IRS. Imagine if, when, say, a hypothetical Republican president is elected and the entire IRS staff were to be replaced with Tea Party supporters. That’s the spoils system.

6 comments

Now My Neighbor, It’s Time to Dance

The Congressional Budget Office, major media outlets, and the commentariat were surprised and delighted when it was reported the federal tax revenues had increased to a record level. Not so fast, says Red Jahnke:

Much of the increase in 2013 receipts is due to final tax payments for 2012 deriving from a rush to realize long-term capital gains before the 15% “Bush” tax rate on such gains expired at the end of 2012—and before the new 23.8% rate on long-term capital gains for higher-income taxpayers took effect on Jan. 1. How do we know this? Because virtually the same tax change occurred during the Reagan years, when the long-term capital gains tax rate jumped eight points, to 28% in 1987, when the Tax Reform Act took effect, from 20% in 1986.

Here are the 1980s data expressed in current dollars: In 1985, before any talk of the Tax Reform Act, individual taxpayers reported about $310 billion in long-term capital gains. In 1986, with the Tax Reform Act signed into law but not yet in effect, reported long-term capital gains ballooned to $580 billion. The following year, with the act’s 28% rate in place, reported gains plunged to $250 billion. Tax revenues naturally followed—long-term capital gains tax revenue doubled to $90 billion in 1986, or 14.7% of total individual incomes taxes, before falling off again in 1987.

After these gyrations, long-term capital gains did not hit the 1986 peak again for a decade. This tax revenue pattern was replicated in many states whose tax systems peg off the federal system.

I would like to see that breakdown quantified. Meanwhile, is anyone willing to bet that if federal tax revenues decline next year the Administration and its allies will blame it on everything but the change in tax policy?

If, on the other hand, revenues continue to increase, it would certainly call Mr. Jahnke’s assertions into question, wouldn’t it?

16 comments

Res Ipsa Loquitur

That’s Latin for “the thing speaks for itself”. Claims that the IRS’s targeting of conservative and libertarian groups was not political in nature are laughable. It speaks for itself. Making distinctions based on politics is inherently political and claiming otherwise is either stupid or arrogant. Or both. From the editors of the Wall Street Journal:

News reports suggest that Ms. Lerner knew about the targeting of conservatives in June 2011, and perhaps as early as 2010. That’s a long time before IRS Commissioner Douglas Shulman flatly denied any political targeting when he testified at a House Ways and Means subcommittee hearing in March 2012.

IRS officials are still claiming that the questions weren’t meant to intimidate these groups. But the evidence that the inquiries were political is already voluminous.

The IRS sent questionnaires to conservative groups that included requests for everything from the resumes of directors past and present to whether an employee or employee family member had plans to run for public office. Cincinnati Tea Party founder Justin Binik-Thomas wrote in the Washington Examiner recently that one nonprofit received a questionnaire that demanded that it “Provide details regarding your relationship with Justin Binik-Thomas.”

According to the American Center for Law and Justice, which represents some of the IRS targets, the IRS letters did not come only from the Cincinnati office (as Ms. Lerner implied on Friday), but also from IRS offices in Laguna Niguel and El Monte in California as well as from Washington D.C. In addition to intrusive questionnaires, the groups were subjected to unusual delays in obtaining tax-exempt status. Of the law center’s 27 clients, 15 were approved, two withdrew out of frustration and 10 are still pending.

The response that nobody was actually injured is vacuous. Being arrested by the Inquisition is inherently harmful, whether you were put to the question or not.

13 comments

More on the IRS’s Pursuit of Conservative, Libertarian Groups

The editors of the Washington Post have questions:

When Ms. Lerner heard about the targeting of tea party groups, she rightly demanded the practice end. But did she reinstitute checks against inappropriate targeting that had been in place years before? If not, why not? What are the safeguards now?

Who else knew about the targeting? In subsequent testimony, IRS leaders assured lawmakers that no one did. Were they ignorant or deliberately untruthful? Did they even ask before reporting to Congress?

Anecdotes about unreasonable demands for information are already circulating, but what were the practical effects of this policy on those 100-plus conservative applicants?

Considering that Ms. Lerner seems to have known about the targeting by 2011, did the IRS ever plan on revealing that it had singled out conservative groups? Or was it only the impending release of the inspector general’s report that compelled agency officials to ’fess up?

IMO this story has a lot more potential to turn into a major scandal than Benghazi does. Abuse of power, politicization of the IRS, incompetence. So far the administration has done little to avert potential disaster. Three days before making a presidential statement is an eternity nowadays. The IRS’s own statements have gotten the organization into more trouble if anything.

I doubt that this particular scandal will reach the White House but it’s not impossible. What would need to happen is for there to be found some kind of coordination or exchange of information between the White House or the president’s re-election committee and the IRS over which organizations to target or what was discovered in the process. That could turn into a major scandal. Otherwise, as I say, I doubt it.

Nonetheless, as I said yesterday, it really does undercut the message.

1 comment

Why Benghazi Won’t Be a Major Scandal

At the Washington Post Glenn Kessler reviews the claim, frequently asserted by the White House and the president’s supporters, that President Obama called the attack on the U. S. consulate in Benghazi, Libya and subsequent murder of four Americans a terrorist act immediately. He finds that the Administration is, to be charitable, mistaken. It won’t make any difference.

Try as they might Republicans will not be able to transmogrify the sad affair into a major scandal and it’s not “because there’s no there there”. That’s irrelevant. Americans don’t care about it. There are any number of reasons they don’t care but IMO first and foremost is that Americans are, in general, uninterested in foreign affairs even when events overseas result in the deaths of Americans. There’s a sort of “what can you expect from the wogs?” reaction.

Move on, already. It’s not a winning issue.

6 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcment post on the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

Talk About Undercutting Your Own Message

Joe Klein makes a valid point in his column:

As in most presidencies, there have been an awful lot of political hacks populating the mid-reaches of this Administration. In the Obama instance, these have shown an anachronistic, pre-Clinton liberal bias when it comes to the rules and regulations governing many of our safety net programs, like social security disability. And now they have violated one of the more sacred rules of our democracy: you do not use the tax code to punish your opponents.

Lois G. Lerner, the IRS official who oversees tax-exempt groups, said the “absolutely inappropriate” actions by “front-line people” were not driven by partisan motives.

Does anyone actually believe this?

Yet again, we have an example of Democrats simply not managing the government properly and with discipline. This is just poisonous at a time of skepticism about the efficacy of government. And the President should know this: the absence of scandal is not the presence of competence. His unwillingness to concentrate–and I mean concentrate obsessively–on making sure that government is managed efficiently will be part of his legacy.

When your basic strategy is to give federal agencies broad discretionary powers as is the case with the PPACA and Dodd-Frank, just to name two, if those powers are abused for what certainly appear to be political motives, it really casts doubt on the innocence of your intentions. Or, as Dan Drezner recently wisecracked, they’ve justified every paranoid conspiracy theory for the next half century.

70 comments

The New York State Officials’ Prayer

“Thank God for Illinois”:

“We have three people in the State Legislature facing trial. Four of the last seven governors have gone to jail,” said Andy Shaw of Illinois’ Better Government Association. “And we’re a fiscal train wreck.”

That four-of-the-last-seven-governors record is really hard to argue with. New York, of course, had the disastrous resignation of Eliot Spitzer. But that was about sex. Sex scandals, while embarrassing, are far less depressing than financial corruption. I would way rather have an important elected official who patronized prostitutes than one who spent $60,000 of the taxpayers’ money on sushi and lobster. Although in New York we have recently had both.

Over the last few years New York has had 32 officials get into trouble with the law. Gail Collins’s op-ed is largely beside the point. Sadly, there are just four kinds of state officials: those who’ve been convicted of corruption, those who haven’t been caught, unindicted co-conspirators, and those who are so stupid and incompetent that they’re completely in the dark.

I don’t know whether I’ve mentioned it before but many years ago there was a purge at the Fortune 500 company for which I worked at the time. A regional sales manager had been found to have been “watering” sales, i.e. booking bogus sales in one quarter to boost commissions and then canceling them later. One by one every person who worked directly for the regional sales manager or alongside him was brought in to an office and interrogated by representatives from corporate. Most were fired, either for being involved in the scam or for knowing about it and keeping mum.

Make no mistake: they all know.

0 comments

What Did They Know and When Did They Know It?

The story about IRS officials targeting conservative and libertarian 501(c)(4) organizations seems to be heating up. Apparently, there was an actual policy in place as early as 2011:

The Treasury Department’s inspector general for tax administration is expected to release the results of a nearly yearlong investigation in the coming week. The AP obtained part of the draft report, which has been shared with congressional aides.

Among the other revelations, on Aug. 4, 2011, staffers in the IRS’ Rulings and Agreements office “held a meeting with chief counsel so that everyone would have the latest information on the issue.”

On Jan, 25, 2012, the criteria for flagging suspect groups was changed to, “political action type organizations involved in limiting/expanding Government, educating on the Constitution and Bill of Rights, social economic reform/movement,” the report says.

While this was happening, several committees in Congress were writing numerous letters IRS Commissioner Douglas Shulman to express concern because tea party groups were complaining of IRS harassment.

I see at least two issues in this. First, if groups were singled out for additional scrutiny based on the causes they espoused, that strikes me as a clear violation of First Amendment rights. Second, if there was an actual written policy in place of which managers at the IRS were aware, that means that the problem goes up to IRS senior management at the very least.

Douglas Shulman, the IRS Commissioner who adamantly denied any such targeting in his testimony before Congress in 2012, left office in November 2012 so there’s no issue of firing him over this. However, there does remain the question of whether he knew about the policies when he testified. Contempt of Congress has the potential penalty of jail time. If he lied under oath, that would add perjury to the charges.

The question for him now becomes as with other senior IRS managers what did they know and when did they know it?

Update

The editors of the Washington Post have produced an outraged editorial on the matter:

If it was not partisanship, was it incompetence? Stupidity, on a breathtaking scale? At this point, the IRS has lost any standing to determine and report on what exactly happened. Certainly Congress will investigate, as House Majority Leader Eric Cantor (R-Va.) promised. Mr. Obama also should guarantee an unimpeachably independent inquiry.

One line of questioning should focus on how the IRS’s procedures failed to catch this “shortcut” before its employees began using it. Another should center on how this misguided practice came to light, and on what the IRS planned and plans to do about it. Ms. Lerner was responding to a question when the news first came out; it’s not clear whether the government intended otherwise to disclose what had happened. Nor have officials been clear whether disciplinary measures have been taken.

Tax collectors are never popular. Tax collectors who use the power of their office to harass people they don’t like are criminals. That strikes to the very heart of the organization. For that reason tax collectors, like Caesar’s wife, must be beyond reproach.

29 comments

Tweet of the Week

Speaking of humor, the tweet of the week has to go to Dan Drezner: “So, in all, this has been a pretty crappy week for people who dislike conspiracy theories.” Hat tip: Glenn Reynolds

4 comments