Rex Nutting, writing at MarketWatch, concludes his post on how the increase in income inequality is the consequence, deliberate or inadvertent, of policy with this:
Ultimately, the next generation at the top will be, the friends, neighbors, classmates and children of the current crop.
The country that once boasted of equal opportunities has re-created a self-perpetuating aristocracy. And that’s not the America I dream of.
a view that, unfortunately, I think is quite correct.
The bulk of the post is largely contrasting two different explanations for the growth of income inequality in recent decades. One of those explanations is presented by Harvard econ prof Greg Mankiw and Mr. Nutting summarizes like this:
In his paper, Mankiw explains why the top 1% are doing so well while the rest of us sprint hopelessly to catch up: The rich are simply better than us. They make more money because they contribute more to society than we do. They are smarter, have the skills that are in high demand, have better entrepreneurial instincts, and work harder. What’s more, their kids inherit these traits genetically.
I would phrase it a bit differently in two sentences. The first, practically tautological, is that the rich are rich because they get paid more. The second is that they get paid more because they are smarter and work harder. The first, as I say, is obvious. The second, however, is fallacious.
It’s fallacious for two reasons. Essentially, the correlation between income and IQ is very loose. And I don’t think there’s any scientific basis for believing that the rich work harder than everybody else. That’s just an unbased assumption, without which the conclusion would not be true. In other words, it’s begging the question.
It might well be the case that all Ivy-educated lawyers are smart, work hard, and are rich. What’s mistaken is that Ivy-educated lawyers aren’t the only people who are smart and work hard and in all likelihood there are millions of those who are aren’t rich. Similarly with medical doctors. It might well be true that docs are smart, work hard, and are rich. But they’re a lot richer than other people who are even smarter and work even harder.
I would submit that the incomes of both of those groups, along with those of many, many others in the top 10% of income earners, are due to rent seeking. And that brings us around to the other explanation, this one from Josh Bivens and Larry Mishel, who find that the main reason for the divergence in incomes isn’t intelligence or hard work but rent-seeking.
As I’ve written any number of times here, I think that the stagnation of incomes of people in the lower four income quintiles while the incomes of those in the top decile have soared can be explained by four factors:
- The one-way system of free trade, in which most barriers to trade in the U. S. (except for things like legal and medical services) have been removed while those of our major trading partners, e.g. China, Japan, India, remain largely in place.
- The importation of large numbers of unskilled and semi-skilled workers, mostly from Mexico, whose willingness to work for low wages has eroded wages among the lower income quintiles.
- Technological changes which have tended to erode wages among those in the middle income quintiles.
- Enormous subsidies, most of which have gone to those in the top decile of income earners.
all of which have been the specific result of policies. To change the outcomes, change the policies. For example, want to reduce healthcare costs? Stop voting in “doc fixes”. Allow the wages of medical doctors to fall. Their wages will still be higher than their next-best alternative.