Their Lips Are Moving

How do you know that the various functionaries testifying before Congress about what the IRS did to Tea Party, libertarian, pro-Israel, and a few other sorts of organizations filing for 501(c)(4) status are lying? Former FEC Commissioner Bradley Smith catalogs the systematic lies:

We were told that the White House, like the rest of the country, learned about the program on May 10 through a planted question asked of then IRS official Lois Lerner at an American Bar Association conference. Turns out the White House knew earlier. We were told the targeting was the work of a few rogue IRS employees in Cincinnati. Then those employees insisted that they were being managed from Washington.

We were told that no political appointees were involved, but now we know the scandal goes at least to the office of Obama appointee and IRS Chief Counsel William Wilkins. We were told that liberal groups were targeted, too. But then the IRS’s inspector general, whose report exposed the harassment, clarified that only conservative groups were targeted.

He sees it as a conspiracy against the First Amendment. I see it a little differently—as the obvious consequence of a game in which the stakes are very high.

Remember, the people who are lying are the same people who are tasked with protecting us from abuses of the tax system. Quis custodiet ipsos custodes? There are only a handful of ways dealing with the abuses we’re seeing. My preference would be to lower the stakes but it’s pretty clear that my fellow Americans disagree with me on that.

The other alternatives include increasing the risks for abuse by federal bureaucrats, something I think is long overdue. The path we’re embarked on, which involves putting guards to watch the guards and then more guards to watch the guard-watching guards, is not only doomed to failure but it will inevitably make the Stasi look like underachievers.

2 comments

Business Development the Government Is Good At

At Financial Times Martin Wolf reviews a book on the “entrepeneurial state”:

Mazzucato notes that “75 per cent of the new molecular entities [approved by the Food and Drug Administration between 1993 and 2004] trace their research … to publicly funded National Institutes of Health (NIH) labs in the US”. The UK’s Medical Research Council discovered monoclonal antibodies, which are the foundation of biotechnology. Such discoveries are then handed cheaply to private companies that reap huge profits.

A perhaps even more potent example is the information and communications revolution. The US National Science Foundation funded the algorithm that drove Google’s search engine. Early funding for Apple came from the US government’s Small Business Investment Company. Moreover, “All the technologies which make the iPhone ‘smart’ are also state-funded … the internet, wireless networks, the global positioning system, microelectronics, touchscreen displays and the latest voice-activated SIRI personal assistant.” Apple put this together, brilliantly. But it was gathering the fruit of seven decades of state-supported innovation.

Why is the state’s role so important? The answer lies in the huge uncertainties, time spans and costs associated with fundamental, science-based innovation. Private companies cannot and will not bear these costs, partly because they cannot be sure to reap the fruits and partly because these fruits lie so far in the future.

I think there are some things that the state is good at, some not so good, and some very bad.

I think the state is good at mass engineering projects. Boulder Dam. The power facilities of the Tennessee Valley Authority. The space program. Much as I despise it, the interstate highway system. These have all paid for themselves many times over and in ways that were impossible to foresee.

Although I supported it for many years, I think the evidence now suggests that the investment the federal government has done for so long in pre-school education for normally developing kids has been wasted. To my eye it appears the jury is still out on medical research. We’ve spent an enormous amount and I’m not sure if we had known the actual results in advance we would have made the investment. I think the space program probably did more for medicine and biotechnology than all of the federal government’s investment in medical research.

I think the areas in which government is especially useful are large scale, long term projects with clear deliverables.

There’s something in which I think I may disagree with a lot of those who support federal infrastructure spending. Just because a bridge is good doesn’t mean that two bridges are necessarily better. Sometimes that’s just money wasted.

I guess I should look at the bright side. At least we’re not building empty cities. On a more sobering note, we already have plenty of them.

28 comments

Dining in My Neighborhood

One of the things that’s great about living in a city neighborhood is the close proximity of restaurants. Within three blocks of my home there’s a decent Pan Asian restaurant, a Nepalese/Indian restaurant, and a hamburger stand. There’s also a Whole Foods which, if you’re familiar with the chain, you know offers pretty decent prepared food in its salad bar, hot bar, and bakery. It also has a grill and a sort of deli.

Sadly, the Nepalese/Indian restaurant is spotty, ranging from barely adequate down. Still, if I absolutely need an order of momo, it’s just a few steps away.

In addition, within 10 blocks of my house there are two (yes, two) Starbucks, a Subway, two hot dog stands, a Thai restaurant, two Chinese restaurants, a pizza place, an Irish pub that serves pub food, and a tiny but beloved local landmark: the Edgebrook Cafe, recently re-opened under new management.

The location that houses the Nepalese/Indian restaurant appears to be cursed. For many years it was the location of a pretty crummy Chinese restaurant (there were three Chinese restaurants in that same block). After that disappeared it has hosted a terrible Mexican restaurant, a fair joint with an interesting concept (mostly eggrolls, spring rolls, sushi, and tacos), and now the Nepalese/Indian restaurant.

I think that a decent Mexican restaurant could clean up in this neighborhood but, alas, there’s none to be found.

Update

Makes that two pizza places.

3 comments

Book Idea

Here’s a book idea that occurred to me yesterday. A field guide to ordinary household objects after they’ve passed through a dog’s digestive system.

2 comments

Obama Administration Takes Apple’s Side

The Obama Administration has intervened in the patent war between Apple and Samsung in Apple’s favor:

The Obama administration halted a ban on older models of iPhones and iPads in a rare presidential move to overturn a decision by the International Trade Commission.

The announcement Saturday broke from a long tradition of administrations not intervening when the ITC issues import bans on products. The last time a ban was overturned was in 1987.

I think the explanation offered for the intervention is particularly feeble:

U.S. Trade Representative Michael Froman announced the decision to overturn the ban in a letter to the ITC. He expressed concern that the ban would allow Samsung to gain “undue leverage” and allow it to charge unreasonable rates for the use of its patented technologies.

The letter cited above concludes:

My decision to disapprove this determination does not mean that the patent owner in this case is not entitled to a remedy. On the contrary, the patent owner may continue to pursue its rights through the courts.

whose remedies will, presumably, be blocked by future White House directives.

Nearly all of Apple’s operations are overseas. Just as an example, Apple employs about 5,000 engineers in the United States and more then 30,000 in China. In essence, the administration is safeguarding Apple’s right to offshore its operations while maintaining its sales here.

For me this action raises two questions. The first is whether this intervention is consistent with the rule of law. The second is whether it invites retaliation from other countries. Remember, I ask questions because I want to know the answers.

0 comments

Reason on the Minimum Wage

Megan McArdle has what I think is a reasonable post on the minimum wage. Read the whole thing but I’ll summarize it as bullet points:

  • Small minimum wage hikes don’t seem to produce large, immediate declines in employment.
  • Companies are not rationally maximizing machines that automatically find the best, perfect price for their products.
  • ncreasing wages can lead to greater productivity.
  • Some jobs can’t be automated.
  • Doubling the minimum wage is a whole different story.
  • Timing matters,
  • A big hike means big cost increases for industries that employ a lot of minimum-wage workers.
  • It can’t all come out of profits.
  • Companies aren’t all-knowing value maximizers, but they probably know more about their pricing power than a random person on the Internet.
  • Time frame matters.
  • Most of the efficiency wage arguments you read fundamentally misunderstand how efficiency wages work.
  • It isn’t true that paying workers at the bottom a lot somehow magically makes the economy grow.

She fleshes out each of her points a bit but that’s the gist. I agree with nearly all of what she writers here. Her post is the sort of “more light less heat” post that I wish there were more of.

I think the bottom line is that we just don’t know. That’s why I’ve been asking questions. For those who think that a sharp immediate increase in the minimum wage is worth the gamble, that’s just as faith-based a position as being convinced that such an increase would be disastrous. We just don’t know.

26 comments

Will a Return to Yesterday’s Labor Policies Bring a Return of Yesterday’s Wages?

In the interest of continuing the discussion of wages that’s been going on here, you might want to take a look at an op-ed from The American Prospect editor Robert Kuttner at Reuters. In the op-ed Mr. Kuttner argues that, if you want a return of the high wage America of fifty years ago, we must bring back the labor policies of fifty years ago:

America is moving, at an accelerating pace, toward an economy with tens of millions of poorly paid service jobs at one end, and a relatively small number of astronomically compensated financial jobs at the other. In between the fast food workers, who demonstrated this week for a living wage, and the hedge fund billionaires is a new creative class heavily based on the Internet. But the web entrepreneurs are too narrow a segment on which to rebuild a broad middle class.

For a quarter-century after World War Two, America was a far more equal society — with jobs that paid a “family wage” on a single paycheck. One question dividing economists now is whether the more equal, high-wage economy of the postwar era is irrevocably gone with the steel mills of Pittsburgh. Or whether a service economy can become an egalitarian one with a different set of policies.

I am among those who think America can still be a high-wage economy — but first we need to restore a lot of regulation.

Specifically, he wants a lot more trade unionism and stronger labor regulations:

hat means not just more aggressive prosecution of unfair labor practices by a newly invigorated board. During World War Two, for example, President Franklin D. Roosevelt issued executive orders barring labor violators from receiving government contracts. In the early 1960s, before civil rights laws passed, Presidents John F. Kennedy and Lyndon B. Johnson used the same executive power over contracting to insist that large employers cease practicing racial discrimination in hiring and promotion.

The Labor Department could also crack down on the bogus classification of regular employees as “contractors” — which saves companies payroll taxes, denies workers benefits and makes it impossible for them to unionize.

Obama could also use his authority to change the trade agenda. For three decades, industry has set the agenda for trade talks, making it easier for companies to outsource, hide profits offshore and avoid health, safety, labor and environmental standards. The trading system could instead put a floor under social standards.

He also calls for tougher financial regulation, more effectively progressive taxation, more public investment, and better education. He also wants the president to make use of the “bully pulpit”:

In his Knox College speech, the president, in an aside, called for a higher minimum wage. It would be helpful if he stood with the fast food workers who pointed out that in America today you can’t live on a minimum wage of $7.25 an hour. Who can dispute that?

He could call on industry to pay a living wage, and support local living wage campaigns. He could also call for a national policy of upgrading human service work — so that anyone who cares for the young, the old or the sick is paid a professional wage.

To what forces does he attribute the decline in wages?

What killed the more equal prosperity of the postwar era? It wasn’t just a shift from factories to services. Trade, technology, the unleashing of Wall Street, the gutting of progressive taxation, the failure to extend the welfare state to working families, the weakening of unions — all were implicated.

But one core point connects the others: The economy of that era was more heavily regulated.

I would be prepared to accept his prescription if he offered more evidence. Otherwise, he may be offering a post hoc propter hoc argument, false causation. One thing I notice is that there is very little role for supply and demand in the model that he presents. Under his model employers paid more because they were compelled to do so by law rather than by market forces.

Let’s return to the example we’ve been discussing, fast food. Why does McDonalds pay minimum wage to its crew? If Mr. Kuttner’s model is correct, it’s because that’s what the law forces them to do. That McDonalds can always depend on a continuing supply of entry level workers many of whom are recent immigrants is irrelevant and the company’s management is greedy.

Why doesn’t McDonalds charge $6 for a Big Mac rather than the 4-something it already does? Why not $10? Why not $50? Doesn’t the greed extend that far? Are they just vicious?

Why does In-N-Out, a largely Californian fast food chain to which McDonalds is sometimes unfavorably compared, pay more to its crew employees? I think it’s because it’s family-owned rather than publicly owned, all of its 280 some odd stores are operated by the company rather than being a mix of franchise and company-owned stores, and they need to pay more to retain the employees they want. That its owning family has a a strong Christian orientation may also be a factor.

Please note that I’m not defending McDonalds. One of the constants around here is that I don’t like big companies and McDonalds is no exception. I would prefer that our restaurants were the old individually-owned and operated joints of a half century ago rather than the mammoth, homogenous (like milk) chains of today but, obviously, my fellow citizens disagree with me. I’m not defending McDonalds’s top management, either. I think they’re drastically overpaid.

Political conservatives are sometimes scolded for wanting to return to some imaginary decade—the 1980s, the 1950s, the 1850s. It appears to me that progressives aren’t immune from this temptation. Mr. Kuttner wants to return to the 1950s. Paul Krugman has frequently written nostalgically about the 1940s, when the federal government controlled its largest percentage of GDP. The New Deal era of the 1930s is a frequent target. Or the Heroic Age of American progressivism, when the popular election of the Senate, prohibition, and the income tax were introduced.

I’m neither a conservative nor a progressive and I don’t particularly want to return to any imaginary era. You can’t go home again.

But the 1950s it is. In the 1950s the United States had the only functioning modern economy, imported relatively little, had no system of interstate highways, and controlled immigration very stringently with an eye to limiting the number of low skill workers coming into the country (read: black and Hispanic). Blacks were discriminated against systematically and either legally or by convention barred from participating in the larger economy. Which of these were relevant and which irrelevant to “America’s high-wage economy”? Which of them does Mr. Kuttner want to restore?

16 comments

Hysteria Reigns at the WSJ

I think that Daniel Henninger’s Wall Street Journal column on the president’s “creeping authoritarianism” is overwrought:

Every president since George Washington has felt frustration with the American system’s impediments to change. This president is done with Congress.

The political left, historically inclined by ideological belief to public policy that is imposed rather than legislated, will support Mr. Obama’s expansion of authority. The rest of us should not.

The U.S. has a system of checks and balances. Mr. Obama is rebalancing the system toward a national-leader model that is alien to the American tradition.

In my view President Obama suffers more than his predecessors have from a distinctively oppositionist Congress. However, I don’t think his problems stop there. I think that this president more than others of my memory really doesn’t like to be second-guessed. My impression is that he thinks that Congress should take his ideas, flesh them out, and enact them into legislation. Our government has never worked that way so why not now?

I also think that President Obama doesn’t have much interest in or patience with the mechanics of getting legislation passed.

However, even without “creeping authoritarianism” there’s a lot the president can do that would be well within his constitutional powers and neatly within the practices of prior presidents. The Pentagon would be a very good place to start.

19 comments

Philo Farnsworth and the Heroic Age of American Invention

Who invented television, desktop nuclear fusion, and made major contributions to the development of radar, the electron microscope, and numerous other major developments? Scott Locklin profiles Philo T. Farnsworth, whom he characterizes as “the last great American inventor”. I should also point out that Mr. Locklin has a very low opinion of software development as invention.

I think that’s right. Most software is better thought of as literature than invention and, sadly, literature written by someone who’s never read a book.

3 comments

More On That Big Mac

Commenting on the same study I mentioned yesterday, the one about the impact of increases in wages at McDonalds on the Big Mac, James Taranto points out:

It turns out it was an exaggeration to describe Morelix as a “researcher”; he is in fact an undergraduate. The reference in the story has been corrected to “student,” and a correction has been appended.

But there are other problems here. Morelix’s “study” has a back-of-the-envelope quality to it. He looks at the company’s 2012 annual report and observes that its labor costs amounted to 17% of its total revenue. Therefore, he concludes, the consequence of doubling wages would be a 17% price rise–17 cents on a Dollar Menu item, times 4 for the $4 Big Mac.

There’s a let-them-eat-cake quality about Fairchild’s dismissive reference to a 17% increase in prices. Sixty-eight cents may not amount to much, and the hypothetical increase in the cost of a single meal, even adding fries and Coke, would break hardly anybody’s bank.

There are other, greater problems with the “study”. Mr. Morelix clearly does not understand how the McDonalds corporation works. As I’ve shown here before, the labor costs in the franchises aren’t reflected on the corporation’s financial statement and the corporation’s revenues are derived from multiple sources, both company-owned stores and franchise fees so there’s really not much of any relationship between corporate’s cost of labor and the price of a Big Mac.

Note that I’m not taking a position one way or another on the subject. Just trying to ferret out the truth. The income statement for an “average” McDonalds store might be a good place to start. Crew payroll presently comprises about 20% of the operating expenses of the store and net revenues are about 5.7%. My gut level reaction is that doubling crew payroll would cause the store to close.

28 comments