Dave Schuler
May 31, 2013
Fr. Andrew Greeley, priest, author, and sociologist, has died:
“I’m a priest,†he wrote in his 1986 memoir, Confessions of a Parish Priest. “Not a priest-sociologist or a priest-journalist, or a priest-novelist, or any multiple variation of those hyphenates. I’m a priest, a parish priest. The other things I do in life: sociological research, journalistic writing, storytelling, are merely my way of being a priest.â€
Greeley — who had been in poor health after snagging his coat in the door of a taxicab and being dragged after it pulled away in 2008 — died early Thursday at his condo in the John Hancock Building. He was 85.
He was the author of more than 150 books, some academic texts, others steamy potboilers. His first mystery novel, “The Cardinal Sins,†published in 1981, sold three million of copies, spending eight months on the New York Times best-sellers list.
Yet he bristled at any identification other than one: “a loud-mouthed Irish priest,†to use the phrase he said he wanted engraved on his tombstone. He certainly was a thorn in the side of established Catholic authority.
I was acquainted with Andy. He was best friends with my dear friend, John, with whom he had been friends since they were in Prep. Seminary together. I dined (I think) once at Andy’s and dined with him and John at John’s several times. I didn’t see him again after John died. But I did follow his doings and was much saddened when he was seriously injured in 2008 when his coat got caught in the door of a taxi and he was thrown to the pavement, an injury from which he never recovered.
I found him always engaged and engaging, full of stories and opinions. His views on the church’s hierarchy was even lower than mine, if such a thing is possible. He was a man of parts as the many obituaries
Chicago Tribune
New York Times
Washington Post
Los Angeles Times
Andy’s web site
each different, each with a slight change in emphasis, clearly indicate. The world is a less interesting place without him in it.
Dave Schuler
May 30, 2013
Last week when I read the story about a Chechen acquaintance of Boston Marathon bombing suspect Tamerlan Tsarnaev being shot dead while being interrogated by FBI agents, something about the story really rubbed me the wrong way. More details on the incident are now known:
A Chechen man who was fatally shot by an FBI agent last week during an interview about one of the Boston bombing suspects was unarmed, law enforcement officials said Wednesday.
An air of mystery has surrounded the FBI shooting of Ibragim Todashev, 27, since it occurred in Todashev’s apartment early on the morning of May 22. The FBI said in a news release that day that Todashev, a former Boston resident who knew bombing suspect Tamerlan Tsarnaev, was killed during an interview with several law enforcement officers.
The FBI’s policy on the use of deadly force is that a special agent may only use deadly force when the agent “has a reasonable belief that the subject of such force poses an imminent danger of death or serious physical injury to the agent or another person”.
Now I want to know a lot more about the incident:
- How many agents were in the room when the killing occurred?
- What were the heights, weights, ages, and genders of the agents?
As I’ve mentioned before from time to time, I taught martial arts for many years. You’ll have to take my word on this: two or more armed adult men in good condition with adequate training should never be in fear for their lives when confronting an unarmed assailant, even one who’s in very good condition and with lots of training.
I’m not much of one for conspiracy theories. Honest. Check around the site for confirmation of that. But this story stinks.
Dave Schuler
May 30, 2013
The Congressional Budget Office has produced a report on the distribution of major tax expenditures. A “tax expenditure” is, simply stated, government spending via the tax code. Use of the term may resolve the confusion that may arise when I use the term “subsidy”. Subsidies don’t just consist of giving money to people. They can consist in not taking money from people who meet certain criteria as well.
I’m sure that much of the attention in the press will be on what’s in the summary: 50% of all tax expenditures go to the topmost quintile of income earners. When you recognize that the major tax expenditures are employer-subsidized healthcare insurance, home mortgage interest deductions, charitable contributions, preferential tax rates on capital gains, and dividends, and so on that stands to reason. However, when you delve into the details of the report itself, it becomes even more interesting.
About 15% of all tax expenditures go to the top 1% of income earners while about a fifth of all tax expenditures go to the next 9% of income earners. You may recall that I have been harping for years on how, while we’re thinking about how well the top 1% of income earners are doing, we might want to think about the next 9% of income earners as well. This CBO report is more confirmation of that point.
We can’t take much solace in tax expenditures as a share of income, either. Tax expenditures comprise about 7% of the incomes of those in lowest quintile of income earners (presumably, mostly in the form of non-taxable Social Security benefits) and about 13% of the incomes of those in the topmost quintile of income earners. Yes, we’re subsidizing the incomes of people in the upper middle class and tax expenditures is just the tip of that iceberg.
So, when you condemn consumption taxes in favor of the status quo of income taxes, you’re defending subsidies for the highest income earners. Something to keep in mind.
Dave Schuler
May 30, 2013
Entertainer Russell Brand takes to the pages of the Huffington Post to reassure his countrymen and us that the men who murdered the off-duty English soldier in broad daylight on the streets of Woolwich were insane:
After my Hitler Tweet I got involved in a bit of back and forth with a few people who said stuff like “the murderer said himself he did it for Islam.” Although I wouldn’t dismiss what he’s saying entirely, I think he forfeited the right to have his views received unthinkingly when he murdered a stranger in the street. Someone else regarding my tweet said, “Hitler’s moustache didn’t invent an ideology that sanctions murder.” That is thankfully true but Islam when practiced by normal people does not advocate violence. “People all over the world are killing in the name of Islam,” someone added. This is the most tricky bit to understand. What I think is that all over our country – all over our planet – there are huge numbers of people who feel alienated and sometimes victimized by the privileged and the powerful, whether that’s rich people, powerful corporations or occupying nations. They feel that their interests are not being represented and, in many cases, know that their friends and families are being murdered by foreign soldiers. I suppose people like that may look to their indigenous theology for validation and to sanctify their, to some degree understandable, feelings of rage.
Rage = insanity?
Comfortable belief sometimes runs afoul of reality. In the most recent and reliable survey of worldwide opinion among Muslims, opinion on whether suicide bombing of civilians is justified in defense of Islam varies between 1% in Azerbaijan to a substantial 40% in the Palestinian territories. In Afghanistan the number so believing is 39%; in Indonesia, the country with the largest number of Muslims, the number is 7%.
I would speculate that the number of Muslims who believe that attacks on soldiers in defense of Islam is higher than those who believe that attacks on civilians are so justified. Unfortunately, Pew Research didn’t ask that in their survey so any conjecture I might venture would just be speculation.
Without sitting down to do the math, let’s just pull a number out of thin air. If just 10% of Muslims worldwide think that suicide attacks on civilians are justified in defense of Islam, something I think any reasonable person would construe as advocating violence for that purpose, and there are approximately 1 billion Muslims in the world today, that makes 100 million Muslims who advocate violence in the name of Islam.
That’s a lot of crazy people.
Dave Schuler
May 29, 2013
One of my siblings became a vegetarian after a brief stint working for the United States Department of Agriculture and having read the reports on poultry processing plants. That’s the sort of Grand Guignol reflected in the recent USDA report on swine slaughtering plants. Among the findings were that inspectors weren’t doing their jobs and even when they did their jobs there was no enforcement of the regulations. What went out the door carried the “Inspected” sticker nonetheless. Consequently, repeat violators were not deterred.
You don’t need to look too hard to find Democrats complaining that Republicans want to have too few food inspectors to keep the food supply safe or weaken regulations so their fatcat donors reap ever-higher profits. So, Democrats want to hire more inspectors who don’t do anything and impose more regulations that nobody enforces?
IMO we’re in drastic need of Civil Service reform. The laws that protect members of the Civil Service are more than a century old and enacted when the Civil Service was tiny and nearly powerless. Do I need to document that conditions have changed? Perhaps our Civil Service procedures and policies should change with the times.
I’m not sure what really needs to be done. Just as a hipshot suggestion, why not require that Civil Service employees be evaluated on the curve? At least half should receive at least minorly unsatisfactory performance reviews and at least 14% seriously unsatisfactory performance reviews. I’m open to other suggestions or counter-suggestions.
Dave Schuler
May 29, 2013
Glenn Greenwald hears dogwhistles:
What Obama has specialized in from the beginning of his presidency is putting pretty packaging on ugly and discredited policies. The cosmopolitan, intellectualized flavor of his advocacy makes coastal elites and blue state progressives instinctively confident in the Goodness of whatever he’s selling, much as George W. Bush’s swaggering, evangelical cowboy routine did for red state conservatives.
Conor Friedersdorf sees the surrealism of it all:
Roughly five years ago, when he took over for George 2, he’d promised to change course in the conflict formerly known as the Global War on Terror, which he still wages against terrorists all over the globe. Vowing to stop torturing people, he made good on his pledge, waterboarding zero suspected terrorists, but killing thousands without capturing them. Having assured a reporter, “I reject the Bush Administration’s claim that the president has plenary authority under the Constitution to detain U.S. citizens without charges as unlawful enemy combatants,” he killed four U.S. citizens without charges. Insisting that “it is illegal and unwise for the President to disregard international human rights treaties … ratified by the U.S. Senate,” he disregarded the Convention Against Torture, an international human rights treaty ratified in 1994 by the U.S. Senate.
This is the sort of thing that makes me despair for the future of the Republic. It doesn’t matter what you do. It’s who you are and how you express yourself to your own partisans that matters.
You need only look to the Justice Department’s subpoenaeing of AP reporters’ phone regards for an illustration of just how detached from reality things are. The president disavowed all knowledge and called out for a media shield law. But it’s his own administration. He doesn’t need a media shield law. He could end the whole thing by executive order if he cared to.
Dave Schuler
May 29, 2013
Maureen Dowd muses on the relationship between President Obama and the press:
“What is it about Obama that he so disdains us?†he muses. “Presidents always hate leaks. Ronald Reagan said ‘I’ve had it up to my keister with these leaks.’ But they usually don’t act on it. Even if Obama didn’t personally sign off, people always sense by osmosis what leaders are thinking and go in that direction. His people know that leaks offend his sense of discipline and that he likes to protect his right flank by being tough on national security.
“Kennedy had been a reporter, but Obama is not friendly with the press. And he has contempt for people who don’t do their jobs, and, when you talk to the press out of school, you’re not doing your job.â€
quoting Jonathan Alter on the relationship between the president and the press.
I don’t think that any of the things that she or Mr. Alter cites has much to do with the relationship between the president and the press. Unlike Presidents Clinton or Reagan, President Obama is not afraid of the press. They need him more than he needs them. He can always make a primetime speech, get network time, and have the pundits and reporters fawn over him afterwards. Or his organization will rally social media to his support, avoiding the old-fashioned media outlets entirely.
Dave Schuler
May 28, 2013
As I read this post of Mickey Kaus’s some questions occurred to me. What effect would an increase in the minimum wage have on illegal immigration into the United States? For that matter what effect would comprehensive immigration reform have on illegal immigration?
In my view, unless comprehensive immigration reform includes robust workplace enforcement, immigration reform could actually incentivize illegal immigration. The logic is along these lines. Illegal workers are attractive to employers because they’re illegal. They can be paid below minimum wage, you don’t have to conform with labor laws, you don’t have to worry about health and safety regulations, and they require less paperwork. They cost less and they won’t squeal because they don’t want to be turned int. Legalizing the immigration status of people already here doesn’t change that. Employers who are predisposed to hire illegals won’t suddenly become predisposed to hire the newly legalized. They’ll either want to continue to employ those newly legalized workers off the books or hire new illegals, also off the books.
Additionally, any measures that increase the costs of employment will, at least at the margins, increase the attraction of off-the-books workers. Those measures include a higher minimum wage, mandatory healthcare insurance for employees, health and safety requirements and so on.
I’m concerned that we’re careening willy-nilly towards fewer full-time jobs, more part-time and temp jobs, and more off-the-books workers. With the best of intentions, of course.
Thoughts?
Dave Schuler
May 27, 2013
Scott Sumner has a wonderful post, riffing off a post of Paul Krugman’s. In his post Dr. Krugman lists five “largely empirical questions” that he claims divide progressives from conservatives:
- The existence of anthropogenic climate change
- The effects of fiscal stimulus/austerity
- The effects of monetary expansion, and the risks of inflation
- The revenue effects of tax cuts
- The workability of universal health care
Dr. Sumner gives his responses, for which you should read his post.
I consider myself politically center-center. I can provide empirical evidence and some subjective evidence: most conservatives think I’m liberal and most liberals think I’m conservative, as sure a rule of thumb for being a centrist as one could find. Here are my responses:
- I think that anthropogenic climate change is more likely than not but probably not as dire as many of the global warming advocates claim. Like Dr. Sumner I favor a carbon tax, as much for geopolitical reasons as anything else (although that may have a shelf life). I also think that whether I believe or don’t believe doesn’t make much difference as long as the proposals for slowing global warming won’t do much about it anyway, at least not as long as China and India aren’t on board.
- As I’ve said any number of times I think that fiscal stimulus of the proper sort properly timed can produce economic growth during economic downturns. I also think that the Congress is demonstrably incapable of either structuring fiscal stimulus properly or applying it when needed.
- I think that monetary stimulus would be nifty but I’m not sure how it can be accomplished and I think that persistently very low interest rates are having quite serious negative effects on a lot of businesses (e.g. insurance) and individuals. I’m not that worried about inflation but I am worried that it’s pretty hard to control when hyperinflation begins and that most analyses of hyperinflation are, flatly, wrong. I’m also a bit baffled by Dr. Sumner’s prescriptions which sound to me a lot like Harold Hill’s “Think System”.
- I think the revenue effects of tax cuts are unpredictable as a general proposition. There are conditions under which they will reduce revenue; under other conditions they may increase revenue. I think the same is true of tax increases by the way: there is no single answer as to their revenue effects. I’m skeptical that cuts in the income tax today will increase revenues and, as we have seen recently, increases in the personal income tax rate can increase revenues, at least in the short term. I opposed the “Bush tax cuts” for what it’s worth.
- I’m in favor of universal healthcare, think that there are workable and unworkable systems for accomplishing it, that Canada’s and Singapore’s systems are workable, that our system is unworkable and doesn’t produce universal healthcare. I don’t think that any system is workable that doesn’t include systematic controls on spending.
Progressive/not progressive?
Dave Schuler
May 27, 2013
I want to commend to your attention an op-ed by Paul Roderick Gregory at Forbes. In the op-ed he questions whether the austerity that Keynesians are complaining about really explains Europe’s economic doldrums:
The official figures show that PIIGS governments embarked on massive spending sprees between 2000 and 2008. During this period, their combined general government expenditures rose from 775 billion Euros to 1.3 trillion – a 75 percent increase. Ireland had the largest percentage increase (130 percent), and Italy the smallest (40 percent). These spending binges gave public sector workers generous salaries and benefits, paid for bridges to nowhere, and financed a gold-plated transfer state. What the state gave has proven hard to take away as the riots in Southern Europe show.
Then in 2008, the financial crisis hit. No one wanted to lend to the insolvent PIIGS, and, according to the Keynesian narrative, the PIIGS were forced into extreme austerity by their miserly neighbors to the north. Instead of the stimulus they desperately needed, the PIIGS economies were wrecked by austerity.
Not so according to the official European statistics. Between the onset of the crisis in 2008 and 2011, PIIGS government spending increased by six percent from an already high plateau. Eurostat’s projections (which make the unlikely assumption that the PIIGS will honor the fiscal discipline promised their creditors) still show the PIIGS spending more in 2014 than at the end of their spending binge in 2008.
As Erber wryly notes: “Austerity is everywhere but in the statistics.â€
I think he’s wrong in the particular case of Greece. Greece has, in fact, cut public spending sharply. Greece’s spending is right down where it was in 2006.
Now Greece did increase real public spending from joining the euro to 2006. But that’s not what Mr. Gregory is complaining about and in the case of Greece he’s wrong.
The Greeks really have no choice. As long as they remain on the euro they’re forced to adopt a policy of austerity. The only way they can increase spending is by debt forgiveness and extension of additional credit which in practice means that Germany, France, Holland, and Luxembourg must pay for it. That’s the fundamental flaw in a common currency for countries in drastically different stages of development. It’s been very good for the Germans, though.