Consolidation

In a very interesting op-ed on how China is not buying the world, Martin Wolf includes something I found very thought-provoking from a standpoint of our domestic economy:

Using data from 2006-2009, Prof Nolan concludes that the number of globally dominant businesses in the manufacture of large commercial aircraft and carbonated drinks was two; of mobile telecommunications infrastructure and smart phones, just three; of beer, elevators, heavy-duty trucks and personal computers, four; of digital cameras, six; and of motor vehicles and pharmaceuticals, 10. In these cases, dominant businesses supplied between half and all of the world market.

Similar degrees of concentration have emerged, after consolidation, in many industries. Much the same concentration can be seen among component suppliers.

Look at aircraft. The world has three dominant suppliers of engines, two of brakes, three of tyres, two of seats, one supplier of lavatory systems and one of wiring.

In the motor industries, as well as information technology, beverages and many others, the world has just a few dominant suppliers of the essential components.

If you want an explanation of the worldwide slowdown in economic activity which IMO has produced a worldwide slowdown in job growth, look no farther. Not technology. Not simple employer greed.

Consolidation.

The question worth discussing is whether the consolidation that’s been going on is a force of nature or an artifact. I think the latter.

5 comments

Thought Experiment on Immigration

Let’s play a little game on the subject of immigration reform. List your own top five priorities in immigration reform, in descending order of importance, and then list what you think are the top five priorities of the Senate’s comprehensive immigration reform bill. I’ll start

  • Admitting the agricultural workers we need into the country.
  • Ensuring that the high-skilled workers businesses are demanding to be let into the country are actually needed.
  • Admitting the high-skilled workers we need into the country.
  • Discouraging anyone else from entering the country.
  • Bringing individuals who were provably brought here as children illegally and have never lived anywhere else out of the shadows.

I can think of some other issues that I think are important but those are probably the top five.

Here’s what I think the priorities of the Senate’s bill are:

  • Immediate legalization of all immigrants already in the country illegally.
  • A path to citizenship for immigrants already in the country illegally.
  • Providing plausible deniability to charges that they’re promoting another immigration amnesty.
  • Incentivizing more immigration.
  • Gaining bipartisan support by throwing enough dough in the direction of states whose senators are leaning towards supporting the bill.

or, more simply stated, re-election.

Your turn.

10 comments

Defining Genocide Down

There’s one more peculiar tidbit in the article cited in my last post:

There was one other development in the flurry of gun debate at the Statehouse: a call from state Rep. Monique Davis (D-Chicago) on Gov. Pat Quinn and Mayor Rahm Emanuel to open the door for the National Guard to come into the city to help quell gun violence.

“It’s almost as if there’s a war going on,” Davis told the Chicago Sun-Times. “It seems like it’s genocide, and those officials who can do something about it have chosen not to do anything about it. I’m calling for the National Guard to come to Chicago and ride up and down these streets.”

As I’ve documented in previous posts, shooters in instances of gun homicide in Chicago are preponderantly black and the victims of gun homicide by black perpetrators are overwhelmingly black as well. No genocide involved. Unless you think that competing gangs are separate, warring tribes.

What there is is more like internecine warfare. I know that some believe that the underlying problem is the War on Drugs but my own view is that the WoD is actually just a small part of a much larger problem which I would summarize as the rule of law does not extend into the black community here in Chicago at least in part because people have lost confidence in the Chicago Police. The homicides that are occurring on a weekly basis are the result of gang initiations and turf battles between rival gangs. The gangs themselves exist to provide protection, support, and something to do under conditions of social and economic disintegration.

You can end the War on Drugs with the stroke of a pen but providing basic security, changing perverse social structures, and reviving the economy are much, much harder.

4 comments

Governor’s Veto Overridden

Illinois Gov. Pat Quinn’s amendatory veto of concealed carry legislation for Illinois has been overriden by both houses of the Illinois legislature:

SPRINGFIELD-Illinois joined 49 other states Tuesday by approving legislation allowing gun owners to carry their weapons in public places, overriding Gov. Pat Quinn and dealing the governor a resounding defeat.

The Senate put the finishing touches on the override push, voting 41-17 to reject a series of changes Quinn had recommended to the concealed-carry legislation that passed in May. The Senate’s action followed a 77-31 vote by the House earlier Tuesday.

This move has been necessitated by a federal appeals court’s decision back in December that Illinois’s strict ban on gunowners’ carrying their firearms in public was unconstitutional.

Despite extensive lobbying by the governor the vote wasn’t even close and, honestly, he only persuaded a handful of members of the Illinois House.

2 comments

Where’s the Bright Line?

Where’s the bright line between executive overreach and executive discretion? That’s the question is think that former judge and law prof Michael McConnell is addressing in an op-ed in the Wall Street Journal:

President Obama’s decision last week to suspend the employer mandate of the Affordable Care Act may be welcome relief to businesses affected by this provision, but it raises grave concerns about his understanding of the role of the executive in our system of government.

Article II, Section 3, of the Constitution states that the president “shall take Care that the Laws be faithfully executed.” This is a duty, not a discretionary power. While the president does have substantial discretion about how to enforce a law, he has no discretion about whether to do so.”

As Mr. McConnell notes, stretching the limits of discretion has become a bad habit for the Obama Administration:

This is not the first time Mr. Obama has suspended the operation of statutes by executive decree, but it is the most barefaced. In June of last year, for example, the administration stopped initiating deportation proceedings against some 800,000 illegal immigrants who came to the U.S. before age 16, lived here at least five years, and met a variety of other criteria. This was after Congress refused to enact the Dream Act, which would have allowed these individuals to stay in accordance with these conditions. Earlier in 2012, the president effectively replaced congressional requirements governing state compliance under the No Child Left Behind Act with new ones crafted by his administration.

The president defended his suspension of the immigration laws as an exercise of prosecutorial discretion. He defended his amending of No Child Left Behind as an exercise of authority in the statute to waive certain requirements. The administration has yet to offer a legal justification for last week’s suspension of the employer mandate.

I think there are basic differences about the function and purpose of law at the root of this. I think that at the very least a good faith attempt should be made at the rigorous enforcement of every law without exception. Exceptions are for the courts to decide, not the executive.

However, I recognize that others believe that laws are more of a statement of intent rather than something to be rigorously enforced. In this view it’s the idea of the PPACA or the ARRA that matters rather their precise implementation.

I couldn’t disagree more. I think that discretion is just another word for abuse.

23 comments

Carpe Diem

The Illinois legislature has seized the opportunity afforded by the veto session convened by Gov. Pat Quinn to deal with Illinois’s public pension mess to do, well, just about anything other than deal with Illinois’s public pension mess:

July 8, 2013 (SPRINGFIELD, Ill.) (WLS) — On Tuesday, Illinois lawmakers will attempt to override the governor’s rewrite of a bill to allow the concealed carry of firearms.

Governor Pat Quinn hopes the changes he made to a concealed carry bill last week survive a challenge by state lawmakers. Among the changes is a call to allow communities to ban assault weapons.

On Monday night, it was a contentious debate in Evanston. Those who support a ban on assault weapons want the City of Evanston to join with a number of other communities who have already banned them.

The debate come on the eve of a special session that begins in the morning in Springfield when lawmakers are expected to vote on the concealed carry bill again, overriding amendments governor Quinn made to the bill.

Those amendments include provisions to allow towns to vote on assault weapons and to ban guns in drinking establishments.

Gun rights supporters accuse the Governor of standing in the way of a court ordered compromise plan.

But they will not consider pension reform, the reason Pat Quinn called the special session.

“It’s time for them to do their job. If they don’t do their job by tomorrow, there will be consequences,” said Gov. Pat Quinn.

I still like the idea I heard attributed to Quinn: the governor should veto the legislators’ salaries and office budgets until they start doing their jobs. No work—no pay.

He won’t make any friends that way, of course, but he isn’t making many friends as it is and the continuous delays over pension reform give Bill Daley ammo to use against him. Aggressive action including taking on the legislature might be Pat Quinn’s only hope of getting re-elected. The guy is a populist, after all. He might as well start acting like one.

4 comments

Foreign Policy Blogging at OTB

I’ve just published a foreign policy-related post at Outside the Beltway:

U. S. Aid to Egypt Is Complicated

I had no idea how complicated U. S. aid to Egypt was until I started digging into it.

0 comments

It’s the Messenger

In his latest column Paul Krugman reiterates the point I’ve been making for more than a year now:

Friday’s employment report wasn’t bad. But given how depressed our economy remains, we really should be adding more than 300,000 jobs a month, not fewer than 200,000.

and generally get dinged for.

I know that some people believe that our “new normal” is completely due to technological obsolescence but I just don’t see it. I tend to look at phenomena in terms of changes, I don’t see changes over the last six years that can explain what we’re experiencing.

I can see declines in economic activity over that period so that’s where I tend to look for solutions. Unfortunately, the Obama Administration certainly appears to be much more interested in controlling economic activity than in promoting it. I’m not sure what the Republican opposition is interested in other than defeating Obama. The track record of the late Bush Administration doesn’t to any great interest in goosing economic activity, at least not to my eye.

4 comments

How Will They Convict George Zimmerman?

ABC’s Dan Abrmas explains why George Zimmerman is unlikely to be convicted of murder or manslaughter:

As a legal matter, even if jurors find parts of Zimmerman’s story fishy, that is not enough to convict. Even if they believe that Zimmerman initiated the altercation, and that his injuries were relatively minor, that too would be insufficient evidence to convict. Prosecutors have to effectively disprove self defense beyond a reasonable doubt. So what exactly would that mean based on the facts as we know them?

[…]

While prosecutors argue that Zimmerman’s statements to the 911 operator about the “f—— punks” always “getting away,” shows ill will, most legal analysts felt from the beginning that with a fight, a murder charge was overreaching.

Manslaughter is far more likely to create debate in that jury room (there could also be even lesser crimes they consider, where they could find him guilty of something).

Zimmerman’s injuries alone — his broken nose and cuts on the back of his head — are objective evidence to support his account that he shot Martin as he was being pummeled.

Just as important is the testimony of neighbor John Good, who lived directly in front of the location where Martin was shot. He very precisely (but reluctantly) testified that he saw the lighter skinned man in the red jacket on the bottom of the scuffle with the darker skinned man with the darker clothing on the top in a “mixed martial arts position.” He said he now believes that Trayvon Martin was on top of Zimmerman.

To be honest I was a bit surprised when the judge didn’t dismiss the case after the prosecution rested. If the published reports are to be believed, it certainly does not look to me as though the prosecution had made its prima facie case and, under the circumstances, the judge really should have dismissed. I can’t help but wonder if she decided to pass the buck.

At the very least there certainly seems to be reasonable doubt which means acquittal. Assuming, again, that the published reports have represented the proceedings fairly, conviction would require a sort of reverse jury nullification in which the jury convicts regardless of the evidence.

Andrew Branca has compiled a detailed legal argument supporting the position I suggested above, that Zimmerman should have been acquitted when the prosecution rested:

Immediately following the close of the State’s case on Friday, Mark O’Mara, the lawyer leading George Zimmerman’s defense team, stood before Judge Nelson and made his oral motion for a judgment of acquittal for his client (a parallel written motion was also submitted to the Court).

The motion was well-reasoned, and strongly founded on Florida’s case law. It was also doomed to fail before a Judge who has consistently denied reasonable defense motions out of hand, while rubber-stamping motions by the State that bear not the slightest relevancy to the facts of this case.

Details matter in the law, and in any case the quick-and-short reporting of Nelsons denial of the motion for a judgment of acquittal has already been widely reported (by us, among others). Here, we take a different approach, delving into the details of O’Mara’s motion. Part of this detail includes the full-length decisions of almost every court case cited by O’Mara in support of his motion.

Sounds to me like a good argument for legal error on appeal. It also sounds like a violation of Canon 3 of the Florida Code of Judicial Conduct.

6 comments

Foreign Policy Blogging at OTB

I’ve just published two foreign policy-related posts at Outside the Beltway:

The Tiger or the Tiger: What’s Ahead for Egypt?
Egypt’s Grim Economics

In the first post I make the observation that the only two likely outcomes in Egypt are for the effective return of Mubarak’s regime or another incompetent Islamist government.

In the second post I sketch the economic underpinnings of Egypt’s problems.

With these two posts, brick by brick, I’m assembling a case that has two points. First, there is no do-over. That’s fatuous. The likelihood of an outcome that is good either for the U. S. or Egypt is quite low and the U. S. is in a lose-lose situation there.

Secondly, Egypt’s problems are basic. There’s no short term solution.

I believe that, sadly, our best course of action in Egypt is studied neutrality. We gain practically nothing by anything else.

1 comment