Build a Smarter Scalpel


I’ve always thought it was pretty good engineering to take a waste product produced during a process and exploit it. In electrosurgery an electric current rapidly heats tissue, vaporizing it, producing smoke. The smoke is then extracted. What if the smoke could be analyzed in real-time (or nearly real-time) to identify what was being cut?

The inventor of the iKnife, Dr. Zoltan Takats of Imperial College London, realized that this smoke would be a rich source of biological information. To create the iKnife, he connected an electrosurgical knife to a mass spectrometer, an analytical instrument used to identify what chemicals are present in a sample. Different types of cell produce thousands of metabolites in different concentrations, so the profile of chemicals in a biological sample can reveal information about the state of that tissue.

In the new study, the researchers first used the iKnife to analyze tissue samples collected from 302 surgery patients, recording the characteristics of thousands of cancerous and non-cancerous tissues, including brain, lung, breast, stomach, colon, and liver tumors to create a reference library. The iKnife works by matching its readings during surgery to the reference library to determine what type of tissue is being cut, giving a result in less than three seconds.

The technology was then transferred to the operating theater to perform real-time analysis during surgery. In all 91 tests, the tissue type identified by the iKnife matched the post-operative diagnosis based on traditional methods.

Pretty darned clever.

More:

Dr Zoltan Takats, who invented the system at Imperial, said: “These results provide compelling evidence that the iKnife can be applied in a wide range of cancer surgery procedures.

“It provides a result almost instantly, allowing surgeons to carry out procedures with a level of accuracy that hasn’t been possible before.

“We believe it has the potential to reduce tumour recurrence rates and enable more patients to survive.”

Trials are now taking place at three hospitals in London – St Mary’s, Hammersmith and Charing Cross.

Potentially, the iKnife could reduce time waiting for pathology, anyway.

3 comments

What’s the Empirical Evidence?

As I read this article at Forbes on the impact that raising the wage paid to McDonald’s workers to $15 per hour would have on the price of a Big Mac (they say $.68), it made me start thinking about raising the minimum wage more generally. I think that whether you believe in raising the minimum wage depends on other beliefs, particularly what you think about the price elasticity of labor.

The “price elasticity of the demand for labor” means, roughly, the effect that increasing or decreasing a wage has on the number of people employed. If you think that an increasing wage has no effect whatever on the number of people employed, that means you think that when the minimum wage rises it has no effect at all on the number of people who are employed. If you think that it has a lot of effect, presumably you think that raising the minimum wage would cause lots of jobs to be lost. I think that this is a completely empirical question. I don’t think the answer can just be deduced from first principles.

In the case of McDonalds I would guess that the price elasticity of labor would be related to the price elasticity of a Big Mac. Does anybody have any empirical information on that? I would guess that McDonalds does.

4 comments

How Disconnected?

Mickey Kaus found President Obama’s speech of last week articulate but tremendously disconnected from reality:

Does Obama recognize that his initiatives have a weak connection, and even perverse connection, with actually achieving his goal? I hope his biographer, Jonathan Alter, will tell me. But either way, there’s a vacuum between his speechmaking and governing. Is that unusual? After all, Democrats have campaigned for years by arguing that Republican policies benefit the rich–think of all the distributional tables Democrats distributed to fight Reagan’s budgets-without ever saying how much inequality, exactly, they’d be willing to tolerate.

But Obama isn’t vague or incoherent. He’s quite precise about where he wants to go–namely back to something like what we had three decades ago. If his means don’t come close to matching his ends, if they even subvert them, that seems a more troubling, almost pathological mismatch, in which liberalism becomes a sort of cargo cult whose mechanisms have zero hope of achieving the desired results.

If I interpret Mickey correctly, he believes that the president is either being dishonest or is delusional. My interpretation is kinder than that. I think he’s sincere but misinformed.

3 comments

Who Are the Poor?

In preparing a post expanding on some of the points I made in my earlier post on income inequality, I realized how difficult it was to discuss the subject without thinking about who are actually poor. Based on information from the Census Bureau, particularly Table 3, I think the poor can actually be summarized fairly simply:

  • non-native born Hispanics and their children
  • urban blacks
  • people who live in rural areas and small towns regardless of race or national origin

Any summary is bound to over-simplify. According to the Census Bureau roughly 45 million people are poor. There are other ways of summarizing who those people actually are, e.g. by age or household structure, than the one I’ve presented and if you think you have a summary that’s a better representation of the reality of poverty in the United States, I’m open to it.

Wrong? Too simple? Right? What?

4 comments

Montana Cuts Healthcare Costs

The state of Montana has undertaken an experiment in cutting its healthcare expenses that I thought I’d pass along:

A year ago, Montana opened the nation’s first clinic for free primary healthcare services to its state government employees. The Helena, Mont., clinic was pitched as a way to improve overall employee health, but the idea has faced its fair share of political opposition.

A year later, the state says the clinic is already saving money.

Pamela Weitz, a 61-year-old state library technician, was skeptical about the place at first.

“I thought it was just the goofiest idea, but you know, it’s really good,” she says. In the last year, she’s been there for checkups, blood tests and flu shots. She doesn’t have to go; she still has her normal health insurance provided by the state. But at the clinic, she has no co-pays, no deductibles. It’s free.

That’s the case for the Helena area’s 11,000 state workers and their dependents. With an appointment, patients wait just a couple minutes to see a doctor. Visitation is more than 75 percent higher than initial estimates.

[…]

Physicians are paid by the hour, not by the number of procedures they prescribe like many in the private sector. The state is able to buy supplies at lower prices.

The public employees are happy. The healthcare providers are happy. The public employees are healthier. The state is saving money—possibly as much as half of what it would otherwise be paying. What’s not to like?

Critics of the approach have generally taken one of two tacks. Either they object on philosophical grounds, i.e. the state just shouldn’t be in the healthcare business, or they make a sort of “free rider” argument, i.e. the state is saving money but local hospitals are making up the difference by charging more to people other than public employees. I’m not sure that either argument holds water.

Maybe Montana’s circumstances are unique but I think this is an experiment that bears repeating elsewhere.

9 comments

The President’s Speech: Income Inequality

In his speech last week President Obama made a very standard explanation of the Fordist argument:

Just a little context here — in the period after World War II, you had a growing middle class that was the engine of our prosperity. The economy did well in part because everybody was participating. And whether you owned a company, or you swept the floors of that company, or you worked anywhere in between, America offered a basic bargain: If you work hard, then you will be rewarded with fair wages and benefits. You’ll have the chance to buy your own home. You’ll have the chance to save for retirement. You’ll have the protection of decent health insurance. But most of all, you’ll have the chance to pass on a better life to your kids.

For a more complete exposition on “Fordism” see here or one of my many posts in which I’ve touched on the subject. The term was coined by Antonio Gramsci and refers to a form of technocracy consisting of a set of compromises among big business, organized labor, and government in which business pays higher wages, income inequality is accepted, and labor remains peaceful with the whole shebang overseen by a benevolent government. That compromise has broken down under the pressures of globalization, technology, the sheer pace of economic affairs, now far beyond the ability of any government to control, and, frankly, greed, not merely on the part of business but on those of labor and government as well.

Like most other commentators, the president described the problem but doesn’t really present a solution.

I think that income inequality is a problem, too, for all sorts of reasons. For one thing, the America of today really doesn’t look a good deal as I expected it would when I was twenty and not in a good way. When I was twenty, most of America’s wealth and income, the overwhelming preponderance, were in the hands of the middle class. Now most of both wealth and income are mostly in the hands of the wealthiest Americans.

My concerns are somewhat different than those of most people who remark on the subject. I don’t really care how much Tiger Woods, Johnny Depp, or even Warren Buffett earn, at least to the extent that they earn what they do based on their own efforts without government subsidies. The earnings of the top 1% of income earners is just about the same as the income of the next 9% of income earners, the top 90-99%, and an astounding proportion of those earn what they do as a consequence of government subsidies. What I care about is rent-seeking and its consequences.

The highest earners in the healthcare sector, not just the half million physicians but the millions of technicians, administrators, and so on who are in the top decile of income earners derive two-thirds of their income from the government at one level or another. That’s even more true of the defense sector.

We are continually told that only swift government action saved the banking sector in 2007 but that means that the multi-million dollar incomes that were saved were dependent on that government action, too.

The list goes on and even includes some teachers, police officers, firefighters, and other civil servants. Needless to say, their income is derived from tax revenues. Unless your concern about income inequality to the Tiger Woodses and Warren Buffetts or the world, an enormous amount of income inequality is a direct consequence of government policy.

I also see no way that you can import millions of uneducated, low skill workers into the United States and not have increasing income inequality, not just as a consequence of those workers themselves but due to the effects of those workers on the lowest wage native born workers. Warehouses full of treatises on the effects of immigration on income have been written and there’s not a lot of agreement but there’s one thing there is agreement on: adding low wage workers depresses the wages of other low wage workers even farther.

And then there’s China. Our trade policy with respect to China in particular has had the effect of increasing income inequality here at home both by increasing the earnings of the highest income earners and decreasing the wages of the lowest income earners and even the middle income earners.

The president’s strategy for addressing the problems of income inequality seem to rely heavily on education and infrastructure spending. We might get more bang for the buck by reconsidering some of our perverse policies.

10 comments

What Went Wrong in Detroit

Bill Nojay, formerly the chief operating officer of the Detroit Department of Transportation, tells a tale of corruption, greed, and incompetence:

While I was at the DDOT, roughly 10% of bus-fare collection boxes were broken. In another city, getting a contract to buy spare parts to repair these boxes would be routine. The City Council publicly expressed outrage that we didn’t fix the fare boxes, since the city was losing an estimated $5 million a year in uncollected fares.

But the reason we couldn’t fix the fare boxes was that the contract for the necessary spare parts had been sitting, untouched, in the City Council’s offices for nine months. Due to past corruption, virtually every contract had to be approved by the council, resulting in months-long delays. Micromanagement by the council was endemic; I once sat for five hours waiting to discuss a minor transportation matter while City Council members debated whether to authorize the demolition of individual vacant and vandalized houses, one by one. There are over 40,000 vacant houses in Detroit.

Union and civil-service rules made it virtually impossible to fire anyone. A six-step disciplinary process provided job protection to anyone with a pulse, regardless of poor performance or bad behavior. Even the time-honored management technique of moving someone up or sideways where he would do less harm didn’t work in Detroit: Job descriptions and qualification requirements were so strict it was impossible for management to rearrange the organization chart. I was a manager with virtually no authority over personnel.

There are several strategies for Detroit that make sense. Detroit could just be allowed to stew in its own juices which are, more than anything else, the product of decades of corruption, greed, and incompetence. That is too lacking in mercy or charity to suit me.

Detroit could remain in a lengthy sort of receivership, as is its condition now. On an increasing basis the day-to-day decision-making could be removed from the citizens of Detroit and their elected representatives and done by state or federal officials. There have been attacks on that strategy as undemocratic or even racist but I think that those attacks are mostly just meaningless noise. Any city in Detroit’s straits would have Detroit’s problems and would be taken into receivership. Not everything is about ideology or race.

Unfortunately, as Mr. Nojay notes, that does nothing for Detroit but manage its ongoing decline. You can’t get blood from a turnip, the near term prospects for more revenue are bleak, and Detroit can’t pay its bills now.

What I’ve been advocating is for the state to step in and manage a disincorporation process in which large areas of the city, already largely vacant, are forcibly de-populated and put into a decent condition so that they don’t provide an ongoing source of hazard to the remaining city. The state would need to provide the funds for doing that. Detroit needs fewer public employees who aren’t as highly compensated maintaining a smaller city. Bankruptcy proceedings are the only way to accomplish that.

This won’t be the last time this happens and we may as well start learning how to resolve situations like this in an orderly and humane basis now.

17 comments

The President’s Speech: Education

Much of the president’s speech last week was focused on education. In this post I’ll try to explain why I think that education is a red herring. At best it’s confused and at worst it’s politically motivated and counter-productive.

First, the United States is the fourth most educated country in the OECD. At 42% of the population with tertiary education, only Japan (45%), Israel (46%), and Canada (51%) are more educated.

Second, about 13% of the U. S. population (39 million) is foreign-born and a little more than half of that (21 million) are from Mexico, Central America, and the Caribbean. Immigrants from those areas tend to have rather low levels of educational attainment. Excluding those individuals, we’re just about in Canada’s territory from the standpoint of educational attainment. Said another way, if the economic future of the United States depends on ever-greater proportions of the population having tertiary education and above, that policy is in direct contradiction to accepting large numbers of uneducated immigrants. You just can’t have it both ways.

Third, the unemployment rate of Canada, the OECD country we most resemble culturally and economically is 7.1%, roughly the same as ours (7.6%).

Fourth, pre-school education is virtually unrelated to later educational attainment. Universal pre-school education would be a middle class subsidy without clear long-term benefits.

Fifth, here are the state-by-state statistics on educational attainment and here are the state-by-state statistics on unemployment. There is no simple, straight line relationship between the two.

Sixth, 52.2% of Chicago’s children graduate from high school. That’s a higher percentage than many other comparable cities and significantly better than Los Angeles (42.2%), New York (38.9%), and Detroit (21.7%). How in the world do you plan to get kids to graduate from college who won’t stay in high school? Simply committing to the importance of tertiary education effectively writes off about half of city kids.

Finally, Germany has a much lower rate of tertiary education than does the United States and has a 5.4% rate of unemployment. If it were the case that tertiary education were a necessary condition for reducing unemployment, that would be impossible.

There is essentially no relationship between jobs and education. Look somewhere else.

7 comments

The Politics of Futility

Last week President Obama gave a much-heralded speech on the economy. The complete text of the speech is here.

The president’s speech met with a variety of reactions. E. J. Dionne was jubilant. He saw the speech as a sign that the president would “go big”:

In the long history of the country, concentrations of wealth and income always have created perverse effects. Broadening our nation’s winners’ circle, on the other hand, has always been the best strategy for sustainable growth. We need to acknowledge this once again.

There is more Obama needs to do to make his case for the specific steps Washington can take to restore shared, robust prosperity. He will have to beat back the forces that would continue to shrink government through a sequester that is making the recovery slower than it should be.

But this time, he cannot let himself be sidetracked. With 1,276 days left in his presidency, he chose to draw a clear line and start a big argument. His place in history will hang in large part on whether he can win it.

Kevin Drum was mystified. This is big?

The reason Obama should be bolder is not because it might “break through the resistance.” He should be bolder precisely because it wouldn’t make any difference. If you’re going to meet an adamantine wall no matter what you do, why not shoot for the stars? At least that way you’ve made it clear whose side you’re on. Obama’s speech got in some good shots at the Republican Party’s continuing economic derangement, but he needs more than that.

Raise the minimum wage to $12! Split up the big banks, tax hedge funds at regular rates, stomp on derivatives and commodities trading, and increase capital requirements to 20 percent! Raise Social Security payments! Guarantee universal pre-K/childcare starting at three months! Invest a trillion dollars in infrastructure! Mandate four weeks of vacation for all employees! Eliminate software patents! Increase the capital gains tax to 40 percent!

None of this has the slightest chance of passage. But when you’re competing with a party whose message is about as subtle as a blood-and-guts slasher pic, you need something equally dramatic to show everyone what your party stands for. Dana Milbank still wouldn’t be happy, of course. He’d call you crazy. But that’s better than having him call you lifeless, isn’t it?

Dana Milbank found that the speech indicated that the president just didn’t know what to do:

I admire Pfeiffer’s pluck in trying to generate enthusiasm for what is largely a news-free initiative. And it’s smart politics for Obama to keep his emphasis on economic matters. But it would be easier to rally enthusiasm if he gave supporters something big, bold and new to reach for, rather than leftover proposals coupled with lofty ideals.

“It will be a pretty good speech,” Obama told activists this week at a gathering of Organizing for America, an outgrowth of his campaign. “But as we’ve learned, I’ve given some pretty good speeches before, and then things still get stuck here in Washington, which is why I’m going to need your help.”

True, but with three years to go in his presidency, Obama needs to help his supporters help him — by giving them the power of fresh ideas.

Megan McArdle thought the speech reflected the president’s impotence in doing anything about the economy:

If you listened closely, the speech seemed like a confession that the president knows he can’t do much. The deep problems afflicting America — social and economic breakdown in inner cities and rural areas; rising economic insecurity; widening gulfs between ideologies, regions, and socioeconomic classes — are simply far beyond the president’s reach.

But we don’t like to feel like our president isn’t even trying. And presumably, Obama hates to feel like a do-nothing. And so we get speeches that ultimately tell us what we already know: that we’d like to get to a better world. If we only knew how.

My own reaction to the speech was, I guess, despondency. I thought it was both weak on policy and on politics for reasons very much along the lines that Kevin Drum outlines. You may as well be hung for a sheep as a goat. Why make such limp proposals?

In the speech the president touched on a number of areas: income inequality, immigration, education, infrastructure, and jobs. In a series of short posts I plan to explain why I think the president’s approach to each of them is inadequate.

15 comments

What If There Are No Cost Savings?

Physician and Democratic party stalwart Howard Dean takes to the pages of the Wall Street Journal in an op-ed, pointing out what everybody not overwhelmed by the hype or partisan fervor already knows—that one of the main cost control mechanisms of the Affordable Care Act, the Independent Payment Advisory Board, won’t control costs:

There does have to be control of costs in our health-care system. However, rate setting—the essential mechanism of the IPAB—has a 40-year track record of failure. What ends up happening in these schemes (which many states including my home state of Vermont have implemented with virtually no long-term effect on costs) is that patients and physicians get aggravated because bureaucrats in either the private or public sector are making medical decisions without knowing the patients. Most important, once again, these kinds of schemes do not control costs. The medical system simply becomes more bureaucratic.

The nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office has indicated that the IPAB, in its current form, won’t save a single dime before 2021. As everyone in Washington knows, but less frequently admits, CBO projections of any kind—past five years or so—are really just speculation. I believe the IPAB will never control costs based on the long record of previous attempts in many of the states, including my own state of Vermont.

That’s assuming that the IPAB passes constitutional muster, far from a sure thing. It involves a bit too much delegating of Congress’s power to what would be an instrumentality of the executive branch.

That’s a leg of the ACA that’s unlikely to produce cost savings. Anyone with ground-level experience has known that another of those legs, electronic recordkeeping, is equally unlikely to produce much in the way of cost savings.

As I have pointed out before just as Republicans are attacking aspects of the ACA they should be supporting merely out of a desire to deny President Obama a victory some Democrats will defend aspects of the law that aren’t worth defending to spare him from taking a loss. This is a case in point.

Dr. Dean goes on to consider one of the real structural problems with the healthcare system, something that remains unaddressed by the ACA:

If Medicare is to have a secure future, we have to move away from fee-for-service medicine, which is all about incentives to spend more, and has no incentives in the system to keep patients healthy. The IPAB has no possibility of helping to solve this major problem and will almost certainly make the system more bureaucratic and therefore drive up administrative costs.

That sort of structural reform is a sine qua non of healthcare reform. Without it the ACA isn’t a good first step in the direction of genuine healthcare reform. It’s a misstep, costly in time, energy, and money.

10 comments