Knowing Right From Wrong

I don’t divide the world between friends and enemies. I do think that some things are right while others are wrong. Arresting a reporter for espionage in order to do an end-run around federal law is wrong:

Journalists, First Amendment watchdogs and government transparency advocates reacted with outrage Monday to the revelation that the Justice Department had investigated the newsgathering activities of a Fox News reporter as a potential crime in a probe of classified leaks.

Critics said the government’s suggestion that James Rosen, Fox News’s chief Washington correspondent, was a “co-conspirator” for soliciting classified information threatened to criminalize press freedoms protected by the First Amendment. Others also suggested that the Justice Department’s claim in pursuing an alleged leak from the State Department was little more than pretext to seize his e-mails to build their case against the suspected leaker.

The Obama Administration is not covering itself with glory. They are not alleging that the reporter was doing anything other than reporting. Apparently, reporting is now espionage.

The Washington Post, Wall Street Journal, and ABC News have already leapt to the defense of the Fox News reporter. The New York Times, on the other hand, apparently approves on cracking down on leaks. Eugene Robinson notes:

If this had been the view of prior administrations, surely Bob Woodward would be a lifer in some federal prison. The cell next door might be occupied by my Post colleague Dana Priest, who disclosed the CIA’s network of secret prisons. Or by the New York Times’ James Risen and Eric Lichtblau, who revealed the National Security Agency’s eavesdropping program.

I can only speculate that the NYT sees the world in terms of friends and enemies.

63 comments

Milestone

As of last Friday Tally became the oldest Samoyed my wife has ever had. 15 years, 1 month, a couple of weeks. She’s quite the dowager now.

As you can see she’s still happy. That’s our yardstick for intervention. As long as she’s happy, we’ll do what we can to keep her that way.

2 comments

Stage Managing the News

In an op-ed comparing President Obama with former President Nixon, a subject I think is being much exaggerated, Carl Cannon makes an interesting observation:

Those who work for this president have a fetish for stage managing the news. They never simply trust the facts; or maybe a better way of saying it is that they don’t trust the American people be able to handle the facts. Washington has been consumed in recent weeks about who, exactly, massaged the administration’s “talking points” on Benghazi.

The underlying problem is that there were talking points at all. The phrase was popularized in the 1970s in the State Department. Originally the practice ensured that government officials were employing the precise, but opaque, language required in the field of international diplomacy. But the phrase soon migrated to politics, where it meant something quite different: Talking points were the lines of the day to be employed in interviews by partisan political operatives either to defend their position or attack the other side.

The irony of such a “fetish” is that they’re trying to maintain a high level of control even as such control has become impossible. Even with a compliant and complacent press it’s simply no longer possible for anybody, whether a film star, a company, or a politician to control public opinion in the way that used not only to be possible but to be the norm.

How well is the “fetish” working for the Administration? I would submit that it’s a major contributing factor to the scandals (is is four or six of them now?) that are dominating the professional and amateur opinion pages these days. The truth may hurt but does it really hurt more than the speculations?

6 comments

Sticker Shock

You might want to take a look at an interesting op-ed from S. Lawrence Kocot, writing at RealClearMarkets. In the op-ed Mr. Kocot outlines some of the factors to keep an eye on in determining how smoothly the implementation of the PPACA, “ObamaCare”, is going. Among the factors he identifies are, broadly, affordability, availability, and outreach.

I think that many of things that people are worried about in the implementation of ObamaCare are the unknowns, both what have been referred to as the known unknowns and the unknown unknowns. Let’s consider just one of those unknowns. How will the plan affect high deductible healthcare plans?

The two fastest-growing forms of healthcare insurance are self-insurance, having no insurance which will essentially be banned under the new order of things, and high deductible healthcare insurance, also known as catastrophic healthcare insurance, in which most of the healthcare that people consume is paid out-of-pocket and insurance covers only amounts over some fairly large amount, $5,000 per year, $7,000, something like that.

About a sixth of all of those with employer-provided healthcare insurance are in high deductible plans.

In the individual insurance market high deductible plans almost certainly will not qualify as having healthcare insurance under the new requirement. The plans just don’t cover enough things. Additionally, the guaranteed cover and community rating provisions of ObamaCare (no disqualification for pre-existing conditions and a provision that everybody in a given area pay roughly the same rates) may cause insurers to stop offering high deductible plans.

Finally, under the new requirements for insurance companies to maintain a high medical loss ratio, most premiums must go to paying for healthcare. It’s not really clear how medical loss ratio requirements may fit in with high deductible plans.

If high deductible plans go the way of the dodo, quite a few employers and individuals who pay for their own insurance may be forced into significantly more expensive plans, not even taking into account the higher premiums for all plans that the CBO has pointed out. Paying more for healthcare insurance means that people have less money available to spend on other things which in turn will reduce general economic activity, a further depressant on employment.

6 comments

Passages

Yesterday my nephew, Neal, graduated from medical school. Somewhat to his surprise he also received the school’s award for achievement in clinical neurology. He has a couple of weeks to get himself settled before he begins his internship. Congratulations, Neal!

Today my youngest nephew, Eric, graduated from college. Congratulations, Eric!

Both of them are smart, good-looking, industrious young men. I have no doubts they’ll prosper even in today’s very uncertain economic circumstances.

It occurred to me that as of today there will be no one in my family in school for the first time in twenty years or so. If you discount a brief hiatus in the 1980s, it will be the first time no one in my family has been in school over a period of a half century of more.

If you include Neal’s fiancée, we do have someone in the family who’s still in school. She’s studying to be a veterinarian.

3 comments

Foreign Policy Blogging at OTB

I’ve just published a foreign policy-related post at Outside the Beltway:

French Dip

The French economy is drifting into recession for the second time in four years.

2 comments

Le Bon Mot

I do not believe that the word that David Ignatius is searching for here:

The crippling problem in Washington these days isn’t any organized conspiracy against conservatives, journalists or anyone else. Rather, it’s a federal establishment that’s increasingly paralyzed because of poor management and political second-guessing.

What should frighten the public is not the federal government’s monstrous power but its impotence.

is “impotence”. I think the word is incompetence. As I’ve said before I find an inherent problem with the view that government should be given broad discretionary powers. The greater those powers the more oversight they require.

Firing a few people may be necessary but it’s not nearly enough. We need better management of government 365 days a year.

The first job of the president isn’t commander-in-chief or inspirer-in-child, scold-in-chief, the 51st governor, or the 101st senator. Look in Article 2, Section 1 of the Constitution. It’s manager of the federal government. There is only one and there isn’t anybody else to do it.

45 comments

Ignorance Is an Excuse

of, if you’d prefer the Latin, ignorantia legis excusat. That turns on its head the normal principle in which ignorance of the law is no excuse. That, however, appears to be the position of Attorney General Eric Holder:

Holder seemed to regard this ignorance as a shield protecting him and the Justice Department from all criticism of the Obama administration’s assault on press freedoms. But his claim that his “recusal” from the case exempted him from all discussion of the matter didn’t fly with Republicans or Democrats on the committee, who justifiably saw his recusal as more of an abdication.

“There doesn’t seem to be any acceptance of responsibility in the Justice Department for things that have gone wrong,” said Rep. James Sensenbrenner (R-Wis.), after Holder placed the AP matter in the lap of his deputy. “We don’t know where the buck stops.”

Of course, as we all know, a Republican’s complaint that an attorney general in a Democratic administration should, oh, do his job or know what’s going on is completely invalid because of his obviously partisan motivation while a Democrat’s complaints about an attorney general in a hypothetical Republican administration would be motivated solely by the purest of intentions.

What astounds me in the revelations of the Department of Justice’s extraction of the phone records of hundreds of reporters is its imprudence. They must be remarkably confident in the loyalty of the press. There’s a wisecrack falsely attributed to Sam Clemens that you should never start an argument with a man who buys ink by the barrel. For the Obama Administration the situation is even more serious. They’ve benefited enormously by a friendly press.

Either they don’t understand just how friendly the press has been to them or they’re very confident that they’ll hold that friendship even if they challenge it by going after reporters’ phone records. Quite a gamble.

14 comments

An Emerging Theme

At Politico Alexander Burns and John Harris make the following observation:

For five years, this president has been making the case that a growing and activist government has good intentions and can carry these intentions out with competence. Conservatives have warned that government is dangerous, and even good intentions get bungled in the execution. In different ways, the IRS uproar, the Justice Department leak investigations, the Benghazi tragedy and the misleading attempts to explain it, and the growing problems with implementation of health care reform all bolster the conservative worldview.

To stain reputations, presidential controversies usually need some kind of powerful connection to the style and values of the person occupying the Oval Office. Watergate was not a random scandal — it flowed directly from President Richard M. Nixon’s paranoia and contempt for law. No one who knew Bill Clinton in the decades before he became president would have been surprised that his second-term scandal involved weaknesses of the flesh. Under George W. Bush, the misjudgments at the outset of the Iraq War reflected an instinct for certitude and a disdain for dissenting views that started at the top.

In Obama’s case, the narrative emerging from this tumultuous week goes something like this: None of these messes would have happened under a president less obsessed with politics, less insulated within his own White House and less trusting of government as an institution.

Note how that dovetails with the “undercutting your own message” point I made a few days ago.

It might not be clear from what I’ve written but I honestly want the president to succeed. I want that to happen by his doing things that succeed rather than for the things that he does to succeed because he does them (if you understand the distinction I’m trying to make). The emergence of the theme of a president who wants to give broad discretionary powers to the federal government and then free them from oversight, hoping for the best is not a move in the right direction.

24 comments

A Series of Unfortunate Incidents

The more people speak in defense of the IRS’s actions in targeting conservative and libertarian groups for scrutiny, the worse the situation becomes. Contrary to those defending the IRS:

  1. The “short cut” policy that resulted in conservative and libertarian groups being targeted for scrutiny was not a consequence of a sudden increase in applications. The policy preceded the increase.
  2. The policy was apparently used in Cincinnatti, Southern California, and Washington, DC. There was nothing isolated about it.
  3. The director of the Exempt Organizations Division, Lois Lerner, the woman who made the announcement last week that got this whole ball rolling, appears to have known about and been complicit in the policy
  4. That no one was actually injured in the matter is simultaneously false and irrevelant. Intimidation is an injury.
  5. That Republicans benefit politically is irrelevant. Where does judging how we should react to bad behavior or wrongdoing based on political benefit end? Obviously, not at murder. I’ve seen any number of comments on the trial of Kermit Gosnell, recently convicted of three counts of first degree murder for infanticide and one of involuntary manslaughter in the death of one of his patients, that suggested that such a trial outcome would be bad because it would give so much fuel to the pro-life movement.

None of these defenses can be seen as tenable. They’re simply raw partisanship.

The federal civil service was originally founded in the 1880s in reaction to the assassination of President Garfield at the hands of a frustrated applicant for a federal job. Ms. Lerner and, no doubt, most of those involved in these IRS actions aren’t political appointees but civil service employees. I’m sure that they have decades of glowing performance reviews in their files and short of criminal conviction without a pattern of bad behavior there is for practical purposes no way to get rid of them.

The now-disgraced Illinois Congressman Dan Rostenkowski, once Chairman of the House Ways and Means Committee, arguably the third most powerful position in the House after the Speaker and the Majority Whip, was quoted as saying “Never take a bribe. Just hand ’em your business card.” Since I seriously doubt there was ever an agreement among the various IRS offices, there’s no conspiracy involved. The effect was certainly conspiratorial.

The modern civil service was founded to establish an explicit procedure for hiring and firing federal employees and to place the civil service above politics. What happens when members of the civil service pursue their responsibilities as political actors rather than as above politics? What happens when they can’t even recognize that’s what they’re doing?

My preference would be for a federal civil service that was, in fact, above politics. Civil service employees are human and, consequently, political. That means that strong, persistent oversight of the activities of civil service employees is a necessity. Right now their managers are either complicit or asleep at the switch.

55 comments