What’s a Scandal?

Scott Rasmussen makes an interesting point:

White House press secretary Jay Carney, speaking on CNN, dismissed “the premise, the idea that these were scandals.” However, voters see it differently. Just over half believe each of the three qualifies as a scandal. Only one out of eight sees them as no big deal.

Voters also reject the notion that the IRS targeting was the work of some low-level rogue employees. Just 20 percent believe that to be the case. A slightly larger number (26 percent) thinks the decision came from IRS headquarters. But 39 percent believe the decision to target conservative groups was made by someone who works at the White House.

At this point the scandals, if that’s what they are, aren’t touching the president himself. His personal approval rating remains high. However, remarkably, Republicans now have a two point advantage in the public opinion on governmental ethics and corruption and a whopping 23 point lead among independents. I don’t think that bodes well for a strategy that depends on trusting the government.

2 comments

Is Obama Ideological?

It’s not easy being tempered, pragmatic, and non-ideological during a period dominated by partisanship and ideology. That’s the theme of E. J. Dionne’s most recent column in the Washington Post:

In fact, Obama is a tempered sort of progressive who repeatedly annoys his party’s left with an incessant pursuit of Republican support for “grand bargains” — one reason his health-care plan is so state-oriented and gives Republican governors and legislatures so much opportunity to undermine it.

[…]

He’s an anti-ideological leader in an ideological age, a middle-of-the-road liberal skeptical of the demands placed on a movement leader, a politician often disdainful of the tasks that politics asks him to perform. He wants to invite the nation to reason together with him when nearly half the country thinks his premises and theirs are utterly at odds. Doing so is unlikely to get any easier. But being Barack Obama, he’ll keep trying.

One of the problems with being guided by ideology, especially when you’re surrounded by others who share your ideology, is that you’re inclined to view it as pragmatic which is what I think that Mr. Dionne is doing here.

I find the president quite moderate in demeanor which is easy to confuse with being moderate in policy as well. I think he’s highly political, highly partisan, and ideological. I don’t think he’s a crypto-Marxist, a radical leftist, a secret Muslim, or any of the other idiocies he’s been charged with.

I think he’s a technocrat and that is an ideology. I also think that in his operational hierarchy of values politics is first, then partisanship, then ideology. That’s the easiest way to explain some of the lacunae in his technocracy. How, for example, do you explain appointing Rahm Emanuel as your chief-of-staff? Or Steve Rattner as “auto czar”? Now Penny Pritzker as Secretary of Commerce? Is the prominence of fundraisers and bundlers in his administration just a coincidence?

Additionally, I think he has the tropism common to members of a profession in underestimating the expertise of individuals not members of that profession and overestimating the expertise of those who are. It is not, in fact, true that a good, Ivy-educated lawyer can do anything he sets his (or her) mind to.

It might be that I’m radicalized on this subject and can’t judge fairly. I’m predisposed towards being anti-technocratic since I think that in practice technocracy is a stalking horse for putting people who think like you do in charge of everything.

4 comments

Memorial Day, 2013

As I presume you’re all aware, most of us have one father, two grandfathers, four great-grandfathers, and eight great-great-grandfathers. The farther back in time you go the more likely it is that the progression will grow more slowly than exponentially but that’s a subject for another time.

I wasn’t good enough for military service—I was called up but rejected. I think I’ve told the story before but my dad tried multiple times to enlist during World War II but was turned down by every branch of the service plus the FBI.

Neither of my grandfathers served in World War I. They were both too old. Neither of them served in the Spanish-American War, either. Indeed, you have to go back to the American Civil War before you find anyone in my direct ancestral line who saw military service. Three of my great-great-grandfathers served in the Union Army. My great-great-grandfather Schuler, presumably, was in the Swiss army but he emigrated to the United States in 1865. I just don’t know about the other four. I suspect they never served in the U. S. military.

My mom’s Uncle Ed was one of the happy few who volunteered for and served in World War II and was called up both for Korea and Viet Nam. Thanks, Ed.

My wife’s father and her maternal uncles all served in the Navy in World War II, her father as a radioman onboard a battleship and her uncles in submarines. Her maternal grandfather served in World War I, also in submarines.

Memorial Day began as Decoration Day, a day in which the graves of the Union Army dead were decorated. Over time it has transmogrified into a day in which we commemorate all who served (that would actually be Veteran’s Day, once Armistice Day) but, particularly, those who gave their lives. My family has been fortunate in that we have no war dead. That is, in part, because others served and even gave their lives and we’re grateful for that.

3 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

Sovereign States

In 1950 there were fewer than 100 sovereign countries in the world. Today there are well over 200 and I think that trend is more likely to continue than to reverse itself. I don’t see any prospects for world government in my lifetime.

1 comment

Another Part of the Forest

I’ve just been reading some reactions over at Russia Today to the rioting in Sweden, now into its seventh day and spreading beyond Stockholm. The reactions, particularly from the Russians and Swedes, are harsher than what you’d read in all but the most strident Stateside blogs. I hope they’re not typical.

0 comments

The Other Fourth Estate

The phrase “the Fourth Estate” was popularized by Thomas Carlyle in his book Heroes and Hero Worship (which deserves to be read more than it is now) and he attributed it to Edmund Burke. The three “estates” were the nobility, the clergy, and the common people. The fourth estate was one distinct from those three. In the United States is generally means the press. Here’s the passage, referring to the French Revolution, in which the phrase was used in that sense:

A Fourth Estate, of Able Editors, springs up; increases and multiplies, irrepressible, incalculable.

I want to commend to your attention an op-ed by Jonathan Turley in the Washington Post in which Mr. Turley takes note with some alarm at the incredible and unanswerable power of a different fourth estate—the federal bureaucracy:

The growing dominance of the federal government over the states has obscured more fundamental changes within the federal government itself: It is not just bigger, it is dangerously off kilter. Our carefully constructed system of checks and balances is being negated by the rise of a fourth branch, an administrative state of sprawling departments and agencies that govern with increasing autonomy and decreasing transparency.

For much of our nation’s history, the federal government was quite small. In 1790, it had just 1,000 nonmilitary workers. In 1962, there were 2,515,000 federal employees. Today, we have 2,840,000 federal workers in 15 departments, 69 agencies and 383 nonmilitary sub-agencies.

This exponential growth has led to increasing power and independence for agencies. The shift of authority has been staggering. The fourth branch now has a larger practical impact on the lives of citizens than all the other branches combined.

The op-ed trails off somewhat at its conclusion which to my mind consists of a series of non sequiturs. Don’t let that diminish his essential point: it’s an important one.

The events of the last few weeks, particularly those involving the ever-widening and tremendously depressing affair of the IRS’s institutional problems, remind me enormously of The Trial or, perhaps, the Tsarist bureaucracy as portrayed by Gogol: all-powerful, eternal, incomprehensible, and drab. What is to be done?

I can think of any number of solutions but I can’t honestly see a workable process for getting from where we are to any of them. My preference, as I have mentioned any number of times before, would be a steep reduction in federal power in favor of state and local power in the hopes of bringing the unquestionably necessary bureaucracy down to something more closely resembling human scale. One cannot be a resident of the city of Chicago and believe that state and local governments are free of corruption or inanity but at least they’re something you can get your mind around.

Others want more centralization. I honesty don’t see how that will come out well.

18 comments

The Mandate of Heaven

In traditional Chinese political philosophy the “mandate of heaven” was what gave the ruler the right to rule. It was thought to be based and conditional on virtue but the ability to take and retain power was seen as indicative of the presence of the mandate of heaven. We might call it “legitimacy” or “authority”.

Attorney General Eric Holder has lost the mandate of heaven. In the Rosen case he has, apparently, been caught committing perjury. Either he perjured himself in his signed statements to the judge to gain search warrants or in his sworn statements to Congress in which he denied any involvement in the matter.

It’s time for him to go. Organizations on all sides of the political spectrum are calling for his resignation or firing. He has lost the mandate of heaven. His continued presence brings discredit on the administration he’s supposed to serve. Primum non nocere is not just the cardinal rule for physicians. It’s also the minimum requirement for political appointees. It’s time for him to go.

12 comments

Let the Ad Hominems Begin!

Ken Rogoff explains why fiscal stimulus won’t solve the eurozone’s problems:

The eurozone’s difficulties, I have long argued, stem from European financial and monetary integration having gotten too far ahead of actual political, fiscal, and banking union. This is not a problem with which Keynes was familiar, much less one that he sought to address.

Above all, any realistic strategy for dealing with the eurozone crisis must involve massive write-downs (forgiveness) of peripheral countries’ debt. These countries’ massive combined bank and government debt – the distinction everywhere in Europe has become blurred – makes rapid sustained growth a dream.

The way I’ve characterized the problem is that as long as Germany and Greece use the same currency and Germans believe that Greece is a fiscal shambles because the Greeks are lazy and profligate, Greece’s problems will only get worse. The same for Spain, Italy, and Portugal. When France joins countries of the “eurozone periphery” in economic decline and fiscal problems, the fur will really begin to fly.

Meanwhile, I expect the immediate response to Dr. Rogoff’s comments, as obvious as they are, to be personal attacks on him on the grounds that he’s a partisan hack, that his work on deficits has been thoroughly debunked, etc. As he notes at the beginning of the piece:

Commentators are consumed by politics, flailing away at any available target, while the “anti-austerity” masses apparently believe that there are easy cyclical solutions to tough structural problems.

7 comments

Foreign Policy Blogging at OTB

I’ve just published a foreign policy-related post at Outside the Beltway:

The Violence in England and Sweden

0 comments