Where There’s Smoke

I haven’t read the story, just the headline: “West Wing briefly evacuated due to smoke, Secret Service says”. Talk about crying out for a Top 10 List. Think about the top 10 reasons smoke was coming out of a White House closet.

3 comments

The Post-Information Revolution

I sincerely hope that Walter Russell Mead is right in his assessment of the direction of the American economy. After acknowledging that the transition from the old agrarian America of small farmers to the industrial America that took its place and which we have seen dwindle over the last several decades he continues:

A service economy resting on the high productivity agriculture, manufacturing and information processing will be a more affluent and a more human economy than what we have now. Human energy will be liberated from wringing the bare necessities from a reluctant nature; energy and talent will flow into making life more beautiful, more interesting, more entertaining and easier to use. By 1960 few American suburbanites really envied their hardscrabble, uneducated ancestors shivering through the winter in sod huts on the open prairie; one suspects that few Americans in 2060 will be pining for the glorious old days of 9 to 5 at GM.

I must say that I see things somewhat differently. I think that today’s growth industries (healthcare, education, and finance) are only growth industries by virtue of the privileges they’ve secured from government. There are really only two possible directions. Either they’ll retain their privileges which will be at the expense of just about every other sector or they’ll lose those privileges. Right now it looks like the former.

What I see on the horizon is movement towards a state capitalism simulacrum of Mexico with a relatively small, very affluent upper class. That upper class can either hold on to its prerogatives or it can relinqish them. It can’t do both.

I also think think that we’re about one steep recession from rioting in the streets.

6 comments

Scandal/No Scandal?

  Underlying offense Allegations/Reason for Scandal
Teapot Dome Bribery Corruption, cover-up
Alger Hiss Perjury Espionage, charges that FDR’s foreign policy was influenced by Soviet agents
Watergate Burglary Cover-up
Iran-Contra Funding Nicaraguan Contras in violation of Boland Amendment Sale of arms to Iran, proceeds used to free American hostages and fund Contras, cover-up
Monica Lewinsky Marital infidelity Perjury, cover-up
Benghazi Death of four Americans in Benghazi consulate in terrorist attack Failure to come to the aid of the American consulate in Benghazi for political reasons, incompetence, soft on Islamist terrorism, cover-up
IRS targeting conservatives Abuse of power Conservative and libertarian 501(c)(4)s targeted for scrutiny by IRS, cover-up

Which of these incidents constitute scandals and which don’t? Why?

A few random remarks. I was in Europe while the whole Watergate thing was going on. Many Europeans simply couldn’t understand what all the hubbub was about.

I think the whole Benghazi affair is terribly sad. Right now it’s somewhere between scandal and not a scandal. It’s not nothing but it’s not the apocalypse, either. I think that there was a brief attempt at a cover-up but the reality is that it’s a lot harder to maintain the pretense than it used to be even with a press that’s favorably predisposed towards you and it was abandoned quickly. By that time Mitt Romney had already shot himself in the foot by inserting himself into the story.

I think the story about the IRS’s targeting of conservative and libertarian groups for heightened scrutiny is, in fact, a scandal but even more than that it highlights a serious management problem at the IRS. When low-level staffers are setting policy, that’s not just a faux pas by the staffers, as the “mistakes were made” formulation would seem to suggest. The job of such staffers is to follow policy, not set it. If they’re setting policy, that’s a prima facie case for inadequate management. The very least that should happen is that the immediate superiors of whoever was responsible should be terminated for cause. I don’t think that the scandal rises very far but it might if it’s allowed to stretch on long enough.

13 comments

The Origin of Languages

It isn’t often that Nostratic makes its way into the pages of the Washington Post. Starting in the 16th century people bagan to notice the similarities among the languages spoken from Ireland to India. By the 19th century it was suggested that languages as different as Irish Gaelic and Armenian were all actually members of one large family of languages, the Indo-European language family.

When you get right down to it there are only a couple of likely theories for how languages developed in the first place. Either human beings developed languages many, many times which resulted in who knows how many completely distinct language families, human beings developed languages a few times and that’s reflected in a few language superfamilies, or that human beings developed language just once and all languages are ultimately related. Some scholars have identified three language superfamilies: Nostratic (which includes the Indo-European language family, the Uralic languages—Finnish, Hungarian, and others, and the Afroasiatic languges—those include the Semitic languages, Berber, Chadic, Egyptian, etc.), the Dené–Caucasian language superfamily (which includes the Sino-Tibetan languages, Basque, the North Caucasian languages, and the Na-Dené languages—the Athabaskan, Tlingit, and Haida languages), and the Austric superfamily (languages spoken in East Asia and the Pacific).

The process generally used for identifying these language relationships is one of searching for cognates and applying principles of phonemic change, i.e. what might be a “p” in a Romance language becomes an “f” in Germanic languages. For example, Italian pesce is cognate with German Fisch.

It’s not a mainstream view in linguistics. Many linguists think that the people constructing these hypothetical superfamilies are extending the process much too far. That brings us to the Washington Post article:

A new study, however, suggests that’s not always true.

A team of researchers has come up with a list of two dozen “ultraconserved words” that have survived 150 centuries. It includes some predictable entries: “mother,” “not,” “what,” “to hear” and “man.” It also contains surprises: “to flow,” “ashes” and “worm.”

The existence of the long-lived words suggests there was a “proto-Eurasiatic” language that was the common ancestor to about 700 contemporary languages that are the native tongues of more than half the world’s people.

I first learned about language families while paging through an old copy of Webster’s Collegiate Dictionary nearly 50 years ago (I used to read the dictionary). I was first exposed to the idea of language superfamilies through the works of Merritt Ruhlen—I have several of his books on my shelf.

To be honest I have my doubts even about the old family tree structure proposed for the Indo-European languages and, possibly, about language families themselves. I think a more complex network model is probably more realistic.

7 comments

I Guess This Makes Me a Dissident

A recent Pew Research study finds that two-thirds of Americans think that immigration policy, the tax system, the educational system, and the healthcare system either need a complete overhaul or major changes. More than half think that the Medicare system and Social Security system either need complete overhauls or major changes. More than half think that the homeland security system is working pretty well.

I guess that makes me a dissident. I think they all need complete overhauls.

The commentary from Pew focuses on immigration. In that area it’s pretty clear that the opinions of Americans are pretty widely separated from those of elites, at least as reflected in the comprehensive immigration reform that’s making its way through Congress. Nearly three-quarters of Americans think that illegal immigrants who meet certain requirements should be allowed to stay while more than 80% think that we need more border security. Let’s have a show of hands. Does anybody think that whatever requirements a new law imposes will actually be enforced? What in your experience of American immigration policy enforcement makes you think that?

Here’s another shocker: the more your own job is likely to be affected by more immigrants the less likely you are to favor more immigration. Something that may surprise you: more Hispanics think that legal immigration should be decreased or remain the same than think that it should be increased or remain the same.

1 comment

The Jobs of the Future

won’t pay very much. That’s the message of the info from the Bureau of Labor Statistics, analyzed here at Forbes. That’s not Forbes’s analysis, it’s mine. Their analysis is that a lot of them don’t require college degrees, a drum I’ve been beating for some time. They also claim that the fastest growing jobs will pay well, something not borne out by the actual numbers. The median wage for all of the fastest-growing occupations is just under $34,000 and that includes quite a number of jobs, e.g. physical therapist, that require graduate degrees. Pretty obviously, Forbes’s analysts aren’t numbers guys.

Don’t be distracted by the bright, shiny objects, e.g. “biomedical engineer”. Biomedical engineer is a very good job, decent programs are hard to get into, and they make good money—more than $80,000 per year according to the BLS. But biomedical engineers account for only .03% of the total. By comparison personal care aides and home health aides account for about 1% of the total of the “fastest growing occupations” and they pay about $10 an hour.

At that wage you’d better hope you don’t have a college education. You’ll never pay off your student loans.

Some of the others? Veterinarians make okay money but vet schools are more selective than med schools, their tuition is about the same, and the median wage is about half what a medical doctor’s is. You’ve got to really want to be a vet to make that choice.

here at Forbes

19 comments

How Much Does Healthcare Cost?

The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services has made available detailed information about the charges it’s paid for by state, facility, and procedure. I imagine there will be quite a bit of data mining going on.

A quick glance suggests it’s pretty chaotic. It doesn’t seem to make any rhyme or reason. Charges vary widely in ways that can’t be explained by geography.

36 comments

The Nation’s Against Her

I see that The Nation doesn’t think much of Penny Pritzker’s nomination as Secretary of Commerce. In fairness, most of their complaints are about the sources of her inherited money rather than Penny Priztker herself. However, that does add a bit of evidence to my theory that the appointment is a) throwing a sop to a major contributor and b) seen as a sinecure from which she’ll be able to continue her fund-raising operations.

Here’s a list of the agencies that fall under the Department of Commerce. Thank goodness none of them do anything important.

1 comment

Ray Harryhausen, 1920-2013

Stop-motion pioneer and genius Ray Harryhausen has died:

Ray Harryhausen, the stop-motion animation legend whose work on “The Beast From 20,000 Fathoms,” “Jason and the Argonauts” and other science fiction and fantasy film classics made him a cult figure who inspired later generations of filmmakers and special-effects artists, has died. He was 92.

Harryhausen died Tuesday in London, where he had lived for decades. His death was confirmed by Kenneth Kleinberg, his longtime legal representative in the United States.

In the pre-computer-generated-imagery era in which he worked, Harryhausen used the painstaking process of making slight adjustments to the position of his three-dimensional, ball-and-socket-jointed scale models and then shooting them frame-by-frame to create the illusion of movement. Footage of his exotic beasts and creatures was later often combined with live action.

His work began with short subjects in the 1940s and continued for sixty years. His technique of rear and front projecting footage one frame at time while animating to do stop-motion, originally invented to keep costs down and which he called “Dynamation”, continues to be used today. His remarkable work inspires much of the look of special effects today, including what’s one in computer graphics rather than the time-consuming and costly stop-motion animation.

I don’t know that anyone so embodies Edison’s wisecrack that genius was 10% inspiration, 90% perspiration. The time and effort that his work required, much of done alone or with just an assistant or two was enormous.

1 comment

It’s Not Quantum Physics

If you’re not familiar with the name, Stephen Wolfram is a British mathematician and physicist and the chief designer of the Mathematica computer program and Wolfram Alpha Answer Engine. In a recent interview with Spiegel Online he makes an interesting if provocative observation in connect with his latest project, mining the wealth of data provided by Facebook users. Apparently, people are a lot less complicated than atomic particles.

That may be because people are social while particles aren’t.

6 comments