In his speech last week President Obama made a very standard explanation of the Fordist argument:
Just a little context here — in the period after World War II, you had a growing middle class that was the engine of our prosperity. The economy did well in part because everybody was participating. And whether you owned a company, or you swept the floors of that company, or you worked anywhere in between, America offered a basic bargain: If you work hard, then you will be rewarded with fair wages and benefits. You’ll have the chance to buy your own home. You’ll have the chance to save for retirement. You’ll have the protection of decent health insurance. But most of all, you’ll have the chance to pass on a better life to your kids.
For a more complete exposition on “Fordism” see here or one of my many posts in which I’ve touched on the subject. The term was coined by Antonio Gramsci and refers to a form of technocracy consisting of a set of compromises among big business, organized labor, and government in which business pays higher wages, income inequality is accepted, and labor remains peaceful with the whole shebang overseen by a benevolent government. That compromise has broken down under the pressures of globalization, technology, the sheer pace of economic affairs, now far beyond the ability of any government to control, and, frankly, greed, not merely on the part of business but on those of labor and government as well.
Like most other commentators, the president described the problem but doesn’t really present a solution.
I think that income inequality is a problem, too, for all sorts of reasons. For one thing, the America of today really doesn’t look a good deal as I expected it would when I was twenty and not in a good way. When I was twenty, most of America’s wealth and income, the overwhelming preponderance, were in the hands of the middle class. Now most of both wealth and income are mostly in the hands of the wealthiest Americans.
My concerns are somewhat different than those of most people who remark on the subject. I don’t really care how much Tiger Woods, Johnny Depp, or even Warren Buffett earn, at least to the extent that they earn what they do based on their own efforts without government subsidies. The earnings of the top 1% of income earners is just about the same as the income of the next 9% of income earners, the top 90-99%, and an astounding proportion of those earn what they do as a consequence of government subsidies. What I care about is rent-seeking and its consequences.
The highest earners in the healthcare sector, not just the half million physicians but the millions of technicians, administrators, and so on who are in the top decile of income earners derive two-thirds of their income from the government at one level or another. That’s even more true of the defense sector.
We are continually told that only swift government action saved the banking sector in 2007 but that means that the multi-million dollar incomes that were saved were dependent on that government action, too.
The list goes on and even includes some teachers, police officers, firefighters, and other civil servants. Needless to say, their income is derived from tax revenues. Unless your concern about income inequality to the Tiger Woodses and Warren Buffetts or the world, an enormous amount of income inequality is a direct consequence of government policy.
I also see no way that you can import millions of uneducated, low skill workers into the United States and not have increasing income inequality, not just as a consequence of those workers themselves but due to the effects of those workers on the lowest wage native born workers. Warehouses full of treatises on the effects of immigration on income have been written and there’s not a lot of agreement but there’s one thing there is agreement on: adding low wage workers depresses the wages of other low wage workers even farther.
And then there’s China. Our trade policy with respect to China in particular has had the effect of increasing income inequality here at home both by increasing the earnings of the highest income earners and decreasing the wages of the lowest income earners and even the middle income earners.
The president’s strategy for addressing the problems of income inequality seem to rely heavily on education and infrastructure spending. We might get more bang for the buck by reconsidering some of our perverse policies.